Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 238Certification, measurement and acceptance dossierChapter 6 of 10 in the section

Acceptance with reservations: failed links, deadline and retention

Faced with IT cabling measurements showing a few non-compliant links, the telematics technician and the site management must formalise acceptance without bringing the construction site to a standstill. This chapter details the technical qualification of defects, the precise drafting of the minutes according to standard SIA 118, setting a realistic rectification deadline and calculating a proportionate financial retention.

Key takeaways

  • Three defective links out of one hundred and twenty constitute a minor defect that does not prevent acceptance of the work.
  • Standard SIA 118 requires every reservation to be recorded explicitly and verifiably in the minutes.
  • The rectification deadline must take into account site access constraints and necessary restockings.
  • The financial retention on the final invoice must remain strictly proportionate to the foreseeable cost of rectification.

Qualify the technical defect and formalise acceptance subject to reservations

During the acceptance testing of copper or fibre-optic IT cabling comprising one hundred and twenty links, the appearance of three links reported as failed by the certifier does not justify refusing the entire work. The installation fulfils its overall function for more than ninety-seven percent of its capacity. In Swiss construction site practice, the site management and the telematics technician distinguish between a redhibitory defect making operation impossible and a secondary, localised defect. The work is therefore accepted, but this acceptance must be accompanied by written technical reservations preventing the full release of the contractor's contractual obligations.

Each rejected link must be subject to a precise record taken directly from the cabling certifier's test report. A vague entry on the acceptance document is not sufficient. The minutes must formally identify the patch panel, port number, terminal outlet in the workspace, and the technical reason for the rejection measured during the test: excessive near-end crosstalk (NEXT), non-compliant return loss, or pair reversals on the RJ45 modular jack. This traceability prevents any subsequent dispute regarding the exact scope of the non-conformity.

Typology of reservations identified on RJ45 copper cabling
Link identifierMeasured defectOperational impactClassification
Link R01-P14Exceeding NEXT marginPotential throughput drop on 10 Gbit/sMinor defect with reservation
Link R01-P48Broken continuity on pair 7-8Inactive link, no PoEMinor defect with reservation
Link R02-P03Return loss out of specificationHigh-frequency signal instabilityMinor defect with reservation
Acceptance reservation
Formal entry recorded in the acceptance minutes according to standard SIA 118, noting an execution discrepancy relative to contractual requirements without preventing the general use of the work.

Set the intervention deadline, financial retention and clear reservations

Entering a reservation without a precise schedule generates disputes during the final account. The acceptance minutes must jointly set a deadline for clearing defects. Under the Code of Obligations (CO), the client has clear prerogatives regarding defects in the work, notably rectification, as provided for in art. 368 CO. An execution period of ten to twenty working days constitutes standard practice in French-speaking Switzerland. This period allows the electrician the time required to dismantle faceplates, re-trim the cable, crimp a new connector, or pull a new conductor if the initial pulling damaged the outer jacket.

  1. Joint inspection record and costingRecord the three failed links in the minutes with their precise identifiers and estimate the cost of the remedial work.
  2. Notification of the deadlineSet a firm cut-off date in the acceptance document for carrying out the remedial work and providing the new measurements.
  3. Application of the financial retentionWithhold a proportionate amount on the closing account until validated compliance certificates are submitted.
  4. Formal clearingSubmit the compliant (Pass) certification report generated by the test instrument and sign the reservation clearance slip to release the balance.

As soon as the remedial work is completed, the telematics technician performs a new complete measurement using a standard class certifier. The timestamped measurement file is transmitted to the site management in a secure electronic format. The issuance of this document certifies that the defect has been rectified, validates the start of the two-year warranty period according to standard SIA 118 for the repaired sections, and triggers the immediate release of the funds withheld on the final invoice.

Defect classification and admission of the work under standard SIA 118

On a structured cabling installation comprising one hundred and twenty Class Ea copper links, identifying three failed links during the certification campaign does not constitute grounds for refusing the work. Standard SIA 118 clearly distinguishes a major defect, which renders the work unfit for the agreed use, from a minor defect that does not prevent the premises from being used. The infrastructure remains functional for more than ninety-seven percent of workstations. Consequently, the client cannot issue an overall refusal of handover.

Accepting the work without reservations would release the telematics technician from liability for defects apparent upon inspection, pursuant to the principle established in CO. The site management must therefore record formal acceptance while entering precise written reservations in the minutes. This document seals the transfer of risks and marks the start of the warranty periods for all one hundred and seventeen compliant links, whilst maintaining the obligation to rectify the three failed links.

To protect both parties' rights, the technical cause of the rejection must be recorded in the protocol. The three defective links are generally compromised by excessive local crosstalk at an RJ45 jack, a screen continuity fault, or an exceeded bend radius at the bottom of the trunking. The network electrician uses the complete reports from the certifier to carry out targeted remediation, without re-inspecting the entire construction site.

Wording of reservations, proportionate retention and joint clearing

A vague reservation mentioning non-functional IT cabling exposes the installer to an unfair financial freeze and deprives the client of an effective lever for action. The identification must be rigorous: identification of the floor distributor, patch panel, port number, terminal outlet in the office concerned, and the measurement failed by the certification instrument.

Example of joint recording of reservations on copper links
Targeted linkRoom / OfficeCertifier anomalyAgreed corrective actionFixed deadline
Link R02-P14Bldg. A, Office 204Return Loss failureRework termination on female RJ45 jack at patch panel side10 working days
Link R02-P48Bldg. A, Office 212Broken screen continuity (Shield)Check earth contact on wall socket and rework shielding10 working days
Link R03-P06Bldg. A, Meeting roomNEXT failure (near-end crosstalk)Excessive untwisting identified: re-trim and re-insert Keystone jack10 working days

The retention amount on the final invoice must remain proportionate to the identified technical defect, in keeping with the spirit of art. 368 CO which governs the client's rights in the event of defects in the work. Freezing an entire monthly valuation or the full balance of a telematics trade package for three defective connectors breaches the rules of good faith. Accepted practice in Switzerland consists of retaining an amount covering the actual cost of remediation by a third party, plus a safety margin for administrative procedures.

  1. Written notification of the rectification deadlineThe site management and the site supervisor agree on a realistic deadline in the minutes, generally between ten and fifteen working days, taking into account access to the offices.
  2. Targeted intervention and re-measurementThe telematics technician carries out the physical repair of the cabling, conducts a new full test with the calibrated certifier, and exports the raw trace of the corrected link.
  3. Updating as-built documentation and releasing retentionThe corrected measurement report replaces the failed sheets in the as-built documentation binder. The joint signing of the reservation clearance slip authorises the immediate payment of the retained amount.

Exceeded deadline and dispute over defective links: the procedure to follow

When the deadline set in the acceptance minutes expires without the three affected copper or fibre links being brought into technical conformity, the situation escalates into an execution dispute. Under standard SIA 118, minor defects that do not prevent the normal operation of the IT network do not authorise the client to revoke overall acceptance of the installation. Faced with an unresponsive installer or telematics technician, the client applies CO by setting a reasonable written deadline to clear the defects, with notice that upon expiry, the rectification will be entrusted to a third party at the contractor's expense and risk.

  1. Notice of default and written notificationNotify the expiry of the deadline agreed in the minutes. Demand the submission of compliant measurement traces for the three failed links within ten working days.
  2. On-site joint inspectionConnect the cabling certifier in the presence of the site management. Identify the exact anomaly: poor termination on the patch panel or physical crushing of the cable inside the conduit.
  3. Substitution limited to the retained amountInstruct a third-party network contractor to terminate the connectors or pull new conductors, charging the intervention against the retention without affecting the main balance.

Disputes frequently concern the management of financial flows during the final account. Under art. 368 CO, the client has the right to demand rectification of the defective work. However, this legal right does not permit freezing payment for the one hundred and seventeen links accepted without reservation. The agreed financial retention must remain equitable and proportionate: it covers the estimated cost of replacing RJ45 jacks, reworking the shielding, or pulling new cables through conduits if required. As soon as the new analysis reports confirm the conformity of crosstalk and return loss parameters, the deposited sum is paid out to the installer.

Frequently asked questions

Do three non-compliant links out of one hundred and twenty justify a total refusal of acceptance?

No. If the network remains globally usable for the end user, acceptance of the work is declared with reservations according to standard SIA 118. The isolated failure of 2.5% of outlets constitutes a minor defect that does not disrupt building operations. The minutes precisely record the failed port numbers, set a rectification deadline, and establish a targeted financial retention solely on those links, without freezing the rest of the work.

What amount of financial retention should be applied for three non-compliant RJ45 links?

The financial retention must remain proportionate to the actual cost of rectification. An arbitrary percentage of the entire construction site is never withheld. A lump-sum amount is generally retained covering outlet dismantling, new connectivity, technician labour for termination and Fluke recertification, plus a contingency for pulling replacement cable through conduit if needed. This sum, recorded in the acceptance minutes, protects the client without unfairly straining the installer's cash flow.

What deadline should be granted to the installer to correct the failed links?

The deadline for clearing reservations is negotiated during the joint acceptance inspection, usually between ten and twenty working days. This timeframe allows the telematics technician to diagnose the anomaly with the certifier, order any replacement module, redo the terminations, and generate the new test report. If the building is to be occupied immediately, an intervention within forty-eight hours may be required for outlets serving critical network equipment.

What should be done if the measurement failure stems from a conduit crushed by another trade?

The installer must locate the break using the fault distance measurement displayed by the cabling certifier. If the test reveals physical crushing or drilling damage away from the patch panel, the reservation is reclassified. The telematics technician notifies the site management: rectification no longer falls under their contractual warranty but constitutes additional work to be charged to the trade responsible for damaging the conduit.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 118General conditions for construction works (acceptance of the work, notice of defects, and exercise of warranty rights).
  • CODelay and foreseeable defective execution: setting a deadline to eliminate defects and third-party execution at the contractor's expense.
  • CO art. 368Client's rights in the event of defects in the work: rectification, price reduction, or damages.

In the same section