Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 283Glued, floating or nailed installationChapter 1 of 10 in the section

Glued, floating or nailed: substrate, acoustics, underfloor heating and foot feel

This chapter guides you through the technical trade-off between glued, floating or nailed installation. You will learn to compare the nature of the existing substrate with the thermal constraints of an underfloor heating system. You will know how to precisely evaluate the acoustic impact and mechanical foot feel to guide the construction direction towards the installation method adapted to the requirements of the work.

Key takeaways

  • The nature of the substrate determines the technical admissibility of full-surface bonding or nailing onto battens.
  • The SIA 253 standard requires strict control of the substrate's residual moisture before any direct bonding.
  • Glued parquet eliminates ambient resonance and optimises the thermal transfer of underfloor heating.
  • Floating installation requires an intermediate underlay whose acoustic resilience significantly alters walking comfort.

Substrate compatibility and thermal transfer according to the SIA 253 standard

Choosing a parquet fixing method is never just a simple comparison of hourly rates or construction site progress rates. The initial trade-off depends first on the geometry, rigidity and composition of the receiving substrate. According to the SIA 253 standard, the parquet layer must check the conformity of the laying base before any intervention: surface flatness, surface cohesion, cleanliness and residual moisture. A cement screed or a calcium sulphate-based fluid screed (anhydrite) does not impose the same installation constraints as an old floor on timber joists or a wood-based panel nailed to joists.

Admissibility matrix for installation methods according to substrate and heating
Receiving substrateFull-surface glued installationFloating installation (tongue-and-groove / click)Nailed installation on battens
Unbonded cement screedOptimal (direct adhesion after sanding and vacuuming)Possible (requires continuous vapour barrier and underlay)Excluded (unless battens are mechanically fixed into the concrete)
Anhydrite fluid screedExcellent (requires laitance removal by sanding and primer)Possible (mandatory PE vapour barrier)Not recommended (drilling fixings risks breaking the bed)
Screed with integrated underfloor heatingRecommended (minimum thermal resistance, direct contact)Admitted with reservation (special low thermal resistance underlay)Strictly prohibited (risk of perforating the coil)
Existing timber floor / joist systemConditional (on screwed OSB / particle boards)Possible (prior check of differential deflections)Historical and recommended (solid boards nailed perpendicularly)

The thickness and composition of the board play a direct role in the balance. A multilayer parquet with a noble wear layer perfectly withstands the shear stresses imposed by gluing onto a heated screed, because its cross-layers compensate for tangential shrinkage. A thick solid parquet will experience more severe hygrometric gradients: if glued down, its board width must remain proportional to its thickness to prevent any screed detachment resulting from internal cracking of the mineral substrate.

Impact acoustics and walking sound: trading off perceived comfort

The acoustic behaviour of a wooden floor is analysed from two distinct angles that are frequently confused on construction sites: the transmission of impact noise to adjacent or lower rooms (impact noise) and sound emission inside the room of use itself (resonance noise or walking sound). The installation method is the predominant parameter for this differentiation, radically influencing the physical perception of rigidity under the user's foot.

Impact noise versus walking sound
Impact noise corresponds to the vibrational energy transmitted through the floor slab to the floors below when an object falls or a heel strikes. Walking sound represents the acoustic radiation reflected back into the room by the vibration of the parquet board during a stride.

In a floating installation, the complete decoupling of the parquet from the screed ensures, thanks to a resilient polyolefin foam or cork underlay, very effective attenuation of impact noises directed towards the neighbouring flat. In return, the thin residual air gap beneath the floor creates a resonance box phenomenon. Each step produces a dry, hollow thud, often perceived by the client as a lack of solid material or poor seating. In addition, the elastic deformation under load generates micro-pumping at the end joints.

Full-surface glued installation closely bonds the wood to the mass of the mineral screed. This mass slows down the oscillation of the boards: the walking sound becomes deadened, muffled, compact, giving the step an immediate impression of heaviness and monolithic solidity. However, the impact sound insulation performance then relies entirely on the decoupling quality of the underlying floating screed. If the cement or anhydrite screed has acoustic bridges at the periphery, the vibrations generated by the heel will propagate throughout the building's load-bearing structure.

Nailed installation on battens offers an incomparable physical sensation sought after by heritage restoration enthusiasts. The natural elasticity of the framing and skewed nails provides progressive cushioning that is very gentle on the joints, impossible to reproduce on a rigid mineral substrate. The sound produced when walking is deep, muffled, sometimes accompanied by the discreet creaking of wood-on-metal or wood-on-wood friction linked to seasonal dimensional variations of the solid wood.

Comparative decision table for choosing the installation method

The choice of implementation is not just a calculation of cost or installation speed. For the parquet layer, the trade-off involves physical compatibility with the substrate, thermal transfer on underfloor heating and the acoustic requirements of the SIA 181 standard. Nailed installation requires a significant installation height for the battens, which excludes it from modern thin slabs without a recess. Floating installation avoids surface uplift constraints but creates a resonance box in the room without a dense underlay. Full-surface glued installation remains the benchmark for thermal efficiency and the stability of large formats, provided the screed is prepared according to the SIA 253 standard.

Decision matrix according to substrate, acoustics and comfort of use
Decision criterionFull-surface glued installationClip-on or glued floating installationNailed installation on battens
Underfloor heating compatibilityOptimal: minimum thermal resistance, direct contact without air gap.Average: insulating air cushion; total thermal resistance to be limited according to the SIA 253 standard.Incompatible: the air cushion and battens block heat diffusion.
Admissible substrateCement or calcium sulphate screed, rigid panels; strict cohesion and flatness.Mineral screed, existing tiling, old stable parquet; tolerates heterogeneous substrates.Timber joists, battens on pedestals or resilient strips, technical raised floors.
Transmitted impact noise (SIA 181)Linked to the performance of the underlying floating screed.Excellent damping thanks to the inserted resilient underlay.Very low transmission if the battens rest on continuous insulation strips.
Walking sound (in the room)Muffled feel, dull impact sound, absence of resonance under the sole.Higher-pitched and reverberated sound (drum effect), hollow feel at the heel.Crisp solid parquet sound, no hollow resonance if solidly wedged.
Step feel and dynamicsRigid support, mineral solidity feel, no dynamic deflection.Slight flexibility underfoot, sometimes perceived as a flatness defect.Very comfortable natural mechanical elasticity, wood-on-battens dynamics.
Renovation and future sandingOptimal: boards do not vibrate under the sander, multiple sandings.Delicate: risk of bouncing under heavy machinery, wear layer often thin.Maximum: allows numerous planings on thick solid parquet.

This thermal threshold stipulated for underfloor heating explains why floating installation requires rigorous insulation selection. Residual air trapped between the screed and the board forms an unfavourable thermal barrier. Full-surface bonding eliminates any air cushion and directly transmits the calories emitted by the fluid or cement screed, guaranteeing a steady temperature rise without energy loss.

Foot feel, walking dynamics and site diagnosis

The behaviour of a parquet floor under pedestrian load determines the perceived quality of the work. In floating installation, mechanical compression of the resilient underlay causes micro-flexion of the joints underfoot. This dynamic movement, clearly noticeable at doorways and along walls, creates an air-pumping effect and amplifies airborne noise in the room. Conversely, full-surface gluing bonds the wood to the mass of the screed. The floor offers clear firmness, comparable to tiling, while retaining the contact warmth of wood. Nailed installation provides historical soft cushioning that relieves joints but requires millimeter-precise wedging to prevent metal-to-wood friction squeaks.

  1. Check the height clearanceMeasure the available recess under thresholds. A nailed installation requires 50 to 80 mm to incorporate the battens. Glued installation fits from 10 to 15 mm, compared to 9 to 16 mm for a standard floating installation.
  2. Check substrate cohesionPerform the scratch test on the mineral screed. Gluing requires surface cohesion compliant with SIA 253 standard tolerances. A chalky or unstable screed requires either a floating installation or mechanical reinforcement.
  3. Measure flatness under the straightedgeCheck tolerances with the two-metre straightedge. Point-specific hollows rule out floating installation, which would make the joints bend. In glued installation, prior smoothing compound restores the intimate contact of the adhesive bed.
  4. Consult the reference moisture logDemand the carbide residual moisture measurement report (CM method) before any intervention. The admissibility thresholds of the SIA 253 standard apply to all methods to prevent trapping moisture under the wood.

Management of non-conformities and trade-offs during construction work

When the dynamic behaviour, sound or adhesion of the parquet do not meet the client's expectations, the parquet layer must isolate the physical cause before considering remedial work. On underfloor heating or an anhydrite screed, a hollow under a glued board or a clicking sound under a floating parquet often indicates an interface defect rather than a wood flaw. According to the SIA 253 standard, substrate flatness and surface cohesion directly condition the stability of the assembly. In the event of a dispute over acoustic comfort or step flexibility, destructive measurements must be limited to what is strictly necessary.

  1. Joint inspection record of tolerancesPlace the two-metre straightedge and tapered gauge on the incriminated area to check if the deflection exceeds the tolerances of the SIA 253 standard. Check the peripheral clearance against walls and door frames to rule out any blocked expansion stress.
  2. Non-destructive testing of the interfaceCarry out a sounding test with a wood or nylon mallet to map adhesion defects in glued installations. For nailed parquet on battens, check the mechanical fixing and the absence of rigid contact with the masonry, which would create an acoustic bridge.
  3. Targeted treatment without full dismantlingFor localized detachment in glued installation, inject fluid epoxy or polyurethane resin through a discreet hole the diameter of a wooden dowel. For bouncing floating parquet, check whether a heavy load is immobilizing the membrane and causing localized bending.

If the substrate proves powdery or if the screed exhibits through-cracking not reported during the prior inspection, responsibility for the defects lies with construction site coordination. Work must be interrupted as soon as a cohesion failure is detected to preserve the parties' rights under the Code of Obligations, without undertaking makeshift repairs that would mask the origin of the damage.

Frequently asked questions

Is a nailed parquet floor that squeaks after heating is commissioned an execution defect?

Not necessarily. In traditional nailed installation, the wood undergoes winter hygrothermal shrinkage due to the drop in ambient air relative humidity. Friction between tongues, grooves and nails can generate localized squeaks. If the parquet layer respected peripheral clearances and regular batten spacing in accordance with trade practice, this seasonal phenomenon stems from the living nature of the material and not a technical defect.

Why is a spring effect felt under engineered parquet installed as a floating floor?

This elastic bounce results from crushing of the resilient underlay combined with imperfect substrate flatness. If the screed has hollows under the two-metre straightedge, the floor floats above the void before touching the ground under the weight of the walking person. An underlay film that is too thick or too compressible accentuates this unpleasant sensation without improving the acoustic attenuation performance sought by the client.

Can an acoustic bridge be corrected in a glued installation without tearing up the parquet?

No. If a rigid adhesive or run has filled the peripheral decoupling joint against partitions or around radiator pipes, vibrational energy is transmitted directly to the building structure. The only solution is to remove the skirting boards, then rout the edge of the parquet using a guided plunge saw to re-establish a gap clear of any rigid contact, in accordance with sound insulation rules.

How should one react if the client demands a floating installation on low-temperature underfloor heating?

A written warning should be formalized. Although technically feasible with a very low thermal resistance underlay, floating installation creates an air gap that considerably slows heat flow and impairs system efficiency. The parquet layer must recommend full-surface gluing, which optimizes heat transfer and eliminates the dull impact noise specific to floating systems on underfloor heating.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 253Resilient floor coverings, textiles and parquet: flatness tolerances, substrate criteria and fixing methods
  • CORules governing the works contract, the contractor's obligations and the management of notices of defects

In the same section