Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 226Checks, damage claims and safety for the waterprooferChapter 6 of 10 in the section

Infiltration detected: record, safety measures and sharing of liabilities

Water ingress on a flat roof demands a methodical response. This guide explains how to halt property damage immediately without compromising technical evidence, draft a dated joint inspection record and trigger leak detection mechanisms. You will know how to apply the rules of standard SIA 118 to manage the two-year warranty period and define responsibilities on the construction site.

Key takeaways

  • Priority safety measures protect the building without destroying evidence that determines the exact origin of the incident.
  • A dated and signed joint inspection record freezes defects in place before any technical intervention on the waterproofing system.
  • Leak detection by tracer gas or smoke identifies punctures without prematurely tearing up the system.
  • Standard SIA 118 governs the period for giving notice of defects during the first two years of operation.

Halting water ingress and freezing the situation with a dated joint inspection record

As soon as water ingress is reported through a flat roof slab or a basement ceiling, the operational priority consists of halting the aggravation of internal damage. The intervention team implements protective measures: diverting surface flows using sandbags, laying tarpaulins ballasted with concrete paving slabs on pedestals, immediately clearing clogged spouts or rainwater outlets, and pumping out abnormal water retention. These emergency operations must strictly be carried out without cutting or tearing out existing bituminous or synthetic sheets, otherwise material evidence necessary for the subsequent establishment of liabilities will be destroyed.

Before any permanent repair, the site foreman or works manager summons site management and the client to draw up a joint inspection record on site. This written document lists visible defects on both the underside and the top surface of the roof. The report records the precise time of intervention, weather conditions over the preceding forty-eight hours, the level and coordinate location of the leak, as well as the maintenance condition of upstands, expansion joints and technical penetrations. Overview and detailed photographs supplement the text, accompanied by dimensioned sketches showing damp areas identified with a surface moisture meter.

  • Recording coordinates of the pool on the ceiling and transferring them onto the upper roof plan.
  • Inspection of the cleanliness of leaf guards, overflows and gravity drainage outlets.
  • Verification of the integrity of connections on ventilation ducts and roof light upstands.
  • Visual inspection of areas subjected to recent interventions by other trades, such as metalworkers or solar panel installers.
  • Joint signing of the inspection minutes by the waterproofing contractor and site management.

Investigating the origin of the infiltration and applying the framework of standard SIA 118

Investigating the source requires non-destructive methods of investigation before considering destructive trial pits. Blowing smoke beneath the vapour control layer or directly into the insulation layer allows micro-tears, nail punctures or defective overlap welds to be identified instantly. For inverted roofs or green roofs under gravel, the tracer gas technique—a harmless mixture of nitrogen and hydrogen—penetrates drainage layers and reveals the impact point without clearing ballast from the entire roof. If these methods yield no results, flooded water tests with fluorescein in compartmentalised areas isolate perimeter upstands from main flat areas.

  1. Non-destructive identificationInjection of a tracer gas beneath the waterproofing membrane and electro-acoustic or sniffing-probe localisation of escape points on the surface.
  2. Targeted surgical trial openingClean cutting of a 30 cm by 30 cm inspection window at the designated point to examine the dampness of the insulation board and the continuity of the vapour control layer.
  3. Sampling and analysisMaterial sampling to check weld cohesion or measure the presence of corrosive chemical agents that may have pierced the sheet.
  4. Immediate watertight sealingSealing of the opened area with a hot-welded bridging piece overlapping by at least 150 mm around the entire perimeter.

Legally and contractually, management of the incident depends on the applicable regime. When the contract for work incorporates standard SIA 118, a warranty period of two years begins upon acceptance of the work. During these first two years, the client may notify a defect at any time without observing the duty of immediate notice. For their part, the contractor enjoys the primary right to remedy the established defect at their own expense, provided that the failure arises from their workmanship or materials. Investigations frequently establish that the infiltration in reality stems from punctures caused by the safety boots of an electrical subcontractor or from a guardrail fixing improperly sealed by a third party.

After delivery, the client examines the condition of the work as soon as they can and notifies defects to the contractor; for an immovable work, they have 60 days to notify them and a shorter contractual period is void.

art. 367 CO

Outside the specific regime of standard SIA 118, the rules of the Code of Obligations (CO) apply directly. Art. 367 CO requires the examination of the work upon delivery and the notification of defects, on pain of tacit acceptance. For warranty actions regarding an immovable work, art. 371 CO provides for the limitation period of the client's rights on account of defects after five years from acceptance. Formally drawing up the joint inspection record thus avoids any dispute over notice periods and protects the waterproofing company against unwarranted claims for compensation concerning deteriorations attributable to building operation or failure to carry out regular maintenance on drainage outlets.

Non-destructive investigation methods and joint trial openings

As soon as emergency protective measures are in place to halt the progression of water in the insulation or suspended ceiling, identifying the point of failure demands a rigorous protocol. On a flat roof protected by gravel, paving slabs on pedestals or a green roof build-up, the area where water drips beneath the reinforced concrete slab rarely corresponds to the puncture in the membrane. Water migrates horizontally along falls in the vapour control layer or through gaps in the thermal insulation before finding a slab penetration, a service duct or an expansion joint. Blindly stripping dozens of square metres of ballast destroys evidence and unnecessarily inflates remediation costs.

The choice of diagnostic technique depends on the nature of the waterproofing system (two-ply bituminous, synthetic PVC or FPO membranes) and the type of upper surfacing. The investigation must be conducted in the presence of the parties or their technical representatives so that recorded anomalies cannot be contested at a later stage.

Comparison of leak detection technologies on flat roofs
TechniquePhysical principleOptimal configurationLimits on the construction site
Tracer gas (hydrogen/nitrogen)Injection beneath membrane and surface detection using a sniffing probeGravelled roofs or terrace paving on pedestalsRequires stable positive pressure; ineffective if the vapour control layer is not airtight
Pressurised smokeBlowing white smoke beneath the build-up and visual identification of leakage ventsExposed roofs or complex waterproofing upstandsDoes not penetrate thick soil substrates; risk of smoke ingress into service shafts
Electric pulse (low voltage)Creating an electrical field loop on a wet surface connected to the slab groundExtensive green roofs and damp gravelled roofsRequires a conductive underlying substrate or a dedicated metallic grid
Colorimetry (fluorescein)Localised flooding of upstands or outlets using a UV-reactive tracerTargeted testing of outlets, overflows and door thresholdsPercolation times sometimes long; risk of residual staining on finishes

If resorting to destructive investigation becomes unavoidable to verify the degree of saturation in mineral wool or polyurethane, the opening must be limited to the strict minimum, photographed at each layer (protection, waterproofing, insulation, vapour control layer, concrete substrate) and resealed immediately by vulcanisation or welding of a compatible reinforcement piece. The trial opening record notes the thickness of each layer, any presence of residual moisture beneath the vapour control layer, and joint adhesion.

Arbitration of causes and claim regime under standard SIA 118

Once the puncture or defect is located, the joint technical analysis makes it possible to distinguish three separate origins: poor workmanship attributable to the waterproofing contractor, damage caused by a third party who intervened subsequently, or lack of maintenance falling under the building operator's remit. A clean cut on a waterproofing upstand following the anchoring of a photovoltaic structure, or the start of a tear caused by fixing nails for rainscreen cladding, exempt the waterproofing contractor from their obligation to carry out free remediation. Conversely, a poorly chamfered bituminous bleed line, seam delamination caused by welding at too low a temperature, or an upstand height below technical specifications constitute direct defects in execution.

When the parties have agreed to incorporate standard SIA 118 into the contract for work, rules relating to notice of defects and warranty apply within a clearly defined framework. During the two-year warranty period starting upon acceptance of the work, the client may notify defects at any time, without being forced to act within the ordinary examination period under statutory law. During this two-year window, presumption plays a central role: as soon as a waterproofing defect appears, the waterproofing contractor must prove that their work was performed according to accepted rules or that the damage results from an external cause, such as unauthorised mechanical intervention or water backflow due to complete blockage of rainwater outlets by organic sludge.

If the contract does not incorporate standard SIA 118, ordinary statutory rules apply: according to art. 367 CO, after delivery, the client examines the condition of the work as soon as they can and notifies defects to the contractor. For building constructions, art. 367 CO specifies that the client has 60 days to notify defects. Finally, if the joint expert assessment demonstrates that the waterproofing contractor is entirely blameless, the company is entitled to invoice the principal for all leak detection hours, safety consumables and temporary repairs carried out during the incident.

Management of technical disagreements and escalation routes

When the joint inspection record results in a refusal to sign or a formal dispute regarding the origin of water ingress, the works manager must strictly freeze the technical situation without interrupting temporary watertightness measures. Halting water ingress always takes precedence over financial disputes. If site management attempts to attribute the defect to the waterproofing system when a roof penetration or subsequent fixing by a third party appears to be at fault, the waterproofing contractor records their substantiated reservations in writing via registered letter or tracked email. They document the exact condition of the premises with high-definition photographs, non-destructive moisture readings and geometric surveying of penetrations on the underside of the slab.

  1. Unilateral recording and formal notificationIn the event of the representative's refusal to sign the joint record, immediately notify a detailed report with timestamped photographs and a description of protective measures executed on the flat roof.
  2. Mandating a neutral technical expertPropose the joint appointment of a neutral building envelope expert to carry out targeted destructive openings and supervise smoke or tracer gas watertightness tests.
  3. Formal notice for damage caused by a third partyIf infiltration results from punctures or mechanical damage caused by another trade, summon site management to convene the contractors at fault.

When technical dialogue breaks down and execution by substitute performance is threatened, art. 367 CO governs examination of the work and notice of defects. The waterproofing contractor may request the appointment of a court-appointed expert via an application for preservation of evidence prior to any major intervention on the roof. Under the regime of standard SIA 118, the limitation period of the client's rights for defects in building construction remains subject to art. 371 CO. Carrying out temporary sealing under express reservation of liability protects the building while ruling out any implicit admission of liability for consequential damage.

Frequently asked questions

Who pays for the cost of leak detection if the waterproofing membrane is not defective?

When technical investigations demonstrate that water ingress stems from a third-party element, such as a joinery junction or a puncture by another trade, diagnostic costs fall upon the client or the party responsible for the damage. The waterproofing contractor invoices for their detection, opening and temporary resealing services at agreed daywork rates, provided that they formulated prior written reservations before commencing destructive openings on the build-up.

Does applying a temporary patch over an infiltration amount to an admission of liability by the waterproofing contractor?

No, emergency safety measures constitute a protective obligation aimed at mitigating the aggravation of damage inside the building. To avoid any legal ambiguity, the waterproofing contractor must record on the work order or daily site report that the installation of the temporary membrane is performed "strictly as a protective measure and without admission of liability". This formal note fully preserves the company's rights during any subsequent joint expert assessment of the roof.

How should one react if site management refuses to sign the infiltration inspection report?

If the architect or the client refuses to sign the joint document, record this refusal expressly on the sheet with the date and time. Then issue the unilateral minutes accompanied by detailed photographs on the same day by registered post or secure email. This notification demonstrates the diligence of the waterproofing contractor, freezes the condition of the build-up at that exact moment and formally triggers the duty of coordination incumbent on site management.

What is the period for notice of defects during the two-year warranty period under standard SIA 118?

During the two-year notice period provided for by standard SIA 118, the client may report identified defects at any time, without being bound by the ordinary law requirement of immediate notice. However, in the event of active infiltration liable to damage thermal insulation or interior finishes, the client has a duty to mitigate loss and must notify the waterproofing contractor without undue delay to allow prompt implementation of safety measures.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 118General conditions for construction work
  • CO art. 367after delivery, the client examines the condition of the work as soon as they can and notifies defects to the contractor; for an immovable work, they have 60 days to notify them and a shorter contractual period is void (para. 1bis, in force since 1 January 2026); each party may request an examination by experts (para. 2).
  • CO art. 371limitation period of the client's rights on account of defects: two years from acceptance of the work (para. 1); five years for defects in an immovable work against the contractor, the architect or the engineer (para. 2) and for defects in a movable work integrated into an immovable work (para. 1); the five-year period cannot be amended to the detriment of the client (para. 3).

In the same section