Skip to content
Website
Sign in Sign up
Practical guide

Solving Recurring Errors with the 5 Whys and Pareto

Eliminate recurring non-conformities in Swiss construction SMEs using the 5 Whys method and the Pareto chart in line with directive CFST 6508.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: Recurring forgotten tools or setting-out mistakes lead to non-billable returns to the workshop, reducing the operational gross margin by around 4% to 8% on every structure executed under a contract governed by the Code of Obligations (CO).
  2. Legal / Joint body / SUVA: Failing to carry out causal analyses on repeated anomalies breaches the employer's obligation to take the prevention measures required by art. 82 LAA and art. 3 OPA, exposing management to formal notices from SUVA or joint commission inspections.
  3. Administrative / Handover: Accumulating minor defects not resolved at the root delays the joint verification prescribed by standard SIA 118, holding up the release of final advance payments and unduly extending the commitment of completion guarantees.

In the operational management of a French-speaking Swiss construction SME with 5 to 50 employees, the chronic recurrence of the same technical and logistical incidents acts as an invisible drain on profitability. Whether it is repeatedly forgetting consumables in vans, a reinforcement layout mistake, or poor coordination with other trades, these anomalies are all too often handled in a rush without identifying their root cause. The quality approach built into the MSST system, formalised under directive CFST 6508, requires eliminating repetitive failures by relying on proven continuous improvement methods tailored to the practical realities of Swiss jobsites.

This methodological guide demonstrates how to combine the Pareto principle (the 80/20 rule) with the iterative questioning technique of the 5 Whys to establish lasting operational health across the firm's internal setup. By isolating the 20% of error sources that cause 80% of rework and unproductive hours, site managers and foremen implement robust visual operating standards. This structured approach eliminates hidden costs, protects the health of crews in line with occupational safety requirements, and secures overall profitability without adding to the administrative burden on construction sites.

The 5 Whys method: identifying the root cause on site

On French-speaking Swiss construction sites, the instinctive reaction to defective workmanship or a delay is often to blame the worker or address the visible symptom. This superficial approach guarantees the problem will resurface within a few weeks. The 5 Whys method provides a sequential, factual breakdown to trace the issue back to the underlying organisational breakdown.

To apply this method in a trade or construction firm, the site manager brings together the foreman and the installers involved as soon as the anomaly occurs. The questioning relies on measurable facts and strictly avoids personal blame:

  • Why 1: Why is the slab penetration leaking? Because the sealing sleeve was not fitted prior to concrete pouring.
  • Why 2: Why was the sleeve not fitted? Because the part was not available in the van during rebar placement.
  • Why 3: Why was the part missing from the vehicle? Because the picking slip was not handed over to the warehouse keeper the day before.
  • Why 4: Why was the slip not handed over? Because the foreman only received the blockout drawings at 17:30 on his mobile phone.
  • Why 5 (Root cause): Why were the drawings sent late without checks? Because the company has no standard milestone requiring blockouts to be approved 48 hours before structural work begins.

Eliminating the breakdown does not require reprimanding the worker, but introducing an internal document approval workflow. This formal structure aligns with the safe planning requirements defined by the construction work ordinance and directive CFST 6508.

Pareto principle: prioritising the 20% of causes generating 80% of losses

An SME lacks the resources needed to address fifty micro-anomalies at the same time. The Pareto principle allows management to focus its efforts on the critical core of failures. The analysis relies on collecting weekly non-conformity sheets and workshop returns logged by foremen.

Defects observed on the construction site are categorised objectively: tooling logistics, setting-out errors, lack of trade-to-trade coordination, non-conforming materials, or missing technical instructions. By quantifying the cost in lost hours and wasted supplies for each category, the firm consistently finds that two or three root causes generate four-fifths of the operating cost overruns.

Comparison table of recurring breakdowns and standardisation levers

Observed recurring anomalyApparent immediate causeRoot cause revealed by analysisCompany standard to deployWaste avoided (approximate magnitude)
Forgotten consumables or small toolsCrew inattention when heading outLack of a standardised load-out checklist per van typeWeekly visual inventory sheet mounted inside the vehicleIn the region of 4 500,00 CHF per vehicle per year
Wrong positioning dimensions on blockoutsReading error from a soiled paper drawingUse of an outdated, unsynchronised drawing revisionSingle digital filing system with rejection of obsolete drawingsIn the region of 8 200,00 CHF per core-drilling rework
Installation halted because substrate is not readyDelay caused by the preceding mason or plastererNo formal substrate acceptance procedure prior to dispatchAdvance substrate check sheet at D-2 completed by the foremanIn the region of 3 800,00 CHF in unproductive waiting hours
Damage to finished worksAccidental impact by a third-party contractorLack of contractually agreed collective protection measuresSystematic standardisation of protective tarpaulins and edge guardsIn the region of 6 100,00 CHF in unrecovered repairs
Prolonged waiting for hoisting equipmentCrane occupied by another companyTime slot scheduling not formalised during technical meetingsWritten booking protocol submitted to site managementIn the region of 2 900,00 CHF per week of downtime

Common methodological mistakes and economic consequences

Rolling out the 5 Whys and Pareto often fails when management confuses technical analysis with searching for a culprit. If site staff fear disciplinary sanctions, real incidents are hidden, preventing any organisational improvement. Management must foster a culture of factual reporting for variances.

A second error involves cutting the questioning short at the second or third tier of review. Stopping at "the equipment was defective" without asking why the periodic maintenance prescribed by the accident prevention ordinance was omitted leaves the company needlessly buying replacement equipment without fixing the underlying organizational flaw.

Finally, overlooking the financial quantification of anomalies prevents management from engaging fully. Half an hour wasted daily by a two-person installation team looking for drill bits or fittings adds up, over a two hundred and twenty working-day year, to more than two hundred unproductive hours. For a company with twenty workers, the total bill easily exceeds an amount in the region of 45 000,00 CHF of gross margin squandered with zero value created.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures shown in the scenarios below are illustrative examples intended to guide operational analysis within a construction firm.

Scenario 1: Finishing work SME in plumbing and sanitary installations in the Canton of Vaud

A Vaud firm of 18 employees is working on a new residential development of forty apartments. During the first two months on the construction site, the fitters face daily round trips between the site and the central depot in Crissier to pick up specific drainage fittings. Each run causes a two-hour loss for a van carrying two installers.

The site manager applies the 5 Whys method: parts are missing because jobsite orders are placed on an ad hoc basis without standardised parts lists. The Pareto analysis shows that this logistical oversight alone accounts for 72% of the team's unproductive hours on this project. The company decides to introduce pre-configured kit boxes tailored to each apartment layout, assembled at the depot 48 hours in advance. The cost of residual runs drops immediately from an estimated 12 400,00 CHF to less than 850,00 CHF over the remainder of the project, preserving the profitability of the works contract.

Scenario 2: General contractor for masonry work in the Canton of Fribourg

A Fribourg firm with 35 workers faces repeated rejections of fair-faced concrete works during joint inspections on rental housing sites in Bulle. Successive cosmetic repairs cost in the region of 28 500,00 CHF across three consecutive jobsites.

Causal analysis shows that surface defects stem from using unsuitable formwork release agents and inconsistent concrete vibration. By applying the 5 Whys, management discovers that auxiliary workers have never received hands-on training on adjusting vibrating pokers and simply grab whichever release agent container is most accessible in the van. Management standardises a visual operating procedure posted inside each equipment container and organises a forty-five-minute hands-on workshop. Surface defects drop by 85% on subsequent works, protecting the company from contractual disputes with the client.

Frequently asked questions

How do you link the 5 Whys method to directive CFST 6508 requirements?

Directive CFST 6508 requires methodical tracking of operational failures. A 5 Whys analysis identifies the organisational origin of an incident, preventing losses in the region of 350.00 CHF per stoppage and strengthening the trade business's MSST system.

What financial gain can be expected from applying Pareto to tooling returns on site?

Addressing the 20% of root causes eliminates roughly 80% of unnecessary round trips. An SME routinely saves an illustrative amount of 18 500.00 CHF per year by cutting unproductive travel hours and clutter in vans.

Who should facilitate the 5 Whys process within the operations team?

The site manager or foreman conducts this discussion on site with the workers involved. This pragmatic routine empowers team members without adding administrative friction, in line with SUVA safety regulations.

How can recurring anomalies be logged without increasing the administrative workload?

A simple standardised digital form accessible via QR code allows an issue to be logged in thirty seconds. Monthly analysis pools the data to address failures according to the Pareto principle and improve overall profitability.

Can the client levy penalties for repeated logistical failures?

Under the Code of Obligations (CO), performance delays may trigger the contractor's liability if a formal notice of default has been served. Preventing logistical bottlenecks protects operating margins and avoids complex financial disputes.

Where should contractual disputes or formal punch-list items at project completion be handled?

Disputes over quantities fall under tender negotiations, while reservations noted during verification under standard SIA 118 are managed using tools dedicated to the contractual monitoring of works handovers.

Applying the Pareto chart and the 5 Whys together turns daily disruptions into measurable profitability drivers for SMEs across French-speaking Switzerland. By eliminating the root causes of procurement delays and workmanship defects, site management protects the financial margin of every project while strictly complying with the prevention requirements set out in the Construction Work Ordinance. Methodically standardising your processes provides the essential operational foundation to ensure your internal organisation thrives amid the realities of the construction sector.

To structure your internal protocols and take the management of your company further, explore our dedicated resources:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.