Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Chronic vehicle turnover drift leads to massive unproductive hours. At a rate of two unplanned returns a week to fetch a forgotten tool and twenty minutes lost daily per installer, the direct loss regularly exceeds an order of magnitude of 25 000,00 CHF to 45 000,00 CHF per van each year, undermining the gross margin agreed in the contract for work under the Code of Obligations (CO).
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Structural clutter in a van hinders access to personal protective equipment and encourages carrying damaged, non-compliant gear. The employer breaches the preventive organisational duty set out in art. 82 LAA, while labour inspectorate or joint commission audits uncover overtime worked by crews forced to make up for these delays in breach of the Labour Act (LTr).
- Administrative / Acceptance: Lacking the right tools in the work area delays the completion of critical technical stages on the master schedule. These logistical shortfalls trigger work interruptions, leaving the firm exposed to notices of defects, contractual delay penalties, and postponements of joint inspection and acceptance of the work under SIA 118.
Among building trades contractors in French-speaking Switzerland, poor logistical preparation in the morning is a primary driver of disappearing operating margins. Systematically forgetting a core drill bit, a specific fitting, or a charged battery forces a crew of two or three tradesmen to halt work and make an unscheduled run back to the central yard or the builders' merchant. These return trips not only burn fuel and rack up vehicle wear, but also tie up a total hourly rate during which zero value is delivered on the construction site.
At the same time, cluttering screw boxes, consumables, and power tools haphazardly across trade van shelving creates continuous operational friction. Every fifteen minutes spent digging through the skip or cargo bed for a sealant cartridge or an adapter undermines the work pace and wears on the installers' nerves. Strictly implementing 5S storage standards and loading checklists permanently embeds the company safety system required by CFST 6508 while safeguarding operational cash flow.
Calculation method and operational formula transparency
Assessing logistical waste relies on breaking down unproductive hours and vehicle fleet depreciation analytically. The BOSS method applies a clear separation between unplanned travel costs and tool search time on site, in line with the rationalisation goals of directive CFST 6508 regarding occupational health and safety organisation.
Direct Logistical Cost Calculation Formulas
Calculating the annual cost of catch-up trips factors in the travel time of all vehicle occupants as well as actual vehicle mileage costs:
- Unit cost of one return trip:
Cout_retour = (Duree_h × Cout_horaire_equipe) + (Distance_km × Cout_km) - Annual impact of return trips:
Total_retours = Retours_mois × Cout_retour × 12 - Annual hours spent searching for tools:
Heures_recherche = (Minutes_jour / 60) × Personnes × Jours_an - Annual impact of van disorder:
Total_desordre = Heures_recherche × Cout_horaire_personne - Total annual cost of poor preparation:
Perte_totale = Total_retours + Total_desordre
The hourly rates used reflect the company's average daywork rates, which include social security contributions, depreciation, and overheads. For standard CLA wage scales or hiring, employers consult industry benchmarks on Jobs. For exact pricing of unit prices and tender breakdowns using standard item catalogues, the Soumissions platform centralises this data without affecting this internal workflow analysis.
Mobile Workshop Organisation Scenarios: Comparative Overview
| Operational parameter | Disorganised fleet | Intermediate organisation | 5S standard and sized bin racks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unplanned return trips per month | 8 trips | 4 trips | 1 trip |
| Search time per day per installer | 25 minutes | 12 minutes | 3 minutes |
| Unproductive hours per year (crew of 3) | 458,35 h | 220,00 h | 55,00 h |
| Annual mileage expenses (0,70 CHF/km) | 2 016,00 CHF | 1 008,00 CHF | 252,00 CHF |
| Total annual financial cost excl. VAT | 41 266,00 CHF | 19 808,00 CHF | 4 952,00 CHF |
Full Cost Example of a Poorly Fitted Van
Consider a crew of two installers in the canton of Vaud working 220 days a year. The van logs 5 return trips to the yard per month, averaging 1,20 hours, for a round-trip distance of 24 km. The consolidated hourly rate for the halted crew comes to 170,00 CHF per hour, with vehicle operating costs of 0,70 CHF per kilometre. Each worker spends 15 minutes a day hunting for consumables and tools, valued at an individual cost of 85,00 CHF per hour.
- Round-trip cost: (1,20 h × 170,00 CHF) + (24 km × 0,70 CHF) = 204,00 CHF + 16,80 CHF = 220,80 CHF
- Annual losses from return trips: 5 trips × 220,80 CHF × 12 months = 13 248,00 CHF excl. VAT
- Hours lost searching: (15 min / 60) × 2 people × 220 days = 110,00 working hours
- Annual losses from disorganisation: 110,00 h × 85,00 CHF = 9 350,00 CHF excl. VAT
- Total annual cost excluding tax: 13 248,00 CHF + 9 350,00 CHF = 22 598,00 CHF excl. VAT
- Swiss VAT (8,1%): 1 830,45 CHF
- Total operating expense incl. VAT: 24 428,45 CHF
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following scenarios are illustrative case studies designed for management analysis and do not depict real construction sites.
Scenario 1: Plumbing & Sanitary Installations contractor on major refurbishment (Geneva)
A Geneva SME with 14 employees runs 3 vans on refurbishment construction sites in dense urban areas. Each van makes 6 return trips per month because fittings or threaders were left behind, wasting 1,50 hours and 30 km in Geneva traffic. The on-board crew of 2 installers accounts for 180,00 CHF per hour. Searching for crimping pliers and tool inserts takes 15 minutes per installer each day.
The calculation shows an annual loss of 24 494,40 CHF excl. VAT per vehicle, or 73 483,20 CHF excl. VAT across the fleet. The company standardised its inventory using the BOSS method by introducing a morning restock protocol with labelled storage bins. This technical setup cuts return runs by seventy-five percent by avoiding congested routes, while preserving compliance with directive CFST 6508 regarding trip hazard prevention and clear walkways.
Scenario 2: General electrical contractor on new-build development (Fribourg)
A Fribourg contractor deploys 4 electricians on a multi-family housing scheme. Operating a roomy van that lacks partitioned shelving, the site foreman records 20 minutes spent sorting through bins per worker per day to locate cable reels, circuit breakers, and connection terminals. Unplanned runs back to the branch number 3 per month (40 km and 1,00 hour of travel time) at a joint hourly rate of 160,00 CHF.
The tool quantifies this drift at 25 660,80 CHF excl. VAT per year, of which 20 753,35 CHF excl. VAT stems purely from disordered storage crates. Management installed fixed modular racking with a dedicated spot for each power tool. This step eliminates falling objects during transport, makes everyday handling safer, and frees up the equivalent of two hundred and forty hours of direct production per year, all while upholding the SIA 118 acceptance standards managed on Portail.
Frequently asked questions
How should hours lost to yard return runs be booked in accounting?
Your fiduciary recommends isolating these non-productive hours in an internal cost centre. This avoids distorting the cost price of construction sites or measurements tracked in /soumissions/.
Does disorganisation in a commercial vehicle engage employer liability?
Yes. The Ordinance on Accident Prevention and directive CFST 6508 require firms to ensure proper cargo restraint to safeguard workers against injury during business journeys.
What financial payback can be expected from 5S applied to service vans?
Cutting tool search times by ninety percent on average saves roughly 14 000,00 CHF in billable hours each year for a four-person crew.
Can excess mileage caused by forgotten tools be written down?
No. The illustrative mileage allowance of 0,70 CHF per kilometre represents a direct net drain on cash flow that penalises operations and cannot be rebilled to the end client.
How can daily vehicle checks be formalised without adding administrative burden?
Displaying a QR code in the van takes the installer directly to a visual standardised list, integrated into the safety procedures mandated by CFST 6508.
What should be done if travel hours are contested by the client?
Contractual acceptances and disputes fall under SIA 118 within /portail/. Unplanned runs back to the yard remain at the sole expense of the contractor and cannot be billed as daywork.
Keeping indirect costs under control calls for steady operational discipline at your yard and out on the road. To reinforce your internal workflows and protect your margin, consult the following resources:
