Loss Coverage Diagnosis: RC Company Liability vs Construction Works Insurance (ATC)
Determine whether a loss is covered by the company liability insurance (RC) or by the construction works insurance (ATC).
Interactive tool
1 Loss scenario
2 Claim amounts
3 Your coverage
Share paid by the insurance and remainder to be paid out of the contractor's pocket
| Line item | Amount (CHF) | Who pays? | Share paid by the insurer | Remainder to pay out of your own pocket |
|---|
Typical rules of RC Entreprise (business liability) and ATC (construction works insurance) policies. The general conditions of your insurer (exclusions, sub-limits, excesses) prevail: this diagnosis guides your claim, it is not an insurer's decision.
Embed this calculator on a website page
Paste this code into the page, or write [outil code="3.9"] in the content of a page on the site.
📄 Files and templates linked to this tool (free)
- PDFDOCX ⚖️ Pure Law Fire Prevention & Claims on Site Pack + Hot Work Permit Complete 7-page guide (PDF) and Word template. Who bears the loss of the work in case of fire before the keys are handed over: insurance, a ready-to-fill hot-work permit, damage claim and letters to the insurer and the client. See the file, its mini-tool and the pack →
- PDFDOCX ⚖️ Pure Law Joint Inspection Report Template for Neighbouring Properties Complete 6-page guide (PDF) and Word template. Documenting neighbours' cracks before the works: owner's liability, invitation letter, joint inspection record, photographic survey and RC (liability) insurance. See the file, its mini-tool and the pack →
- PDFDOCX ⚖️ Pure Law Custody Transfer Protocol & Theft of Materials on Site Complete 8-page guide (PDF) and Word template. Materials delivered but not yet installed: who bears the theft, record of transfer of custody and storage, clause on advance payment for materials and template letters. See the file, its mini-tool and the pack →
Move from calculation to full management
Keep your references at hand, then automate them in your quotes, bids and final statements.
Technical reference guide
Why basic RC Entreprise (business liability) insurance NEVER covers your own defective work (The fatal exclusion)
Many tradesmen believe their RC Entreprise pays for everything that goes wrong on a site. This is false, and it is the first cause of nasty surprises after a loss. The exclusion damage to the delivered work RC entreprise is the basic rule: the insurance pays what you owe to third parties, never the rework of what you did badly. Redoing badly bonded tiles, replacing a badly crimped pipe or correcting a botched screed is a business risk: it is the price of your trade, and it stays at your expense in every case.
1. The fundamental distinction between "damage to the work executed" (excluded) and "consequential damage to third parties or to the existing structure" (covered)
Damage to the work executed is the value of your own defective work: the RC does not cover it. Consequential damage is what the defect causes elsewhere: the parquet and ceiling soaked by a badly crimped pipe, the neighbour's wall cracked by sheet piling, the client's installation damaged. That is covered by the basic RC Entreprise, less the excess. The RC answers for your civil liability towards third parties, and the SIA 118 standard moreover obliges you to insure against this risk (art. 26 SIA 118). Example from the tool: CHF 2'400 of rework (at your expense), CHF 3'500 of leak detection and CHF 12'000 of damage to the floor below: without an extension, the insurance pays CHF 11'000 (CHF 12'000 minus CHF 1'000 excess) and CHF 6'900 remains with you.
2. The 4 vital cover extensions a building tradesman must demand in their RC Entreprise policy (Removal/refitting costs, Leak detection, Damage to objects entrusted/worked on, Lost keys)
The removal and refitting costs clause reimburses the cost of opening up and restoring the work of other trades to reach and repair your defect (screeds, partitions, tiling). The leak detection water damage site covers the cost of locating the leak or the cause of the defect. The extension "objects entrusted or worked on" covers damage to the thing you are working on (the slab, the pipe, the existing structure you are converting), normally excluded from the basic RC. The extension "lost keys" reimburses the replacement of the cylinders and keys of a building or a site. For each extension, check the sub-limit, the excess and the exclusions: they vary from one insurer to another.
Construction Works Insurance (ATC) and Client's Liability (RC Maître d'Ouvrage): who covers what before acceptance?
The difference between RC entreprise and construction works insurance ATC lies in what they protect: RC Entreprise protects third parties against your faults; the ATC (contractor's all-risks insurance) protects the work under construction against unforeseen events. Before acceptance, the work is at the contractor's risk for what it has executed: if it perishes by accident, the contract may lapse and remuneration is due only if the contract so provides, except in cases of force majeure (art. 187 SIA 118). If the law imposes no insurance on the client, the client must state in the tender documents whether the work has been insured and by which insurances (art. 189 para. 3). The client also answers for damage caused to third parties as owner of a structure (art. 58 CO) or of land (art. 679 CC): this is the RC maître d'ouvrage Switzerland, which may have recourse against the faulty contractor.
1. Cover for unforeseeable damage during the works (collapse, vandalism, theft of elements already fixed, extraordinary weather) and subcontractors' share of the premium (0.3% to 0.8%)
The ATC covers the work under construction against sudden and unforeseen damage: collapse, vandalism, theft of elements already fixed to the work, extraordinary weather. It does not cover the defective part itself, and material simply placed on a pallet or left in a vehicle is generally not insured. When the client takes it out, contractors often contribute to the premium, under a contract clause: the tool's specifications indicate 0.3% to 0.8% of the contract price, i.e. CHF 1'500 to 4'000 for a CHF 500'000 site (indicative value, to be confirmed with your broker). Compare this contribution with the other deductions in a general contractor agreement using the prorata auditor.
Summary Table of Cover by Type of Site Loss
This table shows, for each of the tool's six scenarios, who bears each head of loss in typical configurations. Enter your amounts in the tool to get the remainder at your expense.
| Scenario | Your own work | Search, removal / reinstallation | Consequential damage | Who pays in principle |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Case 1: Badly crimped sanitary pipe causing water damage to the parquet and the ceiling of the floor below | Excluded (business risk) | Extension "removal / refitting and leak detection" | Basic business liability (RC) | Business liability (RC) + extension |
| Case 2: Tiles or parquet coming loose over 80 m² because of a defective adhesive or a damp screed | Excluded (business risk) | 'Removal / reinstallation' extension | Basic business liability (RC) | Business liability (RC) + extension |
| Case 3: Drilling into an electric cable or an existing underfloor-heating pipe during core drilling | Excluded (business risk) | Extension "objects entrusted or worked on" or "removal / refitting" | Basic business liability (RC) | Business liability (RC) + extension |
| Case 4: Theft of materials / equipment on site before acceptance (copper, PAC, electrical board already fixed vs on a pallet) | ATC, if the element is already fixed to the structure | ATC, if the element is already fixed to the structure | ATC | ATC only (never the RC) |
| Case 5: Cracking of the neighbouring building during excavation or sheet-piling work | Excluded (no defective work) | Basic business liability (RC) (expert opinion, inspection report) | Basic business liability (RC) (subject to exclusions) | Business liability (RC); client's RC in parallel |
| Case 6: Loss of the master key of a rental building or a site (replacement of 60 Kaba cylinders) | Excluded | 'Lost keys' extension | 'Lost keys' extension | Business liability (RC) with extension, otherwise you |
Typical rules: the general conditions of your policy (exclusions, sub-limits, excesses) prevail. Always report the loss to the insurer and, in writing, to the site management (art. 25 SIA 118).
Frequently Asked Questions about Site Insurance in Switzerland (FAQ)
1. What exactly does RC Entreprise (business liability) cover, and what does it never cover?
It covers the damage you cause to third parties (persons and property) in the course of your business, which is also the insurance obligation of article 26 SIA 118. It never covers your own defective work: redoing or replacing what you executed badly is a business risk, at your expense in every case.
Example from the tool: a defective crimping causes water damage (CHF 2'400 of rework, CHF 3'500 of leak detection, CHF 12'000 of damage, CHF 1'000 excess). With the "removal / refitting" extension, the insurance pays CHF 14'500 and CHF 3'400 remains with you; without it, the insurance pays CHF 11'000 and CHF 6'900 remains with you.
2. What is the difference between RC Entreprise (business liability) and construction works insurance (ATC)?
RC Entreprise protects third parties against your faults; it follows your business. The ATC (also called contractor's all-risks insurance) covers the work under construction against unforeseen events: collapse, vandalism, theft of elements already fixed, extraordinary weather. It does not cover repair of the defective part itself.
Before acceptance, the work is in principle at the contractor's risk for what it has executed: if the work perishes by accident, the contract may lapse and remuneration is due only if the contract so provides, except in cases of force majeure (art. 187 SIA 118). That is why cover of the work must be arranged in advance.
3. Who must take out the insurance of the work and who pays the premium?
SIA 118 does not require an ATC: if the law imposes no insurance on the client, the client states in the tender documents whether the work under construction has been insured and by which (art. 189 para. 3). When the ATC is taken out by the client, contractors often contribute to the premium under a contract clause.
The tool's specifications indicate a contribution of 0.3% to 0.8% of the contract price, i.e. between CHF 1'500 and 4'000 for a CHF 500'000 site: indicative value to be confirmed with your broker or the contract.
4. What is the "removal and refitting costs" clause for, and leak detection?
To repair your defect, it is often necessary to open up or dismantle the work of other trades (screeds, partitions, tiling), then restore it. These costs are reimbursed only if your policy includes the extension "removal / refitting costs and defect detection". It covers these incidental costs, not the replacement of your own work.
Check in your general conditions the sub-limit of this extension, the excess and the exclusions (piping, damp, vibration): they vary widely from one insurer to another.
5. What exactly should be done in the event of a loss on a site?
Report it immediately to your insurer and, in writing, to the site management: the contractor is obliged to give notice without delay of any circumstance that might jeopardise execution of the work (art. 25 SIA 118). Do not admit liability before speaking to the insurer, keep the evidence (photos, invoices, replaced parts) and limit the damage.
The client may, for its part, be liable as owner of a structure (art. 58 CO) or of land (art. 679 CC): its RC maître d'ouvrage (client's liability) applies towards third parties, with a possible claim back against you.
Indicative information: it replaces neither your general insurance conditions nor the advice of your broker or a lawyer.
