General Contractor Contract Auditor: Hidden Prorata Deductions Calculator
Spot the prorata deductions and unfavourable clauses of a general contractor contract, and quantify the loss.
Interactive tool
3 Contractual deductions imposed by the general contractor
- %
- %
- %
- %
- CHF
- %
What these deductions really cost you
- Total hidden deductions
- As a percentage of the contract
- Target margin
- Your actual remaining net margin
Preventive markup before submitting your bid
Coefficient = 1 / (1 − total of the deduction rates). Flat amounts in CHF are converted into a percentage of your bid.
- Markup coefficient
- Markup to apply
- Marked-up bid
B Interactive checklist of the 12 abusive clauses to strike out or negotiate
-
The general contractor has you sign a waiver of the right to register the statutory lien. According to the specifications, such an advance waiver is void (art. 837 para. 3 Civil Code (CC)): it takes nothing away from you, but the presence of the clause reveals a risky principal. Strike it out.
Reference: Art. 837 CC -
You would only be paid when the general contractor is paid itself: you bear the client's insolvency risk, which you do not control. To be struck out, or limited to a firm maximum payment period.
Reference: Art. 190 SIA 118 -
SIA 118 allows only "equitable" penalties (art. 98), and not if you are entitled to an extension of the deadline. Demand a cap (in practice 5% to 10% of the price) and reserve extensions; a judge may reduce an excessive penalty (art. 163 para. 3 CO).
Reference: art. 98 SIA 118, art. 163 CO -
A percentage levy, with no statement of actual costs, directly erodes your margin. Ask for a documented statement, a clear basis and a cap.
Reference: Art. 129 to 135 SIA 118 -
SIA 118 puts the electricity supply up to the connection point (art. 129) and water (art. 133) on the client, as well as the consumption of the finishing trades (art. 135 para. 3), unless a clause provides otherwise. Refuse a flat-rate deduction or price it into your bid.
Reference: art. 129, 133 to 135 SIA 118 -
Have costs allocated by cause: everyone removes their own waste, and shared cleaning is invoiced according to a justified key.
Reference: Art. 129 to 135 SIA 118 -
You sometimes pay twice: your own RC and the general contractor's share. Ask for the policy, the actual premium and the allocation key.
-
Flat amounts unrelated to your share of the site: cap them or build them into a single rate, negotiated before signing.
-
Under SIA 118, a client who pays after 30 days loses the right to the discount (art. 190 para. 1). An automatic deduction circumvents this rule: make the discount conditional on payment within the deadline.
Reference: Art. 190 SIA 118 -
SIA 118 provides for a retention of 10% of the value of the services (5% of the value, at least 50'000 CHF, from 500'000 CHF) and a surety of 10% of the total sum (5% of the total sum, at least 30'000 CHF, from 300'000 CHF); the retention falls due on acceptance, at the final statement and on delivery of the surety (art. 150, 152, 181). Align the contract with these values.
Reference: Art. 150, 152, 181 SIA 118 -
The SIA 118 period is 30 days (art. 190). Demand a firm period, default interest and the possibility to terminate after an additional period.
Reference: Art. 190 SIA 118 -
This clause may deprive you of art. 86 (variation of quantities), art. 87 (new services) and price escalation. The flat price excludes price escalation if it is expressly designated as such (art. 41): check what is written.
Reference: art. 41, 64, 86, 87 SIA 118
Your ticks stay on this device. This list is a reading guide, not legal advice: have any important contract reviewed by a lawyer. An advance waiver of the craftsmen's statutory lien is void (art. 837 para. 3 Civil Code (CC)).
Embed this calculator on a website page
Paste this code into the page, or write [outil code="3.6"] in the content of a page on the site.
📄 Files and templates linked to this tool (free)
- PDFDOCX ⚖️ Pure Law Secured Consortium Agreement (simple partnership) & Status Report (PV) at End of Lot Complete 6-page guide (PDF) and Word template. Bidding together as two without paying alone for the other's mistakes: full internal agreement, liability towards the client, default, exits, letters and end-of-lot report. See the file, its mini-tool and the pack →
- DOCXXLSXPDF Prorata Account Kit & Guide to the 12 Abusive Clauses in General Contractor (EG) Contracts Complete 7-page guide (PDF) and Word template. Challenging an abusive pro rata deduction and striking out the dangerous clauses of a general contractor agreement: procedure, 12 clauses to watch, letter templates and an Excel offset grid. See the file, its mini-tool and the pack →
- PDFDOCX ⚖️ Pure Law Custody Transfer Protocol & Theft of Materials on Site Complete 8-page guide (PDF) and Word template. Materials delivered but not yet installed: who bears the theft, record of transfer of custody and storage, clause on advance payment for materials and template letters. See the file, its mini-tool and the pack →
Move from calculation to full management
Keep your references at hand, then automate them in your quotes, bids and final statements.
Technical reference guide
Why do the flat-rate "prorata account" deductions (3% to 6%) destroy your net margin?
The prorata account Swiss site deduction groups common site costs (energy, water, cleaning, skips, insurance, sanitary facilities) that the general contractor allocates among the trades, often by a percentage of the contract amount. A flat percentage is deducted from each interim statement, whether these costs are real or not. On a bid of 150'000 CHF and a target margin of 10% (15'000 CHF), the tool's default deductions total 9'600 CHF, i.e. 6.4% of the contract: the net margin falls to 5'400 CHF (3.6%), a loss of 64% of your profit.
1. What the SIA 118 standard really says (Art. 129 to 135): water, electricity and non-attributable cleaning must be borne by the client unless a clause provides otherwise
On the deduction cleaning electricity water site SIA 118 art 129, the standard is clear for energy and water: the client provides the supply of electrical energy at the connection point (art. 129), the water supply up to the site (art. 133) and, for the finishing trades of buildings, bears the cost of consumption of electricity, gas and water (art. 135 para. 3), unless a clause provides otherwise. For cleaning, the standard rather applies the rule of cause: everyone takes care at their own cost of order, cleanliness and hygiene on the site (art. 118) and whoever dirties an access cleans it (art. 117 para. 2). A flat-rate shared cleaning must therefore be justified and allocated by cause. These rules apply only if SIA 118 is incorporated into the contract and no clause departs from them: a signed deduction is in principle valid.
2. How to mathematically mark up your unit prices before submitting your bid (Compensation formula: Price / (1 − Deduction_Rate))
To neutralise the deductions, mark up your prices before submitting the bid: coefficient = 1 / (1 − total of the deduction rates). With 6.4% of deductions, the coefficient is 1.0684, i.e. a markup of 6.84%: a bid of 150'000 CHF becomes 160'256.41 CHF, of which the deductions leave exactly 150'000 CHF. Flat amounts in CHF (site sign, badge) are converted into a percentage of the bid.
| Total deductions | Coefficient 1 / (1 − rate) | Markup to apply |
|---|---|---|
| 3,0 % | 1,0309 | +3,09 % |
| 4,0 % | 1,0417 | +4,17 % |
| 5,0 % | 1,0526 | +5,26 % |
| 6,0 % | 1,0638 | +6,38 % |
| 6,4 % | 1,0684 | +6,84 % |
| 8,0 % | 1,0870 | +8,70 % |
The 12 abusive or illegal clauses to strike out before signing a subcontracting agreement with a General Contractor (EG / ET)
A subcontracting agreement general contractor abusive clauses is not necessarily illegal: most of the clauses below are valid if you sign them. They are to be struck out or negotiated before signing, because they shift risks or costs onto the subcontractor. Only the first is void by operation of law. The tool's interactive checklist lets you tick them off one by one.
1. Clauses illegal by operation of law (advance waiver of the craftsmen's statutory lien — art. 837 para. 3 Civil Code (CC)) and dangerous clauses ("Pay-when-paid", uncapped penalties)
On the waiver statutory lien void art 837 para 3 CC: a clause by which you would waive the craftsmen's statutory lien in advance is void; it takes nothing away from you, but reveals a risky principal (see the deadline calculator). "Pay-when-paid" clauses make you bear the client's insolvency risk. For the late-completion penalty cap: SIA 118 allows only equitable penalties, excluded if you are entitled to an extension of the deadline (art. 98); demand a cap, in practice 5% to 10% of the price, and point out that the judge may reduce an excessive penalty (art. 163 para. 3 CO).
- Advance waiver of the craftsmen's statutory lien (Void by operation of law). The general contractor has you sign a waiver of the right to register the statutory lien. According to the specifications, such an advance waiver is void (art. 837 para. 3 Civil Code (CC)): it takes nothing away from you, but the presence of the clause reveals a risky principal. Strike it out. Reference: art. 837 Civil Code (CC).
- "Pay-when-paid" clause (payment conditional on payment by the client) (Dangerous clause). You would only be paid when the general contractor is paid itself: you bear the client's insolvency risk, which you do not control. To be struck out, or limited to a firm maximum payment period. Reference: art. 190 SIA 118.
- Uncapped late-completion penalties or penalties independent of your fault (Dangerous clause). SIA 118 allows only "equitable" penalties (art. 98), and not if you are entitled to an extension of the deadline. Demand a cap (in practice 5% to 10% of the price) and reserve extensions; a judge may reduce an excessive penalty (art. 163 para. 3 CO). Reference: art. 98 SIA 118, art. 163 CO.
- Flat-rate prorata account of 3% to 6% without supporting documents (To negotiate). A percentage levy, with no statement of actual costs, directly erodes your margin. Ask for a documented statement, a clear basis and a cap. Reference: art. 129 to 135 SIA 118.
- Site water, electricity and heating charged to you (To negotiate). SIA 118 puts the electricity supply up to the connection point (art. 129) and water (art. 133) on the client, as well as the consumption of the finishing trades (art. 135 para. 3), unless a clause provides otherwise. Refuse a flat-rate deduction or price it into your bid. Reference: art. 129, 133 to 135 SIA 118.
- General cleaning and skips spread across all trades (To negotiate). Have costs allocated by cause: everyone removes their own waste, and shared cleaning is invoiced according to a justified key. Reference: art. 129 to 135 SIA 118.
- Global liability (RC) or construction works (ATC) insurance re-invoiced (To negotiate). You sometimes pay twice: your own RC and the general contractor's share. Ask for the policy, the actual premium and the allocation key.
- Flat-rate telephone, sanitary facilities, fencing, site sign and badge charges (To negotiate). Flat amounts unrelated to your share of the site: cap them or build them into a single rate, negotiated before signing.
- Discount deducted automatically, even in case of late payment (Dangerous clause). Under SIA 118, a client who pays after 30 days loses the right to the discount (art. 190 para. 1). An automatic deduction circumvents this rule: make the discount conditional on payment within the deadline. Reference: art. 190 SIA 118.
- Guarantee retention or surety above the standard, or released late (To negotiate). SIA 118 provides for a retention of 10% of the value of the services (5% of the value, at least 50'000 CHF, from 500'000 CHF) and a surety of 10% of the total sum (5% of the total sum, at least 30'000 CHF, from 300'000 CHF); the retention falls due on acceptance, at the final statement and on delivery of the surety (art. 150, 152, 181). Align the contract with these values. Reference: art. 150, 152, 181 SIA 118.
- Extended payment periods (60 to 90 days) or payment subject to an approval with no time limit (To negotiate). The SIA 118 period is 30 days (art. 190). Demand a firm period, default interest and the possibility to terminate after an additional period. Reference: art. 190 SIA 118.
- Ban on invoicing variation orders, daywork or price escalation ("all-inclusive, fixed and non-revisable price") (Dangerous clause). This clause may deprive you of art. 86 (variation of quantities), art. 87 (new services) and price escalation. The flat price excludes price escalation if it is expressly designated as such (art. 41): check what is written. Reference: art. 41, 64, 86, 87 SIA 118.
Reading guide, not legal advice: have any important contract reviewed by a lawyer. Also compare the contract with the rules of SIA 118 using the SIA 118 and Code of Obligations comparator.
Frequently Asked Questions on General Contractor Agreements in Switzerland (FAQ)
1. Is a prorata account of 3% to 6% legal?
A deduction agreed in the contract is in principle valid: the question is whether you signed it knowingly. SIA 118 puts electricity (art. 129), water (art. 133) and, for the finishing trades, the consumption of electricity, gas and water (art. 135 para. 3) on the client, unless a clause provides otherwise: a flat-rate deduction therefore departs from the standard.
On a bid of 150'000 CHF, the tool's default deductions (6.4%) cost 9'600 CHF and bring a margin of 15'000 CHF down to 5'400 CHF: 64% of net profit goes in deductions.
2. How do I offset these deductions in my bid?
Mark up your unit prices before submitting the bid: coefficient = 1 / (1 − total deduction rate). With 6.4% of deductions, the coefficient is 1.0684, i.e. a markup of 6.84%: a bid of 150'000 CHF becomes 160'256.41 CHF, of which the deductions leave exactly 150'000 CHF.
This markup remains to be justified in your price calculation; in a public or competitive market, weigh it against the risk of losing the bid.
3. Can I waive the craftsmen's statutory lien in advance?
No: a clause by which you would waive the right to register the statutory lien in advance is void (art. 837 Civil Code (CC)). It does not bind you, but it flags a principal to watch: strike it out or have it withdrawn before signing.
The right to register the lien must nevertheless be exercised within 4 months from completion of the works (art. 839 para. 2 Civil Code (CC)): see the deadline calculator.
4. What is a "pay-when-paid" clause and how do you avoid it?
In such a clause, the subcontractor is paid only once the general contractor has itself been paid by the client. You thus bear the insolvency or dispute risk of a third party that you do not control. SIA 118 provides instead for payment within 30 days (art. 190 para. 1).
Strike out the clause or limit it to a firm maximum period, and keep the possibility to send a formal notice and to terminate after an additional period (art. 190 para. 2).
Indicative information that does not replace a lawyer's advice. The tool's default percentages are examples: enter those of your contract.
