Down-payment fraud, sham start of performance and abusive emergency repairs: recognise, recover, report
A down payment made at signing, a few pallets left in front of the house, then no more news: or an emergency repair invoiced with no price announced. These situations mainly affect private owners, but also small companies whose name is used wrongly. This page explains how they appear in French-speaking Switzerland, what the Code of Obligations (Art. 366, 372, 377 CO), the Criminal Code (Art. 146 CP) and the Unfair Competition Act provide, what to write and keep, and how an honest company avoids being wrongly suspected. A signal is not proof: only the authorities qualify the facts.
PDFDOCX
The guide: Down-payment fraud and emergency repairs
The detailed guide for this page in PDF and Word: legal basis, steps to follow, template letters and evidence checklist.
An e-mail address is requested: the guide is displayed immediately and is also sent to you by e-mail (signed links valid for 7 days).
How the trap works and which warning signs to look for
The mechanism on the ground in French-speaking Switzerland
The three situations covered here have one point in common: money is asked for before or during the intervention, without the corresponding work being established. The series numbers them 24, 25 and 26 (the “26 anomalies” numbering is the series’ own, not an official classification); their titles are proposed by the editors and remain to be validated.
The three situations on this page
No.
Situation
How it appears
24
Down payment taken, then site never opened (proposed title, to be validated)
A down payment is asked for at signing, often with time pressure; then the excuses follow one another and the site does not start.
25
Sham “start of performance” (proposed title, to be validated)
Material is left or a visit takes place, then this “start” is invoked to refuse to return the down payment.
26
Abusive or fictitious emergency “repair” (proposed title, to be validated)
An emergency intervention is invoiced with no price announced and no quote, with no breakdown, or with no connection to the real fault.
Many site delays have nothing to do with fraud: a late supplier, bad weather, an overloaded tradesperson. What marks a serious signal is the accumulation: a down payment with no detailed contract, a company that cannot be found in the public registers, successive excuses, refusal to give an account. The Criminal Code requires fraudulent deception (Art. 146 CP); mere non-performance is not enough on its own, and the qualification belongs to the criminal authority.
The honest company is exposed too: a down payment requested without explanation or an emergency invoice with no breakdown is enough to make it suspected. The advice that follows applies to both sides.
Warning signs (Red Flags) to check before and during the works
The following indicators are observable facts. Each calls for a check (commercial register, quote, receipt); none is proof.
A down payment is demanded at signing or before any order of material, with no link to a precise stage of the site.
Payment is requested in cash, with no dated receipt, or to an account not in the name of the company on the quote.
The company cannot be found in the Central Index of Business Names, or its address and identification number do not match the quote.
Signing is rushed by an offer “valid today only” or by an unrequested visit to your home.
The start of the works is postponed several times, with successive excuses and no new written schedule.
Material is left or a visit takes place, then nothing more; this “start” is invoked to refuse to return the down payment.
For an emergency repair, no price is announced before the intervention and no quote is offered.
The tradesperson “discovers” other costly faults on site and demands an immediate decision.
The emergency invoice does not break down the hours, the parts or the identity of the company, and no intervention report is handed over.
Mini-diagnosis: how many signals do you spot?
Tick the situations you observe: the tool counts the signals, recalls the legal articles concerned and points you to the guide. Nothing is sent or saved.
Do you spot signals of down-payment fraud or abusive emergency repair?
Tick what matches your situation. Nothing is sent or saved.
This is neither a diagnosis nor proof: a signal calls for a check, not an accusation.
Down-payment fraud, sham start of performance and abusive emergency repairs: recognise, recover, report · https://art-construction.ch/en/outils/dossiers/escroquerie-acompte-travaux-commencement-execution-depannage/
Tick the signals you have observed: the result appears here, box by box.
Swiss legal framework, evidence and template letters
Legal bases: CO, CC, CP, LP and SIA 118
In a works contract, the price is payable on delivery of the work; if partial deliveries and payments have been agreed, the price of each part is payable on delivery of that part (Art. 372 CO). A down payment is therefore the result of an agreement: it must be written, quantified and tied to a stage. Whoever claims performance of a bilateral contract must have performed, or offer to perform, their own obligation (Art. 82 CO). If the contractor does not start the work on time, the owner may withdraw from the contract without waiting (Art. 366 para. 1 CO); in case of default, the owner sets a reasonable deadline, then declares at once that it withdraws from the contract and may reclaim what it has paid (Art. 107 and 109 CO).
The owner may also terminate the contract as long as the work is not finished, but must then pay for the work done and fully compensate the contractor (Art. 377 CO): a real “start” therefore has a price, but it is for the contractor to prove it (Art. 8 CC). Under criminal law, fraud requires fraudulent deception, an intent to obtain unlawful enrichment and a detrimental act (Art. 146 para. 1 CP). Misleading or aggressive commercial practices fall under the Unfair Competition Act (Art. 3 para. 1 let. b and h LCD).
The rules at a glance
Rule
Article
What the text says
Payment of the price
Art. 372 para. 1 and 2 CO
The price of the work is payable on delivery; if partial deliveries and payments have been agreed, the price of each part is payable on delivery of that part.
Defence of non-performance
Art. 82 CO
Whoever claims performance of a bilateral contract must have performed, or offer to perform, their own obligation.
Late start of the works
Art. 366 para. 1 CO
If the contractor does not start the work on time, the owner may withdraw from the contract without waiting for the date set for delivery.
Default and reasonable deadline
Art. 102 para. 1 and Art. 107 para. 1 and 2 CO
The debtor is put in default by a demand; the creditor sets a reasonable deadline, then, by immediate declaration, waives performance or withdraws from the contract.
Return after withdrawal from the contract
Art. 109 para. 1 CO
The creditor who withdraws from the contract may refuse the promised performance and reclaim what has already been paid.
Termination by the owner
Art. 377 CO
As long as the work is not finished, the owner may withdraw from the contract by paying for the work done and fully compensating the contractor.
Price not fixed
Art. 374 CO
If the price was not fixed in advance or was fixed only approximately, it is determined by the value of the work and the contractor’s expenses.
Unjust enrichment
Art. 62 CO
Whoever has been enriched without legitimate cause at another’s expense must make restitution.
Burden of proof
Art. 8 CC
Each party proves the facts it alleges in order to derive its right from them, unless a rule provides otherwise.
Revocation of a contract concluded outside the supplier’s premises
Art. 40a to 40f CO
Fourteen days to revoke, under conditions: personal or family use, circumstances of Art. 40b, written information from the supplier; no revocation if the buyer expressly requested the negotiations.
Fraud
Art. 146 para. 1 to 3 CP
Fraudulent deception with the aim of obtaining an unlawful enrichment, which leads the victim to an act detrimental to their interests: custodial sentence of up to five years or a monetary penalty; six months to ten years if the offender does it as a trade; on complaint if it targets relatives or members of the household.
Unfair practices
Art. 3 para. 1 let. b and h LCD ; Art. 23 LCD
Inaccurate or misleading statements about one’s services or prices, particularly aggressive sales methods; intentional offence prosecuted on complaint: custodial sentence of up to three years or a monetary penalty.
Down payments under SIA 118
Art. 140, 144 and 145 SIA 118
Down payments correspond to the value of the services performed; payment before performance is an exceptional case that requires special contractual provisions (according to a public guide of the State of Bern; the standard is not freely available).
Contractual shield and evidence to gather
For the private owner, five reflexes reduce the risk:
Check the company in the Central Index of Business Names (Zefix) and compare name, address and identification number with the quote.
Demand a detailed written quote, a schedule and a precise down-payment clause: amount, stage that justifies it, bank account in the company’s name.
Never pay in cash without a dated and signed receipt.
For a contract signed at your home, read the information on the right of revocation and act within 14 days (Art. 40b, 40d and 40e CO).
Photograph with the date the state of the site and the material present, and keep all messages.
For the honest company, five practices avoid being mistaken for a fraudster: a detailed and signed quote; a down payment justified by a stage (ordering a named material, for example) and paid into its company account; a dated receipt for every payment; a written notice of the start of works; and, for an emergency repair, a price announced before the intervention, an intervention report (hours, parts, before and after photos) and a detailed invoice. If the contract incorporates SIA 118, down payments follow the value of the services performed (Art. 144 and 145 SIA 118) and payment before performance is an exceptional case that requires special contractual provisions (Art. 140 SIA 118).
Before signing: check the company in the Central Index of Business Names, demand a detailed written quote and a schedule, and pay only a down payment tied to a stage, into an account in the company’s name, against a dated receipt.
If the contract is signed at your home, note the date, read the information on revocation and send your revocation in writing within 14 days (letter 3).
If the site does not start, set a reasonable deadline in writing (letter 1) and keep proof of dispatch.
If the company invokes a “start”, ask for a detailed statement and dated supporting documents (letter 2); sign no receipt in settlement of the balance.
For an emergency repair, ask for the price before the intervention; if the invoice is excessive or has no breakdown, pay what is justified and dispute the rest in writing.
If the signals pile up, inform the police or the public prosecutor’s office and consult a lawyer; observe the three-month period for offences prosecuted on complaint.
Template letter models
Letter 1: formal notice to start the works or return the down payment
Subject: [site], contract of [date]: formal notice and deadline to start the works or return the down payment of CHF [..] (Art. 107 CO)
Dear Sir or Madam,
By the contract of [date], you undertook to carry out [works] at [address], with the start agreed for [date]. We paid a down payment of CHF [..] on [date]. To date, [no work has started / the site has been at a standstill since [date]].
We give you until [date, reasonable period] to start the works and send us a written schedule [or, if you give up, to return the down payment to us]. On expiry of this deadline, we will let you know at once whether we waive performance and withdraw from the contract (Art. 107 para. 2 CO; Art. 366 para. 1 CO) and we will claim return of the down payment (Art. 109 para. 1 CO).
Yours faithfully, [Name, address, date and signature] Registered post and e-mail. Enclosures: contract; proof of payment; dated photos of the site.
Letter 2: request for a statement and proof of the work carried out
Subject: [site]: request for a detailed statement and supporting documents for the work you rely on (Art. 377 CO)
Dear Sir or Madam,
You maintain that you have started the works and are keeping the down payment of CHF [..] on that basis. We dispute that works have been carried out to the extent of that amount.
We ask you to hand us by [date, 10 days]: 1) a detailed statement of the work carried out, with dates, hours and quantities; 2) the invoices and delivery notes for the material ordered, in the name of the site; 3) dated photos of the progress. It is for you to prove the work done. Should the contract be terminated, the owner would pay for the work done and compensate the contractor within the limits of Art. 377 CO, to be deducted from the down payment made. We reserve all our rights, including the return of the excess (Art. 62 CO).
Yours faithfully, [Name, address, date and signature] Registered post and e-mail. Enclosures: contract; proof of payment.
Letter 3: revocation of a contract concluded at home
Subject: [site], contract of [date]: revocation (Art. 40b and 40e CO)
Dear Sir or Madam,
On [date], you visited me at my home and I signed your quote of CHF [..] for [works]. I had not asked you for this visit. In accordance with Art. 40b CO, I revoke my offer and my acceptance. This letter is sent within the fourteen-day period (Art. 40e para. 2 and 4 CO). [You did not give me in writing, at the time of signing, the information on my right of revocation (Art. 40d CO).]
I ask you to return to me by [date] the down payment of CHF [..] made on [date]. I will reimburse the justified advances and costs you have incurred, within the limits of Art. 40f CO. I reserve all my rights.
Yours faithfully, [Name, address, date and signature] Registered post. Enclosures: copy of the signed quote; proof of payment.
Where to report
A criminal report is made to the police or the public prosecutor’s office of your canton; the Swiss ePolice portal helps find a police station. For offences prosecuted on complaint, the right to file a complaint lapses three months after one knows the offender (Art. 31 CP): Art. 23 LCD is one of them. The SECO receives complaints about unfair commercial practice; a consumer association can advise before any step.
Swiss ePolice (find a police station): Common portal of the cantonal police forces: the “Find a police station” section to file a criminal report with your canton’s police. (address read on 7 November 2026)
SECO: complaint about unfair commercial practice: LCD complaint: the SECO acts only if collective interests are affected, does not claim damages for victims and does not handle anonymous complaints. (address read on 7 November 2026)
Fédération romande des consommateurs: Consumer protection association: the home page offers the sections “Obtenir de l'aide” and “Dénoncer”. (address read on 7 November 2026)
Protect yourself with the ACIP index and the Soumission software, frequently asked questions
How to lock down your site with the ACIP index and Soumission
The ACIP index (Art Construction Indice de Prix) classifies prices by trade chapter and by CFC code. Comparing the price of a quote or of an hourly emergency-repair rate with these benchmarks helps spot an amount that departs clearly from practice and deserves a question before signing or paying. These values are indicative, not contractual. Then fix in writing the scope of the works, the price and the due date of the down payment: what is written at the start is the simplest to rely on in case of disagreement.
Can I demand a down payment, and from when may a company keep it?
The Code of Obligations provides that the price of the work is payable on delivery, except for agreed partial payments (Art. 372 CO): a down payment therefore requires an agreement, which must be written, quantified and tied to a stage. The company may in principle keep only the part that corresponds to the work done and the compensation under Art. 377 CO if the owner terminates, and it is for the company to provide proof (Art. 8 CC). Demand a dated receipt for every payment.
The company says it has started the works: can I get my down payment back?
Ask in writing for a detailed statement and dated supporting documents (letter 2). If the contractor did not start on time, you may withdraw from the contract (Art. 366 para. 1 CO) or set a deadline, then declare at once that you withdraw from the contract and claim what you paid (Art. 107 and 109 CO). If you terminate, you pay for the work actually done and compensate the contractor within the limits of Art. 377 CO. The law knows no “start” that would be enough to keep the down payment.
When does non-performance become fraud within the meaning of Art. 146 CP?
Art. 146 para. 1 CP requires fraudulent deception by false statements or the concealment of true facts, an intent to obtain unlawful enrichment and an act detrimental to the victim. A delay, an insolvency arising after signing or a disagreement about the work done may fall under civil law alone. It is for the criminal authority to establish the elements of the offence: do not qualify a person yourself, but gather the documents and inform the police or the public prosecutor’s office.
Can I revoke a works contract signed at my home?
Perhaps. Art. 40b CO allows revocation of a commitment made in particular in residential premises, within a period of fourteen days that begins only when you have signed and know the supplier’s written information about this right (Art. 40d and 40e CO). The right does not exist if you expressly requested the negotiations (Art. 40c let. a CO). It concerns services for personal or family use worth more than 100 francs (Art. 40a CO); its application to renovation works is not confirmed by any source we have read. Act in writing and within 14 days, then consult a lawyer.
What to do about an excessive emergency invoice or one with no breakdown?
Ask in writing for the breakdown of the hours and parts and for the intervention report. If no price was agreed, the price is determined by the value of the work and the contractor’s expenses (Art. 374 CO). Pay the justified part, dispute the rest in writing and keep the evidence. Misleading statements about prices or particularly aggressive sales methods may fall under the Unfair Competition Act (Art. 3 para. 1 let. b and h LCD), which the SECO or a lawyer can examine.
How can an honest company avoid being wrongly suspected?
It presents a detailed and signed quote, justifies the down payment by a stage (the ordering of a specific material) and receives it into its company account, issues a dated receipt, announces the start of works in writing and, for an emergency repair, announces the price before intervening, then hands over an intervention report and a detailed invoice. In case of door-to-door selling, it hands over the written information on the right of revocation (Art. 40d CO). These steps protect the client and its own reputation.
The articles of SIA 118, a standard that is not freely available, must be checked in the edition applicable to your contract (marked (*) when they could not be confirmed). The numerical examples on this page are fictitious.