Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 226Substrate, slope, vapour barrier and thermal insulationChapter 4 of 10 in the section

Flat roof insulation: compressive strength by intended use

This chapter enables you to determine the compressive strength required for thermal insulation according to the building's intended use. You will learn to evaluate stresses under distributed or point loads, prevent differential settlement under terrace pedestals and verify the adequacy of the insulation build-up before installing the covering.

Key takeaways

  • The allowable stress of an insulation material must cover the permanent dead load and anticipated operational live loads.
  • A board intended for a non-trafficable roof crushes quickly under a pedestrian terrace on pedestals.
  • Pedestals concentrate severe point loads that require adequate load distribution over the waterproofing.
  • The total thickness influences absolute settlement and the risk of sagging at upstand connections.

Adapting insulation strength according to access: non-trafficable, pedestrian or vehicular traffic

The choice of thermal insulation on a flat roof does not depend solely on its thermal performance, but on its ability to take up mechanical loads without excessive deformation. A non-trafficable roof primarily bears the self-weight of the build-up and temporary snow loads. As soon as the structure becomes accessible to pedestrians for heavy maintenance, is fitted out as a private terrace or made trafficable for light vehicles, the stresses applied to the insulation change radically in nature and intensity.

Nominal compressive strength and allowable stress
Nominal strength generally corresponds to the stress required to compress the test specimen by 10 % during a short-term laboratory test. Allowable service stress, on the other hand, represents the maximum continuous dead load that the insulation can bear in the long term without undergoing destructive creep, commonly set at a fraction of the nominal value.
Mechanical behaviour of insulation families according to roof use
Insulation familyNon-trafficable use (gravel, exposed)Pedestrian use (terrace)Vehicular use (light vehicles)
High-density mineral woolSuitable under heavy ballastUnsuitable on pedestals without distribution screedExcluded
Expanded polystyrene (EPS)Standard, standard formatsHigh-density EPS admissible under gravel bedLimited to reinforced pedestrian areas
Polyurethane / Polyisocyanurate (PIR)Very common, low thicknessAdmissible with rigid distribution or slabsSubject to specific technical approval
Extruded polystyrene (XPS)Common inverted roofVery high performance under slabs and gravelPermitted according to high compression class
Cellular glassHigh waterproofing reliabilityExcellent behaviour under loadReference material with zero settlement

Laying entry-level insulation sized for a ballasted roof beneath timber decking or slabs causes rupture of the cellular structure. Progressive deformation of the board causes tensile stress in the waterproofing membrane, opening of underlying joints and local back-falls that promote rainwater ponding. Under the Code of Obligations (CO), the contractor is liable for the proper execution of their work and must ensure that installed materials correspond to actual service stresses.

Point loads from slabs on pedestals, total thickness and settlement control

The system of concrete or porcelain stoneware slabs laid on polymer pedestals represents the most aggressive loading condition for underlying insulation. Instead of pressure distributed uniformly across the entire surface, as occurs beneath a gravel bed or green roof build-up, the dead load of the slabs and operational live load are transferred to the circular base of each pedestal. This reduced bearing area concentrates stress across a few square decimetres.

The point load applied to the membrane and transmitted to the insulation can locally exceed the allowable service stress. To prevent mechanical puncturing of the vapour barrier or bituminous membrane, the waterproofing contractor inserts elastomeric pads beneath pedestal bases. If the insulation has too low an elastic modulus, these pads are insufficient to prevent the pedestal base from gradually pressing into the thermal layer.

  • Calculate the load per pedestal by adding the dead weight of the four supported half-slabs and the pedestrian point live load.
  • Select pedestals with a wide base to increase the load diffusion area towards the waterproofing.
  • Check the chemical and mechanical compatibility of distribution pads laid on the waterproofing build-up.
  • Verify that overall insulation thickness does not multiply cumulative absolute settlement across the structure.

Total insulation thickness directly exacerbates vertical deformation. A residual settlement of 2 % remains insignificant on a 60 mm thick board, representing an indentation of approximately 1.2 mm. This same percentage applied to an energy retrofit build-up reaching 200 mm generates an absolute settlement of 4 mm. This sagging creates height offsets between slabs, destabilises pedestal seating and generates critical shear forces at peripheral upstands and rainwater outlets.

Creep behaviour and differential settlement under service loads

Short-term compressive strength in no way guarantees the stability of a build-up under continuous or intensive pedestrian use. In the case of a roof repurposed as an accessible terrace, delayed deformation under constant load — compressive creep — constitutes the critical phenomenon. Insulation sized for occasional maintenance loading undergoes progressive settlement when subjected to the dead load of finishes and repeated foot traffic, destroying drainage falls and shearing peripheral details.

When thermal insulation thickness increases to meet current insulation requirements, absolute settlement becomes decisive. A 2 % deformation on an 80 mm board represents an indentation of 1.6 mm, which is generally tolerated by bituminous or synthetic waterproofing. Conversely, on a thick assembly reaching 200 mm to 240 mm, this same percentage induces settlement of nearly 5 mm. Under a terrace on pedestals, this local height difference causes concrete or ceramic slabs to rock and forms ponding water pockets at the vapour barrier or substrate level.

Suitability of insulation boards according to compressive stress and intended use
Insulation familyNominal strength (at 10 %)Allowable continuous live loadSuitable flat roof application
Standard EPS (expanded polystyrene)100 kPa20 to 30 kPaNon-trafficable roof under gravel only
High-density EPS150 to 200 kPa45 to 60 kPaAccessible terrace on gravel or well-distributed pedestals
PIR / PUR (polyurethane foam)120 to 150 kPa35 to 45 kPaPedestrian terrace with continuous distribution layer
XPS (extruded polystyrene)300 to 700 kPa90 to 210 kPaInverted roof, vehicular terrace and emergency access routes
Cellular glass500 to 1600 kPa150 to 480 kPaHeavy green roof, ramps and light vehicle car parks

Distribution measures and reinforcement under point bearings

Point loading from a terrace pedestal generates stress concentrations that locally crush the cellular structure of standard insulation. To prevent puncturing of the waterproofing and indentation into the insulation layer, the bearing area must be sized according to the overall transmitted load. Standard circular pedestal bases often have insufficient diameter when supporting thick natural stone slabs or permanent outdoor furniture.

  • Systematic installation of regenerated rubber bearing pads (EPDM granulate bound with polyurethane) under each pedestal base to absorb vibrations and prevent mechanical perforation.
  • Interposition of rigid load-spreading elements, such as 30x30 cm concrete slabs laid flat on the waterproofing before installing adjustable pedestals.
  • Installation of a drainage layer combined with a continuous filtration geotextile capable of uniformly dissipating surface loads across the full extent of the thermal insulation.
  • Targeted replacement of compressible insulation with rigid cellular glass or ultra-dense extruded polystyrene elements beneath high-traffic paths and building services equipment.

When the client decides to convert an originally gravelled roof into a usable roof terrace without adapting the type of insulation already installed, the waterproofing contractor faces a defect in the substrate provided for use. In accordance with art. 365 CO, the contractor is liable for the sound quality of the materials they supply; if the materials supplied by the client or the ground designated by them are found to be defective, or if any other circumstance jeopardises the regular or punctual execution of the work, the contractor shall immediately inform the client thereof, under penalty of bearing the consequences.

Managing compressive non-conformities and unexpected settlement

Discovering an insulation board on a construction site that is unsuited to service stresses demands an immediate technical response. If a thermal build-up intended for an inaccessible roof without storage subsequently receives a terrace on pedestals, the risk of localised crushing and membrane puncturing becomes critical. The allowable stress of the material no longer corresponds to the concentrated loads imparted by the pedestals.

When the error is identified before installing the protective or wearing layer, stripping out remains the only compliant solution. If pedestals already rest on the build-up, the waterproofing contractor must immediately formalise the situation with site management.

  • Joint inspection record of insulation thicknesses and precise survey of indentations beneath each pedestal base.
  • Verification of the integrity of the bituminous or synthetic waterproofing build-up under compressed zones.
  • Evaluation of rigid distribution plates beneath pedestals if complete replacement of the insulation proves impossible without major demolition.
  • Verification of the residual fall of the flat roof to avoid any abnormal water ponding resulting from differential settlement.

Governs contractual relations, duty of notification and defect claim procedures relating to works defects between the client and the contractor.

norme SIA 118

Under art. 365 CO, if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by them is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance jeopardises the regular or punctual execution of the work, the contractor shall immediately inform the client thereof. Failure to provide written notice renders the waterproofing contractor liable for subsequent mechanical degradation of the thermal build-up.

Frequently asked questions

How can excessive insulation settlement under slabs on pedestals be identified?

The phenomenon is spotted visually by uneven levels between slabs or wobbling underfoot. When lifting a slab, the pedestal base leaves a distinct depression in the waterproofing and insulation. Using a two-metre straightedge allows quantification of local deflection, revealing whether the compressive strength of the insulation core has been exceeded by the applied point load.

Can insulation that is too soft be compensated for by increasing pedestal base diameter?

Widening the contact area via distribution pads or larger bases reduces the unit pressure transmitted. This corrective measure relieves point stresses but in no way alters the intrinsic strength of the underlying board. If the total thickness of an under-specified insulation is significant, long-term overall settlement will persist under the distributed loads of the terrace.

What mechanical risk affects a waterproofing membrane laid on crushed insulation?

Differential indentation generates shear forces around the perimeter of the pedestal base. The waterproofing membrane undergoes local elongation and severe static puncturing, especially under elevated summer temperatures. Overlap seams are subjected to abnormal tensile stresses, leading to tears in the waterproof sheet and water ingress at depressed areas.

What should be done if the client insists on a terrace on a roof designed to be non-trafficable?

The contractor must refuse the fit-out without prior adaptation of the entire build-up. Written notice must be given regarding the incompatibility of the existing thermal insulation with the intended accessible use. The conversion requires stripping back the upper layers to replace the original board with high mechanical strength insulation, or adding a heavy distribution screed over a suitable decoupling layer.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 118General conditions for construction works.
  • CO art. 365materials and ground: the contractor is liable for the sound quality of the materials they supply; if the materials supplied by the client or the ground designated by them are found to be defective, or if any other circumstance jeopardises the regular or punctual execution of the work, the contractor shall immediately inform the client thereof, under penalty of bearing the consequences (para. 3).

In the same section