Skip to content
Website
Sign in Sign up
Tool and user guide

Interactive Go / No-Go Scorecard Before Pricing a Tender

Assess a tender's profitability in 2 minutes before pricing it. Interactive Go / No-Go scorecard for Swiss construction SMEs and site managers.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: Mobilising 16 to 40 technical office hours on an untargeted call for tenders represents a pure loss of around 1 760,00 CHF to 4 400,00 CHF per study with no award guarantee, undermining overall profitability under the award rules of the Code of Obligations (CO).
  2. Legal / Joint body / SUVA: Committing without prior review of safety constraints violates art. 3 OTConst, which requires an employer seeking to enter into a contract for work and services as a contractor to examine, before concluding the contract, the measures needed to ensure occupational safety and health protection.
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: Accepting an incomplete or poorly coordinated file leads to disputes as early as joint verification, prolonging reservations and stalling the release of the performance bond under standard SIA 118.

In French-speaking Swiss construction, the most frequent commercial mistake is to reply indiscriminately to every tender request received by the firm. Pricing a full tender package takes between ten and forty hours of technical work, tying up site managers and estimators with real direct costs. When the success rate hovers around 20%, the business effectively funds five dossiers to win just one, which weighs heavily on its operating overheads.

This Go / No-Go scorecard allows the business owner to decide in two minutes whether a call for tenders is worth pursuing before committing to any pricing study. By weighting client solvency, clarity of contractual documents, site accessibility and internal crew availability, you filter out toxic jobs and protect your firm's margin.

How the screening algorithm works and calculation formulas

The scorecard relies on a dual mathematical analysis: a weighted multi-criteria assessment on the one hand, and the direct financial impact on estimating costs on the other. Processing runs entirely client-side in your browser, ensuring the strict confidentiality of your business intentions in line with the proportionality and security principles of the Federal Act on Data Protection (LPD).

Scoring structure and detection of deal-breaker criteria

The matrix includes ten operational criteria scored from 0 (unfavourable or unmastered criterion) to 5 (perfect match with operational capacity). Each line is assigned a specific weighting coefficient, for a cumulative total of 100 points. Two criteria carry deal-breaker status: the solvency of the client (verified via an extract from the debt collection register or financial statements) and technical feasibility regarding the availability of qualified teams.

The algorithm first checks for a zero score on any deal-breaker parameter. If one of these items receives a score of 0, the recommendation automatically shifts to "No-Go", regardless of the overall arithmetic result. In all other cases, the overall score is calculated using the following formula:

Overall score = 100 × Σ (Weight_i × Score_i) ÷ Σ (Weight_i × 5)

The resulting score, expressed on a standardised scale from 0 to 100 and rounded to one decimal place, is then compared against the thresholds configured by executive management:

  • Go (tender selected): Score higher than or equal to the high threshold (default value: 70/100). The detailed technical study can proceed.
  • To discuss (collective decision): Score between the low threshold (default value: 50/100) and the high threshold. The opportunity requires arbitration between the business owner and the site manager before investing technical office hours.
  • No-Go (formal rejection): Score strictly below the low threshold or deal-breaker criterion triggered. The dossier is politely declined.

Assessment of acquisition cost per job won

Pricing a tender ties up internal resources valued using the standard estimating cost formula:

Direct estimating cost = Estimating hours × Average loaded hourly cost (CHF/h)

This direct cost is then compared to the firm's historical conversion rate to determine the investment made to secure a contract:

Actual acquisition cost per signed contract = Direct estimating cost × 100 ÷ Success rate (%)

Comparative analysis table of tender profiles

This table illustrates the impact of assigned scores and financial parameters on the final decision across five tender profiles common in French-speaking Switzerland:

Reviewed tender profile Estimating hours Direct cost excl. VAT (CHF) Success rate Score / Decision Cost per job won excl. VAT (CHF)
Rental villa renovation (regular client) 8 h 880,00 45 % 84,5 / Go 1 955,55
Condominium (PPE) conversion (open competition) 16 h 1 760,00 20 % 72,0 / Go 8 800,00
Residential building (new client) 24 h 2 640,00 15 % 58,5 / To discuss 17 600,00
Public procurement tender without allowed variants 32 h 3 520,00 10 % 41,0 / No-Go 35 200,00
Industrial facility (questionable solvency) 40 h 4 400,00 12 % Deal-breaker / No-Go Not applicable

Step-by-step calculation example with VAT applied

A general contractor reviews a dossier requiring 18 hours of technical preparation by a project manager billed at an internal cost price of 115,00 CHF per hour. The typical conversion rate in this market segment is 25%.

1. Direct estimating cost excl. VAT: 18 h × 115,00 CHF = 2 070,00 CHF excl. VAT.

2. Value added tax amount (VAT 8,1%): 2 070,00 CHF × 8,1% = 167,67 CHF, rounded to the nearest 5 centimes according to Swiss commercial practice = 167,65 CHF.

3. Total estimating cost incl. VAT: 2 070,00 CHF + 167,65 CHF = 2 237,65 CHF incl. VAT.

4. Business acquisition cost incurred per contract actually won excl. VAT: 2 070,00 CHF × 100 ÷ 25 = 8 280,00 CHF excl. VAT (or 8 950,70 CHF incl. VAT after applying 8,1% VAT).

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures presented in the following cases are illustrative examples intended to guide the methodical application of screening criteria within the firm.

Typical Scenario 1: Timber vertical extension in the canton of Vaud

A timber construction firm in Vaud with 14 employees receives a call for tenders for the vertical extension of an office building in Lausanne. The client demands a tight completion schedule over the summer. Criteria analysis shows excellent solvency and prior familiarity with the site management. However, internal schedules indicate that installation crews are already committed to another construction site. The estimating workload is assessed at 22 hours at 110,00 CHF/h. The resource availability score is set at 2/5, but projected margin and client history yield an overall score of 64,5 out of 100.

The resulting status is "To discuss". After consultation, the owner approves the tender with a condition precedent regarding the start date, preventing an imprudent commitment that would have jeopardised operating profitability.

Typical Scenario 2: Commercial fit-out in the canton of Geneva

A plastering and painting contractor in Geneva with 8 employees is invited to tender for partition works in a shopping centre. The dossier requires 28 hours of quantity surveying and pricing. The client is a newly registered legal entity whose commercial register extract shows no financial track record. The debt collection register extract reveals several ongoing proceedings. The deal-breaker criterion tied to payment guarantees receives a score of 0.

The tool instantly returns a "No-Go". The business formally turns down the tender, saving 3 080,00 CHF excl. VAT in internal technical office fees and avoiding the risk of a major unpaid invoice.

00:00 - 00:15 AI Avatar: Spending two days on a tender that is doomed from the start costs your company over 1 700,00 CHF. Start screening your incoming files today.

00:15 - 01:10 Screen and Diagrams: Calculator demo: entering the ten operational scores, instant calculation of the weighted score and detection of deal-breaker criteria. View your actual cost per won contract based on your conversion rate.

01:10 - 01:30 AI Avatar: Stop leaving your tender responses to chance. Test the online tool and download your standardised analysis matrix.

Frequently asked questions

Who should complete the screening matrix in an SME?

The business owner or the site manager evaluates the job during a sales meeting. This joint analysis prevents spending around 1 760,00 CHF in estimating costs on a dead-end dossier.

How should the deal-breaker threshold on client solvency be set?

A score of zero on the debt collection register extract requires a refusal. Under the Code of Obligations (CO), the firm shields its cash flow against default before entering any contractual commitment.

Should you price a public tender without visiting the site first?

A site visit confirms technical feasibility. The Construction Work Ordinance requires examining protective measures prior to contract signature, preventing an estimated loss of 3 500,00 CHF on site access.

What success rate justifies investing 24 hours in pricing?

A historical win rate below 15% makes pricing unprofitable. The cost per job acquired then exceeds 17 600,00 CHF, which calls for a decline under the internal sales process.

How should excessively short contractual deadlines be handled?

An unrealistic schedule creates costly overtime under the Code of Obligations (CO). The score assigned to the scheduling criterion must halt the submission to protect the craftsman's gross margin.

Where can you find unit prices to build the quote after a Go?

The scorecard only qualifies business opportunities. For price series analysis, standardised descriptions and detailed quantity take-offs, consult the dedicated section at /soumissions/ without entering any price schedule here.

To structure your responses over the long term and preserve your firm's profitability, rely on complementary resources from our knowledge base:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.