Key takeaways
- Standard SIA 271 prescribes a standard upstand or a drainage channel when thresholds are lowered.
- The drainage channel in front of the joinery prevents run-off water accumulation and backflow into the interior.
- The channel grating must imperatively remain removable to allow periodic cleaning by the client.
- Handing over written maintenance instructions protects the flat roofer against unjustified claims in the event of overflow.
Lowering the upstand at door openings: requirements and derogations of standard SIA 271
On a trafficable flat roof, the transition between indoor and outdoor areas represents the most critical zone for building waterproofing. Standard SIA 271 establishes the principle of a minimum water clearance: the waterproofing upstand must rise at least 120 mm above the finished wearing course. This height effectively protects the structure against water backflow during severe storms, snowmelt, and driving rain splashes. However, accessibility mandates without architectural barriers frequently demand level thresholds or upstands of less than 20 mm. This reduction removes traditional physical safety and exposes the junction to immediate hydrostatic head during any sustained rainfall event.
To authorise this derogating design, standard SIA 271 makes lowering the upstand conditional upon mandatory compensatory measures. The flat roofer cannot simply apply a bonded bituminous upstand against the door frame. They must execute a completely continuous sub-threshold junction, preferably carried out in polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) reinforced liquid resin, fitting closely around the complex subframe profiles without vulnerable seams. Where possible, the facade should feature a protective roof overhang, and the structural work must slope away from the opening. Without a dedicated collection channel providing an immediate break in the water layer, this reduced threshold exposes the building to a major flood risk.
| Configuration | Water clearance | Required system |
|---|---|---|
| Standard threshold without drainage channel | 120 mm above paving | Bituminous or synthetic upstand fixed under profile with flashing |
| Raised intermediate threshold | 60 mm above wearing course | Perforated drainage channel discharging into the filter layer |
| Accessible level threshold | 0 to 20 mm at finished level | Drainage channel with removable grating and liquid resin under frame |
The drainage channel: technical design and the duty to inform regarding maintenance
The drainage channel constitutes the essential mechanical component to compensate for the absence of a vertical upstand. Positioned directly against the bottom rail of the joinery, it intercepts surface run-off and neutralises the kinetic energy of water sheets before they strike the French window seals. This channel does not serve as general drainage for the terrace, but acts as a dynamic water break. Fabricated from stainless steel or corrosion-resistant aluminium, its profile must provide suitable retention capacity and include calibrated perforations in the base and sides. These openings ensure rapid water discharge into the underlying drainage layer or towards a direct rainwater connection, preventing any head of water against the threshold.
- Preparation and liquid waterproofing beneath the frameThoroughly clean the concrete slab edge and degrease the lower profile. Apply a liquid waterproofing system of resin reinforced with a synthetic fleece, turning up at least 50 mm beneath the drip ledge to ensure seamless continuity without mechanical joints.
- Packing and alignment of the channel bodyPlace the perforated channel on the draining screed layer or on pedestals while respecting the threshold elevation. Maintain a 5 mm expansion joint against the joinery to absorb movement without shearing the resin.
- Installation of the removable open gratingFit the grating flush with the terrace slabs or timber decking boards. Check stability under pedestrian traffic and prohibit any mechanical fixings that would prevent its manual removal during maintenance operations.
The effectiveness of the installation relies strictly on regular maintenance. A channel choked with fallen leaves, sediment, or moss loses all discharge capacity and turns the threshold into a flooded low point during a violent storm. In accordance with trade standards and the contractual principles of standard SIA 118, the flat roofer must formalise this technical dependency by delivering a detailed operating and maintenance manual to the client at handover. This document reiterates the requirement for a twice-yearly visual inspection and thorough flushing of collection channels. If a defect occurs following clogging due to lack of maintenance, art. 369 CO excludes the client's rights in respect of defects where the defective execution is personally attributable to them. Proof of this written notice protects the flat roofer against abusive claims.
Junction on profile and stability of the threshold channel
The junction between the flat roof waterproofing system and the French window frame is the most critical operation of a level threshold installation. The flat roofer applies a liquid applied waterproofing system (liquid resin) based on polyurethane or methacrylate (PMMA) resins, reinforced with a calibrated synthetic non-woven fleece. Bituminous sheets create unacceptable extra thickness around ironmongery and built-in profile drainage paths. Reinforced resin, conversely, moulds with precision to the geometry of prefabricated corner pieces and metal frames. The substrate is degreased, abraded by sanding, and prepared with a primer compatible with the joinery (powder-coated aluminium, PVC, or stainless steel). The liquid flashing turns up against the frame to form a continuous upstand trough, located strictly beneath the metal drip ledge.
The bed of the drainage channel requires absolute rigidity to prevent any tipping under foot traffic. No mechanical fixings must perforate the waterproofing membrane on the underside. The channel rests on adjustable pedestals fitted with elastomeric acoustic pads, or on a drainage mortar bed laid over a synthetic protection layer. A 5 mm lateral clearance against the threshold accommodates thermal expansion without shearing the resin. The top edge of the grating is set flush with the internal floor level, with a negative tolerance of 2 to 3 mm towards the exterior to guarantee barrier-free accessibility without an upstand ledge.
| Collection device | Hydraulic capacity | Setting-out constraints | Removability and maintenance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stainless steel grating channel (150 mm width) | Very high: instantly absorbs splashback water | Installation on pedestals or filter bed with level adjustment screws | Excellent: hand-liftable gratings without specific tools |
| Narrow linear slot channel | Moderate: risk of choking during storm rainfall | Strict geometric alignment with paving joints | Demanding: requires removable rodding points at the ends |
| Built-in perforated channel | Combined: direct drainage and infiltration into the drainage layer | Specific recess within the thermal insulation layer | Regular: clipped gratings requiring a removal hook |
Maintenance protocol and prevention of operational disputes
Lowering the waterproofing upstand below the dimensions of standard SIA 271 modifies the safety balance of the flat roof. Building protection no longer relies on a raised waterproof barrier, but on the continuous intake capacity of the channel and its discharge outlet. As soon as fallen leaves, moss, or sediment clog the grating slots, water builds up against the window rebate seals. Because external joinery cannot withstand continuous hydrostatic head, water inevitably penetrates into internal finishes. Handing over the works without maintenance instructions exposes the contractor to immediate disputes at the first autumn storm.
- Formal submission of the maintenance manual to the as-built documentationThe flat roofer sets out maintenance requirements in writing within the documents handed over to the site management, specifying the obligation of bi-annual rodding before winter and after spring thaw.
- Visual inspection and lifting of protective gratingsManually lift each grating unit to inspect the alignment of edge trims and confirm that no deformation obstructs rainwater flow to the base of the channel.
- Manual clearing of solid deposits and gritRemove silt, sand, and organic debris using a synthetic scraper. The use of sharp or pointed metal tools is strictly prohibited to avoid puncturing the membrane or flexible flashing.
- Flow test and inspection of outletsFlush with generous clean water to verify there is no blockage and ensure that the discharge flows freely towards the drainage layer or rainwater downpipe without back-surging under the door.
The durability of an accessible threshold compliant with standard SIA 271 expectations thus relies on strict coordination between the various trade packages and the final building owner. A flat roofer who documents their junction precisely and provides written instructions for channel maintenance safeguards against unjustified liability claims during water ingress caused by neglected operation.
Water ingress disputes at thresholds: investigation protocol and traceability
The appearance of moisture at the base of glazed doors represents the most frequent defect on accessible flat roofs. When water penetrates beneath the frame or bypasses the waterproofing seal, the flat roofer is systematically held suspect first. Faced with this situation, the site foreman or site manager must adopt a methodical approach to investigation before conceding any defect in the bituminous or synthetic waterproofing build-up.
- Immediate inspection of channel conditionRemove the edge grating without disturbing the sediment. Photograph the accumulation level in the channel trough, any presence of gravel, fallen leaves, or silt choking the drainage slots, as well as the obstruction state of drainage pipes.
- Inspection of waterproofing upstand dimensionsMeasure the actual remaining height of the upstand against the edge profile or under the bottom rail of the frame. Compare this dimension with approved construction drawings and record any deviations from the prescriptions of standard SIA 271.
- Verification of water path routesDistinguish between water ingress caused by direct channel overflow and ingress originating from the joinery (clogged weep holes in the sash, failing mitre joints, or unsealed holes from frame fixing brackets).
If the design required a flush threshold without sufficient recess to accommodate the reduced upstand specified by standard SIA 271, and this deficiency was the subject of a notice of suspension or written reservations, the contractor may invoke art. 365 CO. Under art. 365 CO, if the material supplied by the client or the site designated by them is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor shall immediately inform the client. In the absence of a removable channel in front of a flush French window, the expert appraisal report will confirm the inadequacy of the design overseen by the site management.
Frequently asked questions
What minimum upstand height does standard SIA 271 require without a drainage channel?
Without a dedicated drainage channel, standard SIA 271 requires a waterproofing upstand extending 120 millimetres above the finished protective or wearing course of the terrace. This water clearance prevents surface run-off and accumulations of driving snow from entering the external joinery during severe weather.
Under what conditions may the waterproofing upstand be reduced at a French window opening?
Lowering the upstand below the customary 120 millimetres requires the installation of a draining channel in front of the threshold, fitted with a removable grating. Collected water must drain without obstruction, the roof overhang must reduce direct exposure to weather, and the waterproofing junction under the profile must remain completely continuous.
Who is responsible for the supply and installation of the threshold channel on a terrace?
The supply and installation of the channel depend on the contract specifications. They are frequently assigned to the flat roofer to ensure direct connection to the waterproofing sheet, but may fall under the metalworker or the paving contractor. The precise interface between trades must be coordinated from the tender phase.
What duty to inform applies to the flat roofer regarding the maintenance of a level threshold?
The flat roofer must set out operating requirements in writing in the maintenance instructions submitted to the client. They must detail the need to clean gratings, empty silt from the channel before winter, and inspect the permeability of drainage slots, to prevent water overflowing into the interior.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 271Flat roofs: requirements for waterproofing upstands, door thresholds, and compensatory measures
- CO art. 365Material and site: duty to inform the client immediately if any circumstance compromises the proper execution of the work (para. 3)
