Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Poorly targeted rework creates cumulative labor and material losses of around 3 000 to 15 000 CHF per recurring defect, wiping out your net operating margin under the general principles of the Code of Obligations (CO).
- Legal / Joint bodies / SUVA: Failing to identify the root cause of an accident or near miss breaches the general duty of prevention set out in art. 82 LAA, exposing the employer to directives from the labor inspectorate or SUVA.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Recurring defects delay the joint inspection required by standard SIA 118, holding up the final account and the release of retention money by the client.
On construction sites across French-speaking Switzerland, handling an execution defect or an equipment incident too often stops at fixing the visible problem without looking into the organizational cause behind it. This operational tool applies the 5 Whys method to move past the superficial symptom and trace it straight back to the process breakdown, whether an incomplete work order, an updated drawing plan revision delivered late or a missing quality checkpoint. In accordance with art. 3 OTConst on systematic planning of construction work to prevent accident and health risks, pinpointing the root cause lets you establish a definitive site rule that protects your crews and safeguards your margins.
Beyond organizational diagnosis, the calculator quantifies the true financial impact of rework by factoring in non-productive hours, replacement materials, additional van mileage and disposal fees. Project managers and business owners get a structured corrective action plan to assign a responsible person and set a realistic completion deadline. For questions regarding descriptive quotes or unit price calculations, please refer to the tenders section; this module focuses exclusively on internal standardization and defect prevention.
Calculation algorithm transparency and MSST integration
The processing module calculates the financial cost of site rework and evaluates the rigor of the investigation according to directive CFST 6508 on consulting occupational physicians and other occupational safety specialists. The method relies on a structured chain of cause and effect. To move beyond the simple symptom and reach an actionable organizational breakdown, you must complete at least 3 questioning levels. The identified root cause matches the final level entered by the user.
Loss calculations run in real time without sending data to a remote server, fully complying with Swiss data protection requirements. The total cost uses the following breakdown:
Direct rework cost = (labor hours × internal hourly rate) + lost materials + (additional kilometers × mileage allowance) + incidental waste disposal or equipment rental costs.
To determine actual cost prices during initial bidding, estimates should be run through the tenders tools. The internal algorithm applies a standardized travel coefficient and totals all pre-tax amounts before adding 8,1 % Swiss VAT.
Comparative structure of non-conformity parameters
The following table shows the types of failures frequently encountered during internal audits in French-speaking Switzerland; it does not constitute a contractual schedule of rates:
| Type of failure | Minimum causal depth | Primary cost driver | Logistical component | Type of corrective action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elevation layout error | 4 levels | Chipping and leveling hours | Van round trips | Update drawing plan distribution protocol |
| Missing slab blockout | 3 levels | Specialist mechanical core drilling | Heavy equipment transport | Pre-pour inspection checklist |
| Wrong render color applied | 4 levels | Complete rework of topcoat | Disposal costs to landfill | Sample approval form signed by client representative |
| Drilling through a plumbing line | 5 levels | Emergency plumbing repair | Urgent site travel | Prior scanning with rebar detector |
| Missing shoring under lintel | 3 levels | Site securing and structural rework | Certified hydraulic jack rental | Standardize shoring plan according to accepted trade standards |
Cost breakdown of an execution defect
Consider the repair of work damaged due to an internal coordination failure. The calculation of repair costs is structured as follows:
- Rework labor: 18 hours deployed at an internal operating rate of 90,00 CHF per hour, giving a subtotal of 1 620,00 CHF.
- Destroyed materials to replace: replacement purchases totaling 1 250,00 CHF.
- Additional travel: 80 kilometers driven at 0,70 CHF per kilometer, totaling 56,00 CHF.
- Disposal fees and sorting skip: 280,00 CHF.
- Net total excluding tax: 3 206,00 CHF.
- Value added tax (Swiss VAT at 8,1 %): 259,70 CHF.
- Total cost of non-conformity: 3 465,70 CHF.
For a complete advance cost breakdown per square meter or linear meter aligned with standard item catalogs, please use our dedicated tenders modules.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following two cases are sample scenarios built for educational purposes to apply the principles of directive CFST 6508 and the construction work ordinance (OTConst).
Scenario 1: Foundation raft water ingress in an alluvial zone (Canton of Valais)
On a construction site for three terraced houses in Sion, a masonry firm of 14 employees detects water seepage at a cold joint during groundwater table recovery.
- Why 1: Water is getting past the waterstop tape, which shifted during the concrete pour.
- Why 2: The waterstop bent over under the weight of wet concrete discharged from the skip.
- Why 3: No steel fixing clips were installed every fifty centimeters to keep the waterstop upright.
- Why 4: The formwork crew did not know the supplier specification for reinforcing the fixings.
- Why 5: The technical datasheet delivered with the material stayed in the site office and was never passed to the foreman.
Corrective action: Introduce a mandatory sign-off point in the foreman's site log before any concrete pour approval, combined with a distribution process for technical datasheets. Total repair cost using chemical injection is 4 864,50 CHF incl. VAT.
Scenario 2: Incorrect windowsill heights in an office building (Canton of Vaud)
While installing exterior window units on a commercial project in Lausanne, a joinery firm of 22 employees identifies a three-centimeter height discrepancy between the finished sill and project specifications.
- Why 1: The subframe was secured thirty millimeters too low on the rough masonry.
- Why 2: The reference datum line was not visible in this section of level 2.
- Why 3: The initial laser line was rubbed out when grinding the structural work and was never rechecked.
- Why 4: The installation crew did not have the optical transfer equipment to re-verify the level from the stairwell.
Corrective action: Equip every installation crew with a calibrated laser level and introduce a mandatory pre-check form for rough structural levels before any drilling. Reworking the fixings resulted in an internal operating loss of 2 107,95 CHF incl. VAT.
Frequently asked questions
Who should run the 5 Whys analysis in the company?
The site manager or foreman brings the crew together. Under directive CFST 6508, management leads the improvement process without assigning personal blame, focusing squarely on the organization.
How should non-conformity costs be allocated to a construction site?
The cost estimate includes rework hours and materials. The calculation leaves out detailed unit prices, which are handled in the estimating portal without modifying the original quote.
At what cost threshold should you use this method?
An estimated rework cost from 500 CHF justifies filling out the sheet. The construction work ordinance (OTConst) guides prevention to stop costlier technical mistakes from happening again.
How do you know you have really reached the root cause?
The analysis requires at least three logical steps. The root cause always points to a gap in instructions, tooling or internal quality control, never to an individual worker error.
What if rework delays site handover?
The contractual schedule falls under the contract for work pursuant to the Code of Obligations (CO). Tracking snags and formal acceptance is handled directly through our monitoring platform.
How do you link the analysis to QR code operating procedures?
The corrective action updates the workstation instructions. Immediate documentation updates ensure that all crews follow accepted trade standards on site.
Standardizing how you handle defects protects project profitability and strengthens your company's internal operations. To take your operational workflows further, explore our practical resources:
