Key takeaways
- The lack of a waterproofing collar at the drain connection causes diffuse infiltrations under the screed.
- Technical diagnosis localizes the waterproofing failure via colorimetric tracing and targeted probing of the siphon.
- The SIA 118 standard qualifies this defect as a hidden defect subject to the obligation of complete repair.
- The repair requires the complete removal of the tiling to restore continuity according to the SIA 248 standard.
Infiltration trajectory and diagnosis of an unsealed floor penetration
The connection between the drain body installed by the sanitary installer and the waterproofing system under tiling applied by the tiler constitutes the most vulnerable point of a walk-in shower. Omission of the fabric-reinforced elastomeric waterproofing flange or its simple superficial gluing without smoothing into the liquid resin produces a fatal discontinuity. Every time the shower is used, water that naturally infiltrates through the porosity of the cement joints trickles down the waterproofing membrane. Reaching the siphon level, in the absence of a sealed collar sandwiching the clamping plate, this water rushes directly between the discharge sleeve and the screed recess.
Water does not flow vertically in an immediate manner. It first accumulates within the thickness of the screed and the underlying acoustic insulation, creating a liquid reservoir invisible for several weeks. Guided by the uncoupling polyethylene film or by the slope of the compression slab, the damp layer migrates horizontally. It eventually encounters a technical duct penetration, a structural crack or the end of a load-bearing wall, causing moisture halos, paint blistering and mold on the ceiling of the apartment on the floor below, often several meters away from the exact vertical of the shower.
- Hygrometric examination and temporal correlationNon-destructive measurement by dielectric probe of the walls and ceiling at the neighbor's below to delimit the extent of the damp plume and comparison with the occupancy rhythm of the incriminated bathroom.
- Pressure testing and isolation of pipesManometric pressure test on the sanitary water supply network by the installer to formally rule out any leak on the concealed hot or cold water pipes.
- Sectorized watering test and colorimetric tracingTemporary plugging of the drainage grid and standing water test of the shower area using fluorescein (uranine), supplemented by targeted watering of the wall joints and the peripheral drain area.
- Destructive probing of the drainage collarSelective removal of the grid and tiles surrounding the siphon to inspect the connection between the drainage body and the liquid layer; visual observation of the absence of a waterproof collar or its delamination.
Warranty regime according to the SIA 118 standard and full repair protocol
When the claim arises six months after moving in, the work has already been the subject of a tacit or formal acceptance. Under the regime of the SIA 118 standard, the absence of a waterproofing component concealed under the ceramics typically constitutes a defect that could not be detected during a regular examination at the time of delivery. Upon discovery of the halo on the lower ceiling, the client notifies the defect by a formal notice. The tiler contractor is then required to eliminate the defect at their own expense as part of their warranty for hidden defects.
Local remedial work proves technically impossible in the vast majority of cases. The SIA 248 standard requires absolute continuity of the waterproofing system under tiling with minimum overlaps of five centimeters for strips and mats, and perfect bridging on vertical upstands. Cutting four tiles around a siphon to glue a collar a posteriori onto an existing membrane soiled with adhesive and moisture permanently compromises the adhesion of the waterproofing bridge. Furthermore, the cement screed saturated with residual water blocks drying and promotes the alkaline degradation of new adhesives.
| Repair phase | Operations on the construction site | Technical compliance requirements |
|---|---|---|
| Demolition and remediation | Chipping off floor tiles, cutting wall tiles to a height of 50 cm, evacuating the wet screed | Exposing the concrete slab; decontamination of surfaces affected by mold |
| Technical drying | Installation of condensation dehumidifiers and dry air blowing turbines under the slab | Control of the residual moisture of the substrate according to the tolerances required before repair |
| Reconstruction of the assembly | Pouring a new sloping screed, integrating a certified waterproofing collar at the siphon | Connection of the flange to the liquid waterproofing according to the instructions of the SIA 248 standard |
| Finishes and restoration | Glued installation of tiling, water-repellent jointing and repair of ceiling paints at the neighbor's | Full coverage by the company's civil liability of direct and indirect damages |
Sanitary-tiler interface according to the SIA 248 standard and qualification of the defect
The connection between the drainage element and the liquid waterproofing system under tiling constitutes the most vulnerable singular point of a shower without a shower tray. Technical expertise conducted six months after handing over the keys demonstrates a hydraulic barrier rupture: the drainage box installed in the screed contained no elastic bridging device, the tiler having confined themselves to applying their resin directly against the plastic rim of the riser without interposing the prescribed waterproofing collar. Runoff water crossed the porous mortar tile joint, saturated the adhesive-mortar bed and then traveled freely under the waterproofing to the gap surrounding the exhaust pipe. For the co-owner on the floor below, the infiltration resulted in massive degradation of the plasterboard false ceiling and embedded mold right against the concrete slab.
In Swiss construction, the rules of the trade codified by the SIA 248 standard dictate that every pipe penetration and floor drain must undergo a waterproof connection using a manufactured elastomer collar provided with a non-woven fleece. The sanitary installer ensures the leveling and fixing of the drain body in the floor recess, while the tiler assumes the integration of the collar into their surface waterproofing. By accepting the substrate to apply their waterproofing system without demanding or installing the collar compatible with the drainage model, the tiler commits a direct execution defect. The connection defect falls under the technical responsibility of the tiling company, as it was their duty to interrupt their work before gluing if the flange or waterproof collar was missing.
Execution of the full repair and warranty closure according to the SIA 118 standard
Upon notification of the damage by the client, the defect regime defined by the SIA 118 standard requires the contractor to remedy the poor workmanship at their own expense. Construction-wise, a partial connection limited to the immediate area of the drain is technically excluded. The adhesion of a new resin on a waterproofing system under tiling soiled by soap residues, body grease and stagnant moisture cannot be guaranteed. Moreover, the water infiltrated under the tiling has propagated within the thickness of the screed over the entire surface of the shower cubicle. The intervention requires the complete demolition of the floor tiling, chipping off adhesive residues, removal of the first row of wall tiles, technical drying of the screed under residual moisture rate control, and then the methodical reconstruction of the waterproof tub.
| Intervention step | Technical requirement on site | Reference rule of the trade |
|---|---|---|
| Removal and stripping | Evacuation of floor tiling and mechanical elimination of adhesive residues without cracking the screed | Directives of the SIA 248 standard |
| Controlled drying | Placing under dehumidifiers until permissible residual moisture is achieved | Control before installation according to trade practices |
| Collar integration | Gluing the flexible elastomer flange to the siphon collar with careful smoothing without folds | Drain manufacturer's instructions and SIA 248 |
| Application of the waterproof system | Double crossed layer of liquid resin or glued mat with a minimum wall upstand of 15 cm | Minimum thickness compliant with the SIA 248 standard |
| Retiling and joints | Lining with water-resistant adhesive mortar, water-repellent joints and corner sealing with elastic sealant | Execution rules of the SIA 248 standard |
Before installing the new ceramic cladding, a water test of at least 24 hours with the siphon plugged validates the perfect hermeticity of the remediated shower tray. At the end of the work, the acceptance of the repair is recorded in an addendum to the report according to the SIA 118 standard. This document expressly mentions the services redone at no additional cost for the client, settles claims relating to the claim and triggers the renewal of the warranty period on the fully redone parts of the work. Compensation for consequential damages suffered by the underlying dwelling is transmitted to the company's professional civil liability insurance, thus relieving the owner of the costs of restoring the neighbor's painting and plastering.
Interface dispute management and conservatory measures in the event of a claim
When water damage occurs at the lower neighbor's six months after delivery and the origin is located around the shower drainage body, disputes between the sanitary installer and the tiler frequently block the resumption of work. If the sanitary installer maintains that their siphon or flanged channel was installed according to the rules of the trade and the tiler contests the absence of a waterproofing collar or rejects the blame on the assembly of the clamping ring, the client can order an investigative measure without waiting for the outcome of the disputes. The SIA 118 standard governs the duties of the parties when a defect occurs during the warranty period: the implicated contractor must immediately examine the notified defect and take a position. If the tiler refuses to intervene on the grounds of shared or exclusive responsibility of the sanitary installer, the client is entitled to have the repair work carried out by a third-party company at the expense of the initial liable party.
- Immediate joint inspection recordSummoning the site management, the sanitary trade and the respective civil liability insurers on site to carry out a documented destructive probing of the slab penetration.
- Halting the propagationImmediately condemning the use of the shower, drying the false ceiling of the lower neighbor with dehumidifiers and recording in writing the state of the observed damages.
- Coordinated resumption under reserveIf doubt remains regarding the positioning of the siphon body, carry out the complete repair under the SIA 248 standard and settle the financial apportionment later between insurers.
Faced with damage crossing the reinforced concrete slab, the savvy tiler avoids bogging down the dispute. Without hesitation, they accept the circumscribed dismantling, the installation of a compliant elastomer collar glued into the liquid waterproofing and the connection on the flange according to recognized professional rules. This pragmatic approach halts the aggravation of ancillary claims and preserves the relationship of trust with the client.
Frequently asked questions
Who supplies the waterproofing collar: the sanitary installer or the tiler?
According to professional practices and the SIA 248 standard, the manufacturer of the drainage system delivers the elastomer collar or waterproofing ring with the siphon body or channel. The sanitary installer makes this item available during the installation of the drainage body. Conversely, the implementation, incorporation into the waterproofing system under tiling and careful smoothing in the liquid paste or mat fall exclusively under the tiler.
Can the drainage connection be repaired locally without redoing the entire shower?
Technically, a spot repair is discouraged because it rarely guarantees the required waterproof continuity. To ensure compliant overlapping of the new collar on the existing waterproofing, at least fifty millimeters of sound membrane must be cleared without damaging it. In practice, peeling off adjacent tiles tears off the thin waterproofing assembly. A total repair of the shower tray or floor is therefore systematically required to restore the integrity of the work under warranty.
How to prove that the leak comes from the collar and not from a pipe?
The diagnosis requires a methodical step-by-step investigation protocol. The expert or tiler first performs a water test by directly plugging the drainage pipe under the siphon: if the level drops, water escapes through the flange or the absence of a collar. If the level remains stable, fluorescent water is then injected into the pipe. An endoscope camera or targeted probing visually confirms the passage of water between the plastic body and the screed.
Does the tiler's civil liability insurance cover the complete repair of the tiling?
The company's civil liability insurance covers consequential damages caused to third parties, notably degraded false ceilings, plaster and paints at the lower neighbor's. Conversely, the cost of repairing the defective work itself—namely the dismantling and repair of the tiled shower by the tiler—falls under their warranty obligation according to the SIA 118 standard. These direct repair costs therefore remain at the exclusive expense of the responsible contractor.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work, governing the acceptance of the work and the exercise of rights in the event of defects.
- SIA 248Regulations for tiled finishes and waterproofing connections under tiling in interior wet areas.
