Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: The informal commitment of unauthorised expenditure by field staff without managerial approval directly erodes gross margin. An unapproved extra cost in the range of 1'500.00 CHF to 4'000.00 CHF per incident may remain at the contractor's expense if site management refuses to accept the order under the SIA 118 standard.
- Legal / Joint / SUVA: Continuing a task despite serious danger to keep to a schedule leads to work being halted by SUVA. Under the CFST 6508 directive and the provisions of the Construction Works Ordinance, protecting health takes precedence over any cost or scheduling considerations.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Carrying out modified work without prior written agreement complicates drawing up the final account and delays acceptance of the work procedures under the SIA 118 standard, triggering legal disputes governed by the Code of Obligations (CO).
In running a Swiss construction SME, lacking a formal financial delegation matrix leaves supervisors stuck in limbo or leaves the business open to steady budget drift. When something unforeseen crops up on a structure, knowing whether the call rests with the foreman, the site manager, or executive management directly governs the final profitability of the project. Setting stepped tiers frees business owners from minor requests while keeping tight control over major financial commitments.
This operating protocol gives absolute priority to the physical integrity of all personnel on site. No profitability constraints or spending caps can ever restrict the immediate exercise of the right to stop work in the face of an identified hazard. Pairing financial thresholds with the safety STOP button guarantees site governance that complies with SUVA requirements and the BOSS method, giving teams clear structure balancing delegated autonomy and strict regulatory compliance.
How the escalation algorithm and decision logic work
The simulator runs on a two-tier sequential algorithm: a non-negotiable safety priority followed by an ascending financial threshold filter. This architecture puts into practice the MSST system principles defined by the CFST 6508 directive, placing occupational health and safety at the very top of supervisory duties.
The algorithm first evaluates the boolean variable tied to physical integrity. If a hazard to any person is flagged, the safety STOP decision triggers unconditionally, regardless of the expected financial impact. This provision aligns with art. 5 OTConst, which requires the employer to appoint a competent safety officer on every construction site empowered to give directives to workers. The right to stop a dangerous task belongs to every employee, from bricklayer to company owner.
Where no bodily risk exists, the engine calculates the financial allocation based on the tiers configured in the SME. The default thresholds are set as follows:
- Amount up to Threshold 1 (e.g. 500.00 CHF excl. VAT): direct decision by the site foreman.
- Amount between Threshold 1 and Threshold 2 (e.g. 2'000.00 CHF excl. VAT): decision by the site manager.
- Amount between Threshold 2 and Threshold 3 (e.g. 10'000.00 CHF excl. VAT): approval required from the owner or managing director.
- Amount above Threshold 3: formal written decision by executive management, with contractual notification.
Comparative matrix of decision-making authority by amount
The following table outlines the operational division of responsibilities within a firm of 5 to 50 employees for unforeseen work or adjustments on site:
| Commitment level (CHF excl. VAT) | Typical event type | Authorised decision-maker | Required decision turnaround | Required administrative process |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.00 to 500.00 CHF | Purchase of auxiliary tools, specific screws, small shuttering consumables | Foreman | Under 15 minutes | Signed delivery note with site code |
| 500.05 to 2'000.00 CHF | Short-term hire of a 1.5 t mini-excavator, replacement of a submersible pump | Site manager | Under 2 hours | Internal purchase order approved on smartphone |
| 2'000.05 to 5'000.00 CHF | Concrete overconsumption caused by trench collapse, extra truck rotation | Site manager in agreement with owner | Half a working day | Recorded incident report and costed internal sign-off |
| 5'000.05 to 10'000.00 CHF | Unforeseen local underpinning, heavy retaining shoring | Owner / Executive management | 24 working hours | Internal addendum and detailed technical report |
| Above 10'000.00 CHF | Discovery of an unmapped underground utility requiring complete diversion | Owner with written decision | 48 working hours | Written contractual addendum submitted to site management |
Full calculation example of an unforeseen commitment
During earthworks, encountering a soft spot with inadequate bearing capacity requires bringing in recycled gravel and carrying out extra compaction not budgeted in the initial schedule of work. The site manager breaks down the costs of the event:
- Supply of 0/32 gravel delivered to site: 1'450.00 CHF excl. VAT
- Placement and compaction work: 980.00 CHF excl. VAT
- Subtotal net of tax: 2'430.00 CHF excl. VAT
- Value-added tax (Swiss VAT 8,1 %): 196.85 CHF
- Total commitment decision incl. VAT: 2'626.85 CHF
In this example, the pre-tax amount of 2'430.00 CHF exceeds Threshold 2 of 2'000.00 CHF. The algorithm assigns authority to the business owner. The site manager cannot commit to the work alone: they prepare a supporting note before placing the order.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following figures and situations are illustrative examples designed to show how arbitration rules work inside Swiss French SMEs.
Scenario 1: Emergency stop for fall risk on a site in Nyon (Vaud)
On a residential vertical extension in the canton of Vaud, a team of six carpenters is working on the roof. During a gust of wind, part of the temporary guardrails comes loose, leaving an edge without collective protection. The scaffolding specialist demands a flat call-out fee of 1'200.00 CHF excl. VAT to attend within the hour.
The foreman spots the risk of falling. Even though the 1'200.00 CHF excl. VAT amount exceeds his usual 500.00 CHF excl. VAT threshold, safety comes first: the safety STOP button is pressed. Work in the zone is halted in line with art. 82 LAA, which requires employer and employees to cooperate on accident prevention measures. The decision to call out the scaffolding erector is approved by the site manager within ten minutes. Protecting life takes precedence over any schedule or budget pressure.
Scenario 2: Replacing a failed compressor in Meyrin (Geneva)
A Geneva-based masonry contractor with 18 employees is carrying out external works for a retail complex. The main site compressor suffers engine seizure. Two options are on the table: an emergency repair quoted at 1'850.00 CHF excl. VAT or purchasing a new unit at 8'400.00 CHF excl. VAT. Shutting down the sandblasting operation leaves four workers idle.
Because the estimated repair sits below Threshold 2 (2'000.00 CHF excl. VAT), the site manager signs off on the overhaul within two hours without bothering executive management. This avoids downtime for the crew while staying within their delegated budget.
Frequently asked questions
Who triggers work stoppage when serious physical danger arises?
Every employee applies the STOP principle. Under the Construction Works Ordinance, protecting life overrides financial considerations, with no prior debate over expenditure amounts.
Can a site foreman commit an expense of 800 CHF without approval?
No, not if their threshold is 500 CHF. They must refer to their site manager, who has an illustrative spending ceiling of up to 2'000 CHF to safeguard execution profitability.
How do you formalise an unforeseen overrun above 10'000 CHF on site?
The owner approves it with a dated written decision. This internal company protocol ensures fiduciary traceability and shields cash flow from uncoordinated budget blowouts.
How should a change order requested by the client be recorded?
Financial agreement requires contractual confirmation under the Code of Obligations (CO). For detailed costing and ACIP unit prices, use our dedicated tool on the Soumissions platform.
How do internal thresholds connect with occupational safety?
The CFST 6508 directive governs the duty of prevention. Risk assessment rules out any monetary trade-offs: securing a workstation must happen before construction work can resume.
Where should works acceptance and potential technical reservations be recorded?
Joint inspection minutes are standard contractual procedure. Tracking acceptance of the work under the SIA 118 standard is managed separately through modules on our Portail.
Handling technical and budgetary surprises relies on clear delegation of financial authority, paired with occupational safety requirements. To strengthen the overall organisation of your SME and master the day-to-day management of your construction sites, explore our specialised resources:
