Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 282Laying, layout, joints and lippageChapter 9 of 10 in the section

Acceptation of the work: inspection distance, lighting, planeness, joints and relevant reservations

This chapter provides the method for framing the acceptance of your tiled finishes in western Switzerland. You will learn how to enforce standard visual conditions prior to any visit, refute artificial grazing lights, check permissible surface irregularities and record rigorously located reservations to organise undisputed defect rectifications with the site management.

Key takeaways

  • Visual inspection is always carried out standing at standard usage distance, without artificial grazing construction site light.
  • The SIA 248 standard governs overall planeness and maximum surface irregularities between adjacent tiles.
  • Formal acceptance under the SIA 118 standard triggers the transfer of risk and the warranty.
  • Every reservation must specify a precise plan reference and a realistic intervention deadline.

Setting the inspection framework: observation distance and ambient lighting according to the SIA 248 standard

The acceptance of tiling cannot be improvised in a corridor with a site floodlight placed on the floor. Too often, the client or site management points out surface irregularities revealed by temporary halogen spots aimed parallel to the walls. These practices contravene recognised trade rules. Pursuant to the SIA 248 standard, the general appearance of a ceramic or natural stone finish must be assessed under the actual conditions of use of the rooms. The team leader or site manager must establish this contractual framework before starting any surface check.

Normal observation distance
Standardised visual control position according to the SIA 248 standard, corresponding to a standing observer, with the gaze directed perpendicularly or at a usual angle towards the floor or walls, at a distance of at least one metre fifty for walls and from eye level for floors.

The evaluation lighting must be diffuse natural light or the final artificial light of the room, as planned by the project's lighting design concept. A grazing beam, an inspection torch or direct glaring sunlight at the end of the day cannot serve as a reference to declare work non-compliant. If the fixed luminaires are not yet installed at the time of the joint visit, the visual check must take place under suspended general lighting simulating the final atmosphere, rather than using intervention floodlights.

Conditions for visual and geometric examination according to professional rules
Checked elementObservation positionPermitted light sourceMeasurement method
Ceramic floor coveringStanding, eye level (approx. 1.60 m)Diffuse lighting or final ceiling lights2 m rigid straightedge with thickness shims
Glazed tiles and wall partitionsStanding, minimum setback of 1.50 mGeneral ambient light without grazing spotlight2 m straightedge and surface irregularity gauge
Edge surface irregularitiesNormal overall viewRoom ambient lightingDepth gauge or graduated ruler
Joint uniformityUsage distance without magnifying glassDaylight without direct glareVernier calliper on representative points

Regarding geometric tolerances, the SIA 248 standard distinguishes between the overall planeness of the tiled substrate and the step between neighbouring tiles. A rectified large-format tile has its own manufacturing tolerance, accepted by ceramic production standards. The tiler makes up for what falls within their setting bed, but cannot eliminate the inherent curvature of slab firing. It is therefore essential to measure tolerances using a rigid straightedge placed on high points, without forcing the shims, while objectively recording the values obtained.

Formalising the acceptance report according to the SIA 118 standard: precise reservations and defect rectifications

The completion of tiling work implies the formal application of the SIA 118 standard. As soon as final site cleaning is carried out and temporary protections are removed, the contractor informs the site management that the service is complete and requests a joint visit. This act seals the acceptance of the work, materialised by a report signed by both parties. It is at this precise moment that the transfer of risk takes place and the time limits for claiming apparent defects begin.

Metric control of tolerances: planeness, surface irregularities and joint straightness

Once the overall field of vision has been validated while standing under natural light or final service lighting, the check shifts to the dimensional analysis of reported issues. The examination cannot be improvised with unsuitable tools: every dispute raised by the site management or the client must be the subject of an immediate joint inspection record, carried out using calibrated measuring instruments. The SIA 248 standard strictly regulates surface planeness as well as permissible alignment deviations between adjacent tiles to avoid purely subjective judgements.

Overall planeness is checked using a two-metre rigid aluminium straightedge equipped with protective end caps, placed without pressure on the floor or against the tiled wall. Residual gaps are measured with a millimetre-graded bevelled shim or a set of thickness shims. For local surface irregularities, also called steps or tile lips, the operator uses a twenty-centimetre metal rule coupled with a depth gauge. This measurement must imperatively take into account the edge type of the finish: porcelain stoneware with rectified edges tolerates infinitely fewer deviations than an extruded tile or cleaved natural stone, whose inherent dimensional variability adds up to implementation tolerances.

Execution tolerance limit values for interior ceramic finishes according to the SIA 248 standard
Control criterionMeasuring instrumentPermissible tolerance (SIA 248 standard)Action in case of observed non-conformity
Planeness under 2 m straightedge2 m alu straightedge and bevelled shimMaximum gap of 2 mmPartial removal or rework of assembly if reversed slope
Surface irregularity (rectified edges)20 cm metal rule and depth gaugeDeviation less than or equal to 1.0 mmSpot replacement of the incriminated tile
Surface irregularity (natural pressed edges)20 cm metal rule and depth gaugeDeviation less than or equal to 1.5 mmReplacement of tile if proven excess
Joint straightness and alignmentChalk line or laser levelMaximum deviation of 2 mm over 2 mTargeted rework of joints or resetting of the bay

Joint width is also subject to careful examination. On rectified tiling, a regular two-millimetre joint constitutes the minimum reference allowed indoors. Trace regularity is assessed by checking the orthogonality of intersections and the straightness of sight lines using a laser level. An optical offset caused by a batch-specific calibre variation delivered by the manufacturer cannot be blamed on the craftsperson if the latter complied with sorting criteria and intrinsic material tolerances.

Technical handling of reservations: targeted replacement, protection of the assembly and rectification protocol

Any non-conformity validated during the inspection tour must be recorded in the form of a precisely located reservation in the acceptance report drawn up according to the SIA 118 standard. The entry must mention the room, exact zone, tile number identified on the plan and the geometric or visual nature of the defect. The contractor and site management immediately agree on a reasonable execution deadline for rectifying each reservation, integrating potential supply times for tiles from the same batch kept in site storage.

  1. Mechanical joint routingHollow out the joint mortar surrounding the incriminated tile with a diamond oscillating blade over the entire thickness of the body, continuously extracting dust so as not to chip the edges of neighbouring sound tiles.
  2. Fragmentation and removal of the elementMake two diagonal cross-cuts with the diamond disc in the centre of the tile without damaging the substrate, then peel off the triangular fragments inwards using a manual flat chisel handled at a very shallow angle.
  3. Cleaning the setting bed and waterproofing checkScrape down residual grooves of hardened tile adhesive with a manual scraper until a flat base is recovered. In a wet room, meticulously inspect the waterproofing assembly beneath the tiling and apply a targeted liquid waterproofing smoothing layer if the film has been altered.
  4. Re-gluing and finishing groutingApply a deformable adhesive mortar by double gluing, adjust the level with a white mallet while checking planeness with the straightedge, then re-grout after complete hardening using a mortar identical in colour and chemical composition.

Once repairs are completed, the foreman summons the site management for the formal follow-up visit. The record of reservation rectifications is confirmed by the joint signature of an addendum to the acceptance report, marking the final extinction of the client's claims regarding identified apparent defects and confirming the starting point of the warranty periods prescribed by the SIA 118 standard.

Management of acceptance disputes and tolerance arbitration

When the acceptance visit turns into a deadlock, the disagreement almost always concerns aesthetic criteria examined outside the protocol: use of a painter's grazing spotlight, observation with nose pressed against the tiles or claims regarding shades inherent to ceramic material or natural stone. Faced with unagreed requirements, the foreman or site manager must strictly adhere to the framework set by the SIA 248 standard. Tiling is assessed standing, with the gaze at eye level, under diffuse natural light or lighting planned for room operation. Any observation made at floor level or under a site floodlight must be formally rejected when drafting the report.

If the site management maintains a reservation that you consider unfounded, categorically refuse any blind removal. Replacing a sound tile risks damaging the waterproofing mat beneath the tiling or the edges of neighbouring elements. The approach requires immediately entering a joint statement on the acceptance report governed by the SIA 118 standard: stipulate that the contested element complies with permissible thresholds and that the observation conditions deviate from recognised rules.

In the event of persistent disagreement blocking the release of retention money or the payment of the balance of the work, recourse to neutral technical expert appraisal constitutes the only clean outcome. The intervention of an expert appointed jointly or coming from the branch's technical committees makes it possible to decide on the basis of calibres, bevelled straightedges and indisputable surface irregularity measurements. According to the SIA 118 standard, the client may only retain an amount proportional to the estimated cost of the disputed repair, and not block all contractual payments.

Frequently asked questions

What should be done if the client demands an inspection with a hand lamp flush with the tiling?

Inspection with a hand lamp or grazing spotlight contravenes the trade's acceptance principles. The SIA 248 standard specifies that visual assessment is carried out standing, at usage distance, under natural light or the final lighting of the rooms. Ask for temporary lighting to be switched off and blinds opened. If the client insists, refuse notification of the defect on the report without having it expressly recorded that the inspection was carried out under non-compliant grazing lighting.

Can the client refuse acceptance for a single chipped tile?

No. According to the SIA 118 standard, a minor defect that compromises neither the use nor the overall water tightness of the work does not justify a refusal of acceptance. The work is considered accepted, but the report records a specific reservation with an execution deadline set for replacing the damaged tile. The client is only entitled to retain an amount equivalent to the actual costs of this specific intervention until the reservation is lifted.

Who bears the cost of a technical expert appraisal in the event of a persistent dispute?

When the parties mutually agree to appoint a branch expert to rule on metric tolerances or the appearance of tiling, costs are generally advanced in equal shares. The final allocation of the expert's fees depends on the report's conclusions: if the tolerances of the SIA 248 standard are respected, the costs fall to the applicant; if the work presents proven non-conformities, they fall back on the contractor.

How to formalise the lifting of reservations once retouching is completed?

As soon as tile replacement or joint repair is completed, the contractor summons the site management for a joint inspection record on the sole points listed during initial acceptance. A reservation lifting form is completed and signed by both parties, referencing the initial report drawn up according to the SIA 118 standard. This document certifies the final conformity of the work and triggers the release of the retained financial balance.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work
  • norme SIA 248Tiled and bonded finishes

In the same section