Aller au contenu
Website
Format: PDF / DOCX Standard: PDF · Word · CO 373 / SIA 118 Art. 58 DOC 15 ⚖️ 'Pure Law' File

Defects of the Ground, Rock, Water or Pollution in Excavation: Who Pays under the CO (Art. 373) and the SIA 118 Standard (Art. 58)?

Complete 5-page guide (PDF) and Word template. Rock, water, polluted materials, obstacles: who bears the ground risk, reservation clauses, immediate notice, written confirmation and three letters.

Interactive tool: who bears the extra cost and written notification ready to send

Loading the tool…

📄 The « Brut de chantier » pack to download (free)

PDFDOCX ⚖️ 'Pure Law' File

Geotechnical Reservation & Unforeseen Excavation Conditions Pack

Complete 5-page guide (PDF) and Word template. Rock, water, polluted materials, obstacles: who bears the ground risk, reservation clauses, immediate notice, written confirmation and three letters.

  • Art. 365 para. 3 and 373 para. 2 CO, SIA 118: ground risk
  • Geotechnical reservation clauses to insert in the quote
  • Three letters (immediate notice, written confirmation), evidence checklist, frequent mistakes, practical case and cases where a lawyer should be consulted

Printable PDF document · Editable Word template (.docx)

1. The radical opposition between the Code of Obligations and the SIA 118 Standard on geological risk

The same rock outcrop can cost the contractor or the client CHF 45'000 depending on the text governing the contract. So you need to know, before opening the excavation, which text applies.

1.1 Under the Code of Obligations (Art. 373 para. 2 CO): why a lump-sum contractor risks paying for the hydraulic breaker out of its own pocket

With a lump-sum price, ground risk in principle rests on the contractor: only extraordinary circumstances that could not be foreseen allow the judge to grant an increase or termination (Art. 373 para. 2 CO). Meeting rock in a molasse region is not always « extraordinary ».

1.2 Under the SIA 118 Standard (Art. 58 para. 2): the client answers fully for the nature of the ground and for inaccurate plans

According to our fact sheets, SIA 118 puts the nature of the ground and the inaccuracy of the plans on the client, provided the contractor has given its written notice (Art. 25 SIA 118). Read the article in the applicable edition and expressly subject the contract to the standard.

Consequences by party involved

Party involvedWhat the law says for them
ContractorLump sum under pure CO: bears the ground risk (CO 373 para. 2); notifies immediately in writing (CO 365 para. 3; SIA 118 Art. 25).
Subcontractor (earthworks)Passes on the regime of its contract; does not proceed without a change order or written instruction.
ClientUnder SIA 118: bears the nature of the ground and inaccurate plans (Art. 58 para. 2, to be checked); legal holder of the polluted soil.

2. Discovery of polluted soil or buried waste (LPE / OLED): the rules on who bears the cost

Polluted soil is waste: it requires a disposal route, analyses and costs distinct from those of clean soil.

2.1 Why the landowner is always the « legal holder of the waste » and pays the fees of the biological/chemical route

The holder of the polluted materials is in principle the client, owner of the land, who bears the disposal. The contractor must inform it immediately in writing (Art. 365 para. 3 CO) and await its instructions. Routes and tariffs depend on the degree of pollution.

2.2 The fatal mistake to avoid on site: never mix polluted excavation material with sound soil

Mixing polluted soil with sound soil contaminates the whole skip: the extra cost of the route then applies to the whole quantity, at your expense if you caused the mixing. Isolate suspect materials, photograph and have them analysed before removal.

3. Frequently asked questions about unforeseen excavation and earthworks conditions (FAQ)

3.1 What geotechnical reservation clause must be systematically inserted in an earthworks quote?

State the geotechnical report taken as a basis (or its absence), the ground class assumed, and specify that rock, water and polluted materials not announced give rise to a priced change order (rock extra per m³, pumping per hour, removal at actual cost). Our pack contains the full clause.

3.2 Is the architect or the civil engineer liable if he did not order a preliminary geotechnical study?

The agent (architect, engineer) has a duty of care and advice: not recommending a geotechnical study on a risky site may engage his liability, depending on the mandate and the circumstances. This is a question of proof and mandate: seek advice from a lawyer.

3.3 How do you price the extra cost of excavation in rock (CAN 211) compared with loose ground?

Define before the start of the works a unit price for the extra per m³ for rock, depending on hardness and equipment (hydraulic breaker, blasting, milling). The rock excavation heading of CAN 211 serves as a reference; our earthworks tool gives the orders of magnitude.

Keywords covered: discovery rock water excavation who pays Switzerland · article 58 SIA 118 ground defect foundation soil · article 373 para 2 CO extraordinary circumstances · extra cost hydraulic breaker water pumping site · polluted excavated soil OLED who pays landfill · geotechnical reservation clause earthworks quote.

General information based on Swiss law in force — does not replace personalised legal advice.

The articles of the Code of Obligations (CO), the Civil Code (CC), the Criminal Code (CP), the Debt Enforcement Act (LP), the AVS Act (LAVS), the Accident Insurance Act (LAA) and the Posted Workers Act (LDet) cited were re-read on Fedlex on 6 November 2026. The articles of the SIA 118 standard, which is not freely available, are given according to our fact sheets and must be checked in the edition applicable to your contract. Updated: 7 November 2026.

📥 Ready-to-use pack · free

Download the document

The file is displayed on screen right away and we also send it to you by e-mail.

Your address is used to send you this file. See our privacy policy.