Key takeaways
- The usual flatness tolerance for screeds under standard SIA 251 prohibits direct installation.
- A large, rectified tile transfers the slightest millimeter of unevenness directly into lippage.
- The fluid adhesive mortar bed cannot compensate for humps without creating dangerous voids.
- The application of a self-levelling smoothing compound must be priced as a separate item in the initial quote.
The technical incompatibility between the raw screed and large-format tiles
On Swiss construction sites, substrate handover regularly brings the screed layer and the tiler into conflict. A screed delivered in accordance with standard SIA 251 has surface tolerances suitable for resilient flooring or traditional tile dimensions. As soon as a tile's side exceeds 60 cm, or reaches the common dimensions of 120 by 120 cm or even more, this base surface becomes technically unacceptable for durable installation.
Standard SIA 248 governs the installation of tiled finishes and imposes very rigorous final flatness requirements to avoid stepping between adjacent tiles. However, a large-format porcelain stoneware tile has absolute rigidity and an intrinsic curvature tolerance specific to the industrial firing process. When two rectified edges meet at a high point of the screed, levelling becomes impossible with a beating mallet or self-levelling clip without bowing the slab or fracturing the edge.
| Type of check | Standard substrate according to standard SIA 251 | Requirement for large format (standard SIA 248) | Consequence for installation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deflection under the 2 m straightedge | Up to 4 or 5 mm permitted | Less than 2 mm mandatory | Inevitable lippage without compensation |
| Deflection under 20 cm ruler | Unspecified or 2 mm | Less than 1 mm under each edge | Tile rocking and lack of adhesive transfer |
| Thickness of the adhesive bed | Variable from 3 to 8 mm | Continuous and regular bed of 3 to 5 mm | Risk of differential shrinkage of the adhesive mortar |
Attempting to correct a surface depression by locally overloading the thickness of the adhesive mortar is a serious professional error. When hardening by hydration, a deformable adhesive mortar undergoes slight volumetric shrinkage. If the thickness beneath the same tile varies from single to triple, internal stresses pull unevenly on the ceramic, causing spontaneous cracking or a hollow beneath the tile which is fatal under heavy point loads.
The verification protocol and the inclusion of the self-levelling compound in the quote
The team leader or surveyor must audit the floor before the installation team starts work. Checking is done using a 2-metre rigid aluminium straightedge and a measuring wedge graduated in rigid plastic or metal. The straightedge must be swept across several axes: perpendicular to the glass bays, along the diagonals of the room, and at doorways where grazing light accentuates defects.
- Methodical recording of singular pointsPlace the 2-metre straightedge every square metre. Measure the maximum deflection under the profile. Mark with wax crayon the areas where the gap exceeds 2 mm, as well as ridges or laitance burrs.
- Preliminary sanding of local excess thicknessRemove ridges and material build-up around pipes or wall corners using a diamond concrete sander, in order to lower the zero point of the future self-levelling compound.
- Industrial vacuuming and cohesion checkThoroughly dust the screed using a suitable class construction site vacuum cleaner. Check for the absence of chalky or delaminated areas that would prevent adhesion.
- Application of primer and self-levelling mortarApply a primer suited to the nature of the screed binder. Pour a high-strength fibre-reinforced self-levelling smoothing compound to bring the residual deflection below the 2 mm mark under the 2 m straightedge.
To preserve the company's profitability, this service must never be performed at a loss or absorbed as improvised daywork. When the call for tenders specifies large-format slabs but stipulates only a standard screed, the tiler must formalise the technical obligation for an additional self-levelling compound priced in their base tender or as a mandatory variant.
The wording of the quote must distinctly mention the surface to be levelled, the expected average thickness and the chemical compatibility with the underlying screed, particularly on calcium sulphate screeds. Presenting this line item dès la soumission protects the artisan against subsequent financial disputes and secures the technical responsibility of the installation before the site management.
Normative comparison between received screed and large-format tiling
The installation of large-format ceramic slabs highlights a major technical contradiction between two finishing work trades. On the one hand, the screed layer delivers work complying with standard SIA 251, whose usual execution tolerances allow flatness deviations incompatible with large rigid elements. On the other hand, the tiler must comply with the requirements of standard SIA 248, which dictates a rigorously flat finished result, free from perceptible lippage under grazing light. This divergence leaves the installer facing a structurally unsuitable substrate as soon as they take over the construction site.
A fluid or traditional screed executed according to the basic requirements of standard SIA 251 tolerates a deflection of up to several millimetres over a length of two metres. While this margin is suitable for traditional formats laid with generous joints, it becomes critical as soon as a tile's edge exceeds sixty centimetres or the unit surface area crosses one square metre. The absolute rigidity of porcelain stoneware, whether thin or thick, prevents the element from following the hollows or humps of the screed without creating an immediate edge offset with the adjacent slab.
| Type of substrate or work | Reference standard | Received flatness tolerance | Large format compatibility (> 60 cm) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cement or calcium sulphate screed (standard class) | Standard SIA 251 | 5 mm under the 2 m straightedge | Non-compliant without prior compensation |
| Screed with increased flatness requirements | Standard SIA 251 | 3 mm under the 2 m straightedge | Critical, localized adjustment often required |
| Substrate prepared for XXL slabs and thin ceramics | Standard SIA 248 | 1 to 2 mm under the 2 m straightedge | Compliant for direct thin-bed bonding |
Attempting to make up for a hump or flash by increasing the adhesive mortar thickness is a serious professional error. Modern deformable adhesive mortars are formulated to work in thin or medium layers, generally between three and ten millimetres after compaction. An adhesive bed with excessive thickness undergoes differential hydraulic shrinkage during setting. This phenomenon pulls the slab downwards in the centre or at the edges, generating shear stresses that cause either loss of adhesion or the appearance of unacceptable steps at the joint junctions.
Technical prescription and pricing of the additional self-levelling compound
To clear their liability and guarantee the durability of the work, the professional applies their duty to notify as soon as deviations are observed with the two-metre bevelled straightedge and the twenty-centimetre ruler. The written notification to the site management formally states that the flatness tolerance received on the screed does not allow the installation of the prescribed slabs without derogating from the requirements of standard SIA 248. The priced additional self-levelling compound must then be validated as a separate service, ordered by an addendum or a daywork sheet prior to any work.
- Vacuuming and neutralization of the substrateComplete removal of cement laitance, residual dust and form-release oil traces by mechanical sanding with a diamond disc and industrial vacuuming.
- Application of the bonding primerInstallation of an adhesion resin suited to the porosity of the screed (acrylic primer on absorbent cement substrates or sanded epoxy primer on dust-free anhydrite screeds).
- Pouring of the self-levelling smoothing compoundExecution of a high mechanical strength fibre-reinforced self-levelling levelling mortar, spread with a notched squeegee and degassed with a spiked roller to obtain the required flatness.
- Rigorous treatment of jointsMandatory carry-through of all structural movement joints and peripheral decoupling of partition bases using compressible edge insulation strips.
The execution of a high-performance self-levelling compound represents an incompressible technical cost that depends on the average thickness required to make up for substrate defects. For a three to eight millimetre pass with primer, the order of magnitude generally lies between 25 and 45 CHF per square metre supplied and installed, excluding heavy preliminary sanding work. This item must obligatorily appear as a reserve position or priced variant dès la soumission in order to avoid any construction site stoppage upon handover of the substrate.
Flatness conflict: course of action in the face of a refusal to level
When the site management refuses to sign the addendum for the priced additional self-levelling compound, the construction site grinds to a halt. The usual argument consists of claiming that the screed complies with the tolerances of standard SIA 251. This position ignores physical reality: the flatness tolerance received for a raw floor does not make it possible to ensure the adhesive transfer required by standard SIA 248 on large-format slabs. Installing under these conditions leads to lippage lips, voids beneath tiles and breakage under load.
- Instrumented joint inspection recordSummon the site management on site with the 2-metre metal straightedge and the millimetric bevelled wedge. Place the straightedge on the diagonals and note each deflection exceeding the tolerated limit for the intended format. Transfer the measurements onto a layout plan and record everything in a report signed on the spot.
- Written notification according to the Code of Obligations (CO)Formally transmit the notice of defects of the substrate to the client in writing. Specify that the received substrate prevents the execution of work in accordance with professional standards without the prior application of a suitable smoothing compound. Suspend the start of installation until contractual clarification.
- Validation of the addendum or formal noticeDemand a daywork sheet or a modification order before mixing the first bag of levelling compound. If the site management demands direct installation without floor preparation, formally refuse the order: no signed release protects a professional who knowingly carries out work destined for ruin or debonding.
In the event of a persistent deadlock, the tiler must pack up their tools and leave the installation area. Continuing work to maintain the schedule transfers full responsibility for aesthetic and structural defects onto the tile installer.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if the site management claims the screed complies with standard SIA 251?
It is necessary to recall in writing the distinction between the handover of the raw substrate and the installation requirements of the finish. Standard SIA 251 tolerates permissible deviations for the screed layer, but these values remain incompatible with modern ceramic slabs. According to standard SIA 248, the tiler is required to check the suitability of the substrate to receive the chosen tile. If the substrate has incompatible hollows, compensatory self-levelling is mandatory as an extra.
Can a localized screed hollow be made up for by increasing the thickness of the adhesive mortar?
No. Deformable adhesive mortars are formulated for thin or medium beds where the maximum thickness prescribed by the manufacturer rarely exceeds 10 millimetres after compaction. Exceeding this thickness causes very heterogeneous drying shrinkage beneath the slab. This shrinkage pulls the tile asymmetrically, creating irrecoverable lippage between rectified edges, or even premature debonding under heavy traffic.
How should a quote be worded so that the self-levelling compound does not end up at the tiler's expense?
As soon as the quote is drawn up, the contractor must insert a clause specifying the flatness tolerance required under the 2-metre straightedge for the prescribed format. The description must mention that the received screed is deemed to be raw according to standard tolerances. A specific line item pricing the supply, bonding primer and application of a fibre-reinforced self-levelling compound must be provided as a variant or mandatory option.
Do levelling clips make it possible to compensate for a substrate flatness defect?
Absolutely not. Self-levelling clips with wedges or screws serve solely to temporarily align adjacent upper edges while the adhesive mortar sets. If the substrate is hollow or uneven, forcing the edges together with wedges puts the ceramic under continuous mechanical tension and creates an adhesive void beneath the tile body. This hollow bridge leads to tile cracking at the slightest impact.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 248Installation of ceramic and natural stone tiles and finishes, execution specifications and flatness requirements
- SIA 251Floating, bonded and separating-layer screeds, execution and surface tolerances
- Code des obligationsRules governing the works contract, the duty to notify and liability for defects in the work
