Aller au contenu
Website
🛡️ Fraud prevention series Anomaly No. 20 PDF + Word guide FRAUD 13

Landfill, polluted soil and asbestos fraud: recognising disposal outside the proper channel and protecting yourself

A demolition or excavation site produces tonnes of waste, and its removal is often invoiced to the owner as compliant. When polluted soil, asbestos-containing materials or special waste go to an unauthorised site, or under false documents, the risk is environmental, financial and criminal for everyone who took part. This page describes the warning signals, what the Environmental Protection Act, the OLED and the OMoD say, the evidence to keep and the cantonal offices to contact. A signal is not proof: only the authorities qualify the facts.

PDFDOCX

The guide: Landfills, polluted soil and asbestos

The detailed guide for this page in PDF and Word: legal basis, steps to follow, template letters and evidence checklist.

🔎 Scanner of the 26 anomalies

An e-mail address is requested: the guide is displayed immediately and is also sent to you by e-mail (signed links valid for 7 days).

How the trap works and which warning signs to look for

The mechanism on the ground in French-speaking Switzerland

Anomaly No. 20 of the series (proposed title, to be validated: “Landfill fraud: polluted soil, asbestos-containing or downgraded waste taken away outside the proper channel under false weighing slips”) describes a gap between what is invoiced and what is actually done with the waste. The “26 anomalies” numbering is the series’ own, not an official classification.

In the field, the gap shows up in several ways: an acceptance price unrelated to those of authorised facilities; materials taken away without the destination facility being named; incomplete or repetitive reception documents; waste mixed together or classified in a less demanding category than the one that applies; invoiced volumes that match neither the site nor the plans. The owner sometimes pays for a compliant disposal that did not take place, and is then faced with the authority’s questions.

This page does not say how to do it: it says how to recognise it, which documents the law provides for and when to ask for them. It also applies to the honest company, which protects its reputation by keeping complete documents for each transport.

Warning signs (Red Flags) to check before and during the works

The following indicators are observable facts. Each calls for a check with the company, the carrier or the disposal facility; none is proof.

  • The acceptance price offered for the waste is far below those charged by the disposal facilities of the region, with no explanation.
  • The company or carrier refuses to name the destination facility.
  • No tracking document is handed over for waste that requires one, or the document is not signed by the facility.
  • The reception slips carry no facility name, no date and no vehicle number, or are repeated identically.
  • The invoiced volumes or tonnages match neither the excavated volume nor the plans.
  • Suspicious materials (fibres, old sheets, unusual smell or colour) are loaded without separate sorting or analysis.
  • Excavated material is declared “clean” without any analysis, although the location formerly housed an industrial activity.
  • Waste of different kinds is loaded together into the same skip, with no description of the categories.
  • Removals take place without you being present or without a loading slip, and the proof is “sent later”.

Mini-diagnosis: how many signals do you spot?

Tick the situations you observe: the tool counts the signals, recalls the legal articles concerned and points you to the guide. Nothing is sent or saved.

Do you spot signals of waste being taken away outside the proper channel?

Tick what matches your situation. Nothing is sent or saved.

This is neither a diagnosis nor proof: a signal calls for a check, not an accusation.

Warning signs

Tick the signals you have observed: the result appears here, box by box.

📥 Get the PDF/Word guide

Swiss legal framework, evidence and template letters

Legal bases: CO, CC, CP, LP and SIA 118

The Environmental Protection Act (LPE) sets out the principle: waste must be disposed of in an environmentally sound manner (Art. 30 para. 3 LPE), and final storage is permitted only in a controlled landfill authorised by the canton (Art. 30e para. 1 and 2 LPE). The holder of the waste in principle bears the cost of its disposal; if the holder cannot be identified or is insolvent, the cantons bear that cost (Art. 32 LPE).

The Ordinance on the Avoidance and Disposal of Waste (OLED) specifies the site rules. For construction work, the owner states in the building permit application the type, quality and quantity of the waste and the intended disposal channels if the quantity is likely to exceed 200 m3 or if hazardous pollutants (PCB, PAHs (HAP), lead, asbestos) are to be expected; the owner must then, on request, prove to the authority that the waste was disposed of in accordance with its instructions (Art. 16 OLED). Special waste is separated from other waste and disposed of separately (Art. 17 para. 1 OLED).

The Ordinance on the Movement of Waste (OMoD) governs hand-over: before handing over waste, the holder checks whether it is special waste or other waste subject to control and hands it over only to a centre authorised to receive it (Art. 4 OMoD). For special waste and waste that requires a tracking document, this document is mandatory (Art. 6 para. 1 OMoD). Offences are punished by the LPE (Art. 60 and 61 LPE); the Criminal Code may be added in case of fraudulent deception (Art. 146 CP) or forgery of documents (Art. 251 CP).

The rules at a glance

RuleArticleWhat the text says
Principle of disposalArt. 30 para. 3 LPEWaste must be disposed of in an environmentally sound manner.
Final storageArt. 30e para. 1 and 2 LPEProhibited anywhere other than a controlled landfill; setting up and operating a landfill requires authorisation from the canton.
Cost of disposalArt. 32 para. 1 and 2 LPEThe holder of the waste bears the cost; if the holder is unknown or insolvent, the cantons bear it.
Duty to provide informationArt. 46 para. 1 LPEEveryone provides the authorities with the information needed to enforce the law.
Information for the building permitArt. 16 OLEDAbove 200 m3 or if hazardous pollutants are to be expected, the owner states the waste and the intended channels and proves compliant disposal on request.
Sorting on siteArt. 17 para. 1 OLEDSpecial waste is separated and disposed of separately; the rest is sorted (soil, excavated material, concrete, etc.).
Hand-over to an authorised centreArt. 4 para. 1 and 2 OMoDThe holder checks whether it is special waste or waste subject to control and hands it over only to a centre authorised to receive it.
Mixing and dilutionArt. 5 para. 1 OMoDThe handing-over company may neither mix nor dilute special waste before handing it over.
Tracking documentArt. 6 para. 1 and Annex 1 OMoDMandatory document for special waste and waste that requires one; three copies per code, kept for at least five years (Annex 1 No. 1.3 to 1.5).
Offences (waste)Art. 60 para. 1 let. m, n, o, p and para. 2 LPELandfill without authorisation, wrong hand-over of special waste, breaches of the rules on their movement: custodial sentence of up to three years or a monetary penalty; for negligence: monetary penalty.
Minor offences (waste)Art. 61 para. 1 let. g, i, k LPEFinal storage outside a controlled landfill, breaches of the waste rules: fine of up to 20 000 francs.
FraudArt. 146 para. 1 CPFraudulent deception with the aim of obtaining an unlawful enrichment, which leads the victim to an act detrimental to their interests: custodial sentence of up to five years or a monetary penalty.
Forgery of documentsArt. 251 No. 1 CPFalsely recording or causing to be recorded in a document a fact of legal significance, with the aim of obtaining an unlawful advantage: custodial sentence of up to five years or a monetary penalty.

Contractual shield and evidence to gather

Before signing, four simple clauses reduce the risk for the owner:

  • Have the disposal facility and the carrier named in the contract, with the obligation to replace them only in writing and with an equally authorised site.
  • Provide that at each removal the facility’s reception slip and, for the waste concerned, the tracking document signed by the facility are handed over.
  • Have the waste sorted and described on site (soil, concrete, wood, special waste), with dated photos of each skip or lorry before it leaves.
  • Tie payment of the “removal” share to the handing over of these documents: whoever claims performance of a bilateral contract must have performed, or offer to perform, their own obligation (Art. 82 CO).

As for evidence, keep for each transport the date, time, vehicle number, loading place, name of the destination facility and the reception documents. For waste that requires a tracking document, the handing-over company keeps the document for at least five years, and the facility keeps a copy for the same period (OMoD, Annex 1, No. 1.4 and 1.5).

  1. Before the site, ask in the contract for the name of the destination facility and of the carrier, and for the reception slips to be handed over.
  2. Have the waste sorted and photographed, with the date, before each skip or lorry leaves.
  3. If you suspect a pollutant (asbestos, PCB, lead, PAHs (HAP)), suspend the loading concerned and have it analysed before any removal.
  4. Ask in writing for the proof of reception and the tracking documents (letter 1) and withhold the “removal” share of the payment until they are handed over.
  5. If the documents do not arrive, set a final deadline (letter 3) and inform the cantonal environment office (letter 2).
  6. Keep the tracking documents and the reception slips for at least five years.
  7. Consult a lawyer before any criminal report or action against the company.

Template letter models

Letter 1: request for proof of disposal

Subject: [site]: request for the reception slips and tracking documents for the removal of [soil / demolition material / asbestos-containing waste]

Dear Sir or Madam,

According to your statement No. [..] of [date], [quantity] of [type of waste] were removed from the site at [address] for CHF [..]. To date we have no document that states the destination facility.

We ask you to hand us by [date, 10 days]: 1) the name and address of the facility that received the waste and of the carrier; 2) the dated reception slips, with the quantities; 3) for waste that requires it, the tracking document signed by the facility (OMoD, Annex 1); 4) the classification adopted for each category of waste.

We remind you that the holder may hand over its waste only to a centre authorised to receive it (Art. 4 OMoD) and that we may be called on to prove compliant disposal to the authority (Art. 16 para. 2 OLED). We are withholding payment of the “removal” share of CHF [..] until these documents are handed over (Art. 82 CO).

Yours faithfully,
[Name, position, date and signature]
Registered post and e-mail. Enclosures: statement; quote; photos of the loads.

Letter 2: question to the cantonal environment office

Subject: [site], [address]: request for information on the disposal channel of site waste

Dear Sir or Madam,

As the owner of a site at [address], I take the liberty of asking you for information. The company [name] removed on [date] about [quantity] of [type of waste] without telling me the destination facility and without handing me the reception slips I asked for on [date]. I enclose my letters and the photos of the loads.

Could you tell me whether the facility [name, if known] holds an authorisation for this type of waste, and which documents I must keep to establish compliant disposal? I remain at your disposal for anything further and will provide the information the law requires (Art. 46 para. 1 LPE).

Yours faithfully,
[Name, address, telephone, date and signature]
Enclosures: contract; statement; letters of [date]; photos.

Letter 3: deadline for handing over the documents before further steps

Subject: [site]: final deadline for handing over the disposal documents (Art. 102 and 107 CO)

Dear Sir or Madam,

By letter of [date], we asked you for the reception slips and tracking documents relating to the removal of [date]. To date, you have handed us [no document / incomplete documents: specify].

We give you a final deadline until [date, reasonable period]. On expiry of this deadline, we will let you know at once what consequences we draw from this default (Art. 107 para. 2 CO) and we reserve the right to inform the competent cantonal authority. Payment of the “removal” share remains suspended (Art. 82 CO).

Yours faithfully,
[Name, position, date and signature]
Registered post and e-mail. Enclosures: letter of [date]; statement.

Where to report

Enforcement of the OMoD lies with the cantons (Art. 37 OMoD): the cantonal environment office responsible for waste is the first point of contact. The directory of the Conference of Heads of Environmental Protection Offices (CCE) lists the office of each canton. For a criminal report, contact the police or the public prosecutor’s office; the Swiss ePolice portal helps find a police station.

Protect yourself with the ACIP index and the Soumission software, frequently asked questions

How to lock down your site with the ACIP index and Soumission

The ACIP index (Art Construction Indice de Prix) classifies prices by trade chapter and by CFC code. Comparing the “removal” item of a quote with these benchmarks and with the tariffs posted by the facilities in your region makes it possible to spot an abnormally low price, which calls for an explanation before signing. These values are indicative, not contractual. Write in the specification the nature, estimated quantity and channel of each category of waste: what is written at the start is easier to check at the end.

📊 See the ACIP index (Art Construction Indice de Prix)

Who answers for the compliant disposal of site waste: the owner or the company?

The law as read does not designate a single person. The LPE puts the cost of disposal on the holder of the waste (Art. 32 para. 1 LPE) and the OMoD requires the holder to check the nature of the waste and to hand it over to an authorised centre (Art. 4 OMoD). In addition, the OLED makes the owner responsible for stating the intended channels in the permit application and for proving compliant disposal on request (Art. 16 OLED). Who is the “holder” depends on the facts: have your situation examined by a lawyer before concluding that responsibility lies with the other party.

What should I keep as proof of disposal?

Keep for each transport the date, loading place, vehicle number, name of the destination facility and the reception slip it issues. For special waste and waste that requires a tracking document, the document is drawn up in three copies per waste code and the handing-over company keeps it for at least five years (OMoD, Annex 1, No. 1.3 and 1.5). Add dated photos of the sorting and loading: they supplement the documents without replacing them.

How do I know whether a waste is special waste?

Special waste is waste designated as such in the waste list that the DETEC issues under Art. 2 OMoD (Art. 3 let. c OLED). The list gives the code and category of each waste. Before handing over waste, the holder must check whether it is special waste or other waste subject to control (Art. 4 para. 1 OMoD). If in doubt, ask the company in writing for the classification and confirm it with the cantonal environment office.

What is the risk in case of disposal outside the proper channel?

The LPE punishes in particular anyone who intentionally sets up or operates a landfill without authorisation, hands special waste to an unauthorised company or breaches the rules on its movement: custodial sentence of up to three years or a monetary penalty (Art. 60 para. 1 let. m, n, o, p LPE), and a monetary penalty in case of negligence (Art. 60 para. 2 LPE). Final storage outside a controlled landfill is a minor offence (Art. 61 para. 1 let. g LPE). Only the criminal authority qualifies the facts and the presumption of innocence applies.

Can a company mix waste to reduce its pollutant content?

The handing-over company is authorised neither to mix nor to dilute special waste before handing it over (Art. 5 para. 1 OMoD). The cantonal authority may authorise mixing for special waste handed over regularly in large quantities, but not where the operation aims to subject it to less strict rules by reducing its pollutant content (Art. 5 para. 3 let. a OMoD). On site, the OLED also requires special waste to be separated from other waste (Art. 17 para. 1 OLED).

Where to report a doubt about the disposal channel of a site?

The cantons enforce the OMoD (Art. 37 OMoD): contact the cantonal environment office responsible for waste, whose list is in the CCE directory. For a criminal report, the police or the public prosecutor’s office of your canton receives reports; the Swiss ePolice portal helps find a police station. First gather your documents (contract, statement, reception slips, dated photos, letters) and do not publish any accusation: only the authority qualifies the facts.

General information based on Swiss law in force — it does not replace personalised legal advice (lawyer or specialist legal adviser).

Sources read

The articles of SIA 118, a standard that is not freely available, must be checked in the edition applicable to your contract (marked (*) when they could not be confirmed). The numerical examples on this page are fictitious.

📥 Ready-to-use pack · free

Download the document

The file is displayed on screen right away and we also send it to you by e-mail.

Your address is used to send you this file. See our privacy policy.