Aller au contenu
Website
🛡️ Fraud prevention series The 26 anomalies PDF + Word guide FRAUD 01

Fraud Prevention in Swiss Construction: The 26 Site Anomalies and the Legal Audit Scanner

Fraud, abuse, blackmail or plain negligence: on a Swiss construction site, the line is often drawn by a few clues that could have been seen before signing or paying. This page presents the 26 anomalies we track, grouped into six risk families, each with the page that covers it in detail and the main articles of law, checked on Fedlex. The scanner helps you count the signals you observe. A signal calls for a check, never an accusation: only the authority and the judge qualify the facts.

PDFDOCX

The reference guide: the 26 anomalies, the audit grid and the legal shield

The framework of the 26 anomalies, a printable audit grid and the basic reflexes, in PDF and in Word.

An e-mail address is requested: the guide is displayed immediately and is also sent to you by e-mail (signed links valid for 7 days).

How the trap works and which warning signs to look for

The 26 anomalies, grouped into six risk families

A site trap almost always rests on three elements: information the other party does not have (who the company really is, what has actually been installed, what has really been paid), a moment of dependence (down payment, final balance, guarantee, imminent sale of the property) and a document that does not reflect reality (invoice, data sheet, weighbridge ticket, measurement). The tables below describe each anomaly at the level needed to recognise it, and point to the page that explains how to protect yourself.

The “26 anomalies” are Art Construction’s editorial classification, not an official list. The grouping into six families is also editorial: several anomalies touch two families at once. The titles of numbers 19 to 26 are proposals, flagged as such (proposed title, to be confirmed).

Insolvency and shell companies

No.Anomaly (title)How to recognise itPageMain articles
No. 1The “Phoenix Companies” (sociétés phénix) and Serial Bankruptcies (Konkursreiterei)An indebted company is replaced by a company that takes over the business, leaving the creditors unpaid. Recognisable by a succession of company names, registered offices and governing bodies.Page 2Art. 684a CO ; Art. 164 CP ; Art. 288 LP
No. 2The Family “Nominees” (Mother, Father, Uncle, Wife) and Straw MenA person from the circle appears as manager or director while the real management lies elsewhere; legal liability also reaches those who manage in fact.Page 4Art. 52 LAVS ; Art. 754 CO
No. 3The “Company Undertakers” (Firmenbestatter / Mantelhandel)A company with no activity or assets, but with debts, is transferred to a third party to make it disappear; the law renders such a transfer of shares void under certain conditions.Page 3Art. 684a CO ; Art. 164 CP ; Art. 288 LP
No. 7VAT Siphoning (TVA, 8.1 %) and the Boss’s Organised Insolvency (Art. 93 LP)VAT (TVA) or contributions are collected without being paid over, with irregular invoices and overdue public debts. Art. 93 LP does not describe this fraud (see the clarification).Page 2Art. 15 LTVA ; Art. 98 LTVA ; Art. 288 LP

Labour and wages

No.Anomaly (title)How to recognise itPageMain articles
No. 4The “Taxi Companies” (Fake Invoices against Envelopes of Cash)Invoices are issued for services that do not exist or that are foreign to the issuer, the payment coming back in cash. Recognisable by the absence of means, staff and supporting documents.Page 5Art. 251 CP ; Art. 96 LTVA ; Art. 87 LAVS
No. 5Wage Kickbacks at the Cash Machine (Salary Kickback)An employee paid according to the contract has to pay part of it back. The law does not allow waiving a mandatory claim during the contract and the month that follows.Page 5Art. 341 CO ; Art. 14 LAVS ; Art. 87 LAVS
No. 6Unemployment Fraud via “Bad Weather” Compensation (ICI) and Short-Time Work (RHT)Hours of stoppage due to bad weather or of reduced working time are declared without the legal conditions being met (exclusively weather-related cause, regular notification).Page 5Art. 43 LACI ; Art. 105 LACI ; Art. 25 LPGA
No. 15Undeclared Work (“Black”), “Family Arrangements” and Under-Classification under the Collective Agreement (CCT)Employees are hired without declaration or below the collective agreement, sometimes under cover of family arrangements or of too low a classification.Page 11Art. 1 LTN ; Art. 13 LTN ; Art. 4 LECCT
No. 16Sham Subcontracting Hiding Illegal Labour Hire (Breach of the LSE)A front subcontracting arrangement can hide a supply of labour without the authorisation required of the staff-leasing provider.Page 11Art. 12 LSE ; Art. 39 LSE ; Art. 5 LDét

Payments, retentions and guarantees

No.Anomaly (title)How to recognise itPageMain articles
No. 8The Calculated Retention of the 2-Year Guarantee in Cash (Betting on the Subcontractor’s Bankruptcy)A 2-year guarantee withheld from the subcontractor is kept in cash, with no surety and no separate account, at the risk of being lost in a bankruptcy.Page 6Art. 82 CO ; Art. 107 CO ; Art. 181 SIA 118 (*)
No. 9“Blackmail Below the Court-Expert Threshold” (Final Retention of CHF 15'000 to 25'000)A significant amount is withheld from the final balance for undocumented defects, banking on the cost of an expert appraisal. The law sets no “expert-appraisal threshold” (see the clarification).Page 7Art. 367 CO ; Art. 368 CO ; Art. 158 CPC
No. 10The Robbery of the “Prorata Account” (compte prorata) and the Phantom Cleaning PenaltiesThe prorata account (shared site costs) is kept without transparency, with deductions and cleaning penalties without supporting documents.Page 8Art. 163 CO ; Art. 62 CO ; Art. 97 CO
No. 11The Reverse Blackmail with the Ex Parte Statutory Mortgage Lien on the Eve of a Notarised SaleA craftsmen’s statutory mortgage lien (hypothèque légale) is announced without an established amount just before the notarised sale of the property, to obtain a payment or a discount.Page 9Art. 839 CC ; Art. 837 CC ; Art. 265 CPC

Tenders and corruption

No.Anomaly (title)How to recognise itPageMain articles
No. 12The “Bill-of-Quantities Leak” (Rigged Last Round in a Private Tender)In a private tender, a participant knows the other bidders’ prices before the last round, which distorts competition.Page 10Art. 162 CP ; Art. 6 LCD ; Art. 23 LCD
No. 13Bid-Rigging Cartels and “Cover Bids” (Abreden / COMCO)Competitors agree on prices or share out markets; some submit “cover” bids to simulate competition.Page 10Art. 5 LCart ; Art. 49a LCart
No. 14Kickbacks and Free Work in the Decision-Maker’s Private VillaA decision-maker receives a personal benefit (free work, commission) linked to the award or payment of a project, without the conflict of interest being disclosed.Page 10Art. 322octies CP ; Art. 322novies CP ; Art. 322decies CP
No. 17The Deliberate “Suicide” Bid (-25 % at Tender) Followed by Blackmail over Change Orders (avenants)A very low bid is followed by change orders imposed during the works, sometimes making the continuation of the works conditional on them. The figure of -25 % is that of an example, not a legal threshold.Page 11Art. 373 CO ; Art. 29 CO ; Art. 30 CO

Quality, materials, waste and subsidies

No.Anomaly (title)How to recognise itPageMain articles
No. 18The Misuse of Energy Subsidies and Complacent Data SheetsEnergy subsidies are requested on the basis of data sheets, invoices or certificates that do not match the work carried out.Page 12Art. 146 CP ; Art. 251 CP
No. 19Material Substitution (Cheaper Product Installed, Specification Price Invoiced) (proposed title, to be confirmed)Material, brand or thickness different from the offer, installed without written agreement, while the specification price is invoiced.Page 12Art. 368 CO ; Art. 146 CP ; Art. 251 CP
No. 20Landfill Fraud (Polluted Soil, Asbestos or Downgraded Waste Disposed of Outside the Official Channels under False Weighbridge Tickets) (proposed title, to be confirmed)Soil, demolition waste or asbestos-containing elements removed outside the authorised channels, with inaccurate tracking or weighing documents.Page 13Art. 16 OLED ; Art. 17 OLED ; Art. 6 OMoD ; Art. 61 LPE
No. 21Fraudulent Deceit and Deliberately Hidden Defects (Covered-Up Work, Disguised Repair Before Acceptance) (proposed title, to be confirmed)A known defect that is then concealed (covered layer, cosmetic repair) to obtain approval of the work.Page 12Art. 28 CO ; Art. 370 CO ; Art. 367 CO
No. 22The Promised or Brandished “10-Year Guarantee” (Sales Argument Confused with the Legal Time Limits) (proposed title, to be confirmed)A “10-year guarantee” invoked as a sales argument with no direct legal equivalent, then time limits or limitation periods raised against the client (see the clarification).Page 12Art. 371 CO ; Art. 3 LCD
No. 23Inflated Measurements and Phantom Quantities (Final Statement Higher than What Was Actually Carried Out) (proposed title, to be confirmed)Quantities invoiced above those carried out, with no joint measurement and no signed record.Page 12Art. 372 CO ; Art. 373 CO ; Art. 62 CO

Scams against private individuals

No.Anomaly (title)How to recognise itPageMain articles
No. 24The Down Payment Collected and the Site Never Opened (Down-Payment Scam) (proposed title, to be confirmed)Down payment requested at signing without the works starting, with successive excuses and then silence.Page 14Art. 146 CP ; Art. 82 CO ; Art. 107 CO
No. 25The False “Start of Performance” (Material Dropped Off or Token Visit to Justify the Down Payment) (proposed title, to be confirmed)An apparent start of performance (material dropped off, brief visit) is invoked to keep the down payment.Page 14Art. 146 CP ; Art. 377 CO ; Art. 251 CP
No. 26The Abusive or Fictitious Emergency “Repair Call-Out” (Aggravated Breakdown, Price without Quote, Invoice Unrelated to the Job) (proposed title, to be confirmed)Emergency intervention invoiced without a quote or announced price, without supporting documents, or a fictitious intervention.Page 14Art. 146 CP ; Art. 3 LCD ; Art. 41 CO

Warning signs (Red Flags) to check before and during the works

A warning sign is an observable fact that can be checked: a line in the commercial register, a missing certificate, a price with no explanation, a quantity that nobody can justify. It proves nothing on its own: a company may have moved its registered office for good reasons, and a low price may reflect real know-how.

Three questions help sort things out: can I establish it with a document or a dated photo? Is there a simple explanation the other party can give me in writing? Is the signal isolated, or are there others with it? Several signals that overlap justify a closer check, with the help of a lawyer.

  • You are asked to pay in cash, or into the account of a person or company other than the one signing.
  • The company refuses to produce its social-insurance and accident-insurance certificates or the list of its subcontractors.
  • The price is far below all the other offers, with no gap explained by the scope, the quantities or the materials.
  • The commercial register shows frequent changes of company name, registered office or governing bodies.
  • The documents (data sheets, weighbridge tickets, measurements, invoices) do not match what you see on site.
  • A down payment, a signature or a change order is demanded immediately, under time pressure.
  • The people working on the site are neither those of the contract nor those of the announced lists.
  • A retention, a penalty or a deduction is announced without detail or supporting documents.
  • A personal benefit or an “off-invoice” discount is tied to an award or a payment.
  • Defects are raised only verbally, or just before the final balance is paid, with no description and no photograph.

Scanner of the 26 anomalies: tick the signals you have observed

The scanner brings together 61 warning signs sorted by situation (quote and offer, commercial register, subcontractor, contract, final statement, site). You can filter by profile (client, architect, general contractor, subcontractor) and by phase (tender, contract, execution, final statement, guarantee). Each signal shows the articles of law concerned and the page to read.

The result is a simple count, with no percentage and no probability: the number of signals ticked in total and per anomaly, in three bands. No signal: nothing to report at this stage. One to two signals in total: to be watched. From three signals in total, or two signals on the same anomaly: to be checked with a lawyer. These thresholds are an editorial convention of caution, not a statistic: they indicate neither the seriousness nor the probability of an offence. Only the signals shown by the chosen filter are counted.

Everything is calculated in your browser: nothing is sent, nothing is saved. The result can be printed, with the cross-references to the relevant pages 2 to 14.

Scanner of the 26 construction anomalies: count the warning signs you have observed

Tick what you observe (a fact, never an impression). Filter by profile and by phase if you wish. The result is a simple count: everything is calculated in your browser, nothing is sent or saved.

This is neither a diagnosis nor proof: a signal calls for a check, not an accusation.

Quote and offer
Commercial register and company
Subcontractor
Contract
Final statement and invoicing
Site

Tick the signals you have observed: the result appears here, with the pages of the series to consult.

📥 Get the PDF/Word guide

Swiss legal framework, evidence and template letters

Legal bases: CO, CC, CP, LP and SIA 118 (*)

Every anomaly touches at least one of the following three levels: civil law (contract for work, guarantees, defects: CO, CC), debt-enforcement law (LP) and social insurance (LAVS, LACI, LTVA), and criminal or administrative law, which applies only once the facts have been established by the authority. The main articles for each anomaly appear in the tables above; the “Legal basis” table below summarises the rules most useful for protecting yourself.

The rules at a glance

RuleArticleWhat the text says
Transfer of shares of a company with no activity or assets and heavily in debtArt. 684a para. 1 and 2 COThe transfer is void; if the commercial register has a well-founded suspicion, it summons the company to produce its latest signed accounts and refuses registration if the company does not comply or if the accounts confirm the suspicion.
Acts carried out to the detriment of creditors (avoidance action, action révocatoire)Art. 285 to 288 LPAssets removed from enforcement can be recovered: donations made in the year before the attachment or the bankruptcy (Art. 286), acts carried out within five years with a recognisable intention to harm creditors (Art. 288).
Reduction of assets, mismanagement, bookkeepingArt. 164, 165 and 166 CPOffences punished only if the debtor is declared bankrupt or if a certificate of unpaid debts is issued against them; Art. 164 para. 2 CP also targets the third party who takes part.
Liability of the employer and of the governing bodies for AVS contributionsArt. 52 para. 1 and 2 LAVSThe employer is liable for the damage caused to the insurance scheme by an intentional or grossly negligent breach; if it is a legal entity, the members of the board and those who manage are liable in a subsidiary capacity, jointly and severally among themselves.
Liability of the contracting entrepreneur for subcontractorsArt. 5 LDétIn building construction, civil engineering and finishing work, the contracting entrepreneur is liable for the minimum wages and working conditions not respected by subcontractors, after a prior fruitless debt-enforcement action; it can be exempted by proving its duty of care.
Staff leasingArt. 12 para. 1, 20 para. 1 and 39 para. 1 LSEThe staff-leasing provider must hold a cantonal authorisation and apply the wage provisions of the generally binding collective agreement of the hiring company, and anyone who leases staff without authorisation is liable to a fine.
Agreements between competitorsArt. 5 para. 3 and Art. 49a para. 1 LCartAgreements between competitors that fix prices or share out markets are presumed to eliminate effective competition; the sanction can go up to 10 % of the turnover achieved in Switzerland over the last three financial years.
Bribery of private individualsArt. 322octies and 322novies CPOffering or accepting an undue advantage in connection with an act contrary to duty or dependent on discretion is punished; advantages agreed by contract or of minor importance in line with custom are not undue (Art. 322decies).
Defects in the work: notice, repair, limitationArt. 367 para. 1bis, 368 para. 2bis, 370 para. 4 and 371 COFor an immovable work, the client has 60 days to report defects; a clause excluding the repair of a construction defect is void; the limitation period is two years, five years for an immovable work.
Statutory mortgage lien of craftsmen and contractors (hypothèque légale)Art. 839 para. 2 and 3 CCRegistration no later than four months after completion of the works; it takes place only if the amount is established by the owner's acknowledgement or by the judge, and cannot be requested if the owner provides sufficient security.
Preservation of evidenceArt. 158 para. 1 CPCThe court takes evidence at any time if the law so provides or if the endangerment of the evidence or an interest worthy of protection is made plausible.

Contractual shield and evidence to gather

Ten reflexes, applied in this order, are worth more than a long contract: before signing, check the company (commercial register, debt-enforcement register, social-insurance certificates); demand a written contract that describes the materials, the quantities and the method of payment; refuse any clause that excludes the repair of defects in a building (void under Art. 368 para. 2bis CO); note the deadlines. Before paying: pay into the account of the company that signs, never in cash or to a third party; demand a joint measurement and the detail of every retention; agree the form of the guarantee in writing. Before subcontracting: ask each subcontractor for the same certificates, have the whole chain declared and check who actually works on the site.

  1. Check the company before signing: commercial register (Zefix), debt-enforcement register, governing bodies, history.
  2. Demand a complete written contract: price, quantities, named materials, deadlines, method of payment.
  3. Refuse clauses that exclude the repair of defects or shorten the notice periods.
  4. Note every deadline in a diary from the moment of signing (60 days for defects, 4 months for the statutory mortgage lien).
  5. Pay only into the account of the contracting company, with an invoice and proof of payment.
  6. Demand a joint measurement and the detail of any retention, penalty or cost charged.
  7. Agree in writing the form of the guarantee (retention, surety), its amount and its release.
  8. Ask each subcontractor for the social-insurance certificates and the list of its own subcontractors.
  9. Photograph, date and keep: condition of the premises, covered-up work, materials delivered, attendances.
  10. Report the facts observed to the competent authority and consult a lawyer as soon as several signals overlap.

To preserve your evidence, keep the originals and the metadata: dated photographs with the date visible, signed delivery notes, complete written exchanges (no isolated screenshots), commercial-register extracts dated the day of the search, minutes of site meetings. Evidence with no date and no identifiable author carries little weight.

  1. Keep everything in writing: contract, offers, exchanges, invoices, dated photographs. Do not destroy or alter anything.
  2. Check the company: commercial register (Zefix), debt-enforcement register extract, social-insurance certificates (template letter 1).
  3. Count the signals with the scanner and read the pages it refers to (pages 2 to 14).
  4. Ask factual questions in writing, without accusing: a simple, documented explanation clears most signals.
  5. Before paying a balance or signing a final statement, ask for the supporting documents and reserve your rights (template letter 2).
  6. Watch the deadlines: 60 days to report a defect in an immovable work, four months for a statutory mortgage lien.
  7. From three signals, or two on the same anomaly, have the situation checked by a lawyer.
  8. Report the facts to the competent authority with your documents (template letter 3), without characterising them legally.
  9. Never pay in cash or into a third party’s account, and leave no guarantee in cash without a written agreement.

Template letter models

Three factual, sober models to adapt: they request documents, reserve your rights or report facts, without ever accusing anyone.

Template letter 1: compliance documents requested before signing

[Place, date]
Sent by e-mail and by registered mail
To: [company name of the recipient], [address]

Subject: project [description of the site]: compliance documents requested before signing the contract

Dear Sir or Madam,

Before signing the contract for the works of [description], we ask you to provide us, by [date], with the following documents:
1. a recent commercial register extract, showing the exact company name, the registered office and the persons authorised to sign;
2. a certificate from your AVS compensation fund stating that you are affiliated and up to date;
3. the certificate of your accident insurer;
4. the list of the planned subcontractors and, for each of them, the same certificates: the contracting entrepreneur must be able to show that it has complied with its duty of care (Art. 5 para. 3 LDét);
5. if workers are made available by a third party, that third party’s staff-leasing authorisation (Art. 12 para. 1 LSE);
6. the IBAN number of your company’s account to which payments will be made.

We will sign the contract on the basis of these documents. This request contains no accusation: it corresponds to the check we carry out for every partner.

Yours faithfully,
[Name, position, date and signature]

Template letter 2: supporting documents and reservation of rights before paying the balance

[Place, date]
Sent by registered mail and by e-mail
To: [company name of the recipient], [address]

Subject: site [description]: statement of [date]: request for supporting documents and reservation of rights

Dear Sir or Madam,

We have received your statement of [date], for an amount of CHF [amount]. Before any payment of the balance and before signing any final statement, we ask you to provide us, by [date], with:
1. the detail of the quantities, with plans, calculations or signed records (joint measurement);
2. the supporting document for every retention, penalty or cost charged (prorata account, cleaning), with the calculation;
3. for every defect alleged: a description, dated photographs and the date on which it was noted.

At this stage we dispute the following items: [list]. We expressly reserve all our rights, in particular the right to ask for the work to be examined by experts (Art. 367 para. 2 CO) and to request the taking of evidence in advance (Art. 158 CPC). This letter constitutes neither an acknowledgement of debt nor an approval of the statement.

Yours faithfully,
[Name, position, date and signature]

Template letter 3: factual report to an authority

[Place, date]
To: [competent authority: cantonal police or public prosecutor’s office, cantonal body for the control of undeclared work, COMCO, compensation fund]

Subject: report of facts observed: site [description], [municipality]

Dear Sir or Madam,

I report to you the following facts, observed on [date] at [place]: [factual description in three to five sentences: who, when, where, what; without legal characterisation and without judgement on persons].

Enclosures: [numbered list: contract, dated photographs, commercial-register extracts, written exchanges]. I keep these documents at your disposal and can be reached at [telephone / e-mail].

I do not characterise these facts: it is for you to assess whether they fall within your competence. If they do not, I would be grateful if you could tell me which authority I should contact. If it is a criminal authority, I ask you to inform me of the action taken (Art. 301 para. 2 CPP).

Yours faithfully,
[Name, date and signature]

Where to report

Anyone has the right to report an offence to a criminal prosecution authority, in writing or orally (Art. 301 para. 1 CPP); they may ask to be informed of the action taken (Art. 301 para. 2 CPP). For criminal offences, contact the cantonal police or the public prosecutor’s office of the canton where the facts occurred. The other authorities below receive the reports that fall within their field.

Protect yourself with the ACIP index and the Soumission software, frequently asked questions

How to lock down your site with the ACIP index and Soumission

Comparing an offer with an estimate by CFC code gives an independent reference: a large gap with no explanation, or quantities that the estimate does not find, are signals to check, not proof. Art Construction’s Soumission software is used to prepare this estimate and to keep a record of your quotes.

📊 See the ACIP index (Art Construction Indice de Prix)

Do the “26 anomalies” form an official list?

No. No law and no authority publishes such a catalogue: the 26 anomalies are Art Construction’s editorial classification, grouped into six risk families to make it easier to read. The titles of numbers 1 to 18 are those of Art Construction; those of numbers 19 to 26 are proposals, flagged as “proposed title, to be confirmed”. This classification replaces neither the Code of Obligations, nor the Criminal Code, nor a lawyer’s advice. It serves to recognise situations and to refer to the right page, where the main articles of law are cited.

Does a ticked signal prove fraud?

No. A signal is an observable fact that calls for a check, not proof and not an accusation. A company may have moved its registered office for good reasons, and a low price may reflect real know-how. The presumption of innocence applies: only the authority and the judge qualify the facts. The scanner counts the signals and proposes three bands (no signal, to be watched, to be checked with a lawyer); these thresholds are a convention of caution, not a probability. Ask factual questions in writing before drawing any conclusion.

What does the law say if I suspect an offence?

Anyone has the right to report offences to a criminal prosecution authority, in writing or orally (Art. 301 para. 1 CPP), and may ask to be informed of the action taken (Art. 301 para. 2 CPP). Describe the facts you have observed, enclose your documents, without characterising them legally or naming anyone responsible: it is for the authority to assess.Depending on the field, other authorities can also receive a report: COMCO for restraints of competition, the cantonal control body for undeclared work, the compensation fund for contributions.

Which deadlines should be watched first?

For an immovable work, the client has 60 days to report defects (Art. 367 para. 1bis CO) and, for a defect that could not be noticed at acceptance, 60 days from its discovery (Art. 370 para. 4 CO); rights on account of defects are time-barred after five years for an immovable work (Art. 371 para. 2 CO). The registration of a statutory mortgage lien must be obtained no later than four months after completion of the works (Art. 839 para. 2 CC). These rules come in part from a law in force since 1 January 2026: for an older contract, have the applicable version checked.

Does the scanner record my answers?

No. The counting is done in your browser: no ticked box is sent to a server or saved, and nothing is kept when you close the page. You can print the result to attach it to your file. The full guide (framework of the 26 anomalies, printable audit grid and ten reflexes) is delivered as PDF and as Word, to the e-mail address you give in the window provided for this purpose.

Strategic internal linking

In the same series

For the procedure and standard protection

Hub tools to use with this page

Also on the site

All files

The 14 files of the “Fraud Prevention” series

General information based on Swiss law in force — it does not replace personalised legal advice (lawyer or specialist legal adviser).

Sources read

The articles of SIA 118, a standard that is not freely available, must be checked in the edition applicable to your contract (marked (*) when they could not be confirmed). The numerical examples on this page are fictitious.

📥 Ready-to-use pack · free

Download the document

The file is displayed on screen right away and we also send it to you by e-mail.

Your address is used to send you this file. See our privacy policy.