Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Cumulative deduction of daily amounts from advance payments with no upper limit, typically in the range of 10% to 25% of the contract sum, wiping out the SME's net profit. Under art. 161 CO, the contractual penalty is due even if the client suffers no actual damage.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Haphazardly rushed work cadences to make up for delays caused by other trades, leading to working-hour breaches under the National Collective Agreement and safety violations under the OTConst regarding work at height.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Offset of the indemnity during final inspection of the works and disputes over the final account, withholding the contractor's retainage releases if reservations regarding extension of time were not notified pursuant to the SIA 118 standard.
When submitting a tender for a public or private construction project, estimators and business owners frequently encounter contract clauses imposing daily penalties for missing intermediate or final deadlines. In a works contract under art. 363 CO, such a provision constitutes a contractual penalty governed by art. 160 CO. Without an explicit cap, the successful bidder is exposed to substantial financial deductions, particularly since the client does not need to prove actual loss to claim the agreed payment.
To safeguard the project's financial viability, the contract finalisation phase requires rigorous negotiation to cap the cumulative total of this penalty, usually between 5% and 10% of total remuneration. Aligning this with the disruption notification procedures in the SIA 118 standard ensures that delays caused by third parties or bad weather do not improperly trigger the penalty. Drafting these clauses as early as the review of particular conditions prevents liability disputes before final signing.
Contractual Penalty Mechanisms and Normative Justification
In Swiss construction contracts, a clause specifying a daily amount for project delay falls under art. 160 CO. When stipulated for non-performance at the agreed time, the client may demand both performance of the work and the agreed penalty, unless expressly waived or if the works are accepted without reservation. Under art. 161 CO, the contractual penalty is incurred even if the creditor suffers no damage. For the tendering contractor, accepting such an uncapped clause directly threatens the business's balance sheet, as penalty amounts accrue purely mathematically as soon as the contractual deadline passes.
While freedom of contract allows the parties to determine the penalty amount under art. 163 CO, that same provision requires the judge to reduce penalties deemed excessive. To avoid relying on an uncertain court procedure for reduction, preliminary negotiations during the tender phase should establish an explicit cap in the particular conditions. The SIA 118 standard provides a balanced benchmark for time limits and the consequences of default. When the works contract incorporates the SIA 118 standard, the contractor has a solid contractual basis to claim legitimate time extensions, notably for change orders, adverse weather, or delays caused by other parties.
Technical Criteria for Negotiating a Cap
Setting an upper limit relies on several objective criteria to raise when reviewing contract documents:
- Proportionality to the contract sum: Swiss industry practice generally accepts a cap expressed as a percentage of the total amount excluding VAT, typically set between 5% and 10% of the final contract price.
- Calibrated or degressive daily rate: The daily rate per working day or calendar day should reflect a reasonable estimate of the client's standby or alternative accommodation costs, preventing the clause from being viewed as purely punitive.
- Alignment with the master programme: Penalties should apply only to the final completion milestone rather than every intermediate milestone, allowing technical recovery without interim cash deductions.
- Prior notice procedure: Formal notice must follow the principles of art. 102 CO, requiring written notification before daily penalties start running.
Comparative Analysis of Contractual Wordings
The table below compares clauses frequently found in public and private call for tenders documents with recommended protective wording for tenderers:
| Contract parameter | Standard draft (high risk) | Negotiated wording (compliant with SIA 118 standard) | Financial and legal impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall cap | No mention of an upper limit. | Cap set at 5% of the total net contract award amount. | Limits the company's maximum financial exposure in a protracted dispute. |
| Time calculation base | Penalty per calendar day, including Sundays and public holidays. | Penalty applies exclusively per actual working day. | Reduces cumulative exposure over statutory closures by roughly 30%. |
| Intermediate milestones | Separate penalties applied to each intermediate programme date. | Single penalty linked exclusively to the final acceptance of the works. | Prevents deductions from monthly advance payments for temporary, recoverable delays. |
| Evidence of delay | Automatic application as soon as the calendar date passes. | Prior written formal notice pursuant to art. 102 CO principles with a grace period. | Ensures a traceable record of delay causes before any monetary deductions occur. |
| Disruptive events | Penalty applies even in cases of third-party delays or minor changes. | Automatic extension of the contract schedule under SIA 118 standard rules. | Negates penalties when the critical path is affected by site management. |
Frequent Mistakes and Operational Consequences
A frequent mistake made by tenderers is signing a works contract based on contract form SIA 1023 without verifying deviations introduced in the appendices by the client or its representative. Omitting a cap turns an ordinary penalty clause into an unlimited financial liability. For example, on a finishing work contract worth 450 000,00 CHF, an uncapped penalty of 1 000,00 CHF per calendar day results in a 60 000,00 CHF deduction for a two-month delay—over 13% of turnover, completely wiping out profit margin and overheads.
A second pitfall is accepting penalties linked to interim milestones. When site management deducts penalties from monthly interim payment claims, company cash flow is squeezed during construction, endangering payments to suppliers and subcontractors. While art. 364 CO requires the contractor to carry out the work with due care, this duty also entails promptly issuing formal notifications of hindrance whenever conditions on the construction site prevent regular progress.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures presented in the following scenarios are illustrative examples intended to guide your negotiation and calculation process.
Scenario 1: Structural Work in an Urban Setting (Canton of Vaud)
A masonry firm with 22 employees tenders for the construction of a residential building in Lausanne, for an awarded sum of 1 850 000,00 CHF including VAT (at the rate of 8,1 %). The draft contract stipulates an uncapped penalty of 2 500,00 CHF per calendar day of delay. During contract finalisation, the contractor proposes a reconciling addendum: introducing an overall cap of 5% of the contract value (a maximum of 92 500,00 CHF), restricting penalties to working days (1 800,00 CHF per day), and making them enforceable only upon final handover of the works.
The justification was grounded in the SIA 118 standard governing weather-related delays and art. 163 CO to prevent manifest disproportion. During execution, upstream earthworks delays pushed back the contractor's start by 18 days. Thanks to the negotiated cap and the formal registration of reservations as soon as disruptions arose, the company prevented an unwarranted 45 000,00 CHF deduction on its final account.
Scenario 2: Building Services Renovation (Canton of Geneva)
A heating and plumbing & sanitary installations company with 12 employees responds to a call for tenders for the refurbishment of an administrative building in Geneva, valued at 380 000,00 CHF. The works contract originally included an uncapped daily penalty of 800,00 CHF applied across three separate intermediate milestones. The firm formally requested in writing the following contract amendment: deleting penalties on intermediate milestones and establishing a single completion penalty capped at 8% of the contract sum, or 30 400,00 CHF.
This change eliminated the risk of interim retentions caused by equipment delivery delays beyond the firm's control. By strictly applying the verification and notification rules set out in the Code of Obligations (CO) and the SIA 118 standard, the final accounts were closed without financial dispute over completion schedules.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
What is the standard negotiated cap for a delay penalty under Swiss law?
In Swiss market practice, the overall amount is commonly capped between 5% and 10% of the final contract price. For a 500 000,00 CHF contract, setting a 25 000,00 CHF cap protects the contractor's margin while remaining compliant with art. 163 CO.
Does the client have to prove financial loss to claim the agreed penalty?
No. Under art. 161 CO, the contractual penalty is due even if the creditor suffers no damage. However, if the actual loss exceeds the agreed sum, the client can claim additional compensation only by proving specific fault on the contractor's part.
Does accepting overdue works without reservation cancel the penalty clause?
Yes. Under art. 160 CO, where a penalty is stipulated for non-performance at the agreed time, a creditor who accepts late delivery without an express reservation forfeits the right to claim it. Site management must formally state this reservation upon handover.
How do you halt the calculation of delay days when change orders occur?
The contractor must provide written notice of the schedule impact for every addendum as soon as it arises. Under art. 365 CO, if circumstances compromise timely completion, the contractor must warn the client. Without a formal adjustment to the contract programme, the automatic deduction of a 500,00 CHF daily penalty becomes contestable.
Can a court reduce a daily liquidated penalty deemed disproportionate?
Yes. In accordance with art. 163 CO, the judge must reduce penalties deemed excessive. If a contract imposes, for instance, a 2 000,00 CHF deduction per working day on a 40 000,00 CHF joinery contract, this creates a manifest disproportion warranting judicial reduction.
Does the SIA 118 standard provide an automatic scale for contractor default?
No. The SIA 118 standard does not specify any automatic amounts or schedules for delay penalties. The parties must negotiate a specific clause in the works contract, ideally based on a fixed rate per working day and strictly capped at a percentage of the total price.
Securing your contract clauses before final award
Strictly capping delay penalties is a critical decision to safeguard the profitability of a general contractor or craftsman during a tender. An uncapped clause exposes the bidder to disproportionate deductions in the event of technical bottlenecks on the construction site. To delve deeper into the legal framework of Swiss construction contracts, consult our dedicated guides:
- Final Negotiation, SIA 1023 Contract Review, and Handover to Site Operations
- Explicitly Incorporating Standard SIA 118 into the Works Contract: It Is Not Automatic
- Auditing a Works Contract Form: Derogations Introduced by the Architect
- Unit Price, Lump Sum or Fixed Sum: Choosing the Remuneration Method Under Standard SIA 118
