🛡️ Fraud prevention seriesAnomaly No. 8PDF + Word guideFRAUD 06
2-year cash retention and refusal of a surety by the general contractor: recognise the abuse, protect yourself, act
In French-speaking Switzerland, a subcontractor who has finished their package sometimes sees the general contractor hold the retention money in cash for the whole two-year period, refuse the surety they offer, and then raise an unsupported “counterclaim” when it is time to return it. The risk is real: if either party becomes insolvent in the meantime, recovering the money gets complicated. This page teaches you to recognise the signals, to preserve your rights (formal notice, surety, contested set-off) and to know whom to turn to. A signal is not proof: only the authority and the judge characterise the facts.
PDFDOCX
The guide: Abusive withholding of the 2-year guarantee
The detailed guide for this page in PDF and Word: legal basis, steps to follow, template letters and evidence checklist.
An e-mail address is requested: the guide is displayed immediately and is also sent to you by e-mail (signed links valid for 7 days).
How the trap works and which warning signs to look for
The mechanism on the ground in French-speaking Switzerland
On a general-contractor (EG) project, the subcontractor is paid by instalments from which the EG deducts a percentage, the guarantee retention. At the end of the works, the contract generally provides that this retention is released on acceptance and the final statement, or replaced by a joint and several surety issued by a bank or an insurer. The retention is legitimate: it protects the owner and the EG against the subcontractor’s insolvency, and the law allows them to protect themselves when one party’s rights are endangered by the other’s insolvency (Art. 83 CO).
The abuse appears when the retention becomes a way of keeping someone else’s money: keeping it in cash for the two years despite an offered surety, refusal with no written reason, a widened calculation base, set-off without supporting documents. If the subcontractor becomes insolvent before being paid, its claim forms part of the bankruptcy estate (Art. 197 para. 1 LP); the EG can then reduce this effect only by setting off claims it already holds (Art. 213 para. 1 LP), and the law excludes certain set-offs or allows them to be challenged (Art. 213 para. 2 LP, Art. 214 LP). That is why the duration matters as much as the amount.
Each of these facts may have a regular explanation: the EG may have genuine defects to cover. They call for a request for accounts and a written reply, never an accusation.
Warning signs (Red Flags) to check before and during the works
The list below sets out the observable clues. The more of them accumulate, the more useful it is to ask for documents, to offer the surety provided for in writing and to consult a lawyer.
The cash retention is kept for the whole two-year guarantee although the contract allows it to be replaced by a surety or a bank guarantee.
The offered surety is refused orally or without a written reason, and the requirements change with each new version of the document.
The retention is calculated on a wider base than the contract’s (TVA, change orders, daywork) or is added to a surety already delivered: the same claim is covered twice.
After acceptance and the final statement, the answer is “we will see at the end of the guarantee”, with no date and no list of defects.
A counterclaim appears when the retention is due to be returned, with no supporting document, no prior notice and no calculation.
Payments slow down, contacts change, or the general contractor’s registered office and governing bodies change: signs of fragility, not proof of bad faith.
The contract prohibits in advance any set-off or any replacement surety, without this having been pointed out to you at signing.
Mini-diagnosis: how many signals do you spot?
Tick the signals that match your situation: the result is a simple count, calculated in your browser, with no percentage and no recording of your answers.
Mini-diagnosis: does your guarantee retention show warning signs?
Tick the signals that match your situation. The result is a count of signals, calculated in your browser and never sent.
This is neither a diagnosis nor proof: a signal calls for a check, not an accusation.
2-year cash retention and refusal of a surety by the general contractor: recognise the abuse, protect yourself, act · https://art-construction.ch/en/outils/dossiers/retention-abusive-garantie-2-ans-entreprise-generale/
Tick the signals you have observed: the result appears here, box by box.
Swiss legal framework, evidence and template letters
Legal bases: CO, CC, CP, LP and SIA 118
For the EG as for the subcontractor, everything starts from the contract. Where there is no clause, the price is payable on delivery (Art. 372 para. 1 CO). A retention clause, a replacement surety and the conditions of release are read in the signed text and, if the SIA 118 standard forms part of it, in its articles on retention (Art. 145 SIA 118, Art. 150 SIA 118 (*), Art. 152 SIA 118 (*)) and on the contractor’s security (Art. 181 SIA 118 (*)).
Once the conditions are met, return is claimed like any other debt: written formal demand, then default interest at 5 % a year (Art. 102 para. 1 CO, Art. 104 para. 1 CO). The EG may raise set-off even if its own claim is contested (Art. 120 para. 2 CO), but it must declare its intention (Art. 124 para. 1 CO) and prove the basis of its counterclaim (Art. 8 CC). The guide fraude_06 and the files doc_35 (surety) and doc_18 (guarantees and disputes) detail the standard procedure.
The time limits that matter
Time limit
Starting point
Basis
2-year guarantee (SIA 118)
Acceptance of the work
Art. 172 para. 1-2 SIA 118
Limitation of rights for defects: 2 or 5 years
Acceptance of the work
Art. 371 para. 1-2 CO
Objection to the payment order: 10 days
Service of the payment order
Art. 74 para. 1 LP
Conciliation: hearing within 2 months, then action within 3 months
The request, then the authorisation to sue
Art. 203 para. 1 CPC, Art. 209 para. 3 CPC
The rules at a glance
Rule
Article
What the text says
Price payable on delivery
Art. 372 para. 1 CO
Absent other agreement, the price is payable on delivery: retaining requires a contract clause or a statutory exception.
Insolvency of the other party
Art. 83 para. 1-2 CO
If a party’s rights are endangered by the other’s insolvency, it may refuse to perform until security is given, then withdraw from the contract if the security is not provided within a reasonable time.
Default and default interest
Art. 102 para. 1 CO ; Art. 104 para. 1 CO
The debtor of a sum that is due is put in default by the creditor’s formal demand, then owes 5 % a year in interest.
Set-off
Art. 120 para. 2 CO ; Art. 124 para. 1 CO ; Art. 126 CO
A contested claim can be set off if the intention is declared; set-off can be waived in advance.
Surety
Art. 492 CO ; Art. 493 para. 1 CO ; Art. 496 para. 1 CO
The surety states in writing the total amount guaranteed; the joint and several surety can be pursued in the cases provided for.
Limitation of rights for defects
Art. 371 para. 1-3 CO
Two years for a movable work, five years for an immovable work, with no possibility of shortening these five years to the detriment of the owner for contracts governed by the revised law.
Evidence and good faith
Art. 8 CC ; Art. 2 para. 2 CC
Whoever relies on a counterclaim proves its facts; the manifest abuse of a right is not protected.
The claim for return forms part of the estate; set-off is regulated and certain set-offs can be challenged.
Retention and guarantee (SIA 118)
Art. 145 SIA 118 ; Art. 150 SIA 118 (*) ; Art. 152 SIA 118 (*) ; Art. 172 para. 1 SIA 118 ; Art. 181 SIA 118 (*)
The retention is deducted from the instalments, its release depends on conditions to be read in the contract; the guarantee lasts two years from acceptance; the joint and several surety is the contractor’s security after acceptance.
Contractual shield and evidence to gather
Before signing: require the retention clause to state the rate, the base and the cap, the release date, the right to replace the retention with a surety and the obligation to give written reasons for any refusal. Be wary of a clause that prohibits in advance any set-off or any replacement surety: the debtor can waive set-off in advance (Art. 126 CO).
Complete contract, annexes, change orders, and the clause referring to the SIA 118 standard.
All the statements with the amount retained each time and the calculation base.
Dated acceptance report, final statement, written reservations.
Original of the surety offered, proof it was delivered and the EG’s reply (or lack of reply).
Commercial-register extract of the EG (Zefix) dated the day you consult it.
Reread the complete contract: retention clause, conditions of release, right to replace the retention with a surety, any prohibition on set-off, applicability of the SIA 118 standard.
Draw up the exact account of retentions, statement by statement, and compare it with the contract.
Check that the conditions of release are met (acceptance, final statement, security); if not, put yourself in order first.
Offer the security provided for in writing (letter 2) and demand the reasons for any refusal.
Send the general contractor a formal demand with a reasonable time limit (letter 1); default interest runs from default.
If a set-off is raised, ask for the contract, the calculation and the supporting documents, and contest it in writing.
If the general contractor shows signs of fragility, consult a lawyer quickly: the LP time limits and the protection of your claims cannot be made up later.
Keep a single chronological file of all letters sent and replies.
Template letter models
Letter 1: request for release of the retention and formal demand
[Place, date] · Registered mail and e-mail · To: [general contractor] · Copy: [site management]
Subject: site [name] · contract of [date] · release of the guarantee retention of CHF [amount]
Dear Sir or Madam, the work was accepted on [date] and the final statement drawn up on [date]. The conditions of release provided for in Art. [..] of the contract are met. We ask you to pay CHF [amount] by [date: 10 days] or to tell us in writing the clause that justifies keeping the retention and the detailed calculation of any claim raised against it, with supporting documents. This letter constitutes a formal demand within the meaning of Art. 102 para. 1 CO; failing that, we will claim interest at 5 % a year (Art. 104 para. 1 CO). All our rights are reserved. Yours faithfully, [Name, position, signature] · Annexes: acceptance report, final statement, statement of retentions.
Letter 2: offer of a surety in place of the retention
[Place, date] · Registered mail and e-mail · To: [general contractor]
Subject: site [name] · delivery of a joint and several surety of CHF [amount] in place of the cash retention
Dear Sir or Madam, the contract provides in Art. [..] for the retention to be replaced by a joint and several surety. We hand you the original of surety No. [..] of [institution], for a total amount of CHF [amount], valid until [date] (the surety states the amount guaranteed in writing: Art. 493 para. 1 CO). If you consider that it does not meet the contract, tell us in writing, by [date: 10 days], which clauses are not complied with; without a reasoned objection, we consider the condition fulfilled and ask you to pay the retention by [date] at the latest. This offer does not amount to a waiver of any right. Yours faithfully, [Name, position, signature] · Annexes: surety, extract of the contract.
Where to report
An abusive retention is first of all a civil dispute, settled by conciliation and then by the court. Where there are signs of an offence, the criminal complaint is made to the police or the public prosecutor’s office; the addresses below were read on the day of writing.
Central index of company names (Zefix): Check the company name, registered office and governing bodies of a company before contracting. (address read on 7 November 2026)
Protect yourself with the ACIP index and the Soumission software, frequently asked questions
How to lock down your site with the ACIP index and Soumission
A retention is easier to discuss calmly when the price is justified from the offer stage. The ACIP index gives price benchmarks by CFC code to price your items, and the Soumission software helps keep an offer structured, with its payment, retention and surety conditions, before signing the contract.
Is a two-year cash guarantee retention provided for by law?
No, not by the Code of Obligations. The retention exists only if your contract has agreed it, often by reference to the SIA 118 standard. The two-year guarantee period is a rule of that standard (Art. 172 para. 1 SIA 118); the statutory limitation of rights for defects is two years for a movable work and five years for an immovable work (Art. 371 CO). So reread your contract before making any claim, and check against the official copy of the standard the article numbers marked (*) on this page.
Can the general contractor refuse my surety and keep the retention in cash?
It depends on the contract. If it provides that the retention can be replaced by a joint and several surety and your surety meets its conditions, a refusal should be reasoned in writing. Offer the surety by registered letter, with a precise reply deadline, and keep proof of dispatch. A refusal without reasons is not proof of abuse, but it justifies a formal notice and, if necessary, legal advice.
Can the general contractor set off the retention against a claim it says it has?
The law allows set-off to be raised even if the claim is contested (Art. 120 para. 2 CO), provided the intention is declared (Art. 124 para. 1 CO) and the claim exists. Whoever relies on it must prove its basis (Art. 8 CC). Ask in writing for the clause, the calculation, third-party invoices and the notice of defects. Contest the set-off without waiting: silence can be held against you.
What happens if the subcontractor or the general contractor becomes insolvent?
If the subcontractor goes bankrupt, its claim for return of the retention forms part of the estate (Art. 197 para. 1 LP) and the general contractor may set off the claims it already holds, within the limits of the law (Art. 213 LP, Art. 214 LP). If it is the general contractor that is under threat, the LP and your time limits matter: consult a lawyer quickly. A party whose rights are endangered by the other’s insolvency may also ask for security (Art. 83 CO).
Must I report an abusive retention to an authority?
An abusive retention is first of all a civil dispute: formal notice, conciliation, then an action before the court. If you have specific signs of an offence, the criminal complaint is made to the police or the public prosecutor’s office. A signal is not proof and only the authority and the judge characterise the facts: describe dated facts, without characterising the people, and get advice from a lawyer.
The articles of SIA 118, a standard that is not freely available, must be checked in the edition applicable to your contract (marked (*) when they could not be confirmed). The numerical examples on this page are fictitious.