Skip to content
Website
Sign in Sign up
Template and resource

Downloadable Template: Investment Assessment Grid (PDF / Excel)

Download our machinery buy, lease or rent assessment grid for Swiss SMEs. Free Excel & PDF templates to secure your construction site investments.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: A miscalculation between equity and bank financing ties up critical cash flow, generating an operating overhead of around 15 000 CHF to 45 000 CHF per year according to the Code of Obligations (CO).
  2. Legal / Joint / SUVA: Operating machinery without technical compliance or periodic testing breaches art. 3 OTConst governing the planning of works, exposing the business to action by the labour inspectorate and SUVA.
  3. Administration / Acceptance: Failing to track machine hours precisely in daily site reports blocks the approval of statements and delays verification under SIA 118 standard during the final account phase.

This master Excel workbook and its PDF guide help SME owners and site managers structure financial and operational decisions when acquiring equipment. The tool compares outright purchase, finance leasing with residual value, and short- or long-term rental by factoring in maintenance, insurance, and tax depreciation. It gives you an objective view of the cash flow impact before committing the company to a financial institution or Swiss hire company.

Used right from the planning stage or during fleet renewals, this template prevents the pitfall of excessive fixed overheads during winter downtime. It includes five operational sections: Readme sheet, Financial Parameters, Automated Comparison, Qualitative Matrix, and Control Checklist. For detailed earthwork quantification and earthmoving unit prices, management can turn to the dedicated tender tools.

Downloadable document — PDF and XLSX (18 kB)

Machine purchase, leasing, or rental — assessment grid

Get the document

Receive this document by email

Enter your address: the document is sent to you immediately. The link remains valid for 7 days. Your data is not shared with third parties.

Operational structure of the Excel workbook and PDF guide

The template consists of an XLSX workbook paired with a decision-making summary in PDF. Designed for SME owners, finance managers, or site managers, this tool is intended for use prior to any equipment investment, when drawing up the annual capital budget, or whenever a construction site requires specific lifting or excavation plant. The tool brings together five interrelated sections:

  • "Readme" sheet: scope of use, version history, macroeconomic assumptions, and a summary of statutory duties under the Ordinance on the Safety and Health Protection of Workers in Construction Work (OTConst).
  • "Parameters" sheet: input of core variables (interest rates, new purchase price in CHF, estimated operating life in months, Swiss VAT rate at 8,1 %, estimated residual value).
  • "Comparison" sheet: automated calculation model detailing monthly cash flows, maintenance costs, machinery breakdown insurance premiums, and tax depreciation for cash purchase, financial leasing, and operating rental.
  • Qualitative criteria: non-financial weighting matrix (internal mechanic availability, operational flexibility during construction site stoppages, supplier reputation, risk of technological obsolescence).
  • Checklist questions: verification list before signing the contract (return conditions, insurance deductible, transfer of maintenance risks, OMach compliance, RS 819.14).

Step-by-step instructions for the assessment model

1. Completing the "Parameters" sheet

First, enter the discounted net purchase price in CHF as well as the required advance payments. Next, enter the monthly rental rate quoted by your Swiss supplier, the minimum hire term, and the leasing instalments provided by the bank. Make sure to input the projected annual operating hours to obtain an accurate assessment of mechanical wear.

2. Cash flow analysis in the "Comparison" sheet

The workbook automatically calculates the total hourly cost price for each scenario. Outright purchase highlights the upfront cash outflow but eliminates financial interest charges. Leasing spreads the financial burden over the operating lifecycle while leaving maintenance obligations with your business. Rental transfers the entire depreciation and major breakdown risk to the plant hire company, in exchange for a higher unit cost.

3. Evaluation using "Qualitative Criteria" and "Control Checklist"

Each option is scored against non-monetary parameters: flexibility in the event of early termination, compliance with workforce safety standards, and guaranteed delivery of a replacement machine within 24 hours. The matrix helps management decide when the financial difference between two solutions is under 10 %.

High-risk practices and compliant commitment terms

Risky wording / frequent mistakeCompliant formulation or practiceWhy
Looking exclusively at the monthly leasing instalmentCalculate the total cost of ownership, including comprehensive machinery insurance, maintenance, and residual valueA moderate monthly payment can mask a high effective interest rate or contractually excluded service costs.
Entering into a long-term hire agreement without an inclement weather clauseDemand a suspension clause or reduced daily rates during prolonged periods of frostWinter construction site shutdowns turn idle equipment into an unproductive fixed cost centre.
Buying outright with cash to save on interest without a cash flow forecastDecide while preserving working capital equal to at least three months of operating expensesDepleting available liquidity puts the company in default under art. 102 CO when paying supplier invoices.
Neglecting a joint pre-hire condition inspection report when renting equipmentRecord a comprehensive photographic report signed by both parties upon deliveryThe lack of an initial inspection leaves you exposed to unilateral billing for regular wear and tear at the end of the project.
Failing to include the cost of fuel or specific consumablesSeparate energy costs by engine technology within the projected hourly machine rateFuel consumption variances across engine generations significantly alter actual annual operating profitability.
Treating the final book value as equal to the open market resale valueApply a conservative residual value benchmarked against Swiss used plant market ratesOverestimating the buy-back valuation leads directly to a write-off upon final disposal.

Financial errors locked by the document

Using the grid prevents three recurring management mistakes in Swiss SMEs:

  • Unplanned cash drains: an unbudgeted cash purchase of a 15-tonne excavator often locks up around 140 000.00 CHF to 190 000.00 CHF in equity, jeopardising payroll during seasonal downturns.
  • Uncontrolled rental cost overruns: extending short-term plant hire on a delayed construction site creates a financial overrun of roughly 25 000.00 CHF to 45 000.00 CHF compared to a suitable leasing contract.
  • Plant return penalties: failure to comply with the refurbishment standards set out in leasing agreements results in back-charges of 8 000.00 CHF to 18 000.00 CHF upon machine return.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures below are illustrative benchmarks intended to guide your management analysis.

Scenario 1: General masonry contractor in the Canton of Vaud

For the construction of a multi-family residential development requiring 18 workers over 14 months, management evaluated acquiring a self-erecting crane valued at 210 000.00 CHF brand new. The workbook indicated an anticipated utilization rate of 85 % over the next two years. The firm opted for a 48-month finance lease with a purchase option, safeguarding 180 000.00 CHF in working capital while maintaining deductible operating expenses on the income statement.

Scenario 2: Earthmoving and civil engineering firm in Valais

An 8-person SME carried out a 3-month rock stabilization contract. The job required a specialized compact short-tail excavator priced at 95 000.00 CHF new. The analysis in the "Comparison" sheet proved that purchasing or leasing would produce disproportionate depreciation charges relative to the subsequent order book. Monthly plant hire from a regional partner was chosen, capping total expenditure at around 16 500.00 CHF all-inclusive with zero residual commitments.

Frequently asked questions

What annual utilization rate justifies purchasing an earthmoving machine?

Under Swiss construction practices, an annual utilization rate of approximately 60 % justifies direct asset acquisition. Below 500 operating hours, hiring equipment on a project basis protects working capital without tying up equity, avoiding unnecessary fixed servicing costs.

How does an accounting firm handle leasing payments on the income statement?

For an artisan SME, monthly leasing fees represent directly deductible operating expenses. The asset is kept off the commercial balance sheet, optimizing your equity ratio to satisfy Swiss bank lending covenants.

Who is responsible for regular maintenance under occupational safety regulations?

Under the Construction Work Ordinance (OTConst), the employer must ensure that all operating machinery remains in flawless technical condition. For rented equipment, the plant hire company handles major scheduled maintenance, while the lessee performs daily visual checks and routine site inspections.

Can you recover input tax on equipment investments through leasing?

Yes, Swiss VAT at 8,1 % applies to each billed monthly instalment. The company reclaims this input tax on its standard quarterly return filed with the Federal Tax Administration, easing the tax burden without requiring a lump-sum initial outlay.

How should equipment choices be handled during an unexpected peak in activity?

Short-term equipment rental is the ideal option to handle temporary project spikes. It converts a heavy capital expenditure into a directly re-billable operating expense, eliminating the risk of asset depreciation or unproductive downtime in your firm's central yard.

Methodical investment appraisal and fleet management

The financial appraisal between buying, leasing, and renting determines how resilient your balance sheet is against market cycles. For detailed bill of quantities pricing and tender calculations, visit our tender section. To explore further practical resources for administrative management and cash flow monitoring in your construction business:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.