Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 282Cutting, silica, claims and tiler safetyChapter 9 of 10 in the section

Warranty: period, hidden defect, written notice and interruption of the period

On construction sites subject to the SIA 118 standard or the Code of Obligations, late debonding under slabs raises the issue of the warranty. You will learn how to technically classify a hollow sound occurring after acceptance, document the failure of adhesion in the adhesive mortar bed and formalise a compliant written notice to safeguard rights to rectification.

Key takeaways

  • Tiling that sounds hollow after acceptance constitutes a typical hidden installation defect.
  • Under the SIA 118 standard, the period for reporting hidden defects runs for five years.
  • As soon as the hollow sound is identified, the notice of defects must be sent in writing.
  • The formal notice interrupts the forfeiture period and compels the executing company to intervene free of charge.

Classifying the late hollow sound and setting the warranty framework under the SIA 118 standard

When a ceramic floor covering begins to sound hollow several months or even a full year after the handover of the work, the phenomenon indicates a loss of adhesion between the slab and its substrate. This defect could not be detected during the joint acceptance inspection, as the adhesive transfer initially seemed sufficient to hold the ceramics in place. In construction practice in Western Switzerland, this progressive mechanical behaviour is classified as a hidden defect. The early-age shear stress of the adhesive-screed complex eventually ruptured the adhesive bond without showing immediate surface unevenness.

Hidden defect in tiling
Undetectable defect during diligent inspection upon acceptance of the work, such as insufficient crushing of the adhesive ridges or the onset of cohesive failure that only reveals itself under subsequent thermal or mechanical action.

The applicable contractual regime dictates the rules for exercising rights. When the construction contract incorporates the SIA 118 standard, the client benefits from a two-year warranty period for apparent or hidden defects, followed by a limitation period for hidden defects extending up to five years after acceptance. If the construction site is governed exclusively by the Code of Obligations without mention of the SIA 118 standard, any defect appearing after acceptance must be inspected and claimed very quickly, otherwise the work will be considered tacitly accepted despite the defect.

For the site foreman, the first step consists of mapping the faulty area by sounding with a mallet handle or a drag chain. A dull sound indicates solid bonding, whereas a high-pitched, resonant note delineates debonding. As soon as the hollow area exceeds local tolerances or is accompanied by cracking of the grout joints, physical proof of a failure in the adhesive bed must be established without damaging the underlying tile waterproofing system.

Documenting the loss of adhesion and notifying the protective notice of defects

The discovery of a hollow sound during the second or third year requires rigorous traceability before any dismantling. The tiling company that installed the work will frequently seek to blame structural deformations or sudden heating activation. To cut short any dispute regarding the foreclosure of deadlines, the site manager must gather the technical facts and immediately notify the tiling lot contractor of the defect.

On-site diagnosis of hollow-sounding tiling during the operational phase
Visual or acoustic indicatorProbable technical originRequired protective action
Localized hollow sound without cracksPremature drying of adhesive ridges due to exceeding the open timeTake exact measurements and mark with an erasable marker on the tile.
Tile moving under foot traffic loadOmitted double gluing with transfer rate below the required minimumSecure the passageway to prevent chipping of adjacent edges.
Spalling of the cement grout around the tileAbsence of control joints or tight installation without perimeter clearanceCheck for shrinkage at the base of the skirting board and take photographs.
Dome-shaped lifting of multiple tilesDifferential thrust on screed without corner decouplingUrgent summoning of the tile artisan for a joint inspection record.
  1. Locate and measure the unbonded surfaceTrace the precise contours of the hollow-sounding slabs on the floor. Draw up an attached, dated layout plan, stating the number of affected elements and their exact location in the room.
  2. Remove a sample tile in the presence of the installerCarefully open a perimeter joint with a carbide scraper to extract a slab without tearing the mat or liquid waterproofing system. Examine the back of the tile: a smooth back proves poor adhesive wetting.
  3. Send the notice of defects by registered mailPromptly send an official letter describing the nature of the damage, the loss of adhesion and the abnormal resonance, summoning the contractor to remedy the defect by complete rectification of the area within a set timeframe.

Written notification places the contractor in formal notice to execute their warranty obligation. It opens the right to the elimination of the defect, which involves the careful removal of the hollow-sounding tiles, the sanding of the faulty mortar bed without damaging the screed, and then re-laying in a full mortar bed according to professional standards. The notice interrupts the running of contractual extinction periods and preserves the exercise of financial securities, such as retention money or the bank guarantee for the work.

Joint inspection record and localization of the failure interface

Upon formal notification of the hidden defect for a hollow sound during the second year following acceptance of the work, the site manager or the tiling trade master must organize a joint on-site visit. According to the rules of the SIA 118 standard, this meeting makes it possible to record the reality of the defect, log its exact extent and determine the mechanical nature of the adhesion failure without prematurely destroying the assembly.

  1. Acoustic mapping of the unbonded areaSystematic sounding of the floor tile by tile using a white rubber tiler's mallet or a metal rod with a Teflon tip. Tracing tiles exhibiting hollow resonance is done with an erasable marker directly on the ceramics, measuring the cumulative surface area and noting the edges of control or expansion joints.
  2. Targeted destructive sounding outside the passagewayCautious removal of an unbonded tile in the center of the mapped area. The artisan cuts the perimeter joints with an angle grinder equipped with source dust extraction to separate the element without chipping neighbouring tiles, then extracts the piece using a flat chisel or a wide spatula.
  3. Visual inspection of the failure interfacePrecise identification of the failure plane. Observation immediately distinguishes whether the adhesive mortar remained bonded to the substrate with a smooth imprint under the tile, whether it adheres to the back of the ceramic while leaving the screed or primer bare, or whether the failure is purely internal to the adhesive bed.
Technical diagnosis of the failure interface during joint dismantling
Finding upon openingPhysical mechanism involvedCFC 282 technical imputabilityRequired corrective action
Adhesive adhering to substrate, back of ceramic smooth and cleanTransfer defect, open time exceeded or absence of double gluing on large formatDirect responsibility of the tiler (application of the adhesive)Complete removal of hollow-sounding elements and relaying under warranty
Adhesive adhering to tile, bare screed without primerPowdery substrate, unsucked sanding dust or absence of bonding slurryResponsibility of the tiler if the substrate inspection was not the subject of any formal noticeIndustrial vacuuming, application of a suitable primer and repair
Failure beneath the liquid waterproofing film (underlayment)Excessive residual moisture or insufficient surface cohesion of the substrateInterface conflict requiring analysis of the heating activation or hygrometry protocolJoint expertise with the author of the substrate prior to resuming bonded waterproofing

The drafting of a joint report signed on the spot by both parties freezes the material findings. This document records the number of square meters concerned, the visual state of the adhesive ridges, the actual transfer rate under the tile and any technical reservations issued by the contractor.

Preservation of rights, interruption of the period and elimination protocol

Sending the notice of defects upon the manifestation of the hollow sound preserves the client's rights, but is not indefinitely sufficient to prevent the forfeiture of the company's liability. Under the SIA 118 standard regime as well as under the Code of Obligations, the limitation of rights relating to hidden defects in a real estate construction is subject to strict rules that require formalizing the continuation of the procedure without interruption.

When the contractor acknowledges the debonding as falling under their warranty, they draw up a defect elimination agreement. This protocol sets the precise intervention schedule, the conditions for protecting inhabited rooms, the batch of spare tiles used to ensure shade homogeneity, as well as the type of improved controlled-deformation adhesive mortar that will be used for the repair.

In the event of a dispute over the origin of the damage—specifically if the tiler invokes abnormal structural deformation, unfragmented screed shearing or unforeseen thermal shock—appointing a technical expert from the tiling branch is mandatory. As long as the expertise continues, successive registered letters must explicitly renew claims and formalize the parties' agreement on the suspension of deadlines to avoid any procedural forfeiture.

Legal remedies and dispute management in case of contested debonding

When the contractor refuses to acknowledge late debonding as a hidden defect or attempts to blame the hollow sound on thermal and structural movements of the substrate, the site management must lock down the technical and legal file. Although the notice of defects sent upon discovery protects the client's fundamental rights, it does not automatically lead to an agreement if the tiler contests the application of their adhesive. A formal notice by registered letter must summon the artisan to take a stand and set a precise deadline to organize a joint meeting on the damaged work.

Faced with persistent deadlock, resorting to a technical expert from the branch proves essential before any demolition phase. The specialist first methodically maps the hollow-sounding areas by acoustic percussion, then supervises the sampling by coring or careful dismantling. Direct tensile pull-off tests and detailed surface examination identify the exact failure plane. If the adhesive mortar ridges show a dry surface skin betraying an exceeded open time, or if the double gluing prescribed for large formats was not applied, the tiler's execution fault is undeniably characterized.

  1. Formal notice to performSend a registered letter setting a firm deadline to initiate repairs, explicitly stipulating that failing intervention, the rectification will be entrusted to a third-party company at the installer's risk and expense.
  2. Joint inspection of interfacesSummon the installer and their civil liability insurer to remove a sample tile, photograph the back of the ceramic and formally record in writing the effective transfer percentage of the mortar.
  3. Safeguarding the limitation periodFile a conciliation request before the competent authority or demand a written waiver of limitation, preventing the final extinction of claims before the five-year term governed by the Code of Obligations.

Frequently asked questions

Why is a tile sounding hollow after eighteen months considered a hidden defect?

Upon acceptance of the work, underlying debonding produces no surface manifestation: joints are intact, the level is regular and the adhesive mortar maintains temporary residual adhesion. It is only with heating cycles or mechanical stresses that the mechanical failure propagates. Being undetectable by ordinary visual inspection upon handover, this defect falls fully into the category of hidden defects.

Within what exact timeframe must the client report a hollow sound that appeared after acceptance?

Under the SIA 118 standard regime, hidden defects discovered after the two-year warranty period must be reported as soon as they are discovered. If the tiling detaches during the first two years without having been visible at delivery, the client can theoretically act until the end of this period, but good faith and the preservation of rights dictate prompt written notification to block any aggravation of the defect.

Does a simple email suffice to validly notify the notice of defects of tiling?

An email constitutes an admissible written record, but carries a high evidentiary risk regarding its actual date of receipt. To guarantee the interruption of deadlines and avoid any subsequent dispute, the notice of defects must imperatively be sent by registered mail with acknowledgment of receipt, or delivered against a signed receipt on the construction site. The document must specify the exact location of the hollow-sounding slabs and formally demand their repair.

How to determine whether the hollow sound comes from poor adhesive or a weakness in the screed?

The location of the failure reveals the origin of the damage. If the underside of the removed tile is smooth with no adhesive transfer, the error lies with the tiler, often due to exceeding the open time or lack of double gluing. Conversely, if a film of mortar or screed laitance remains firmly glued to the back of the torn-off ceramic, the cohesion of the substrate is faulty, shifting responsibility to the screed layer.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work (warranty, notice of defects and liability)
  • code des obligationsGeneral rules of the construction contract and limitation periods for defects in real estate constructions

In the same section