Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 226Upstands and special detailingChapter 7 of 10 in the section

Securing equipment to a waterproofed roof: ballasted blocks or sealed penetrations

This chapter details the technical criteria for choosing between ballasted blocks and through-brackets on a waterproofed flat roof. You will learn how to design for the impact of wind loads on insulation build-ups, apply the detailing procedure for a special junction, and establish legal liability when working on the waterproofing membrane.

Key takeaways

  • The ballasted block avoids any perforation but transfers the overturning force onto the underlying thermal insulation.
  • The through-bracket anchored into the structural work resolves high wind loads without crushing the build-up.
  • Every waterproofing penetration requires a rigid upstand and a welded upstand flashing according to trade best practice.
  • Prior written agreement defines the installer's liability before any perforation of the membrane.

Choosing between a freestanding ballasted block and a mechanical through-bracket

Installing technical equipment on a flat roof — ventilation units, heat pump frames, guardrails or telecommunication antennas — requires choosing between two opposing physical principles: gravity stabilisation using a penetration-free ballasted block or rigid connection via a through-bracket anchored into the reinforced concrete load-bearing slab.

The freestanding system relies on precast concrete blocks or metal trays ballasted with gravel or slabs. Its decisive advantage lies in the complete absence of perforation of the waterproofing build-up. This solution is suitable for elements with low wind exposure or a distributed footprint, such as cable trays, small-diameter ducts or freestanding counterweighted guardrails. However, overall stability depends directly on friction and the compressive strength of the underlying thermal insulation.

Whenever the wind load on the equipment generates uplift or overturning forces incompatible with the load-bearing capacity of the roof, a metal through-bracket becomes unavoidable. Anchored directly into the load-bearing structure using anchor bolts or chemically bonded threaded rods, it transfers all dynamic forces to the structural work without stressing the insulation.

Comparison criteria between ballasted systems and through-anchors
Technical criterionSystem on ballasted blocksAnchored through-bracket
Perforation of the membraneNone (continuity preserved)Mandatory (creation of a special junction)
Resistance to wind forcesLimited by weight and frictionExcellent (direct transfer into the concrete)
Impact on insulationRisk of mechanical punchingPoint thermal bridge to be addressed
Maintenance and relocationStraightforward dismantling or shiftingFixed and permanent location
Clear height beneath equipmentLow (often < 15 cm)Adjustable (allows roof maintenance)

Wind load design must comply with standard SIA 261, taking into account the site wind zone, the height of the building above ground, the roughness category, and the immediate proximity of parapets, which are zones where turbulence generates particularly destructive suction forces.

Sealed penetration protocol and contractual transfer of liability

Penetrating an in-service waterproofing system is one of the main causes of disputes on Swiss flat roofs. A mechanical through-fixing never simply consists of driving an anchor plug through the waterproofing with a surface silicone bead: this non-compliant practice inevitably causes direct water ingress into the thermal insulation build-up.

Penetration sealed by the roofer
A localized detail consisting of a rigid metal upstand curb or a steel tube sleeve welded to an anchor plate, around which the waterproofing membrane is turned up vertically, fully adhered by welding, and capped with a weather cowl compliant with standard SIA 271.

When a bracket is required, trade best practice dictates anchoring the metal base plate directly to the load-bearing substrate before applying the waterproofing, or fixing a raised reinforced concrete plinth. The sleeve or vertical post must project at least 150 mm above the upper protective layer (gravel, paving slabs, or green roof substrate) to guarantee the statutory upstand flashing height according to standard SIA 271. The roofer then dresses this tube with a prefabricated collar or compatible sealing sleeves, heat-welded to the field sheet.

  1. Technical coordination and upstandExact location of the penetration on plans, sign-off of the point load by the structural engineer, and careful clearance of the protective gravel.
  2. Anchoring the structureDrilling of the concrete substrate by the metalworker or HVAC installer, mechanical or chemical bonding of the threaded rod, and tightening of the metal bracket.
  3. Execution of the watertight connectionApplication by the roofer of a fully bonded bituminous or synthetic flashing skirt, turned up onto the vertical pipe with a stainless steel clamp and suitable sealing mastic.
  4. Installation of the protective counter-flashingInstallation of a metal flashing collar with a drip edge deflecting external runoff water.

From a legal and contractual perspective, art. 365 CO al. 3 requires the contractor to inform the client immediately if any circumstance jeopardises the proper execution of the work. An electrical installer, metalworker, or HVAC technician must under no circumstances perforate the waterproofing membrane on their own initiative. A prior agreement before any drilling must be formalised with the site management and the contracted roofer.

Wind behaviour and installation of penetration-free ballasted blocks

The installation of technical equipment on a flat roof requires a rigorous analysis of aerodynamic loads. Whether it involves a chiller unit, a folding maintenance guardrail, or an antenna, the wind load on the equipment generates drag forces, uplift from suction, and overturning moments. In the penetration-free ballasted block technique, stability relies exclusively on the dead weight of the system and the friction coefficient exerted on the waterproofing build-up. This principle avoids any breach of the waterproofing membrane, directly eliminating the risks of water ingress at fixing points.

Ballast sizing must be determined using structural calculation notes compliant with actions on structures, incorporating the site's wind zone, building height above ground, and the equipment's location relative to edges and parapets. Roof edges and corners experience strong vortex suction, requiring significantly higher ballast masses than those needed in the central roof area. This accumulated weight must strictly remain compatible with the permissible live load of the roof slab and the compressive strength of the underlying thermal insulation.

Equipment behaviour depending on the installation system on a waterproofed roof
Type of equipmentDominant aerodynamic forceSuitable fixing solutionWaterproofing interface precautions
Freestanding perimeter guardrailHorizontal thrust and overturningFootplates ballasted with concrete counterweightsDe-bonding mat beneath footplates, placed outside water ponding zones
Heat pump or air conditioning unitLateral drag and dynamic vibrationsSteel frame on concrete blocks or resilient padsRot-proof vibration-damping elastomer pad, load-distribution packer
Antenna mast or satellite dishHigh overturning moment and pull-outMechanical penetration anchored to the structureRigid sleeve with base plate fully sealed to the membrane and collar
Technical walkway or maintenance pathHorizontal slippage under high windsConcrete slabs placed on distribution pedestalsHeavy synthetic protection layer avoiding local surface repair

Sealed penetration via bracket and prior agreement before any drilling

When the magnitude of uplift forces precludes the use of ballast or the load-bearing capacity of the slab is exhausted, direct mechanical fixing into the framework becomes necessary. The penetration sealed by the roofer is then the only durable method for anchoring brackets, steel support frames, or duct stands. The technical trade installs a sleeve, a structural hollow section, or a bracket secured to the structural work. The roofer intervenes to connect the membrane to this penetration using a waterproofing flange plate, extended by a welded or vulcanised sleeve extending above the finished roof level.

Detailing the penetration requires a strict execution sequence: the base plate is adhered or welded onto the insulation build-up, then bonded to the field membrane with a double weld. The vertical post of the bracket receives a waterproof upstand flashing sealed with a stainless steel clamping band and a bead of elastomeric mastic, topped with a protective weather cowl against direct rainwater runoff. For non-circular or complex cross-sections, the application of liquid synthetic resin reinforced with a non-woven fleece ensures continuous waterproofing over sharp edges.

The integrity of the roof requires prior agreement before any drilling. No plumbing installer, electrician, metalworker, or refrigeration technician is permitted to perforate the waterproofing on their own initiative to secure an anchor plug or anchor bolt. According to art. 97 CO, the debtor is obliged to compensate for the damage unless they prove that no fault is attributable to them. Any uncoordinated perforation voids the warranty of the work and engages the direct liability of the executing company for consequential water damage. Site management must record the location of penetrations in writing, which must strictly be waterproofed and formally signed off by the roofer prior to any electrical energisation or plant installation.

Dispute management: unauthorised drilling, water ingress, and joint inspection record

Discovering an uncoordinated penetration on the roof executed without the roofer's knowledge constitutes an operational emergency. When a plumbing installer, metalworker, or antenna specialist plugs directly through the waterproofing, or when a ballasted block frame shifts in a gust due to a lack of wind load calculations, the build-up is perforated and the insulation build-up becomes waterlogged. Under art. 365 CO, if any circumstance jeopardises the proper execution of the work, the contractor informs the client. The waterproofing foreman must immediately document the non-conformity to protect their company's rights.

  1. Immediate stoppage and joint inspection recordAs soon as an unauthorised fixing is identified, suspend all work in that area. Photograph the anchorage from multiple angles, the equipment markings, the crushed insulation thickness, and the absence of a sealing collar. Immediately summon site management and the responsible company to draw up a joint inspection record.
  2. Emergency remedial measuresApply a temporary welded bridging strip or compatible mastic over the mechanical perforation to block any immediate water pathway into the slab. This protective measure must be notified in writing as temporary and under no circumstances constitutes compliant remedial work.
  3. Formal notice and rectification orderSite management instructs the defaulting third party to cover the financial cost of repairs. The primary roofing contractor issues a formal reservation releasing their warranty for the entire affected area until complete, signed-off rectification.
  4. Remediation according to trade best practiceRemove the disputed equipment. Open up the build-up down to the vapour barrier to inspect the moisture level of the insulation. Replace wet boards, install a bracket with a base plate anchored to the concrete, then weld a two-layer waterproofing sleeve complete with a clamping collar and sealing mastic.

In the event of verified water ingress resulting from the displacement of a block or unlawful drilling, the client can exercise the rights provided by the Code of Obligations (CO), notably under CO which governs the client's rights in the event of defects in the work: refusal, price reduction, rectification, damages. The costs of tracer-gas leak detection, technical drying, and replacement of degraded materials fall entirely upon the contractor who penetrated the membrane without prior agreement.

Frequently asked questions

Who is liable if a subcontractor pierces the waterproofing to fix a cable tray?

The company that performs the drilling incurs direct civil liability for the damage caused. The contracted roofer is released from their warranty over the damaged area once they report the penetration in writing to site management. Only the company that drilled into the build-up bears the costs of core sampling, drying of the thermal insulation, and remediation by the roofer.

How do you stabilise a freestanding guardrail if the roof load capacity is reached?

If structural calculations prohibit adding concrete ballast slabs to comply with the slab's load-bearing capacity, the freestanding system becomes inapplicable. One must then switch to mechanical fixing using through-brackets anchored into the concrete structural work. This alternative requires prior technical agreement, approval from the structural engineer, and the execution of compliant welded upstand flashings with collars.

What clearance must be maintained between the bottom of bracket-mounted technical equipment and the waterproofing?

The minimum clearance required under the frame of a machine or pipework must allow for torch operation, joint inspection, and future maintenance of the build-up. A clear gap of at least 15 to 20 centimetres is provided between the finished surface of the waterproofing and the base of the unit. Without this height, the roofer cannot guarantee the connection of the sleeve.

Can ballasted blocks be placed directly on a bare waterproofing membrane?

No. Direct contact between a concrete block or metal foot and the waterproofing is strictly prohibited. Mechanical shear, equipment vibrations, and wind-induced micro-movements will punch through the waterproofing. It is mandatory to insert a heavy-grade rot-proof protective fleece or vulcanised rubber crumb load-distribution pads to protect the membrane.

Texts and standards cited

  • CO art. 365materials and site: the contractor is liable for the sound quality of the materials they supply; if materials supplied by the client or the building site designated by the client are found to be defective, or if any other circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor shall immediately inform the client, failing which they shall bear the consequences (al. 3).
  • COclient's rights in the event of defects in the work: refusal, reduction in price, rectification, damages; any clause agreed in advance that limits or excludes the right to rectification of defects is null and void if the defect relates to an immovable structure (al. 2bis, since 1 January 2026).

In the same section