Aller au contenu
Website
SIA 118 · Art. 181 Tool 3.10 Online

Cash-Flow Simulator: Guarantee Surety (Art. 181 SIA 118) vs Cash Retention

Compare, for your cash flow, a guarantee surety and a cash retention of 5% or 10%.

Interactive tool

CHF

2 Duration of the defects warranty

% per year
% per year
%
% per year

The SIA 118 guarantees on this amount

Phase 1, during the works: cash retention on interim payments (art. 150)
Phase 2, at acceptance: joint and several surety required (art. 181)

Retention: 10 % of the value of the services; if the consideration exceeds 500'000 CHF, 5 % but at least 50'000 CHF, capped at 2'000'000 CHF. Surety: 10 % of the total sum; once it exceeds 300'000 CHF, 5 % of the total sum (and not by bands), at least 30'000 CHF and at most 2'000'000 CHF. The retention only falls due if acceptance, the final account and the surety are all in place (art. 152).

Financial comparison over the warranty period

Cash retention, bank guarantee and surety insurance: liquidity recovered and cost
CriterionCash retention blocked with the clientBank guaranteeSurety insurance
Liquidity recovered at acceptance
Total cost over the period
Cost breakdownCost of tied-up cash
Net gain compared with the cash retention—

The premiums (insurance 1.20 %, bank 0.90 %) and the cost of money (5.50 %) are examples: request quotes from your bank and from a surety company. The premium is in principle tax-deductible as an operating expense.

Embed this calculator on a website page

Paste this code into the page, or write [outil code="3.10"] in the content of a page on the site.

📄 Files and templates linked to this tool (free)

Move from calculation to full management

Keep your references at hand, then automate them in your quotes, bids and final statements.

⚡ Automate this calculation in our ERP / Soumission software (Trial)

Technical reference guide

How does the cash-flow blockage work on a site governed by the SIA 118 standard?

On a site governed by the SIA 118, the client keeps back part of each interim payment: this is the retention. It is only released when three conditions are met together, including the delivery of a surety. It is this rule that blocks the cash flow of SMEs (PME): on a contract of 450'000 CHF, 45'000 CHF stay with the client, interest-free, until the contractor has provided their guarantee. The simulator quantifies this blockage and compares it with the cost of a surety.

1. Phase 1 (During the works — Art. 149 to 152 SIA 118): the 10 % cash retention on each interim payment (5 % if the contract exceeds 500'000 CHF)

The retention on interim payments art 150 SIA 118 serves as security for the client until acceptance (art. 149). It is 10 % of the value of the services at the end of each month; if the consideration exceeds 500'000 CHF, it is 5 % of the value but at least 50'000 CHF, and cannot exceed 2'000'000 CHF unless otherwise agreed (art. 150). There is no retention on price-escalation invoices or daywork invoices (art. 149 para. 2). The amount retained falls due when the work is accepted, the final account is submitted and its review period has expired, and the guarantee of article 181 is in place; until it falls due, it bears no interest (art. 152).

2. Phase 2 (At acceptance of the work — Art. 181 SIA 118): the release of the cash against delivery of a 2-year joint and several surety certificate (10 % up to 300'000 CHF, then 5 % on the excess, capped at 1'000'000 CHF)

Clarification on the text of the standard. The joint and several surety performance guarantee SIA 118 art 181 is not calculated by bands: the text of article 181 para. 2 provides for 10 % of the total sum of the remuneration; as soon as this sum exceeds 300'000 CHF, 5 % of the total sum, but at least 30'000 CHF and at most 2'000'000 CHF (and not 1'000'000 CHF). For 450'000 CHF, the surety required is therefore 30'000 CHF (the minimum of 30'000 CHF), and not 37'500 CHF. The tool applies the text of the standard.

To replace 10% retention with a surety, the contractor delivers at acceptance a joint and several surety from a bank, a reputable insurance company or, with the client's consent, a professional organisation. The surety remains in force until the 2-year period for notifying defects expires, and must be extended if defects that have been raised are not yet repaired (art. 181 para. 3). It makes it possible to release cash Swiss construction company: on 450'000 CHF, you recover 45'000 CHF of retention against a guarantee of 30'000 CHF, for a premium of 360 CHF per year at 1.20 %. The same thresholds are compared with the Code of Obligations in the SIA 118 and CO comparator.

Retention (art. 150) and surety (art. 181) according to the contract amount
Contract amountCash retention (Art. 150)Joint and several guarantee (Art. 181)
100'000 CHF10'000 CHF10'000 CHF
250'000 CHF25'000 CHF25'000 CHF
300'000 CHF30'000 CHF30'000 CHF
450'000 CHF45'000 CHF30'000 CHF
500'000 CHF50'000 CHF30'000 CHF
600'000 CHF50'000 CHF30'000 CHF
1'000'000 CHF50'000 CHF50'000 CHF
2'000'000 CHF100'000 CHF100'000 CHF
5'000'000 CHF250'000 CHF250'000 CHF

Financial comparison: Cash retention blocked with the client vs Bank Surety vs Surety Insurance Company

The difference between a bank surety and surety insurance is above all a question of hidden cost. A bank charges a lower premium (in the order of 0.8 % to 1.0 % per year) but charges the surety against your credit limit or requires a pledge: this reserved credit line can no longer finance your business. A surety company or an insurance company generally charges more (in the order of 1.2 % per year) but leaves your credit line intact. In both cases, the premium is an operating expense that is in principle deductible.

Comparison over 2 years for a contract of 450'000 CHF
CriterionCash retentionBank guaranteeSurety insurance
Liquidity recovered at acceptance0 CHF (blocked for 2 years)45'000 CHF45'000 CHF
Total cost over 2 years4'950 CHF (tied-up cash at 5,50%)3'840 CHF (premium 540 CHF + reserved credit line 3'300 CHF)720 CHF (premium at 1,20%)
Net gain compared with the retention—+1'110 CHF+4'230 CHF

The rates are examples; the cost of the money tied up depends on your situation. Exceptionally, the parties may agree to replace the surety with a cash deposit at a fair rate of interest (art. 182). A surety company often requires a counter-guarantee or a solvency check.

⚡ Track your retentions and guarantees in Soumission

Frequently Asked Questions on Financial Guarantees in Construction (FAQ)

1. What is the difference between the retention and the joint and several surety?

The retention (art. 149 and 150 SIA 118) is a cash amount deducted from each interim payment during the works: it secures performance until acceptance. The joint and several surety (art. 181) is a commitment by a bank, an insurance company or, with the client's consent, a professional organisation: it secures defects until the end of the 2-year notification period.

The retention bears no interest until it falls due (art. 152 para. 3). The surety does not block your cash: you pay a premium.

2. How is the surety calculated: by bands or on the total sum?

On the total sum, and not by bands: 10 % of the total sum of the remuneration; once it exceeds 300'000 CHF, 5 % of the total sum, but at least 30'000 CHF and at most 2'000'000 CHF (art. 181 para. 2). For 250'000 CHF: 25'000 CHF. For 450'000 CHF: 5 % gives 22'500 CHF, so the minimum of 30'000 CHF applies. For 600'000 CHF: 30'000 CHF.

A calculation by bands (10 % on 300'000 CHF then 5 % beyond) would give 37'500 CHF for 450'000 CHF: this is not what the standard provides, and the tool applies the text of the standard. Likewise, the retention of article 150 is 10 % up to 500'000 CHF (45'000 CHF for 450'000 CHF); beyond that, 5 % but at least 50'000 CHF (50'000 CHF for 600'000 CHF), capped at 2'000'000 CHF.

3. When is the cash retention recovered?

The retention falls due when three conditions are met: acceptance of the work, submission of the final account with expiry of the review period, and the provision of the guarantee of article 181, that is, the surety (art. 152 para. 1). This is precisely what makes the surety useful: without it, the retention remains blocked.

Example from the tool, for 450'000 CHF: a surety of 30'000 CHF lets you recover 45'000 CHF of retention as soon as the three conditions are met.

4. Bank surety or surety insurance: which to choose?

A bank often asks for a lower premium (in the order of 0.8 % to 1.0 % per year) but charges the surety against your credit limit or requires a pledge. A surety company or an insurance company generally charges more (in the order of 1.2 % per year) but does not block your credit line.

With the tool's default values (450'000 CHF, 2 years, money at 5.50 %), the blocked retention costs 4'950 CHF, the surety insurance 720 CHF and the bank surety 3'840 CHF, pledge included. These rates are examples: request quotes.

5. Can the retention be replaced by a guarantee during the works?

The standard provides for the retention during the works (art. 149 and 150) and the surety after acceptance; the contract may also require the contractor to provide, before the first interim payment, an additional guarantee (art. 149 para. 3). Replacing the retention with a bank guarantee from the start of the works is therefore a special agreement to be negotiated with the client.

Exceptionally, the parties may also replace the surety with a cash deposit at a fair rate of interest (art. 182). Have any change reviewed by a lawyer.

Indicative information based on the text of the SIA 118 standard (2013 edition); it does not replace the advice of a lawyer or the quote from your bank or insurer.

📥 Ready-to-use pack · free

Download the document

The file is displayed on screen right away and we also send it to you by e-mail.

Your address is used to send you this file. See our privacy policy.