Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 226Checks, damage claims and safety for the waterprooferChapter 7 of 10 in the section

Another trade has drilled through: impact on warranty and repair

The unforeseen penetration of a ventilation duct through an approved, sealed waterproofing system compromises the integrity of the structure. You will learn how to formalise the joint inspection record, release your civil liability regarding subsequent water ingress, and enforce the approved technical repair method guaranteeing that insurance coverage is maintained.

Key takeaways

  • Any uncoordinated penetration suspends the waterproofer's warranty over the affected area.
  • The site management must require a prior request before any penetrative technical intervention.
  • The immediate joint inspection record establishes physical liabilities and induced damage.
  • Only the original waterproofer is qualified to carry out connections to preserve the structure.

Recording of wild penetrations by the ventilation engineer and repercussions on the warranty

On flat roof construction sites, late core drilling for the passage of air ducts is the leading cause of disputes between finishing trades. When a ventilation installer cuts through a slab to run a duct without coordination, they penetrate successively the vapour barrier, the thermal insulation, and the bituminous or synthetic waterproofing system. This action compromises air- and watertightness, creating a direct entry point for rainwater and loading the insulation with moisture. As soon as such an unauthorised penetration is discovered, the waterproofer must immediately disclaim liability over the damaged sector.

On a contractual level, physical damage caused by a third party breaks the presumption of conformity of the delivered structure. Pursuant to standard SIA 118 and contract law, the warranty for defects can no longer be enforced for defects resulting directly from this external intervention. Under art. 369 CO, the client's rights in respect of defects are excluded when the defective execution is personally attributable to them, notably through orders given or acts of other agents on the site.

Localised loss of warranty
Forfeiture of the waterproofer's obligation to carry out remedial work free of charge on a defined roof compartment, following mechanical alteration caused by a third party without prior technical agreement.

To freeze the situation, the site foreman or the works supervisor draws up a detailed visual inspection record. This survey includes precise photographs of the penetration, positioning dimensions relative to the parapets, and an inventory of collateral damage: torn membrane, water ingress under the sheets, crushed or soaked insulation. This document is forwarded without delay to the site management in the form of a notice of localised warranty suspension, stating that any ingress originating at this duct or migrating beneath the system falls under the exclusive liability of the trade involved.

Intervention protocol: prior request, joint inspection record and technical repair

Avoiding losses relies on strict construction site discipline: no flat roof penetration must be tolerated without a formal prior request submitted by the ventilation engineer at least ten working days prior to execution. This advance notice makes it possible to assess technical feasibility, determine the required upstand height above the finished level of the heavy surfacing or green roof, and incorporate an upstand curb or manufactured flange sleeve adapted to the diameter of the pipe.

  1. Submission of the opening requestThe ventilation engineer supplies the penetration layout drawings, the outside dimensions of the duct including its thermal insulation, and requests opening authorisation from the site management and the waterproofer.
  2. Joint inspection record before drillingThe waterproofer marks out the work area, cuts cleanly through the waterproofing system and exposes the concrete or profiled metal deck substrate. A signed protocol confirms the dry condition of the surrounding insulation.
  3. Drilling and installation of the penetration supportThe third party carries out the core drilling, disposes of the drilling slurry without contaminating the roof, and securely fixes a rigid sleeve or metal curb with at least 150 mm of free height above the finished level.
  4. Exclusive repair by the waterprooferThe waterproofing contractor reinstates the vapour barrier, reinstalls equivalent dry insulation, welds the bituminous or synthetic waterproofing collars with a minimum overlap of 150 mm onto the main surface, and then fits a watertight clamping ring at the top.
  5. Repair inspection record and reinstatement of warrantyJoint inspection by visual check and seam probe testing of the welds. Signing of the acceptance record for the modification work, transferring the costs to the duct installer and reinstating the warranty.

Under art. 365 CO, if any circumstance compromises the proper execution of the work, the contractor informs the client. The waterproofer therefore points out that any waterproofing repair carried out by another contractor will result in the definitive forfeiture of their warranty over the entire roof, owing to the impossibility of tracing the source of a leak beneath a welded membrane.

Liability matrix for retrofitted penetrations
Observed situationLiability for the damageRequired administrative actionStatus of the waterproofer's warranty
Wild penetration discovered unconnectedVentilation installer and site managementImmediate notice of defects and photographic surveyFully suspended over the area
Temporary sealing carried out by the third partyContractor that carried out the penetrationFormal written refusal of approvalVoided at the penetration point
Compliant repair by the original waterprooferWaterproofer for the repair, ventilation installer for the costsConnection acceptance protocolFully maintained or reinstated

Delimitation of liabilities and contractual redefinition of the warranty

The late penetration of a waterproofing system by a ventilation contractor constitutes a unilateral breach of the integrity of the completed or ongoing work. In terms of liabilities, three parties are directly involved: the ventilation installer who carried out the core drilling without coordination, the site management who failed in their duty of interdisciplinary coordination, and the waterproofer holding trade lot CFC 226 whose work has been damaged by third-party action. The moment the drill bit penetrates the bituminous sheet or synthetic membrane, the presumption of conformity of the waterproofing ceases locally.

Under art. 369 CO, the client's rights in respect of defects in the work are excluded when the defective execution is personally attributable to them. If the site management authorised or ordered the drilling of the roof without requiring the waterproofer's presence or specifying the appropriate connection protocol, the client can no longer assert warranty rights against the waterproofer for any water ingress occurring within the relevant area. The waterproofing contractor must without delay notify formal reservations to the site management upon discovery of the cut, otherwise their liability may be engaged in future water damage related to moisture diffusion within the thermal insulation.

Allocation of liabilities and status of the warranty during unauthorised core drilling
Observed situationParty liable for the damageStatus of the CFC 226 warrantyRegularisation procedure
Unsealed raw core holeVentilation contractor (direct fault)Warranty suspended over the zone of influenceImmediate joint inspection record and formal notice issued by the site management
Makeshift repair by the ventilation engineer (sealant, tape)Ventilation contractor and site managementWarranty fully forfeited at the detail pointFormal refusal of approval, removal of makeshift repair and CFC 226 reinstatement
Repair executed by the original waterprooferCosts charged to the ventilation engineer or site managementWarranty reinstated or new specific warranty on the detailEstablishment of an acceptance protocol after repair
Repair entrusted by the site management to a third-party waterprooferSite management (contractual choice)Definitive extinction of the original waterproofer's warranty on the connected workRecord of total discharge in favour of the initial contractor

When the original waterproofer intervenes to repair the penetration at the request of the client, the remedial work is covered by a separate purchase order or a daywork addendum at the expense of the liable third party. This repair sets a new demarcation line: the executed detail starts its own contractual warranty period under standard SIA 118, while the remainder of the roof retains its initial regime. Conversely, if the site management engages a third party to seal the penetration, the initial waterproofer must without fail declare in writing their total release from liability for the entire affected drainage catchment area.

Anticipation protocol and formalisation of joint inspection records

To eliminate systematic disputes between technical packages on flat roofs, site organisation must impose a strict prior notice procedure for any intervention. No finishing trade may be permitted to position bases for air-handling units, drill fixing anchors, or cut duct penetrations without having submitted an intervention notice approved by the site management and forwarded to the waterproofing site foreman at least five working days before the operation.

  1. Submission of the prior opening requestThe ventilation engineer transmits the exact dimensions, duct diameter, and layout plan to the site management and the waterproofer, specifying the required date for core drilling.
  2. Joint inspection record of conditions prior to core drillingThe waterproofer, the ventilation engineer, and the site management inspect the work area. A formal protocol notes the absence of pre-existing defects on the membrane and authorises the cutting layout.
  3. Preparation and drilling under protectionThe waterproofer neatly cuts back the waterproofing system and insulation to a template 100 mm larger than the pipe diameter. The ventilation engineer carries out the core drilling of the concrete slab, immediately vacuuming up slurry and dust.
  4. Installation of the curb and watertight detailingInstallation of a metal curb or rigid sleeve secured to the substrate, connection of the vapour barrier, replacement of the thermal insulation, then welding of the waterproofing sheet with a compliant upstand.
  5. Joint inspection record upon completion and clearance of reservationsVisual and mechanical inspection of the detail welds by the site management and the waterproofer, joint signing of the partial acceptance document, and formal extension of the warranty.

Systematic documentation via protocols before and after drilling protects the financial interests of the waterproofing firm. The post-works document must record precisely the quantities of materials installed, the type of reinforcement used, the nature of connections to the duct, and the exact date of closure. These technical details, countersigned by the site management, are integrated into the as-built documentation and eliminate any future disputes regarding the origin of a possible defect in the roof system.

Dispute management and refusal of warranty assumption

When an uncoordinated penetration of a waterproof system by an HVAC installer occurs, the situation frequently leads to a legal deadlock. If the ventilation installer or the site management refuses to formally commission the waterproofer to carry out remedial work in accordance with recognised trade standards, the CFC 226 contractor must immediately issue a formal notice of warranty suspension on the affected structure.

Art. 365 CO provides that if any circumstance compromises the regular or timely execution of the work, the contractor shall inform the client, under penalty of bearing the consequences. This written notice must pinpoint the exact location of the penetration, the affected layers (vapour barrier, thermal insulation, bituminous or synthetic waterproofing sheets), and the resulting zone of warranty forfeiture.

In accordance with art. 369 CO, the client's rights in respect of defects in the work are excluded when the defective execution is personally attributable to them, notably through orders given or acts of third parties commissioned on the site. For this release of liability to take full effect in the event of subsequent water damage, a joint inspection record is required before any makeshift patching takes place.

  • Immediate preparation of a detailed photographic survey showing the raw penetration, the exposed insulation, and the lack of a compliant upstand curb.
  • Dispatch of a registered letter to the site management and the client specifying the suspension of the waterproofing warranty on the affected section.
  • Explicit refusal to endorse sealing using expanding foam or mastic sealant applied by an unqualified finishing trade.
  • Submission of a quote for the complete reinstatement of the build-up (concrete upstand or metal curb, bridging of the vapour barrier, bituminous or synthetic upstand according to standard SIA 271).

Until a work order for reinstatement is signed and the repair has been validated by a post-works record, the waterproofer maintains their written reservation during the final acceptance of the work in accordance with standard SIA 118.

Frequently asked questions

Can the ventilation installer fit a prefabricated waterproofing sleeve themselves to repair their penetration?

No. Any detailing on a flat roof waterproofing system falls strictly within the professional scope of the waterproofer. Installing a sleeve or flange requires thermal welding or homogeneous bonding to the existing membrane, as well as meticulous jointing with the underlying vapour barrier. Work carried out by an unqualified third party automatically voids the warranty on the affected area and creates an immediate risk of water ingress.

What deadline applies for demanding the repair of an unauthorised roof penetration?

The notice of defects and formal notice must be issued as soon as the core drilling is discovered. The waterproofer submits their record within 24 to 48 working hours to the site management. Because water infiltrates very quickly into flat roof thermal insulation, an immediate temporary weatherproofing measure is required, at the expense of the liable party, prior to the final and compliant reinstatement of the build-up according to standard SIA 271.

Does a localised penetration entirely void the ten-year or five-year warranty?

Warranty forfeiture affects only the zone of influence of the penetration and the potential hydraulic path under the membrane, not the entire building. The waterproofer indicates the exclusion boundaries on the roof plan provided to the site management. If the complete technical repair is subsequently carried out and invoiced by the original waterproofer, the full waterproofing warranty is reinstated across the entire accepted structure.

What should be done if the site management refuses to invoice the repair to the defaulting ventilation contractor?

The waterproofer refuses any unremunerated intervention and does not extend their warranty to the penetrated structure. They send a formal notice to the client recalling that the penetration breaks the continuity of the waterproofing membrane. If the site management orders a repair without a contractual modification order, the waterproofer enters express written reservations in the site minutes in order to release their civil liability entirely in the event of leaks.

Texts and standards cited

  • CO art. 365materials and site: the contractor is liable for the sound quality of the materials they supply; if the materials supplied by the client or the site designated by the client are found to be defective, or if another circumstance compromises the regular or timely execution of the work, the contractor shall immediately inform the client, under penalty of bearing the consequences (para. 3).
  • CO art. 369exclusion of the client's rights for defects in the work when the defective execution is personally attributable to them (orders given contrary to the contractor's formal advice or any other cause).

In the same section