Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: The lack of precise decision thresholds leads to procurement improvisations or unproductive hours, causing profitability drifts of around 4 500,00 CHF to 12 000,00 CHF per phase under the Code of Obligations (CO).
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Hierarchical ambiguity regarding the role of the competent person designated for occupational safety under art. 5 OTConst exposes personnel to serious breaches of SUVA and CFST directives.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Execution changes that are not tracked by intermediate management complicate the joint inspection during the acceptance of the work governed by standard SIA 118.
On Swiss construction sites, the SME business owner or the site manager frequently handles all technical and logistical decisions alone. This excessive centralisation paralyses progress as soon as demands multiply across multiple trades. Establishing a graduated scale with five levels of delegation allows you to assign a clear scope of action to foremen and chargehands, preventing recurrent downtime while maintaining thorough daily tracking of work on site.
This organisational framework structures operational autonomy, from strictly guided execution through to autonomous management of a production sector. It ensures compliance with occupational safety management as required by the Construction Works Ordinance (OTConst) and directive CFST 6508. Questions relating to quantity surveying are handled in the Soumissions workspace, while delivery report tracking is managed via the Portail.
Operational matrix of the 5 progressive delegation levels
Implementing controlled autonomy in the field relies on a clear demarcation of responsibilities between the site management, the site manager and the foreman. This progression is structured around five graduated tiers defining precisely who decides, who approves and who reports back. This framework ensures operational continuity without compromising technical standards or the safety requirements of the MSST system under directive CFST 6508.
For the calculation of unit prices, detailed quantity take-offs and full tender pricing, teams refer to dedicated tender tools, as these financial aspects fall outside field production management. Similarly, joint inspection reports, formal acceptance and the management of defects under standard SIA 118 are centralised on the execution tracking interface. Matters concerning collective labour agreement wage scales, hiring and employment contracts fall under human resources management, while technical drawing under standard SIA 400 remains the responsibility of the technical office.
| Delegation level | Field decision scope | Reporting and notification requirements | Role of management or supervision | Indicative financial commitment ceiling |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Level 1: Guided execution | Strict application of daily task sheets without altering operating procedures. | Prior notification of any discrepancy or doubt before taking corrective action. | Continuous step-by-step oversight and systematic visual inspection of completed work. | 0,00 CHF (no autonomous orders). |
| Level 2: Technical proposal | Identifying on-site bottlenecks, analysing causes and submitting adjustment options. | Mandatory prior approval from the site manager before implementation on the work. | Prompt assessment of proposals to prevent work station stoppages. | 0,00 CHF (approval required). |
| Level 3: Routine operational decision | Direct adjustment of plant and tools, and task reorganisation within the team. | Daily site log entry submitted at the end of the shift. | Weekly audit of production rates and compliance with standard trade practices. | Up to 500,00 CHF (consumables or emergency repairs). |
| Level 4: Sector autonomy | Direct interface coordination between finishing trades and local sequencing. | Structured weekly summary during the technical site meeting. | Verification of planning milestones and monitoring of overall labour budgets. | Around 500,00 CHF to 2 500,00 CHF (ad hoc tool hire). |
| Level 5: Delegated management | Full oversight of production rates, local supplies and team dynamics. | Escalation alerts only in the event of major deviations from forecasts. | Strategic supervision, monthly milestone reviews and formal debrief with executive management. | Written ceiling set around 5 000,00 CHF per event. |
Criteria for moving from one tier to the next
Moving from one level of autonomy to the next is never based on seniority alone. Evaluation relies on verified mastery of assembly procedures, reporting accuracy and the ability to enforce occupational safety and health protection measures. Under art. 5 OTConst, the employer must appoint a competent person for occupational safety and health protection on each construction site, with the authority to issue instructions to workers. Advancing to level 3 and above therefore requires full command of fall prevention regulations, hazardous substance handling and access route signage.
The business owner confirms tier progression after a documented probationary period across three consecutive construction sites. If recurring irregularities appear in daily site logs or if safety directives are breached, the employee is temporarily reassigned to the lower tier to review technical procedures.
Recurring delegation mistakes and impacts on profitability
The most common pitfall for SMEs is granting implicit freedom of action without formalising decision limits. When a foreman orders materials outside approved supplier catalogues or alters sequencing without sign-off, remedial work or excess stock frequently result in losses of around 3 200,00 CHF to 8 500,00 CHF per site.
Conversely, excessive decision bottlenecks held by the site manager paralyse production. Waiting on site for two hours to get approval to clear a skip or replace a power tool idles four skilled tradesmen, creating unproductive hours valued at around 450,00 CHF per lost morning.
A third error lies in confusing technical delegation with abandoning supervisory duties. Even at level 5, the general duty of care under the Code of Obligations (CO) requires the company to maintain regular internal audits and collaborative monitoring of site progress.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following situations represent sample scenarios designed to illustrate how delegation tiers operate in practice in the field.
Scenario A: Structural work and earthworks in the Canton of Vaud
On a three-apartment-block project involving fourteen workers, the site manager oversees two other operations in the canton at the same time. The site foreman holds level 4 delegation.
- Situation encountered: Uncovering an area of poor soil bearing capacity during excavation requires suspending the strip footing pour scheduled for that morning.
- Action taken: Under their level 4 authority, the foreman immediately secures the affected zone to prevent any ground collapse in accordance with the OTConst. They reassign the steel fixing team to the foundation slab prep for the adjacent building. They log the event and submit an inspection request to the site management and the geotechnical engineer.
- Economic impact: Avoiding site downtime prevents the loss of five hours of team production, preserving a labour margin of around 2 850,00 CHF while maintaining records compliant with technical requirements for the as-built documentation.
Scenario B: Roof renovation and sheet-metal work in Valais
A six-person SME works on the refurbishment of a steep-pitch roof in an alpine zone. The lead tradesman holds level 2 delegation.
- Situation encountered: Unforeseen deterioration of the roof boarding under the existing covering threatens the stability of the staging next to the eaves.
- Action taken: Lacking the delegation to change the installation procedure, the foreman stops work in this area in accordance with safety regulations. They propose two reinforcement options to the site manager via instant photo transfer and await written instructions before resuming.
- Economic impact: The prior assessment avoids serious accident risks and prevents installing unsuitable materials that would have required subsequent rework costing around 4 200,00 CHF at the company's expense.
Frequently asked questions
What level of delegation should be granted for emergency minor tool purchases?
Level 3 is ideal. The foreman orders directly from the local merchant up to a defined ceiling, around 350.00 CHF per event, and submits the signed delivery note during weekly timecard tracking.
Can a foreman authorise overtime on site?
No, this falls under level 2. Under art. 321c CO, overtime is subject to strict rules; the foreman suggests the schedule adjustment to the site manager, who retains sole authority to approve this extra work.
How should the right to stop work in case of serious danger be formalised?
This authority falls under level 5 without restriction. In accordance with the MSST system and directive CFST 6508, every employee must halt work whenever safety is compromised before alerting their line manager to secure the area.
What should be done if an employee refuses to take on a higher level of autonomy?
Advancing through tiers requires hands-on support. Keep them at level 2 with weekly checkpoints while scheduling targeted training modules to consolidate their technical expertise before granting direct financial decision-making power.
Does delegating tasks release the business owner from civil liability?
No. Even with operational level 4 in place, employer liability towards third parties remains fully engaged under the Code of Obligations (CO). The owner must prove that they selected, instructed and supervised their staff with all due diligence.
How often should site managerial staff autonomy levels be reassessed?
A biannual review is recommended for every site manager and foreman. During this review, management adjusts expenditure thresholds, technical validation boundaries and profitability targets based on proven field performance.
Introducing structured tiers of autonomy organises operational governance, cuts downtime and protects your SME's profit margins. To explore how to implement these empowerment processes and structure your field human resources further, consult our specialised guides:
- Empowering Foremen, Developing Multi-Skilling and Discipline on Swiss Construction Sites
- Safety Onboarding Process for New Hires and Temporary Workers (Day 1)
- Turning a Skilled CFC Tradesperson into an Autonomous Foreman
- Building Your Skills Matrix and Eliminating Single Points of Failure
- Express Onboarding of a New or Temporary Worker in Safety (D1 to D30)
