Skip to content
Website
Sign in Sign up
Template and resource

Downloadable Template: Construction Site Qualification Grid (PDF)

Download our Excel Go/No-Go grid to qualify tenders in Switzerland, filter out loss-making bids and protect your construction SME's margin.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: committing 20 to 60 hours of unpaid estimating work to an unqualified project, resulting in a net loss of gross margin that can exceed 15% of the award amount under the Code of Obligations (CO).
  2. Legal / Joint committee / SUVA: accepting a construction site with unforeseen safety constraints under art. 3 para. 3 OTConst, exposing the firm to work stoppages ordered by labour inspectors or SUVA.
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: agreeing to non-standard contractual derogations, complicating the joint inspections and final account provided for by standard SIA 118.

This Go/No-Go scorecard template in Excel format (.xlsx) is designed for Swiss construction SME directors, site managers and estimators. Used as soon as a call for tenders or private quote request arrives, it structures a rational decision in ten minutes before committing the engineering office's estimating time. The tool assesses client solvency, execution schedule feasibility, description clarity, and logistical access constraints in urban or alpine areas.

The workbook contains three operational sheets: the "Readme" sheet outlining the commercial filtering methodology, the "Parameters" sheet for adapting weighting factors to your SME's profitability thresholds, and the "Scorecard" sheet calculating the overall opportunity score. This process prevents blind pricing on tenders lost in advance, preserves the operational capacity of installation teams, and safeguards operating cash flow.

Downloadable document — XLSX (10 ko)

Go/No-Go scorecard before pricing a tender

Receive the document

Receive this document by email

Enter your address: the document is sent to you immediately. The link remains valid for 7 days. Your data is not shared with third parties.

Operational structure of the Excel qualification workbook

The Excel workbook (.xlsx) is built for rapid decision-making within the technical office or management of a Swiss construction SME. Completed by the sales manager, site manager or estimator upon receiving a file, it prevents the dispersion of estimating resources. The document is structured around the three sections in its native matrix:

  • "Readme" sheet: defines internal rules of use, outlines the decision sign-off workflow, and sets warning thresholds for triggering a refusal to tender.
  • "Parameters" sheet: allows you to adjust weighting factors according to firm size, available production capacity, and priority selection criteria (target minimum gross margin, solvency, scheduling complexity).
  • "Scorecard" sheet: brings together the evaluation form with scoring inputs, automates the calculation of the overall weighted score, and displays the decision recommendation (Go, No-Go or Conditional Go).

Column-by-column instructions for the "Scorecard" sheet

The assessment is carried out methodically by filling in each column of the qualification matrix in sequence:

  • Column A (Criteria family): breaks the evaluation down into four areas (client solvency and profile, file clarity, technical feasibility and safety, schedule suitability).
  • Column B (Control criterion): lists operational checkpoints, such as a clean extract from the debt collection register, tender deadline compliance, or detailed quote accuracy by construction chapter.
  • Column C (Assigned score): manual input of a score from 1 (unfavourable / major risk) to 5 (compliant / controlled risk) by the evaluator.
  • Column D (Weighting): factor linked from the "Parameters" sheet reflecting the strategic impact of the criterion on final profitability.
  • Column E (Calculated score): automated formula applying the factor to the rating to produce the section's partial score.
  • Column F (Comments and justifications): record of factual points observed in the call for tenders documents or during the initial discussion with site management.

Comparison table of commercial qualification reflexes

Risky wording / Frequent mistake Compliant formulation or practice Why
Pricing without checking the client's financial health Require a debt collection register extract or bank payment guarantees Prevents payment defaults and cash-flow bottlenecks during execution.
Bidding on a call for tenders with an incomplete technical description Submit a formal request for clarification or decline the estimate A vague bill of quantities generates disputes over scope boundaries.
Accepting a tight execution schedule without checking resources Simulate crew workload and reject unrealistic delay penalties Risk of overtime surcharges and disruption to other construction sites.
Overlooking access or site installation constraints Verify site accessibility according to the Construction Works Ordinance Unbudgeted handling costs wipe out the gross margin from day one.
Tendering exclusively on lowest-price criteria Target files that reward quality and technical variants Avoids a destructive price war that fails to cover overheads.
Letting the estimator decide alone without management approval Set up a joint review between management and site management Mandatory alignment between company strategy and contractual commitments.

Fatal costing errors avoided by the scorecard

Using this scorecard systematically eliminates recurring pitfalls that drain the cash flow of construction SMEs. First, it eliminates the compulsive pricing of tenders where the firm has no realistic prospect of being awarded the contract: estimating a complex tender typically ties up 30 to 70 hours of in-house technical work, representing an unproductive overhead cost of roughly 3 500,00 CHF to 8 500,00 CHF per rejected submission. Second, it halts the signing of works contracts containing one-sided clauses on retention money under standard SIA 118, or site conditions that clash with occupational health and safety prevention measures.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The following scenarios are illustrative examples designed to demonstrate how the scorecard applies to commercial decision-making:

Scenario 1: Heavy renovation in an urban centre (Canton of Vaud)

A masonry general contractor with 22 staff receives a call for tenders to renovate an apartment building in Lausanne. The bill of quantities contains inaccurate quantities and an imposed four-month schedule, with no dedicated municipal public-land storage area. In the scorecard, the logistical access criterion scores 1/5 and description clarity scores 2/5. With an overall score of 48/100, below the minimum floor of 65/100 set in the "Parameters" sheet, management immediately issues a "No-Go". The firm saves 40 hours of technical estimation and steers clear of a site prone to contractual delay penalties.

Scenario 2: Commercial workshop construction (Canton of Fribourg)

A Steel Construction firm of 14 people is consulted by a private client for a 1 200 m² load-bearing structure. Solvency checks via Zefix and the debt collection register confirm a sound financial standing. Architectural drawings are comprehensive and site access is clear. The scorecard calculates a weighted total of 84/100 (a firm "Go"). The company launches detailed estimating, negotiates a contract based on standard SIA 118, and secures a gross margin aligned with its financial year targets.

Frequently asked questions

Who should fill out the Go/No-Go grid upon receiving a call for tenders?

The site manager or estimator completes the pre-assessment in ten minutes. The business owner then steps in if the opportunity score drops below 70%, preserving internal estimating resources.

How should excessive delay penalties in special contract conditions be handled?

Under art. 163 CO, a court may reduce excessive penalties. Upfront, the scorecard treats this risk as a disqualifying factor if the requested sum threatens the trade contractor's cash flow.

What is the average cost of estimating a complex tender fruitlessly for an SME?

A detailed estimate often ties up 15 to 40 hours of skilled work, representing an indicative cost of 1 500,00 CHF to 4 200,00 CHF with no award guarantee for the contractor.

Can you decline to bid on a cantonal public procurement tender?

Yes, there is no legal obligation to bid on a simap.ch notice. The firm simply notifies the contracting authority of its withdrawal due to workshop capacity or incompatible completion deadlines.

Where can pricing ratios and wage scales be found to finalise an offer?

Full unit prices calculations are handled on our dedicated platform, while collective agreement minimum wages should be verified in our careers section before final sign-off.

Methodical file qualification secures the profitability of craft and trade SMEs in Western Switzerland by preventing technical offices from burning out on financially unviable projects. Joint inspection records under standard SIA 118 are managed in the operations portal, while quantity take-offs are run in our quote tool. To reinforce your commercial workflows and analytical tools, explore the following resources:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.