Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Spending ten to fifteen technical office hours on an unqualified call for tenders represents a dead loss of around 1 200,00 CHF to 2 000,00 CHF per file with no guarantee of return, eroding the firm's overall profitability under the principles of the Code of Obligations (CO).
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Committing without prior analysis to a project with unrealistic health and safety constraints exposes the company to work stop orders from SUVA or the labour inspectorate, conflicting with art. 3 OTConst, which requires protective measures to be reviewed before signing.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Accepting a project file with one-sided contractual terms or excessive penalties complicates intermediate advance payments and stalls final financial sign-off under standard works contract rules.
In the French-speaking Swiss construction sector, the most common mistake made by SMEs with five to fifty employees is bidding blindly on every incoming enquiry. Site managers, business owners and estimators spend nights assembling full submissions for unknown clients or volatile intermediaries. The Go/No-Go grid serves as the initial operational filter of the BOSS method: in fifteen minutes, you can decide whether to commit estimating hours or politely decline the request, protecting internal resources.
This systematic approach checks the client's solvency via the debt enforcement register and Zefix, verifies whether the delivery schedule matches available crews, and flags specific technical risks. Unit prices are handled during detailed pricing on dedicated platforms, whereas this preliminary grid focuses strictly on whether to pursue the opportunity at all. By applying objective criteria the moment a file arrives, your SME safeguards its operating margin, avoids loss-making construction sites, and directs expertise toward value-generating projects.
Screening criteria of the pre-pricing Go/No-Go grid
Technical office time is a major direct cost for any Swiss construction SME. Committing ten hours of calculations without prior screening scatters resources and compromises ongoing operations. The Go/No-Go grid structures this initial review around objective criteria before you take off quantities or contact suppliers.
1. Verification of identity and financial solvency
Before opening a call for tenders file, check the prospective client's legal status on the central commercial register Zefix. For any corporate entity or private client, obtaining an extract from the debt enforcement register that is clean or shows a controlled history is essential. Requests from intermediaries lacking a clear power of attorney under the Code of Obligations (CO) must be set aside. The financial standing must confirm their ability to pay contractual advance payments throughout the construction site.
2. Technical feasibility, schedule, and internal resources
Your SME must assess whether it can realistically field qualified labor and equipment by the dates stated in the master schedule. A visibly unrealistic completion deadline leaves the contractor open to contractual penalties and disrupts crew rotations. Occupational health and safety rules—notably art. 4 OTConst, which mandates a written plan outlining safety measures before work begins—must be met without cutting corners on protective gear.
3. Clarity of the technical package and contractual consistency
An incomplete enquiry lacking a precise specification makes reliable pricing impossible. Missing working drawings or the lack of a geotechnical report for major earthworks sharpens the risk of subsequent disputes. Scrutinise the contract's special terms: one-sided clauses imposing payment periods beyond ninety days or disproportionate penalties warrant an immediate No-Go decision.
Decision matrix: incoming project evaluation parameters
The table below sets out the weighted criteria for the business owner or site manager to complete in under fifteen minutes to decide whether to continue pricing.
| Evaluated criterion | Green signal (Go) | Orange signal (Clarify) | Red signal (Definite No-Go) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Client solvency | Clean debt enforcement extract, confirmed solvency | Recent entity, substantial advance payment negotiable | Open debt enforcement proceedings, recent loss certificates |
| Tender deadline | More than ten working days to prepare | Between five and ten days with complete bills of quantities | Fewer than five working days for a complex project |
| Construction schedule | Timeframe fits current workload | Temporary peak requiring adjustments | Direct clash with signed priority construction sites |
| Access and safety constraints | Feasible protective measures under the OTConst | Complex site access, but budgetable | Technically impossible to secure crew safety |
| Contractual terms | Staggered thirty-day payments, regular advance payments | Guarantee terms to negotiate before bid submission | Abusive retainage clause, payment terms over 90 days |
Common qualification errors and their financial impact on SMEs
Chasing turnover for its own sake is the main trap facing growing businesses. Agreeing to price work simply as a "favour" to an architect or property manager without a clear mandate directly harms company profitability.
- Unqualified emergency pricing: Bidding on a request received on Friday and due by Tuesday leads to rushed estimates. Mobilising resources in this way wastes around 1 200,00 CHF to 1 800,00 CHF in technical office hours whenever the tender is unsuccessful.
- Accepting legally unbalanced contracts: Skipping a review of special conditions leaves the SME exposed to deferred payment terms. When there is no initial advance payment, your firm must fund materials upfront, locking up roughly 45 000,00 CHF in cash flow from the very first weeks on site.
- Underestimating site installation constraints: Overlooking public roadway permits or underground utilities during the pre-tender phase forces the site manager to reorganise the construction site in a rush, generating unrecoverable operating overheads.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following scenarios are illustrative examples designed to demonstrate how this decision method applies to typical project files in French-speaking Switzerland.
Scenario 1: Roof renovation in the Canton of Vaud
A roofing and sheet-metal work firm with eight employees receives an enquiry to renovate a rental building in Lausanne. The tender submission deadline is set at seven working days. The client is a real estate company registered in the commercial register for two years. The Go/No-Go assessment highlights the following points:
- Prior check: The extract from the debt enforcement register reveals two ongoing proceedings for a combined total of 18 500,00 CHF.
- Technical constraints: Access to the building requires placing scaffolding on the pavement, which calls for a municipal permit that the client has not yet requested.
- Final decision: No-Go. The site manager declines the tender, citing the lack of administrative permits for site setup and the inability to guarantee starting on schedule. The company saves eight hours of technical estimating work—worth around 1 050,00 CHF in office costs—and steers clear of serious default risk.
Scenario 2: Workshop renovation in the Canton of Fribourg
A masonry and reinforced concrete contractor with eighteen staff is invited to price new structural openings and slab reinforcement for an industrial building in Bulle. The projected works amount to around 85 000,00 CHF:
- Prior check: The client is a local SME established for fifteen years, with a clean debt enforcement extract. Zefix filings confirm stable management.
- Technical constraints: Structural engineering drawings are attached, access is unobstructed, and propping requirements are clearly detailed. The execution schedule fits cleanly into a planned workload lull six weeks out.
- Final decision: Go. The project ticks every green box on the grid. The estimator commits ten hours to prepare a rigorous quote, with a strong likelihood of converting the bid into a balanced works contract.
Frequently asked questions
Who fills out the Go/No-Go grid in a Swiss construction SME?
The business owner or site manager completes the grid in ten minutes prior to estimating. For a 150 000.00 CHF project, this step avoids sinking ten technical office hours into an enquiry without first confirming solvency under the Code of Obligations (CO).
What threshold score requires an outright refusal without pricing?
An overall score below seventy percent or a single red flag—such as active debt enforcement proceedings or access that cannot be made safe under the construction work ordinance—warrants walking away. This filter preserves capacity for profitable jobs.
How can you verify solvency without delaying bid submission?
Searching Zefix and reviewing public financial statements can be done the same day. For substantial contract amounts, requiring a debt enforcement extract or a bank guarantee before award protects cash flow under the principles of the Code of Obligations (CO).
Should you turn down a call for tenders if the study deadline is too short?
Yes, if the turnaround prevents checking safety under the construction work ordinance or reviewing special contract terms. Rushed pricing on an 80 000.00 CHF job routinely results in missed bill items that far outweigh the projected profit margin.
How do you turn down work from a recurring client diplomatically?
Citing a full order book protects commercial relations without hurting your firm's reputation. Proposing a later start date keeps the door open while filtering out a project whose contractual terms would erode your operating margin.
Does the grid apply to daywork tickets and minor repair jobs?
No, jobs under 3 000.00 CHF follow a streamlined path based on direct agreement on hourly rates. The full matrix is tailored for tenders and fixed-price contracts requiring hours of upfront preparation to protect your SME's bottom line.
Securing the order book through rigorous selection
Using a Go/No-Go filter transforms your commercial pipeline by protecting margins the moment an enquiry lands. To explore each organisational and contractual dimension of your firm further, consult the following resources:
- Client Selection, Go/No-Go and Margin Protection: The Sales Process of a Swiss Construction SME
- Floor Price Calculator and Negotiation Concession Matrix
- Why Turning Down Bad Projects Improves a Swiss SME's Net Profit
- Checking the Solvency of a Client or Property Management Firm: Debt Collection Register and Zefix
- Calculating Your Price Floor and Negotiating Trade-Offs: Schedule, Advance Payment, Alternative Solution
