Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Arbitrary deduction of 2% to 5% on each payment claim disguised as unsubstantiated shared expenses, wiping out the contractor's net margin without any link to actual costs, in contradiction with the agreed price determination under art. 373 CO.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Undue allocation of cleaning or waste disposal charges attributable to other trades, creating confused site responsibilities across contractors in breach of the principles in art. 364 CO.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Site management withholding approval of the final account until prorata account balances are settled, delaying balance payments under art. 372 CO and the release of securities under standard SIA 118.
During the tender stage and the finalisation of a construction contract in Switzerland, estimators and SME managers frequently face special contract conditions that impose automatic deductions for prorata accounts, site facilities, or general cleaning. While standard SIA 118 and contracts for work under art. 363 CO rest on the exact remuneration of agreed services, inserting unilateral percentage deductions directly undermines operating margins. Establishing clear terms from the tender stage allows contractors to manage these deductions, reject unsupported lump sums, and demand billings backed by verifiable supporting documents.
Accepting a tender form containing a prorata account managed by a third party without reservations leaves the contractor vulnerable to paying for power, skips, or shared facilities unrelated to its actual needs. In application of art. 1 CO, contractual agreement requires mutual consent on how these expenses are calculated and capped. This guide sets out practical methods to spot cost shifts, record targeted reservations in the tender, and incorporate a hard cap or a justified refusal of groundless shared charges into the special conditions.
Legal Nature and Mechanics of Prorata Account Deductions
A prorata account brings together shared site expenditures that cannot be attributed with certainty to a specific trade. In Swiss practice, these costs cover water and power consumption on the construction site, general security, temporary sanitary facilities, and mixed skip waste disposal. However, Swiss contract law does not establish any statutory obligation to participate in an automatic prorata account.
Under art. 363 CO, a contract for work requires the contractor to complete the work in exchange for the agreed price. When the awarding body or site management inserts a clause requiring an automatic flat deduction, such as 2% or 3% withheld automatically from each advance payment, this alters the contract's financial balance. If the parties agreed on a lump-sum price under art. 373 CO, the contractor is required to deliver the work for the fixed sum, and the client cannot make deductions without an express agreement or services actually rendered on its behalf.
Contractually, running a prorata account can be structured as a simple partnership under art. 530 CO among the contractors on site, or through direct back-charging by the general contractor or site management. Without a written agreement specifying the allocation formula, the contractor is only responsible for its own consumption and clearing its own waste, in line with the specifications in the standard catalogues of building articles.
Negotiation Strategies during Tendering
The tender phase is the ideal time to eliminate arbitrary deductions. When submitting technical and commercial offers, bidders must examine the special conditions of the tender documents. If the specifications impose an automatic deduction, several options are open to the firm:
- A justified refusal: State in the tender cover letter that the submitted unit prices or lump sums already cover the contractor's own cleaning and waste removal, ruling out any extra deduction for a general flat rate.
- Contractual capping: Agree to contribute to actual shared costs, but subject to a strict non-revisable ceiling expressed as a percentage of the net invoiced works or as a fixed maximum sum in CHF.
- Requiring an adversarial accounting: Make every debit conditional on the prior delivery of supporting invoices from third-party suppliers, paired with an objective allocation key proportional to the volume of work performed.
- Excluding trade-specific costs: Explicitly stipulate that specific site installation costs for structural work (such as cranes or main site huts) cannot under any circumstances be passed on to finishing work contractors.
Comparison Table of Shared Site Expense Clauses
| Clause Type | Specified Mechanism | Financial Risk | Contractual Compliance | Recommendation for the Bidder |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blind automatic flat rate | 2% to 4% deduction on each payment claim without receipts | Direct net loss on operating gross margin | Breaches art. 373 CO if the lump sum was set without this charge | Expressly refuse in the tender or build the cost into the prices |
| Simple partnership prorata account | Joint management of shared costs under art. 530 CO | Joint financial liability if the overall site budget is overrun | Compliant if the account rules are negotiated and signed | Require an independent managing office and regular approval votes |
| General contractor management | 1,5% deduction for management fees and shared site services | Overheads shifted onto contractors without equivalent value | Enforceable special contractual clause if agreed | Request a breakdown of included items and cap the percentage |
| Accounting based on supporting vouchers | Recharging actual expenditures at the end of the project | Belatedly discovering contested invoices at account closing | Fully compliant with the logic of a contract for work | Require quarterly interim accountings with supporting vouchers |
| Cleaning and skips charged at actual cost | Each trade orders its own waste removal or handles it directly | Risk of unjustified back-charges if the site is poorly kept | Respects a clear division of contractor scopes of work | Take regular dated photos of work areas before leaving site |
Common Pitfalls and Practices to Avoid
Many SMEs suffer significant financial losses when the final account is closed because of oversights when signing the award agreement. The most frequent errors observed in the Swiss market should be examined carefully:
The first mistake is signing a construction contract referring to special conditions without reviewing the section covering site costs. A clause stating that "the contractor contributes to prorata account expenses at a rate of 3,5% of the invoiced amount" produces a 17 500,00 CHF clawback on a 500 000,00 CHF contract. This amount is then withheld from the final payment without the client showing that any actual expense was incurred.
The second mistake is accepting automatic charges for joint site cleaning without prior formal notice. When a construction site has debris or mixed waste whose origin is unassigned, site management cannot bring in a third-party company at a trade's expense without a written notice setting an appropriate deadline to take action. Art. 366 para. 2 CO sets strict conditions for having work completed or repaired by a third party at the contractor's expense and risk: the client must give a reasonable deadline before undertaking substitute performance.
The third mistake is failing to set a reporting schedule. Letting the prorata account administrator issue a single financial statement two years after practical completion deprives the contractor of any way to review the accounts collaboratively. Skip collection orders and utility bills become impossible to verify, making it difficult to resolve residual balances.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures shown in the following scenarios are illustrative examples intended to demonstrate the financial impact of managing shared expenses in the contract.
Scenario 1: Finishing work in the Canton of Vaud
A plastering and painting contractor with 8 employees bids on a call for tenders for an office building refurbishment in Lausanne. The quote totals 280 000,00 CHF exclusive of tax. The tender documents include a clause requiring a non-negotiable 3% flat deduction for site overheads and power.
When tendering, the estimator rejects the standard clause and inserts an alternative wording: "The agreed price is net of any prorata account deduction; the contractor takes care of daily cleaning of its work areas and removes its own packaging. A contribution to water and power supplies is accepted on the basis of a fixed sum capped at 1 500,00 CHF for the entire duration of the works." The awarding body approves this provision in the final contract. The company saves 6 900,00 CHF compared to the original 8 400,00 CHF deduction that would have cut into its operating margin.
Scenario 2: Major refurbishment in Central Switzerland
On a 650 000,00 CHF refurbishment project in Lucerne awarded to a steel construction contractor (12 employees), project management institutes a prorata account organised as a simple partnership under art. 530 CO. The contract calls for a 1,5% advance payment on each monthly payment claim.
The company insists on appending operating rules requiring a statement of expenses every three months, backed by invoices for power and sanitary facility rentals. In the second-quarter account, an expense of 18 500,00 CHF for securing external access points is debited to the prorata account. Relying on the contract specifications, the contractor proves that this item fell under the structural work contractor's site installations obligations. The misallocated amount is taken out of the prorata account, saving the steel contractor an unjustified loss of 2 215,00 CHF on the final account.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
Can a mandatory prorata lump sum in a tender be refused?
Yes. At the tender stage, the bidder states written reservations. Under standard SIA 118 and the Code of Obligations (CO), a contract requires mutual consent. An automatic flat-rate deduction imposed without consideration can be struck out or capped at an illustrative rate of 0,5% of the net amount.
How do you challenge an excessive flat deduction for site power?
The contractor requests an account based on actual costs supported by submeters or utility invoices. Unless specifically agreed under standard SIA 118, shared energy costs cannot be debited as an unjustified unilateral flat deduction against the contractor's monthly advance payments.
What is the financial exposure of an uncapped prorata clause?
Without a contractual ceiling, cleaning overruns or shared skips are passed on to the trades. For a trade package of 300 000,00 CHF for instance, a 2,5% deduction represents 7 500,00 CHF of lost margin, debited directly on the final account by site management.
Can site management impose an external prorata manager?
Only if the special conditions of the contract state this explicitly. Under the Code of Obligations (CO) and the rules of mandate, third-party management costs only bind the contractor if it joined the prorata agreement or the site rules appended to the order.
What if the client refuses to remove a flat cleaning clause?
The contractor incorporates this cost into the unit price or global price, then clearly defines the scope of the service. You should specify in writing that the lump sum covers collective waste removal, but excludes third-party cleaning interventions billed without a prior joint inspection record on the construction site.
How to structure your refusal of an unagreed deduction on the final account
The successful bidder challenges the statement in writing by citing the initial enterprise contract. In accordance with the Code of Obligations (CO), any deduction requires mutual consent or a proven claim. To secure payment rights, the contractor can initiate proceedings for a statutory mortgage lien of craftsmen and contractors.
Locking in rules for prorata deductions and shared site setup costs before signing directly safeguards the contractor's margin against unilateral debits at final settlement. To explore the Swiss legal framework and clause negotiations in greater depth, consult our dedicated guides:
- Final Negotiation, SIA 1023 Contract Review, and Handover to Site Operations
- Explicitly Incorporating Standard SIA 118 into the Works Contract: It Is Not Automatic
- Auditing a Works Contract Form: Derogations Introduced by the Architect
- Unit Price, Lump Sum or Fixed Sum: Choosing the Remuneration Method Under Standard SIA 118
