Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 283Glued, floating or nailed installationChapter 8 of 10 in the section

Sorting boards: selection grade, knots, sapwood, and the sample setting expectations

This chapter teaches you to rigorously qualify parquet appearance grades according to standard SIA 253. You will learn to identify permissible singularities such as knots or sapwood, lock in the client's agreement on a representative signed sample prior to ordering, and organise the methodical sorting of packages on the construction site to prevent any aesthetic disputes.

Key takeaways

  • The visual conformity of parquet is assessed according to the appearance grades defined by standard SIA 253.
  • A contractual sample validated by signature commits the parties to the actual heterogeneity of the delivered wood.
  • The parquet installer must mix the packages and sort out singular boards before applying the adhesive.
  • Coloured or unpermitted sapwood requires immediate downgrading or reallocation to peripheral cuts.

Qualifying appearance grades and identifying wood singularities according to standard SIA 253

The installation of a wooden floor begins with the visual inspection of delivered packages. In parquet flooring, the most frequent dispute concerns the discrepancy between the appearance expected by the client and the reality of the natural material installed. Standard SIA 253 governs the requirements applicable to wooden floor coverings and refers to standardised appearance classifications. Wood cannot be judged defective based solely on its biological variability: the presence of sound knots, filled black knots or torn grain falls under the contractual choice agreed upon at the time of ordering.

Coloured sapwood
Peripheral zone of the trunk, biologically younger and softer than the heartwood, displaying marked chromatic variations tending towards grey or pale brown, often rejected in superior grades but tolerated according to technical classes.
Common appearance classification for oak according to professional requirements
Appearance gradeSound adhering knotsFilled or black knotsSapwoodShade variations
Elite / Triangle GradeSmall pin knots permitted up to 2 mmExcluded or invisibleStrictly excluded on the wear layerVery slight and harmonious
Nature / Round GradeAdmitted up to 15 mm without open cracksTolerated up to 5 mm if factory-filledMinimal traces tolerated at the edgeModerate natural grain contrasts
Rustic / Square GradeAdmitted without strict diameter limitationFilled cracks and open knots admittedSound sapwood admitted without limitationStrong variations and heart marks

The distinction between sound sapwood and altered sapwood remains fundamental for the durability of the flooring. While sound sapwood retains its mechanical cohesion despite its low density, stained or decayed sapwood compromises the structural integrity of the work and leads to the rejection of the batch. Regarding knots, the team leader checks the adhesion of the material and the quality of the filling binder. Hot-melt filler or shrunk wood putty forming a cavity of more than one millisecond constitutes a machining defect, independently of the rusticity stipulated in the contract.

Locking expectations with the contractual sample and mastering blending during installation

Conflict almost systematically arises when a client validates their project on a simple thirty-centimetre sample strip from a material library, then discovers forty square metres of boards grained with dark brown, peppered with star-shaped knots and bordered with light sapwood. To defuse the risk of dispute, the company must have a representative control panel validated before placing the purchase order with the manufacturer. This sample must deliberately display the extreme cases of the selected grade.

  1. Signature of the reference sampleHave the back of the control panel initialled by the site management or the client, expressly noting the finish, the filling range and the variability interval.
  2. Delivery inspection and storageInspect package labels upon receipt to verify the correspondence of the sorting code and measure the moisture content of the wood before starting any unpacking.
  3. Systematic blending of packsOpen at least four to five packages simultaneously to mix the shades and distribute the singularities homogeneously across the entire surface of the room.
  4. Exclusion sorting and priming cutsSet aside boards containing excessively contrasted sapwood or atypical knots to integrate them in cuts under fixed furniture, in cupboards or along edges.

If the client disputes the appearance during execution, the construction site must come to a halt. According to finishing work customs and the Code of Obligations, a board glued or nailed to the floor is deemed accepted by the applicator and by the client attending the works. The installation halt protocol makes it possible to compare the installed parquet with the sealed contractual sample. If the discrepancy exceeds visual tolerances, the supplier is held liable; if the boards correspond to the validated reference sample, the requirement for more selective sorting becomes a negotiable extra.

Construction site sorting protocol and management of wood singularities

From the opening of packages on the construction site, the parquet installer assumes responsibility for the final appearance of the work. Laying a board technically amounts to accepting it. Methodical sorting prior to gluing constitutes the sole bulwark against subsequent aesthetic disputes. In accordance with the rules of the trade of standard SIA 253, the practitioner must simultaneously open at least four to five packs to mix the elements, assess chromatic variability, and check the conformity of the delivered industrial sorting with the order specifications.

Criteria for visual assessment of singularities according to standard SIA 253
Wood singularityFirst choice (select / clear)Intermediate choice (nature)Rustic / country choice
Sound and adhering knotsAdmitted if punctual (diameter less than 5 mm), without cracks.Admitted up to 20 to 25 mm depending on board width, small fillers tolerated.Admitted without strict diameter limitation, subject to stable filling.
Black or filled knotsGenerally excluded or residual (pinholes).Admitted in small sizes, factory-filled with matching shade.Admitted, filled black or dark brown, through-knots accepted if stabilised.
Sound sapwood (edge wood)Totally excluded on the visible face of hardwood species (oak).Tolerated as a discreet border on one edge, without exceeding a minimal fraction of the face.Admitted without restriction of proportion, forming marked light contrasts.
Coloured sapwood / fungal stainingFormally excluded.Excluded on the visible face; neutral mechanical coloration admitted.Tolerated according to supplier tolerances, without structural alteration of the wood.

Progressive sorting is not limited to isolating unacceptable defects. It organises visual distribution. A board exhibiting highly contrasted figuring, an imposing filled knot or a light sapwood zone must not end up juxtaposed with a similar board, otherwise creating a visual "spot" that immediately catches the eye under the grazing light of picture windows. Boards displaying the most distinct singularities are systematically reserved for dark areas, secondary corridors, the backs of cupboards or peripheral cuts along skirtings.

Prevention of aesthetic disputes: contractual sample and installation stop

Aesthetic disputes almost always arise from the gap between the client's idealized perception and the reality of a living material cut at the factory. A client who validates a quote mentioning "rustic oak" parquet often expects a warm floor with a few discreet knots, whereas the industrial standard for this category delivers filled cracks, split black knots and wide bands of contrasted sapwood. Once the adhesive has set, the client invokes a lack of conformity, whereas the contractor counters with compliance with the manufacturer's commercial designation.

To cut short any dispute, the formal validation of a representative sample before placing the supplier order is the only secure procedure. A simple 30 cm strip distributed by a merchant is incapable of expressing the actual dispersion of a rustic or country choice. The contractual sample must consist of a panel of at least 1 m² or several complete boards assembled dry, explicitly showing the accepted extremes: the largest knot, the darkest filler and the maximum proportion of allowable sapwood. This sample must be countersigned on the back by the site management and the client.

  1. Joint inspection of the first deliveryUpon delivery to the site, before any start of work, open two representative packages and directly compare the delivered boards with the countersigned sample under the final natural lighting of the rooms.
  2. Immediate stop in case of grade discrepancyIf the batch exhibits a density of knots, filler pockets or a proportion of sapwood non-compliant with the reference sample, interrupt the work. According to the Code of Obligations, the contractor who notices defective or non-compliant material must notify the client without delay.
  3. Establishment of an appearance reportDraft a formal notice recording the refusal to install the batch or, conversely, organise an on-site meeting to have the delivered batch validated in writing prior to any gluing. Never attempt to mitigate an undesired grade through selective sorting without a written agreement on material overconsumption.

Crisis management on site: appearance divergence and installation stop

Aesthetic disputes generally arise during the first half-day of work: the client discovers large-diameter filled knots or traces of coloured sapwood on their oak, whereas they envisioned a uniform and sleek floor. As soon as the first verbal reservation is formulated by the client or the site management, the team leader applies an absolute principle: the immediate stoppage of installation. Under the customs governed by standards SIA 253 and SIA 118, gluing or nailing a board technically equates to validating its visual conformity. Continuing work in the hope of blending the rustic elements into the mass engages the full liability of the parquet installer.

  1. Sealing of the reference panelBring the initialled contractual sample close before ordering and place it directly on the floor, in the centre of the room, under natural daylight. This sample serves as binding proof to assess the permitted variation range.
  2. Opening of a joint samplingOpen three to five closed packs in the presence of the site management. Lay out the boards dry without gluing them to objectively quantify the actual proportion of singularities in relation to the sorting criteria of standard SIA 253.
  3. Formal notification according to the Code of ObligationsDraft a formal notice recording the aesthetic disagreement. If the delivery does not correspond to the ordered grade, the notice of defects is transmitted to the supplier without delay. If the wood complies with the order but is rejected by the client, the work is suspended.

If the deadlock persists, two technical outcomes are negotiated in writing: either an addendum for the supply of a higher appearance grade with cost and schedule repercussions, or the relegation of the most contrasted boards to secondary areas, under furniture or in enclosed corridors.

Frequently asked questions

The client refuses the presence of sapwood in oak, what does the standard provide?

Standard SIA 253 refers to wood appearance classifications where sapwood tolerance strictly depends on the chosen grade. In rustic grade, sound sapwood is admitted without surface limitation, sometimes even with natural coloration. In first choice or select grade, sapwood is conversely strictly excluded or confined to very small percentages on the edges. The initial purchase order determines the applicable law.

What to do if the client contests the sorting when half of the room is glued?

Immediately interrupt the work. According to finishing work customs and standard SIA 118, glued boards are deemed accepted regarding their visible appearance at the time of execution. The parquet installer must not dismantle the installed surface without a written service order. A joint inspection on the remaining part should be organized and the dispute recorded in the site diary.

What minimum surface area must a sample cover to be contractually opposable?

A sample of a single board never protects the parquet installer against a dispute over singularities. To validly set expectations according to standard SIA 253, the control panel must measure at least one square metre and assemble at least six to eight boards. This surface area makes it possible to represent the actual amplitude of knots, fillers, grain deviations and sapwood.

Can the parquet installer be required to eliminate all cracked knots on a rustic grade?

No. In a rustic appearance class, sound knots, black knots and filled cracks form an integral part of the admitted characteristics of the material. As long as the factory or on-site filling is flush, stable and compatible with the surface treatment required by standard SIA 253, the client cannot demand the rejection of boards presenting these natural singularities without sorting compensation.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 253Wooden floor coverings (parquet): appearance requirements, moisture, storage and installation rules
  • SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction works: notice of defects, handover and dispute management

In the same section