Aller au contenu
Website
🛡️ Fraud prevention series Anomalies No. 12, 13, 14 PDF + Word guide FRAUD 10

Rigged tenders, bill-of-quantities leaks and COMCO bid-rigging cartels in Swiss construction: recognise, protect yourself, report

A tender protects the owner only if competition is real. Three situations recur on French-speaking Switzerland’s sites: a last round of negotiation in which only one bidder knows the price to beat, so-called “cover” bids submitted so that a company chosen in advance wins, and private benefits that flow back to the decision-maker. This page teaches you to recognise these signals, recalls what the cartel act, the Criminal Code and public procurement law say, and tells you whom to turn to. A signal is not proof: only the authority and the judge characterise the facts.

PDFDOCX

The guide: Rigged tenders and cartels

The detailed guide for this page in PDF and Word: legal basis, steps to follow, template letters and evidence checklist.

🔎 Scanner of the 26 anomalies

An e-mail address is requested: the guide is displayed immediately and is also sent to you by e-mail (signed links valid for 7 days).

How the trap works and which warning signs to look for

The mechanism on the ground in French-speaking Switzerland

Bill-of-quantities leak (anomaly 12). In a private tender, the owner or its agent invites several companies to price the same bill of quantities, then sometimes organises a last round. The signal: a single bidder receives, before the others, information that they do not have (the others’ prices, the amount to beat) and adjusts its bid. The others have worked on a competition that no longer existed.

Cartels and cover bids (anomaly 13). The COMCO describes the bid-rigging cartel as an agreement on the price to submit and on the company supposed to win, for public or private calls for tender. The other bids, called cover bids (“Abreden” in German-speaking Switzerland), give the appearance of competition: prices too high, unacceptable conditions, withdrawal for no reason. On 16 April 2026, the COMCO announced two investigations into private construction projects in the canton of Vaud; they establish nothing at this stage, and the companies concerned enjoy the presumption of innocence.

Kickbacks and free work (anomaly 14). A decision-maker (the owner’s representative, an architect or an appointed site manager) draws a personal benefit from a company on the site: free or discounted work in their home, a cash discount, a service without an invoice in their name. The cost may reappear in change orders or quantity measurements that nothing explains.

Warning signs (Red Flags) to check before and during the works

The first clues below are those that the COMCO itself publishes (leaflet “Combating bid-rigging cartels”, version of 9 September 2019, put online on 24 July 2025); the last ones concern the relationship between a decision-maker and a company. A single clue proves nothing: it is their accumulation, without explanation, that justifies asking questions in writing.

  • Identical or very similar prices on several individual items, or the same calculation errors in different bids.
  • A large, unexplained price gap between the best and second-best bid, while the other bids are bunched just above.
  • The same companies win the contracts in turn, or there are fewer bids than usual.
  • A bidder tries to find out who else is submitting a bid, or knows more than it should in the last round.
  • A bid is withdrawn for no understandable reason, or submitted by a company that cannot perform the contract.
  • A last round is offered to a single bidder, or figures are given orally without being passed on to everyone.
  • A decision-maker or their circle has received work, a discount or a service from a company on the site, without a written agreement or an invoice in their name.
  • Change orders, quantity measurements or unit prices rise without technical explanation at a company close to the decision-maker.

Mini-diagnosis: how many signals do you spot?

Tick what matches your case. The result is a simple count: nothing is sent or saved.

Do you see signals of a rigged tender or of a benefit to the decision-maker?

Tick what matches your case. Nothing is sent or saved: the result is a simple count of signals.

This is neither a diagnosis nor proof: a signal calls for a check, not an accusation.

Warning signs

Tick the signals you have observed: the result appears here, box by box.

📥 Get the PDF/Word guide

Swiss legal framework, evidence and template letters

Legal bases: CO, CC, CP, LP and SIA 118

Cartel law targets companies that collude, public procurement law public contracting authorities, criminal law bribery, trade secrets and unfaithful management, the law of obligations damages and restitution. Texts read on Fedlex on 2026-11-07. No article of the SIA 118 standard is cited here.

The rules at a glance

RuleArticleWhat the text says
Unlawful agreementsArt. 4 para. 1 and Art. 5 para. 3 LCartBetween competitors, fixing prices, restricting quantities or dividing up markets or trading partners is presumed to eliminate effective competition.
Sanction, cooperation and notificationArt. 49a LCart ; Art. 8 and 12 OS LCartUp to 10 % of Swiss turnover; waiver possible if the company cooperates; first company to notify: full waiver.
Report and civil actionsArt. 26, 27, 12 and 13 LCartInvestigation on a third party’s report; cessation, damages, surrender of profit, contracts void in whole or in part.
Public procurementArt. 11, 43, 44 and 45 LMP ; Art. 45 AIMPEqual treatment; interruption or exclusion on signs of an unlawful agreement, up to five years; information to the COMCO.
Bribery between private partiesArt. 322octies, 322novies and 322decies CPOffering or accepting an undue advantage: three years at most; on complaint if of minor gravity; authorised or minor advantages excluded.
Secrecy, unfaithful management, agentArt. 162 and 158 CP ; Art. 6 LCD ; Art. 398 and 400 CODisclosing a trade secret, harming the interests managed in breach of one’s duties; the agent accounts for and returns what it has received on that account.
Report, complaint, fraudArt. 301 CPP ; Art. 31 CP ; Art. 28 COAnyone may report; the complaint lapses three months after the offender becomes known; a contract obtained by fraud is not binding.

Contractual shield and evidence to gather

These measures partly follow those that the COMCO recommends to purchasers. Keeping them in writing, dated, is your first evidence.

  1. Owner: invite all the bidders by the same written notice, with the same bill of quantities and the same deadline; pass the answers to questions on to everyone.
  2. Have a declaration of independence of the bid signed and state the consequences of a breach, for example through a penalty clause, as the COMCO recommends.
  3. Avoid joint site visits that reveal the bidders’ identities; ask for the consortia and planned subcontractors to be declared.
  4. Open the bids with at least two people and a report (rule of Art. 37 LMP for the public sector, good practice in private tenders).
  5. Decide in writing who is invited to a last round and give everyone the same information; require from your agents a written declaration of advantages received (letter 2).
  6. Company asked to “coordinate”: record the proposal (date, person, content), do not follow it and take a lawyer’s advice before any step.
  7. Keep your evidence intact (bids, original e-mails, reports) and describe the facts, without characterising anyone, in your reports.

Template letter models

Letter 1: request for explanations and reservation of rights (unsuccessful company)

[Place], [date] · registered mail and e-mail

Subject: site [name], package [..], tender of [date], request for written explanations and reservation of rights

Dear Sir or Madam,

We submitted a bid of CHF [..] on [date]. We found that [specific, verifiable fact: an additional round was offered to only one bidder / information about the other bids was given to only one bidder]. We make no accusation: we ask for explanations.

Please tell us in writing, by [date, 10 days], the list of bidders invited, the dates and participants of the exchanges after the submission of the bids, the information given to each, and the bid-opening report. Please keep all the documents of this tender. We reserve all our rights.

Yours faithfully.
[Name, position, signature]

Letter 2: rendering of accounts and declaration of advantages by the agent (owner)

[Place], [date] · registered mail and e-mail

Subject: mandate of [date], site [name], rendering of accounts and declaration of any advantage received (Art. 398 para. 2 and Art. 400 para. 1 CO)

Dear Sir or Madam,

The agent is liable for the faithful and careful performance of the mandate; it accounts for its management and returns everything it has received on that account, on whatever basis. We ask you, by [date, 10 days], for a written report on the tender of package [..], together with a declaration stating whether you yourself or a person close to you received a service, a discount or a payment from a company on this site (nature, date, value), with the invoices. Please keep this file. We reserve all our rights.

Yours faithfully.
[Name, position, signature]

Where to report

For a suspected agreement between companies, the COMCO collects all clues, even rudimentary ones. For bribery or unfaithful management, the report is made to the police or the public prosecutor’s office. In public procurement, a contracting authority that suspects an unlawful agreement informs the COMCO (Art. 45 para. 2 LMP).

Protect yourself with the ACIP index and the Soumission software, frequently asked questions

How to lock down your site with the ACIP index and Soumission

A price is suspicious only by comparison. Before opening the bids, date and keep a reference costing: price your quotes by CFC with the ACIP 2026 prices (Art Construction Indice de Prix) on our platform, with the Soumission software. You can then write, without accusing anyone: “the gap with the bids received is CHF [..]; can you explain it?”. This benchmark proves no agreement: it grounds a question.

📊 See the ACIP index (Art Construction Indice de Prix)

Is a “last round” in a private tender illegal?

No, not in itself. A private owner is not subject to the equal-treatment rules of public procurement: it may negotiate and organise a last round. The difficulty appears when a single bidder receives confidential information (the others’ prices, the amount to beat) in breach of a duty of loyalty or confidentiality, or in exchange for an advantage. That may then engage the agent’s liability (Art. 398 para. 2 CO), fall under trade secrecy (Art. 162 CP, Art. 6 LCD) or bribery between private parties (Art. 322octies and 322novies CP). Only an authority can characterise the facts.

What is a cover bid?

It is a bid submitted not to win, but to give the impression of competition while the companies have agreed on the winner. It is sometimes recognised by a deliberately too high price, by unacceptable conditions or by a withdrawal for no reason. The COMCO describes the bid-rigging cartel as an agreement on the price to submit and on the company that is to win the contract, including for private calls for tender. A single clue is not enough: it is their accumulation, without explanation, that justifies a check.

Can a company that took part in an agreement report it to the COMCO?

The law provides for this possibility, with conditions. Art. 49a para. 2 LCart allows the sanction on a cooperating company to be waived in whole or in part. Art. 8 OS LCart provides for a full waiver for the first company that notifies its participation and meets all the conditions (not having coerced anyone, being neither instigator nor main actor, cooperating without reservation, ending its participation). Art. 12 OS LCart otherwise provides for a reduction of up to 50 %. Art. 9 para. 2 OS LCart allows a first anonymous contact. This general information does not replace a lawyer’s advice.

Is offering free work to an architect or a project manager always bribery?

No. The Criminal Code targets the “undue” advantage, granted for an act contrary to duty or within the person’s discretion (Art. 322octies and 322novies CP). Art. 322decies para. 1 CP excludes advantages authorised by contract or regulation and minor ones in line with social custom. Private work by a company on the site, with no invoice at market price, is however a warning sign to examine. The owner may ask the agent to account for and return what it has received on that account (Art. 400 para. 1 CO).

What does a company that takes part in a bid-rigging cartel risk?

The LCart provides for a direct sanction on the company of up to 10 % of the turnover achieved in Switzerland over the last three financial years (Art. 49a para. 1), calculated according to duration and gravity. In public procurement, the contracting authority may interrupt the procedure, exclude the bidder or revoke the award, and exclusion from future contracts may last up to five years in serious cases (Art. 43, 44 and 45 LMP). The injured owner may sue in civil court (Art. 12 LCart). These are consequences provided for by law, not convictions: only the authority and the judge decide.

General information based on Swiss law in force — it does not replace personalised legal advice (lawyer or specialist legal adviser).

Sources read

The articles of SIA 118, a standard that is not freely available, must be checked in the edition applicable to your contract (marked (*) when they could not be confirmed). The numerical examples on this page are fictitious.

📥 Ready-to-use pack · free

Download the document

The file is displayed on screen right away and we also send it to you by e-mail.

Your address is used to send you this file. See our privacy policy.