Skip to content
Website
Sign in Sign up
Template and resource

Downloadable Template: Margin Defence Guide (PDF)

Download the floor price and negotiation trade-offs Excel workbook to protect your Swiss construction SME's margins.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: An uncompensated 4% price concession on an offer of 250 000,00 CHF reduces net margin by around 10 000,00 CHF, leading to zero profitability on the construction site under the rules of the Code of Obligations (CO).
  2. Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Unilaterally reducing a quote without adjusting working methods leads to neglecting the safety measures required by the construction work ordinance, exposing the company to inspections by joint committees.
  3. Administrative / Handover: Giving in on price without formalising a written addendum on the agreed services complicates the joint inspection of the work under SIA 118 and leads to numerous disputes at the final account stage.

This operational Excel workbook structures the sales policy of SME owners, site managers, and commercial managers in French-speaking Switzerland's construction sector. Used right from the pre-award negotiation phase, this tool prevents granting arbitrary discounts when facing demands from the site management or the client. The model establishes the break-even threshold below which no works contract should be signed, sustainably protecting your business cash flow.

The document contains four coordinated sheets (Read-Me, Parameters, Floor Price, Trade-offs) that link every price drop to a measurable operational advantage, such as shorter payment deadlines, simplified access, or the client covering Site Installations. For accurate calculation of your unit prices and detailed quantities, refer to the dedicated tools on our platform.

Downloadable document — XLSX (11 ko)

Floor price and negotiation trade-offs matrix

Get the document

Receive this document by email

Enter your address: the document is sent to you immediately. The link remains valid for 7 days. Your data is not shared with third parties.

Architecture and operational deployment of the Excel workbook

The Excel workbook "Floor price and negotiation trade-offs matrix" is structured for direct use within building SMEs in French-speaking Switzerland. This technical xlsx template is managed by the business owner, the site manager, or the commercial manager during the final award meeting. Filled in prior to any order confirmation under the Code of Obligations (CO), it prevents margin-destroying spontaneous discounts. The workbook contains exactly four interdependent sheets: "Read-Me", "Parameters", "Floor Price", and "Trade-offs".

Column-by-column user instructions and operational logic

The tool is built around strict calculation rules, avoiding any commercial improvisation in front of the site management:

  • "Read-Me" sheet: This section records internal approval protocols, version control, and the company's commercial governance policy. It reiterates cash-flow integrity rules and the signatory's responsibility when approving a works contract.
  • "Parameters" sheet: Here, the manager enters the company's overheads rate, hourly markup coefficient, and applicable discount or rebate rates according to SIA 118. The tool locks basic assumptions, preventing any tampering during meetings. For baseline cost estimates and quantities, the user refers to the Soumissions tools.
  • "Floor Price" sheet: The quantity surveyor or commercial manager enters the total prime costs (materials, approved subcontracting, productive hours). The sheet applies the entered coefficients to calculate the zero-profit technical selling price and the absolute floor price. The manager checks the gap between the initial offer amount and this strict bottom line.
  • "Trade-offs" sheet: During discussions with the client, every price cut request is logged alongside a required concession: splitting advance payments, free provision of storage areas, or simplified site access. The user ensures that the financial concession remains strictly offset by an equivalent technical or financial gain.

Comparison table of negotiation postures

The table below contrasts common mistakes seen on site with compliant practices required by rigorous management in Swiss general contractor or trade firms.

Risky wording / frequent mistake Compliant formulation or practice Why
Granting a 3% commercial discount without asking for anything in return to win the contract. Making any 3% price reduction conditional on signing an accelerated payment schedule with bi-monthly advance payments. Preserves operating cash flow and secures working capital requirements without eroding net margin.
Accepting the 2% discount under SIA 118 alongside a ninety-day payment term. Contractually restricting the 2% cash discount to actual settlement within thirty days of receiving the progress claim. Prevents the client's unilateral enrichment through the contractor's short-term financing.
Lowering the lump-sum price while maintaining fragmented, urgent intervention schedules. Conditioning the price cut on full, continuous handover of work platforms phase by phase. Fragmented work creates idle transfer time that quickly exceeds the savings granted to the client.
Allowing the client to charge site utilities to the site-sharing account. Demanding free supply of site water and electricity as a trade-off for a price concession on the offer. Reduces unrecoverable site overheads that are often disputed during the final account under SIA 118.
Modifying the scope of work to lower the price without prior written confirmation. Recording the contract amendment under art. 6 CO via a written addendum defining the revised scope. Under art. 6 CO, silence implies acceptance only in strict situations; a written document rules out disputes on obligations.
Eliminating the profit margin just to keep a crew occupied during bad-weather periods. Applying the strict floor price and declining the award if prime costs and overheads are not covered. Financing construction sites at a loss depletes equity and accelerates SME insolvency.

Critical mistakes eliminated by the tool

Using this file shuts down three major financial leakages. The first is the "courtesy concession" at the end of a meeting: granting an uncompensated 15 000,00 CHF discount on a 300 000,00 CHF contract wipes out the entire expected profit. The second involves relinquishing logistical clearance conditions, generating demobilisation and remobilisation cost overruns estimated at around 6 500,00 CHF per uncoordinated deployment. The third issue is the open-ended extension of progress claim verification periods, costing around 4 200,00 CHF in bridging interest and administrative fees.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The following figures and situations are illustrative examples showing how the negotiation matrix operates.

In the canton of Vaud, a masonry company of eighteen employees negotiates the refurbishment of an apartment complex. Faced with a 12 000,00 CHF price reduction requested by the site management, the business owner uses the "Trade-offs" sheet. He refuses a pure discount but accepts an 8 500,00 CHF price adjustment in exchange for formal concessions: free use of the site hoist provided by the structural work contractor and dedicated storage space at the base of the building. Overall profitability is thus preserved.

Frequently asked questions

How do you formalise a discount agreement with trade-offs under SIA 118?

The price concession requires immediate written confirmation stating the agreed trade-off, such as raising an initial advance payment from around 10% to 30%. Under SIA 118, this written agreement binds both the contractor and the site management.

Can you reject a price negotiation without breaching talks under the Code of Obligations (CO)?

Yes. Under the general contract formation rules of the Code of Obligations (CO), a company is free to enforce its floor price against unilateral discount requests, offering a priced technical alternative instead.

What financial impact does an uncompensated discount have on a 100 000 CHF contract?

For an illustrative 100 000 CHF site with an anticipated 6% net margin, granting a 3% discount without any trade-off eliminates half the profit, representing a net loss of around 3 000 CHF for the business.

Where should operational trade-off clauses be placed in a Swiss SME's tender?

Trade-offs should be inserted directly into the special conditions appended to the tender. They clarify unhindered site access, the provision of site utilities, or the advance payment schedule agreed with the client.

Does a logistical trade-off exempt the contractor from OTConst safety rules?

No. Even if the client takes on certain access provisions, health and safety obligations under the construction work ordinance remain mandatory for the employer, who must safeguard crews across every work area.

Securing the profitability of your SME's offers

Systematic margin defence relies on inviolable financial thresholds and tangible trade-offs. To calculate quantities or evaluate unit prices, visit our dedicated section on /soumissions/. For joint inspection reports and reservations under SIA 118, proceed to /portail/. Finally, wage scales and recruiting can be accessed via /jobs/, while technical drafting is carried out on /plans/.

Deploy these operational tools in your commercial management:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.