Aller au contenu
Website
Format: DOCX / XLSX / PDF Standard: Word · Excel · PDF · SIA 118 DOC 33

Prorata Account Challenge Kit (Art. 129-135 SIA 118) & Guide to the 12 Abusive Clauses of General Contractor Agreements

Complete 7-page guide (PDF) and Word template. Challenging an abusive pro rata deduction and striking out the dangerous clauses of a general contractor agreement: procedure, 12 clauses to watch, letter templates and an Excel offset grid.

Interactive tool: siphoned-off margin and exact mark-up coefficient before submitting the bid

Loading the tool…

📄 The « Brut de chantier » pack to download (free)

DOCXXLSXPDF

Prorata Account Kit & Guide to the 12 Abusive Clauses of EG Agreements

Complete 7-page guide (PDF) and Word template. Challenging an abusive pro rata deduction and striking out the dangerous clauses of a general contractor agreement: procedure, 12 clauses to watch, letter templates and an Excel offset grid.

  • The prorata account, legal basis, deadlines and procedure for challenging it
  • The 12 clauses to watch and what the law allows against general terms and conditions
  • Template letters, price-compensation grid (Excel), evidence checklist, frequent mistakes, practical case and cases where a lawyer should be consulted

Editable Word template (.docx) · Excel workbook (.xlsx) with formulas · Printable PDF document

1. What the SIA 118 standard (Art. 129 to 135) really says about water, electricity, skips and site cleaning

The prorata account spreads the common site costs among the companies. It is not a deduction at discretion: it must rest on the contract and be justified. The articles of SIA 118 are given according to our sheets and are to be checked in the applicable edition.

1.1 Why a flat-rate deduction of 3% to 6% is open to challenge if you did not use the common skips or if the site management refuses to produce the supporting invoices

A percentage levy, without a statement of the actual costs, directly eats into your margin. Ask for a justified statement, a clear basis and a cap. If you removed your own waste, a share in the common skips is not justified.

1.2 How to use our Word letter template to have the costs of skips, heating or damage by unknown persons not attributable to your lot cancelled

The letter challenges the deduction by ticking the applicable grounds (no clause, no supporting document, wrong basis, costs borne by the client, rate exceeding the contract) and demands a detailed statement within 10 days, subject to set-off and suspension after formal notice (mise en demeure).

2. The 12 abusive or unlawful clauses to strike out (or to compensate financially) before signing an EG agreement

General contractor agreements often pass the risks on to subcontractors. Twelve clauses come up most often: some are void, others dangerous, others negotiable.

2.1 Clauses void by operation of law (advance waiver of the craftsmen's statutory mortgage lien, Art. 837 para. 3 CC)

The right to the statutory mortgage lien cannot be abolished in advance (Art. 837 para. 3 CC): the waiver you sign is void. Its mere presence reveals a risky principal: strike it out.

2.2 Dangerous clauses: abstract « first demand » guarantee, uncapped late-completion penalties and the « Pay-when-paid » clause

Three clauses keep coming back: the « first demand » guarantee, which allows a call without proving a defect; late-completion penalties with no cap (5% to 10% of the price in practice); and the « pay-when-paid », which makes you bear the client's insolvency. Strike them out or limit them.

3. Frequently asked questions about the prorata account and General Contractor agreements (FAQ)

3.1 Can a General Contractor deduct a prorata account from me if this was not mentioned in the initial tender documents?

The prorata can only be deducted if it is provided for in the contract. If the tender and the contract do not mention it, ask for the contractual basis in writing; SIA 118 (Art. 129 et seq.) provides for the sharing of certain costs between the client and the contractor, to be checked in the applicable edition.

3.2 Am I obliged to pay for breakage caused by another unidentified trade (« damage by unknown persons »)?

Not without a contractual basis: a collective deduction for damage by unknown persons must be provided for in the contract and justified. Challenge any flat-rate deduction without a record, photos and a statement.

3.3 Why is it not enough to mark up your prices by +5% to compensate for 5% of contractual deductions (formula Price / 0.95)?

Because the 5% deduction applies to the marked-up price, not to the net price. To collect 100'000 CHF net with 5% deductions, you have to offer 100'000 / 0.95 = 105'263 CHF, i.e. +5.26%. Our calculator gives the coefficient 1 / (1 − rate) to apply.

Keywords covered: challenge prorata account site Switzerland template letter · article 129 to 135 SIA 118 water electricity site cleaning · abusive clauses subcontracting agreement general contractor Switzerland · flat-rate deduction skips site board insurance · formula compensation prorata deduction unit price · damage by unknown persons site SIA 118.

General information based on Swiss law in force — does not replace personalised legal advice.

The articles of the Code of Obligations (CO), the Civil Code (CC), the Criminal Code (CP), the Debt Enforcement Act (LP), the AVS Act (LAVS), the Accident Insurance Act (LAA) and the Posted Workers Act (LDet) cited were re-read on Fedlex on 6 November 2026. The articles of the SIA 118 standard, which is not freely available, are given according to our fact sheets and must be checked in the edition applicable to your contract. Updated: 7 November 2026.

📥 Ready-to-use pack · free

Download the document

The file is displayed on screen right away and we also send it to you by e-mail.

Your address is used to send you this file. See our privacy policy.