Aller au contenu
Website
🛡️ Fraud prevention series Anomaly No. 9 PDF + Word guide FRAUD 07

Blackmail with false defects at the end of a project: blocked balance, notice of defects, preservation of evidence and expert opinion (CPC)

At the end of a project, the contractor sometimes discovers that their balance is being withheld in the name of “various defects”, with no list, no photo, and a proposed discount to be signed quickly. It may be a genuine disagreement or pressure to obtain a reduction. The law provides tools: notice of defects, expert opinion, preservation of evidence, debt enforcement, legal action. This page teaches you to recognise the signals, to keep proof of the state of the work and to know whom to turn to. A signal is not proof: only the authority and the judge characterise the facts.

PDFDOCX

The guide: Blackmail with false defects at the end of a project

The detailed guide for this page in PDF and Word: legal basis, steps to follow, template letters and evidence checklist.

🔎 Scanner of the 26 anomalies

An e-mail address is requested: the guide is displayed immediately and is also sent to you by e-mail (signed links valid for 7 days).

How the trap works and which warning signs to look for

The mechanism on the ground in French-speaking Switzerland

When the balance falls due, the owner or the general contractor (EG) invokes defects and withholds a large sum. An owner with genuine defects is acting legitimately: price reduction, rectification, damages if the contractor is at fault (Art. 368 para. 1-2 CO). The problem arises when the allegation is used as leverage: undescribed defects, a retention unrelated to the cost of rectification, a discount proposal to be signed “to be done with it”, a deadline invoked (sale, financing).

The contractor is then tempted to give in, because an expert opinion costs time and money. The law does not quantify the part of the balance that may be withheld: whoever withholds must remain proportionate to the real defects (Art. 82 CO). And whoever signs a receipt or a discount is bound, because a release of debt is valid without any form (Art. 115 CO).

Each fact on this page may have a regular explanation. They call for a written request for details, never an accusation.

Warning signs (Red Flags) to check before and during the works

The list below sets out the observable clues. The more of them accumulate, the more useful it is to ask for the list of defects, to propose a joint inspection and to consult a lawyer.

  • Defects are announced for the first time when the balance falls due, with no detailed list or photo, although nothing had been noted at acceptance.
  • The amount withheld bears no relation to the cost of rectification or the reduction in value that can reasonably be expected from the alleged defects, and no costing is provided.
  • Access to the work to inspect or repair is refused, or a third party steps in before you have been able to inspect the defects.
  • The list of defects grows with each exchange and changes in nature without any new inspection.
  • A discount is proposed together with the retention, with urgency to sign (sale, financing, deadline).
  • The joint inspection, the joint expert or the preservation of evidence are dismissed without reason given.
  • The defects invoked stem from choices imposed by the owner or from other trades, which you flagged in writing.

Mini-diagnosis: how many signals do you spot?

Tick the signals that match your situation: the result is a simple count, calculated in your browser, with no percentage and no recording of your answers.

Mini-diagnosis: is your balance being withheld for doubtful defects?

Tick the signals that match your situation. The result is a count of signals, calculated in your browser and never sent.

This is neither a diagnosis nor proof: a signal calls for a check, not an accusation.

Warning signs

Tick the signals you have observed: the result appears here, box by box.

📥 Get the PDF/Word guide

Swiss legal framework, evidence and template letters

Legal bases: CO, CC, CP, LP and SIA 118

The owner must check the work and report defects as soon as it can; for an immovable work it has 60 days and a shorter agreement is void (Art. 367 para. 1-1bis CO). This rule applies to contracts concluded from 1 January 2026; before that, notice had to be immediate (see doc_09). Without notice, the work is deemed accepted with those defects (Art. 370 para. 2-3 CO). The owner cannot invoke defects attributable to it, for example through orders given against the contractor’s formal warnings (Art. 369 CO).

To establish the state of the work, each party may ask for an examination by experts (Art. 367 para. 2 CO). The court also takes evidence in advance where its endangerment or an interest worthy of protection is made plausible (Art. 158 para. 1 CPC); appointing an expert to examine the work falls under the summary procedure (Art. 250 CPC). To claim the balance, the contractor may have a payment order served (Art. 74 para. 1 LP), apply for provisional removal of the objection if it holds an acknowledgment of debt (Art. 82 para. 1 LP) or sue after conciliation (Art. 197 CPC), under the simplified procedure up to 30'000 francs (Art. 243 para. 1 CPC).

Under pressure, the law protects: an agreement concluded under well-founded fear is not binding, but fear of seeing a right invoked counts only if the victim’s predicament was exploited to extort excessive advantages (Art. 29 para. 1 CO, Art. 30 para. 2 CO); the time limit for acting is one year (Art. 31 para. 1-2 CO). Criminal law knows extortion (Art. 156 No. 1 CP) and coercion (Art. 181 CP), but only the public prosecutor’s office and the criminal court decide whether they apply to specific facts. The files doc_09 and doc_18 detail the standard procedure for defects and disputes.

The rules at a glance

RuleArticleWhat the text says
Price payable on deliveryArt. 372 para. 1 COThe price is payable on delivery of the work; withholding the balance requires a clause or a statutory exception.
Defence of non-performanceArt. 82 COWhoever claims performance must have performed; the law does not quantify the part of the balance the owner may withhold, which must remain in proportion to the real defects.
Checking and notice of defectsArt. 367 para. 1-1bis CO ; Art. 370 para. 2-4 COThe owner checks and reports defects; 60 days for an immovable work under the revised law; without notice, the work is deemed accepted with those defects.
Owner’s rightsArt. 368 para. 1-2 CO ; Art. 369 CORejection if the work is unusable, otherwise price reduction or rectification, plus damages if at fault; no rights for defects attributable to the owner.
Expert opinion and preservation of evidenceArt. 367 para. 2 CO ; Art. 158 para. 1-2 CPC ; Art. 250 CPCEach party may ask for an examination by experts; the court takes endangered evidence; appointing an expert falls under the summary procedure.
Amount in dispute and procedureArt. 243 para. 1 CPC ; Art. 210 para. 1 CPC ; Art. 212 para. 1 CPC ; Art. 308 para. 2 CPC30'000 francs: simplified procedure; 10'000: proposed decision and appeal; 2'000: decision of the conciliation authority.
Debt enforcementArt. 74 para. 1 LP ; Art. 82 para. 1 LPObjection within ten days; provisional removal of the objection on an acknowledgment of debt.
Release of debt, pressureArt. 115 CO ; Art. 29 para. 1 CO ; Art. 30 para. 2 CO ; Art. 31 para. 1 COA discount or a receipt is valid without any form; an agreement concluded under well-founded fear is not binding, but the action is time-barred after one year.
Possible criminal consequencesArt. 156 No. 1 CP ; Art. 181 CPExtortion and coercion presuppose a threat of serious harm; only the criminal authorities decide on their application.

Contractual shield and evidence to gather

Before signing: have the contract provide for an acceptance with a signed report, a joint check within a fixed time limit, the appointment of a neutral expert in case of disagreement and a rule for a retention proportionate to the quantified defects. On the day of acceptance, photograph the work and keep proof of its state.

  • Dated and signed acceptance report, or notice of completion and letters setting the check.
  • Dated photos and videos at the end of the works, before any intervention by a third party.
  • Daily reports, delivery notes and technical data sheets of the materials installed.
  • All notices of defects received: date of receipt, method of sending, exact content.
  • A dated summary, written the same day, of any conversation involving pressure or a discount.
  1. Demand the written list of defects: description, location, dated photos, date of discovery, amount withheld and calculation (letter 1).
  2. Check the chronology: date of acceptance, date of notice of defects, applicable time limit.
  3. Offer access and a joint inspection on a specific date, as well as a neutral joint expert.
  4. If the state of the work is likely to change (work by third parties, sale, bad weather), consider preservation of evidence with a lawyer.
  5. Pay or claim the undisputed part (letter 2) with formal notice and a reservation of rights.
  6. Do not sign any full-and-final receipt or discount without legal advice.
  7. Document any pressure in writing, without answering a threat with a threat.
  8. On the side of the owner acting in good faith: give notice, describe, quantify, allow access to repair and withhold proportionately (letter 3).

Template letter models

Letter 1: request for the detailed list of alleged defects

[Place, date] · Registered mail and e-mail · To: [owner / general contractor] · Copy: [site management]

Subject: site [name] · final invoice No. [..] · retention of CHF [amount] for alleged defects

Dear Sir or Madam, you are withholding CHF [amount] from our final invoice, citing undescribed defects. The work was accepted on [date]; we received no notice of defects before [date]. Please send us by [date: 10 days] the list of each defect (nature, location, date of discovery), the dated photographs, the estimated cost of rectification and the calculation of the amount withheld. We propose a joint inspection on [date] and the appointment of a joint expert (Art. 367 para. 2 CO). We dispute that the retention is proportionate to the defects announced (Art. 82 CO, Art. 368 para. 2 CO). All our rights are reserved. Yours faithfully, [Name, position, signature] · Annexes: acceptance report, final invoice.

Letter 2: formal notice to pay the undisputed part and reservation of rights

[Place, date] · Registered mail and e-mail · To: [owner / general contractor]

Subject: site [name] · final invoice No. [..] · formal notice to pay CHF [amount]

Dear Sir or Madam, our final invoice of CHF [amount] has been due since [date] (Art. 372 para. 1 CO). You are withholding CHF [amount] of it in the name of defects that you have neither described nor costed; the undisputed part therefore amounts to CHF [amount]. We call on you to pay it by [date: 10 days] (Art. 102 para. 1 CO), failing which we will claim default interest at 5 % a year (Art. 104 para. 1 CO) and have a payment order served. For the disputed part, we remain available for a joint inspection and a joint expert, and we reserve preservation of evidence (Art. 158 CPC) should the state of the work change. We will not sign any full-and-final receipt. Yours faithfully, [Name, position, signature]

Letter 3: notice of defects with reasoned retention (owner acting in good faith)

[Place, date] · Registered mail and e-mail · To: [company] · Copy: [site management]

Subject: site [name] · notice of defects of [date] · request for rectification · retention of CHF [amount]

Dear Sir or Madam, we have found the following defects, described and photographed in the annex: [defect 1: location, nature]; [defect 2: location, nature]. We discovered them on [date] and report them to you within the statutory time limit (Art. 367 para. 1 CO). We ask you to remedy them by [date: reasonable time limit] (Art. 368 para. 2 CO). We have estimated the cost of rectification at CHF [amount] (quote attached) and are withholding CHF [amount] from your invoice; this retention will be released once the remedy has been jointly verified. We remain open to a joint expert (Art. 367 para. 2 CO). Yours faithfully, [Name, position, signature] · Annexes: list of defects with photographs, rectification quote.

Where to report

A disagreement about defects is first of all a civil dispute: conciliation, then the court. Where there are signs of threats, coercion or extortion, the criminal complaint is made to the police or the public prosecutor’s office; the addresses below were read on the day of writing.

Protect yourself with the ACIP index and the Soumission software, frequently asked questions

How to lock down your site with the ACIP index and Soumission

A balance is easier to defend when the offer, the quantities and the prices are documented from the start. The ACIP index gives price benchmarks by CFC code to justify your items, and the Soumission software helps keep an offer structured, with its payment, acceptance and guarantee conditions, before signing the contract.

📊 See the ACIP index (Art Construction Indice de Prix)

Is there a legal threshold below which a judicial expert opinion is not possible?

No. In the texts read, each party may ask, at its own expense, for the work to be examined by experts (Art. 367 para. 2 CO) and the court takes evidence in advance with no amount condition (Art. 158 para. 1 CPC). The CPC thresholds concern the procedure: 2'000 francs, 10'000 francs and 30'000 francs. A retention of 15'000 to 25'000 francs falls under the simplified procedure, preceded by conciliation. The cost of an expert opinion remains an economic calculation, to be discussed with a lawyer.

How long does the owner have to report defects?

For an immovable work, it has 60 days to report them, and a shorter agreement is void (Art. 367 para. 1bis CO); this rule applies to contracts concluded from 1 January 2026. Before that, notice had to be given immediately. Without notice, the work is deemed accepted with its defects (Art. 370 para. 2-3 CO). The starting point for a visible defect is not specified by the text: check with a lawyer.

Can I deposit the disputed balance instead of paying it?

The law provides for deposit when the creditor is in default (Art. 92 para. 1 CO) or when ownership of the claim is disputed (Art. 168 para. 1 CO). In the texts read, nothing provides for it in a disagreement about defects. The parties may nevertheless agree to deposit the disputed sum with a notary, a bank or a third party, until the expert report or a decision. That arrangement is an agreement, not a rule of law.

Have I already signed a discount under pressure: can I go back?

A release of debt is valid without any form (Art. 115 CO). An agreement concluded under well-founded fear is not binding, but fear of seeing a right invoked is taken into account only if the victim’s predicament was exploited to extort excessive advantages (Art. 29 para. 1 CO, Art. 30 para. 2 CO). The time limit for acting is one year (Art. 31 para. 1-2 CO). Consult a lawyer quickly with your dated evidence.

Must I report a threat of this kind?

A disagreement about defects is first of all civil. If you receive specific threats, the criminal complaint is made to the police or the public prosecutor’s office. Extortion and coercion presuppose a threat of serious harm (Art. 156 No. 1 CP, Art. 181 CP); only the authorities decide whether these provisions apply. Keep the messages, describe dated facts and take advice before acting.

General information based on Swiss law in force — it does not replace personalised legal advice (lawyer or specialist legal adviser).

Sources read

The articles of SIA 118, a standard that is not freely available, must be checked in the edition applicable to your contract (marked (*) when they could not be confirmed). The numerical examples on this page are fictitious.

📥 Ready-to-use pack · free

Download the document

The file is displayed on screen right away and we also send it to you by e-mail.

Your address is used to send you this file. See our privacy policy.