🛡️ Fraud prevention seriesAnomaly No. 10PDF + Word guideFRAUD 08
Shared-costs account abuse and phantom cleaning penalties on site: demand the accounts, contest the deductions (SIA 118)
On a general-contractor project, the final statement sometimes contains deductions that the subcontractor does not understand: a higher pro rata share than provided for, skip costs, “cleaning penalties” that have appeared without notice. A deduction is not automatically wrongful: everything depends on the contract, the supporting documents and the procedure followed. This page teaches you to recognise the signals, to demand the accounts in writing, to contest without losing your rights and to know whom to turn to. A signal is not proof: only the authority and the judge characterise the facts.
PDFDOCX
The guide: Abuse of the shared-costs account and phantom penalties
The detailed guide for this page in PDF and Word: legal basis, steps to follow, template letters and evidence checklist.
An e-mail address is requested: the guide is displayed immediately and is also sent to you by e-mail (signed links valid for 7 days).
How the trap works and which warning signs to look for
The mechanism on the ground in French-speaking Switzerland
The shared-costs (pro rata) account spreads common costs (water, electricity, skips, general cleaning, sanitary facilities, fencing) among the companies on the site. The general contractor (EG) generally withholds a percentage from each interim statement. That is legitimate when the clause is clear, the costs are real, the allocation key is known and the statement is handed to the participants.
The abuse appears when opacity becomes a tool: no statement is handed over, costs already included in the EG’s prices reappear, or “cleaning penalties” pop up in the final statement, with no clause, no prior notice, no inspection report. The subcontractor is then tempted to accept in order to receive its balance. Yet a penalty requires a clause (Art. 160 para. 1 CO), and whoever deducts an amount must prove its basis and calculation (Art. 8 CC).
Each fact on this page may have a regular explanation. They call for a written request for accounts, never an accusation.
Warning signs (Red Flags) to check before and during the works
The list below sets out the observable clues. The more of them accumulate, the more useful it is to ask for the pro rata statement, to contest the penalties in writing and to consult a lawyer.
The percentage withheld is higher than the contract’s, or the base is wider (TVA, daywork, change orders), or no cap is stated although the contract provides one.
You are not handed any pro rata statement: no list of participants, no allocation key, no invoices for the common costs.
Costs already included in the general contractor’s prices (crane, general scaffolding, site set-up) reappear in the pro rata share.
“Cleaning penalties” appear for the first time in the final statement, with no written notice, no date, no photo and no time limit to restore the area.
The same cleaning amount is charged to several trades without identifying who left what, or is added to a general cleaning already included in the pro rata share.
The deductions are presented as non-negotiable and set off automatically against the guarantee retention or the balance, with no supporting document.
The amount of the deductions is significant compared with the invoice although no clause of the contract provides for them or the procedure provided for has not been followed.
Mini-diagnosis: how many signals do you spot?
Tick the signals that match your situation: the result is a simple count, calculated in your browser, with no percentage and no recording of your answers.
Mini-diagnosis: are your pro rata and cleaning deductions justified?
Tick the signals that match your situation. The result is a count of signals, calculated in your browser and never sent.
This is neither a diagnosis nor proof: a signal calls for a check, not an accusation.
Shared-costs account abuse and phantom cleaning penalties on site: demand the accounts, contest the deductions (SIA 118) · https://art-construction.ch/en/outils/dossiers/abus-compte-prorata-penalites-fantomes-sia-118/
Tick the signals you have observed: the result appears here, box by box.
Swiss legal framework, evidence and template letters
Legal bases: CO, CC, CP, LP and SIA 118
A contractual penalty requires a clause (Art. 160 para. 1 CO); it is due even without damage (Art. 161 para. 1 CO), but cannot be demanded if it sanctions an unlawful or immoral obligation (Art. 163 para. 2 CO) and must be reduced if excessive (Art. 163 para. 3 CO). If SIA 118 forms part of the contract, penalties must be fair and are not due during an extension of the time limit (Art. 98 para. 1-2 SIA 118); the standard does not create a penalty without a clause.
To obtain the accounts, the contract is the first basis. In the alternative, whoever manages another’s affairs must account for them at the other party’s request (Art. 394 para. 2 CO, Art. 400 para. 1 CO); whether these rules on mandate apply to a shared-costs account depends on the contract and must not be presented as a certainty. The EG may raise set-off even if its claim is contested (Art. 120 para. 2 CO), but it must declare it (Art. 124 para. 1 CO) and prove its facts (Art. 8 CC). The file doc_33 details the 12 clauses to watch.
The final statement under SIA 118 summarises the payments: without a written reservation in that summary, the company may lose rights (Art. 153 SIA 118); the site management checks the statement and communicates its report without delay (Art. 154 SIA 118). Also read the time limits for contesting that are specific to your contract.
The rules at a glance
Rule
Article
What the text says
Site costs and pro rata share
Art. 129 to 135 SIA 118 (*)
Site costs charged to the owner or shared: values taken from our data sheets, to be confirmed against the standard and compared with your contract.
Contractual penalty
Art. 160 para. 1 CO ; Art. 161 para. 1 CO ; Art. 163 para. 2-3 CO
It requires a clause, is due even without damage, cannot sanction an unlawful obligation and must be reduced if excessive.
Fair penalties (SIA 118)
Art. 98 para. 1-2 SIA 118
Fair penalties, none during an extension of the time limit; the standard does not create a penalty without a clause.
Rendering of accounts
Art. 394 para. 2 CO ; Art. 400 para. 1 CO
Whoever manages another’s affairs accounts for them at the other party’s request; application to the pro rata share depends on the contract.
Evidence and good faith
Art. 8 CC ; Art. 2 para. 1-2 CC
Whoever deducts an amount proves its basis; the manifest abuse of a right is not protected.
Set-off
Art. 120 para. 2 CO ; Art. 124 para. 1 CO ; Art. 126 CO
A contested claim can be set off if declared; set-off can be waived in advance: read this clause.
Default and interest
Art. 102 para. 1 CO ; Art. 104 para. 1 CO ; Art. 372 para. 1 CO
The price is payable on delivery; the formal demand starts interest at 5 % a year running.
Final statement (SIA 118)
Art. 153 SIA 118 ; Art. 154 SIA 118 ; Art. 156 SIA 118 ; Art. 190 SIA 118 (*)
Written reservation in the summary of payments, checking by the site management, payment within 30 days according to our data sheets (*).
Possible criminal consequences
Art. 138 No. 1 CP ; Art. 158 No. 1 CP
Misappropriation and unfaithful management: only the criminal authorities decide on their application to specific facts.
Contractual shield and evidence to gather
Before signing: require the contract to state the pro rata rate, its base, its cap, the costs covered, the obligation to hand over a documented statement at the end of the project, the cleaning procedure (who, when, written notice, time limit) and the amount, if any, of each penalty. A pro rata share with no cap and no statement is a signal to discuss before signing.
Complete contract with the pro rata, cleaning and penalty clauses, and the indication of whether the SIA 118 standard applies.
All interim statements and all instalments, with the pro rata amount withheld each time.
Daily reports, area handover reports and dated photographs of your areas when you left.
The cleaning notices received, or the absence of notices, with date and method of sending.
The final statement with your written reservations, and proof that your objections were sent.
Note the contract clause on the pro rata share (rate, base, cap) and on cleaning (who, when, notice, penalty).
Reconcile the statement with the contract line by line: each deduction must have a clause, a calculation and a supporting document.
Ask for the accounts in writing (letter 1), with a reasonable time limit.
Contest the penalties (letter 2), asking for the clause, the date, the inspection report, the prior notice and the calculation.
Pay or claim the undisputed part with formal notice; do not sign the final statement without a written reservation.
Wait for a reasoned reply, follow up once, then move on to debt enforcement or conciliation.
On the general contractor’s side: send a precise prior notice (letter 3) and hand over a complete pro rata statement.
If there are signs of funds being used for other purposes, keep the supporting documents and consult a lawyer before any report.
Template letter models
Letter 1: request for the rendering of the pro rata account
[Place, date] · Registered mail and e-mail · To: [general contractor] · Copy: [site management]
Subject: site [name] · contract of [date] · request for the rendering of the pro rata account and for the deductions in the statement of [date]
Dear Sir or Madam, your statement of [date] deducts CHF [amount] as pro rata share and CHF [amount] as [skips / cleaning]. The contract provides in Art. [..] for a pro rata share of [..] % on [base] [capped at CHF [..] / with no cap]; we cannot reconcile your statement with this clause. We ask you to hand us by [date: 10 days] the detailed statement of the pro rata account, the list of participating companies, the allocation key, the invoices for the common costs and any balance to be returned. We base this request on the contract and, in the alternative, on Art. 400 para. 1 CO. This letter constitutes a formal demand within the meaning of Art. 102 para. 1 CO for the deductions we contest; it does not amount to acceptance of any amount. Yours faithfully, [Name, position, signature] · Annexes: statement of [date], extract of the contract.
Letter 2: contesting unjustified cleaning penalties
[Place, date] · Registered mail and e-mail · To: [general contractor] · Copy: [site management]
Subject: site [name] · contesting the cleaning penalties of CHF [amount] shown in the statement of [date]
Dear Sir or Madam, your statement withholds CHF [amount] as cleaning penalties ([..] inspections). We contest them in principle and in amount for the following reasons (tick as applicable): [ ] the contract provides for no cleaning penalty (a contractual penalty requires a clause: Art. 160 para. 1 CO); [ ] the clause provides for a written notice and a time limit that we did not receive; no dated inspection report or photo has been communicated to us; [ ] general cleaning is already covered by the pro rata share; [ ] the breach is not attributable to our company; [ ] the amount is excessive (Art. 163 para. 3 CO). It is for you to establish the breach and the calculation (Art. 8 CC). We ask you to hand us by [date] the clause relied on, the inspection reports, the photographs and the prior notice; failing supporting documents, we ask you to return CHF [amount] by [date], failing which we will claim interest at 5 % a year (Art. 104 para. 1 CO). All our rights are reserved. Yours faithfully, [Name, position, signature]
Letter 3: prior cleaning notice with time limit (good-practice model for the general contractor)
[Place, date] · E-mail and registered mail · To: [company] · Copy: [site management]
Subject: site [name] · cleaning notice for the area [designation] · time limit until [date and time]
Dear Sir or Madam, during our visit on [date, time], we found that the area [designation], under your responsibility according to Art. [..] of the contract, has not been cleared of its waste (dated photographs and report attached). We ask you to restore it by [date and time: reasonable time limit]. After that time limit, and if the contract allows it (Art. [..]), we will have the cleaning carried out by [cleaning company] at the cost of [whom, according to the contract], on the third party’s invoice sent with the details. [If the contract provides for a contractual penalty: cite it here with its article and amount.] Yours faithfully, [Name, position, signature]
Where to report
Contesting a deduction is first of all a civil dispute. Where there are signs of an offence, for example the use of entrusted sums for other purposes, the criminal complaint is made to the police or the public prosecutor’s office; the addresses below were read on the day of writing.
Protect yourself with the ACIP index and the Soumission software, frequently asked questions
How to lock down your site with the ACIP index and Soumission
A pro rata share is easier to discuss when your site costs are priced from the offer stage. The ACIP index gives price benchmarks by CFC code to justify what your price already includes, and the Soumission software helps keep an offer structured, with its pro rata, cleaning and payment conditions, before signing the contract.
Is the shared-costs (pro rata) account defined by law?
To our knowledge, no: no rule of the CO defines the shared-costs account, and this negative statement is not exhaustive. It rests on a contract clause that sets the rate, the base and the cap. The SIA 118 standard regulates part of the site costs (Art. 129 to 135 SIA 118 (*)), numbers to be confirmed against the official copy. So reread your contract and ask for the detailed statement before contesting. The file doc_33 explains the principles of the pro rata share.
Can the general contractor deduct a cleaning penalty with no clause?
A penalty is a contractual penalty: it requires a clause of the contract (Art. 160 para. 1 CO). Even with a clause, the judge must reduce an excessive penalty (Art. 163 para. 3 CO), and whoever claims it must prove the breach (Art. 8 CC). If SIA 118 forms part of the contract, penalties must be fair (Art. 98 para. 1 SIA 118). Ask for the clause, the date of the inspection, the photo and the prior notice before paying.
Can I demand the pro rata accounts?
Yes, you can ask for them in writing, relying on the contract and, in the alternative, on the obligation of whoever manages another’s affairs to account for them (Art. 400 para. 1 CO). Whether these rules on mandate apply to the shared-costs account depends on your contract: do not assert it as a certainty. Set a reasonable time limit, attach the list of the documents requested and keep proof of dispatch.
Must I sign the final statement with these deductions to receive my balance?
Sign only with written reservations. Under SIA 118, without a reservation in the summary of payments, the company may lose rights (Art. 153 SIA 118). Enter the contested amounts, refer to your letters of contestation and ask for payment of the undisputed part. If in doubt, have a lawyer read the statement before you sign.
Is an unjustified pro rata deduction misappropriation?
Not in itself: it is first of all a contested claim. Misappropriation (Art. 138 No. 1 CP) or unfaithful management (Art. 158 No. 1 CP) presuppose specific situations, for example entrusted assets used unlawfully, and only the public prosecutor’s office and the criminal court decide. Keep the supporting documents, stay factual in your letters and consult a lawyer before any report.
The articles of SIA 118, a standard that is not freely available, must be checked in the edition applicable to your contract (marked (*) when they could not be confirmed). The numerical examples on this page are fictitious.