Key takeaways
- Systematic hammer sounding instantly reveals delamination and voids beneath the screed.
- Friable laitance and residual dust prevent the mechanical adhesion of the setting mortar.
- Standard SIA 248 requires visual and mechanical inspection of the substrate before work starts.
- Any unsuitable area must be marked out in chalk, quantified and notified in writing.
Hammer sounding, laitance and surface cohesion control
From the moment a substrate is taken over, testing surface cohesion determines the durability of the bonded assembly. Standard SIA 248 requires the tiler to inspect the condition of the substrate before any work begins. Common defects stem from internal debonding within the screed or separation between the levelling mortar and the raw slab. Five minutes spent on careful sounding prevents subsequent debonding of ceramic elements under traffic or thermal stress.
- Surface laitance
- A whitish, powdery layer formed by the upward migration of water and fine cement particles during the setting of a mortar. Lacking mechanical strength, it prevents the direct bonding of tile adhesives.
Diagnosis begins by striking with a light tiler's hammer, weighing 100 to 200 grams, or using a steel rod fitted with a metal ball. The tradesperson slides the tool across the surface with regular taps in a tight one-metre by one-metre grid. A dull, solid sound confirms the compactness of the material. A clear, dry, resonant sound indicates frank delamination or the presence of a void pocket beneath an indurated crust.
After acoustic sounding, the surface condition is checked by cross-hatch scraping with a chisel or hardened steel point. If the substrate disintegrates into dust or edges crumble without resistance, the presence of carbonated laitance or premature drying is confirmed. The adhesive tape adhesion test then confirms the absence of residual loose dust: a visible trace on the adhesive indicates insufficient dust removal, which will compromise the priming process.
Drawing up the rejection map and transmitting the formal inspection record
As soon as an anomaly exceeds permitted local tolerances, work must be stopped in the affected area. The tiler must not attempt to repair a structural deficiency without a written order from the site management. Any area exhibiting a hollow sound or excessive friability must be physically outlined directly. This marking is carried out using industrial wax chalk or temporary spray paint, precisely hatching the boundaries of the defect.
- Floor marking of defectsEncircle the periphery of the hollow sound with a continuous line and hatch the debonded surface. Indicate the date of the survey and the rejection notice directly on the screed.
- Metric survey and locationMeasure the lengths and widths of the defective areas. Transfer these dimensions onto the floor plan of the structure, specifying the room references and grid lines.
- Joint inspection record photographyPhotograph the area in a wide shot with a visible metric scale, then photograph details of disintegration or loss of cohesion.
- Drafting the notice of defectsDraw up the written report recording the cumulative non-compliant surfaces, in accordance with the obligations of standard SIA 118, and send it to the site management.
| Sounding observation | Probable origin | Action required from the tiler |
|---|---|---|
| Localized hollow sound | Debonding of a levelling compound or void beneath screed | Floor marking, refusal to install, written notification |
| Friable surface laitance | Bleeding of mixing water, agglomerated fines | Request for heavy grinding and industrial vacuuming |
| Persistent powdery dust | Screed burnt on the surface, lack of vacuuming | Enhanced vacuuming, mineral primer impregnation after agreement |
The anomaly report sent by email the same day freezes the technical situation. This document protects the tiler against any blame related to construction site delays caused by purging, grinding or screed remedial work, which are the responsibility of prior trades. Resumption of tiling work only takes place after observed elimination of defects and receipt of a substrate that is perfectly compact, dry and cleaned.
Mechanical purging of delaminated areas and removal of residual laitance
The acoustic diagnosis established by systematic sounding determines the immediate boundary between preparatory work falling within the installation service and structural defects requiring substrate remediation. When an area sounds hollow, the mechanical adhesion between the setting mortar, the screed or the underlying slab is broken. Bonding porcelain stoneware or natural stone to such a surface transfers shear stresses directly into the debonding plane: under the effect of residual shrinkage of the adhesive and thermal expansion of the building, the tiling lifts, cracks or comes loose under rolling loads. According to the rules of the trade governed by standard SIA 248, no bonding may be undertaken on an unstable crust or a debonded screed.
For very localized hollow sounds that do not call into question the overall compactness of the structure, the tiler opens up the area using a flat chisel or light hammer drill, cutting the edges at right angles to avoid feather edges. The rubble is removed and the substrate base is exposed down to sound material. The purging of cement or calcium sulphate laitance and trowelling films is carried out by heavy mechanical grinding using an angle grinder or planetary floor grinder equipped with hard-bond diamond segments. This operation strips the superficial powdery film without polishing the sandy matrix, creating the rough texture required for anchoring bonding bridges.
| Sounding observation | Technical origin | Required action | Allocation of service |
|---|---|---|---|
| Extensive hollow sound (> 0.2 m²) | Screed/slab interface delamination or underlying cracking | Work stoppage, complete purge, repair with resin mortar | Masonry or screed layer (CFC 281) |
| Spot hollow sound (< 0.05 m²) | Air nodule or skin-side bleeding pocket | Local chipping, vacuuming, spot fibre-reinforced levelling | Tiler preparation (CFC 282) |
| White chalky film | Bleeding water migration and carbonated laitance | Aggressive diamond grinding down to visible aggregate | As per specification or prior claim |
| Persistent powdery dust | Premature surface drying (burning of the binder) | Impregnation with mineral surface-hardener primer | Tiling contractor after notification |
Protocol for transmitting mapping and transfer of liability
The discovery of non-compliant surfaces requires immediate and documented notification to the site management as well as to the author of the underlying structure. The physical marking of hollow areas with indelible wax chalk or site spray directly on the floor serves as the basis for the joint inspection record. For the record to have binding probative value, the tiler accurately plots the rejected perimeters on the trade's execution plan. Each area is dimensioned, referenced to the wall axes and identified by a text marker corresponding to the close-up and overview photographs.
The dossier transmitted electronically includes the annotated grid plan, the debonding survey sheet with cumulative surfaces in square metres, as well as a formal reminder of the tolerance limits permitted by standard SIA 248. This sounding report formally requests the site management's agreement on the remedial procedure: either the installation company is ordered to repair spalling and spot levelling under complementary work governed by standard SIA 118, or the screeding contractor is recalled to site to purge and re-pour the damaged bays.
- Take photographs incorporating a millimetre rule or a visible metric reference next to the marked area.
- Record the ambient relative humidity and room temperature at the time of sounding to contextualize surface adhesion.
- Keep a copy of the annotated and signed plan on the site hut noticeboard.
- Demand a day-work sheet or written confirmation before undertaking cutting or repair mortars exceeding standard preparation.
Managing disagreements: technical arbitration and work stoppage in case of refusal
When the site management contests the rejection map or the company responsible for the screed refuses to remove residual laitance and re-purge hollow sounds, the tiler faces a major legal and structural risk. According to standard SIA 248, bonded installation work must only begin on a substrate with sufficient surface cohesion and which is perfectly adhered to its backing. Applying a covering to a debonded or powdery area while relying on the flexibility of a deformable adhesive constitutes a clear technical failure.
- Convening the joint inspection recordImmediately summon the site management and the screeding contractor for an in-situ joint inspection. Walk the surface together with a tiler's hammer, check the laitance by scratching with a fingernail or nail, and record the hollow sounds.
- Recording and operational withdrawalLog the work interruption in the site diary. Transmit the mapping backed up by clear photographs, physically delimit the prohibited area on the slab and redeploy the installation crew to a cleared and previously validated sector.
- Formal validation after remediationDemand the required curative interventions: mechanical milling of laitance, chipping out of blistered areas and pouring of a resin mortar. No tiling rework is to be carried out without a new re-inspection report signed by both parties.
As long as preparatory work has not been completed by the responsible trade, refusing to intervene remains the applicator's sole technical safeguard. The Code of Obligations clearly stipulates that the contractor is required to refuse any unsuitable substrate provided by the client, failing which they alone will bear the consequences of the subsequent defect. Undertaking installation on a powdery or hollow-sounding surface inevitably leads to loss of adhesion under the effect of thermo-mechanical stresses, resulting in complete removal and replacement at the sole expense of the tiler.
Frequently asked questions
How to distinguish acoustically between a floating screed on insulation and a genuine debonding?
A floating screed laid on acoustic or thermal insulation naturally produces a duller and more homogeneous resonance throughout the room. Localized debonding or a blister under laitance results in a high-pitched, hollow, localized tone, the sound contrast of which is immediately noticeable when passing from a sound area. In case of persistent doubt, opening a core sample allows direct observation of the mechanical bond.
Is the sanding of laitance the responsibility of the tiler or the screeding contractor?
Standard SIA 248 and Swiss trade rules attribute the delivery of a clean screed, free from its bleeding laitance film, to the company that poured it. The tiler only intervenes for fine sweeping and industrial vacuuming before bonding. If heavy sanding or diamond planning proves essential to remove untreated friable crust, this service constitutes additional work that must be the subject of a written day-work sheet.
Why is the simple scratch test not sufficient before tiling?
The scratch test using a steel nail or grid only provides information on the surface hardness and surface cohesion of the mortar. It in no way detects internal debonding, thickness delamination or a break in adhesion between the screed and the load-bearing concrete slab. Only systematic sounding with a tiler's hammer guarantees the absence of underlying air voids likely to cause tiles to shatter under load.
What should be done if the site management refuses to sign the rejection mapping?
Faced with a refusal to sign, immediately transmit the photographed mapping by registered mail or time-stamped email with acknowledgement of receipt, making express reference to standard SIA 118. Explicitly mention the stoppage of installation on the hatched areas and suspend work in this sector. This formal procedure legally freezes the condition of the substrate and protects you against any unjustified delay penalties or subsequent claims for defects.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 248Floor and wall coverings in tiles and slabs: requirements for the substrate and conditions for executing bonded installation
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work: contractor's duty to warn and management of defects in prior work
