Safety Glass Decision Tree (ESG / VSG — SIGaB 002) & Weight Calculator
Mandatory decision tree: toughened glass ESG vs laminated glass VSG (from <1 m above ground).
Interactive tool
Rules of the bpa / bfu (2020), which takes over the SIGAB 002 directive; texts of SIGAB 002 and SIA 358 not consulted. Guardrails: VSG; lower edge below 1,00 m: ESG or VSG; roof, canopy, glazed roof: VSG on the underside, from 15° to the vertical (the specifications said 10°). ESG of 6 or 8 mm in showers: specifications. Weight: 2,5 kg/m² per mm of glass; PVB film of 0,38 mm about 0,4 kg/m². Carrying limits: Suva for 25 and 15 kg, specifications for 60 to 80 kg.
A Decision tree: which safety glass?
Glass to be used
- Visual marking
SIGAB 002 directive "Sicherheit mit Glas – Anforderungen an Glasbauteile" (2017) and SIA 358: texts not consulted, rules taken from the bpa / bfu.
B Glazing weight and handling
Weight and number of installers
- Area
- Weight per m²
- Glass weight
- Weight of the PVB films
- Total weight
Weight = width × height × (glass thickness × 2.50 + number of films × 0.4). "66.2" = 2 sheets of 6 mm and 2 films of 0.38 mm; in triple glazing only the glass counts.
Embed this calculator on a website page
Paste this code into the page, or write [outil code="6.29"] in the content of a page on the site.
📄 File linked to this tool (free)
Move from calculation to full management
Keep your references at hand, then automate them in your quotes, bids and final statements.
Technical reference guide
SIGaB 002 directive in Switzerland: the mandatory 1.00-metre-from-floor rule and the craftsperson's responsibility
The SIGaB 002 directive safety glass mandatory ESG VSG Switzerland is published by the Schweizerisches Institut für Glas am Bau (SIGAB, Schlieren) under the title "Sicherheit mit Glas – Anforderungen an Glasbauteile" (2017). The bpa / bfu documentation "Glas in der Architektur" (2020) states that, when a technical standard does not answer a question about glass, the SIGAB directives and the bfu recommendations apply. Glazing less than 1 metre from the floor SIGaB 002 is the most common case: ordinary glass (float) is permitted only if the upper edge of the lower rebate is at least 1.0 m above the walkable surface; below that, safety glass is used, ESG or VSG.
According to the bfu, the client or their representative defines the protection requirements (SIA 118) and is responsible for the proper tendering of the glazing. The glazier who supplies safety glass must be able to provide written proof of it: an ESG carries a mark visible after installation, with the manufacturer's name and the numbers of standards EN 12150-1 and EN 14179 or EN 14428. Unsuitable glazing noted before installation is reported in writing to the site management.
Clarification on the text of the directive. The SIGAB 002 directive itself was not consulted: the rules below are those that the bpa / bfu documentation (2020) takes from it, together with the SIA 358 standard "Railings and parapets", whose fall threshold of 1.00 m is cited by the bpa. The French title "Le verre et la sécurité" in the specification was not found.
ESG (Toughened safety glass) vs VSG (Laminated safety glass with PVB film): which to choose according to the application?
The difference toughened glass ESG and laminated glass VSG lies in the way it breaks. ESG is a single thermally toughened glass: more resistant to impact and heat, it disintegrates on breaking into small blunt pieces, which avoid serious cuts but free the whole opening, with no residual strength. VSG consists of at least two sheets bonded by a film (PVB): after breakage, the fragments stay stuck to the film and the opening stays closed. Heat-strengthened glass (TVG) alone is not safety glass (it breaks into shards like float), but a VSG made of TVG offers high residual strength.
For an all-glass railing VSG/TVG SIA 358, VSG with residual strength is the rule: ESG is unsuitable, the glass must not let the user fall into the void. Which glass where, according to the bpa / bfu documentation:
| Application | Float, patterned glass, TVG only | ESG | VSG |
|---|---|---|---|
| Glass guardrails and balustrades | Unsuitable | Unsuitable | Suitable (residual strength) |
| Window with a sill, glass at 1.0 m or more above the floor | Suitable | Suitable | Suitable |
| Window whose glass is less than 1.0 m above the floor | Unsuitable | Suitable (fall protection under SIA 358 if there is a danger of falling) | Suitable |
| Glazed façades | Unsuitable | Suitable (fall protection under SIA 358 if there is a danger of falling) | Suitable |
| Interior glass walls, all-glass installations, wet rooms | Unsuitable | Suitable | Suitable |
| Glass doors or doors with glazed infill | Unsuitable | Suitable (both sides in insulating glazing) | Suitable (both sides in insulating glazing) |
| Stairs, floors, walkable glazing | Unsuitable | Unsuitable | Suitable (non-slip surface) |
| Glazed roofs, overhead glazing | Unsuitable | Unsuitable (except the middle or upper pane of an insulating unit) | Suitable |
For the structure of a steel railing receiving glass, see the steel and railing tool SIA 358.
Formula of 2.5 kg/m2 per millimetre: calculating the weight of triple glazing or a VSG glass railing
The calculation glazing weight kg/m2 2.5 kg per mm follows from the density of glass, 2 500 kg/m³: one millimetre of glass weighs 2.5 kg per square metre. Total weight = width × height × (total glass thickness in mm × 2.5 + number of PVB films × 0.4), because a PVB film of 0.38 mm weighs about 0.4 kg/m². Only the glass sheets count: the air gaps of triple glazing weigh nothing. The digit after the point in "66.2" is the number of 0.38 mm films. For 1.40 × 2.20 m:
| Composition | Glass | PVB films | Weight per m² | Total weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single glazing 4 mm | 4 mm | 0 | 10,00 kg/m² | 30,8 kg |
| Single glazing 6 mm | 6 mm | 0 | 15,00 kg/m² | 46,2 kg |
| Single glazing 8 mm | 8 mm | 0 | 20,00 kg/m² | 61,6 kg |
| Single glazing 10 mm | 10 mm | 0 | 25,00 kg/m² | 77,0 kg |
| Single glazing 12 mm | 12 mm | 0 | 30,00 kg/m² | 92,4 kg |
| Double glazing 4 / 16 / 4 (8 mm of glass) | 8 mm | 0 | 20,00 kg/m² | 61,6 kg |
| VSG 44.2 (8 mm of glass, 2 PVB films of 0.38 mm) | 8 mm | 2 | 20,80 kg/m² | 64,1 kg |
| VSG 55.2 (10 mm of glass, 2 PVB films) | 10 mm | 2 | 25,80 kg/m² | 79,5 kg |
| VSG 66.2 (12 mm of glass, 2 PVB films) | 12 mm | 2 | 30,80 kg/m² | 94,9 kg |
| VSG 88.2 (16 mm of glass, 2 PVB films) | 16 mm | 2 | 40,80 kg/m² | 125,7 kg |
| Triple glazing 4 / 16 / 4 / 16 / 44.2 (16 mm of glass in total, 2 PVB films) | 16 mm | 2 | 40,80 kg/m² | 125,7 kg |
Up to 25 kg, a fitter can carry the pane occasionally (Suva reference value for a man, 15 kg for a woman); between 25 and 60 kg, several fitters with suction cups are needed; between 60 and 80 kg, the specification recommends a suction-cup lifting beam; beyond that, mechanical lifting or a glazing robot. The railing in the example weighs 94.9 kg. For windows and their insulation, see the windows tool SIA 331.
Clarification on the values. The density of 2 500 kg/m³ is physical; the weight of the PVB film (about 0.4 kg/m²) is that of the specification, consistent with a density of about 1.07 g/cm³. The thresholds of 25 and 15 kg are those of the Suva for occasional carrying; the Suva gives no value for carrying by several people, and the thresholds of 60 to 80 kg are those of the specification. Manufacturers' weights prevail for ordering.
Visual marking of glass walls (SIA 500 standard) and safety of glazing in roofs or canopies (overhead glass)
Glazed doors and large walls without a horizontal profile present a collision risk. The bpa / bfu recommends marking glass elements in the circulation zone, and the SIA 500 standard "Barrier-free construction" requires obstacles to be marked; according to the bfu, it applies to buildings open to the public, buildings with more than 50 workstations and housing with more than eight apartments per entrance. The marking combines light and dark patterns in the field of view of a standing person as well as of a person in a wheelchair; 50 % of the marked surfaces remain transparent and the gap between two marked surfaces does not exceed 10 cm.
Above people, glazing that deviates from the vertical by 15° or more is roof glazing: the single glazing, or the lower pane of an insulating unit, is VSG of float or TVG, to retain shards; the upper pane is preferably ESG against hail. Glass roofs, canopies and awnings often have free edges: the glass and fixing are adapted to the use below (access, delivery, bicycle parking). A shower screen is made of ESG; a large mirror is bonded over its whole surface or receives a safety film.
Clarification on the text. The specification sets the threshold for inclined glazing at more than 10° from the vertical; the bfu uses 15° or more (10° is the minimum slope of a glass roof for draining water): the tool applies 15°. ESG of 6 or 8 mm for a shower is a value from the specification, not verified. The marking heights appear in the bfu figure and in SIA 500, not reproduced here. ⚡ Price your glazing in Soumission
Frequently Asked Questions on ESG and VSG Safety Glass and the Weight of Glazing (FAQ)
1. When is toughened glass (ESG) or laminated safety glass (VSG) mandatory?
According to the bpa / bfu documentation, which takes up the SIGAB 002 directive and the SIA 358 standard: a glass railing or a sill with a fall height of at least 1.00 m requires VSG with residual strength (ESG is not suitable); glazing whose lower edge is less than 1.00 m from the floor requires safety glass, ESG or VSG, ordinary glass being permitted only from 1.00 m; a fully glazed door requires safety glass on both sides in an insulating unit; glazing in a roof, canopy or glass roof requires VSG on the underside; a shower screen is made of ESG and a large mirror as a mirror bonded over its whole surface or fitted with a safety film.
The specification speaks of an inclination of more than 10° for glass roofs; the bpa / bfu uses 15° or more from the vertical, the value applied here. The SIGAB 002 directive ("Sicherheit mit Glas – Anforderungen an Glasbauteile", 2017) and SIA 358 were not consulted directly, and ESG of 6 or 8 mm in a shower is a value from the specification.
2. How do you calculate the weight of glazing with the formula of 2.5 kg/m² per millimetre?
The weight is the width × the height × (the glass thickness in mm × 2.5 + the number of PVB films × 0.4): for 1.40 × 2.20 m in VSG 66.2 (2 sheets of 6 mm and 2 films of 0.38 mm), that gives 30.8 kg/m², that is 94.9 kg; a triple glazing 4 / 16 / 4 / 16 / 44.2 (16 mm of glass in total) weighs 125.7 kg, and a single glazing of 8 mm 61.6 kg. Only the glass counts: the air gaps weigh nothing.
The density of glass is 2'500 kg/m³ and a PVB film of 0.38 mm weighs about 0.4 kg/m² (value from the specification). Manufacturers' weights prevail for ordering.
3. How many fitters are needed and from what weight should a suction-cup lifting beam be used?
The Suva gives 25 kg for a man and 15 kg for a woman as reference values for occasionally carrying a load: up to 25 kg, one fitter is enough. Between 25 and 60 kg, several fitters with manual suction cups are needed; between 60 and 80 kg, the specification recommends a suction-cup lifting beam; above 80 kg, lifting is mechanical. The railing in the example (94.9 kg) therefore calls for a suction-cup lifting beam or a glazing robot.
The Suva gives no value for carrying by several people, and the thresholds of 60 to 80 kg are those of the specification, not verified: follow the lifting beam's instructions and the site's risk analysis.
Indicative information based on the tool's specification and the bpa / bfu documentation; it does not replace the SIGAB 002 directive, the SIA 358 and SIA 500 standards, or the opinion of the glazier or engineer.
