Key takeaways
- Polygonal pattern crazing accompanied by white gel exudates is the primary visual sign.
- Standard SIA 269 governs the methodical investigation and serviceability assessment of existing structures.
- Petrographic analysis on thin-section core samples formally confirms the mineralogical reactivity of siliceous aggregates.
- Multi-year dimensional monitoring quantifies residual expansion and guides the selection of potential structural confinement.
Identify visual manifestations of alkali-aggregate reaction on the structure
On Swiss civil engineering structures (retaining walls, bridge piers, road tunnels), alkali-aggregate reaction (AAR) occurs when three factors coexist: an internal relative humidity exceeding 80%, a sufficient concentration of alkali ions (sodium and potassium) in the cement paste, and crushed or alluvial aggregates containing forms of reactive silica (opal, chalcedony, microcrystalline or strained quartz). The chemical reaction produces a hydrophilic alkali-silica gel that swells in the presence of water, exerting internal pressures capable of exceeding the tensile strength of the concrete.
| Observation criterion | Plastic or drying shrinkage | Alkali-aggregate reaction (AAR) |
|---|---|---|
| Network orientation | Straight cracks, often parallel or aligned with surface reinforcement | Multidirectional polygonal network (closed meshes of 50 to 200 mm) or cracking oriented by prestress |
| Time of appearance | A few hours to a few months after concreting | Several years or decades (commonly 10 to 25 years after commissioning) |
| Associated substances | Absence of gelatinous exudate; fine, dry calcium carbonate deposits | Viscous or hardened silica gel exudates, alteration halos around aggregates visible on broken surfaces |
| Evolution over time | Opening stabilised after complete drying of the concrete | Progressive and continuous opening as long as relative humidity remains high |
In highly compressed or prestressed elements (bridge decks, tie rods), swelling does not express itself in a polygonal pattern: cracks align parallel to the direction of the principal compressive stress. On site, the inspection must also check for indirect mechanical distress, such as jammed bearings, misaligned expansion joints, or spalling at edges in confined zones.
Deploy the investigation campaign and monitoring according to standard SIA 269
The diagnosis of a suspected structure cannot rely solely on visual inspection. It falls within the assessment procedure of standard SIA 269 (Basis for maintenance of structures) and standard SIA 269/2 (Concrete structures). The engineer and the contractor must quantify the current state of degradation, characterise the chemical mechanism, and measure the residual expansion potential to determine structural safety.
- Mapping survey and targeted core samplingLocate damp areas and map the cracking index. Take core samples with a minimum diameter of 100 mm (length 200 to 300 mm) by wet diamond coring, positioned outside zones of main reinforcement after preliminary detection by covermeter survey.
- Petrographic analysis in a specialised laboratoryPrepare fluorescent thin sections (thickness 20 to 30 micrometres) for examination under a polarising optical microscope. The analysis confirms the presence of microcracks running through reactive aggregates, the presence of dark or light reaction rims, and the impregnation of the cement matrix by alkali-silica gel.
- Measurement of residual swelling potentialPlace test specimens in an accelerated expansion chamber (controlled thermo-hygrometric conditions, for instance at 60 °C and 100% relative humidity). Recording length changes determines whether the reaction has exhausted its chemical potential or whether a volumetric thrust remains.
- Implementation of in situ dimensional monitoringInstall deformation measurement studs on the structure (mechanical extensometry using anchored balls, inductive sensors or strain gauges) and high-precision survey targets. Monitoring requires regular, thermally compensated readings over a multi-year cycle.
The technical measures required by standard SIA 269 consist primarily in cutting off external water ingress (refurbishment of waterproofing, abutment drainage, application of hydrophobic impregnations). When residual expansion threatens the stability of the element, structural strengthening measures such as external post-tensioning, confinement with additional prestressing, or through transverse tie rods are designed to mechanically arrest triaxial dilation.
Laboratory characterisation and internal expansion mechanisms
Formal confirmation of an alkali-aggregate reaction requires petrographic and microstructural investigations on cores taken from sound and deteriorated areas. Initial macroscopic examination reveals peripheral reaction halos around reactive siliceous aggregates, such as siliceous limestones, sandstones, or crushed quartzites, as well as interstitial voids filled with translucent or whitish alkali-silica gel. Thin-section petrographic analysis under a polarising microscope reveals intra-granular cracking, the network of microcracks traversing the hardened cement paste, and direct chemical alteration of unstable mineral phases.
- Thin-section petrographic analysis
- Microscopic examination of a concrete slice taken by coring, ground down to a thickness of approximately 30 micrometres, enabling mapping of the degradation of reactive aggregates, the width of microcracks, and the extent of hydrated silicate gel formation.
The destructive mechanism results from moisture uptake by the alkali-silica gel formed upon contact between the paste alkalis and the reactive silica. In the presence of liquid water or sustained internal relative humidity above 80%, this gel swells and generates internal hydraulic expansion pressures capable of exceeding the tensile strength of the concrete. Kinetics depend on moisture availability, average temperature, and the residual concentration of hydroxide ions in the pore solution.
Structural assessment, expansion monitoring, and remediation measures
Alkali-aggregate reaction does not systematically condemn a structure to demolition, but it induces progressive stress anisotropy and marked degradation of mechanical properties. The loss of secant modulus of elasticity substantially precedes the drop in axial compressive strength. According to standard SIA 269, the civil engineer must recalculate section load-bearing capacities by taking into account the internal tensile stresses imposed on passive reinforcement by the swelling of the concrete core, which risks reaching the yield strength of the steel.
| Degree of degradation | Physical manifestations | Consequence on the structure | Required operational measures |
|---|---|---|---|
| Initial to moderate | Fine surface crazing, faint halos around coarse aggregates | Drop in modulus of elasticity (10 to 30%), negligible settlement | Installation of crack telltales, annual moisture monitoring |
| Advanced | Cracks oriented along reinforcement, abundant whitish exudates | Loss of steel-to-concrete bond, overall elongation of the element | Three-dimensional extensometric monitoring, reduction of live loads |
| Severe | Local bursting, potential stirrup rupture, surface delamination | Loss of confinement, drastic decrease in shear capacity | Emergency propping, external confinement, or partial deconstruction |
- Installation of extensometric measurement basesInstallation of core-anchored studs or vibrating wire sensors to quantify the residual strain rate in three dimensions in accordance with standard SIA 269.
- Measurement of residual expansion potentialStorage of cored specimens in a saturated chamber at controlled temperature to determine whether the chemical reaction is stabilised or still active.
- Interventions on water contentInstallation of heavy-duty waterproofing, renewal of expansion joints, and peripheral drainage to cut off any ingress of liquid water into the concrete.
- Strengthening by external confinementApplication of post-confinement using external prestressing or supplemental reinforcement to restrain transverse expansion and restore shear capacity.
On the construction site, during exploratory probing or structural work strengthening operations, compliance with accident prevention rules is mandatory for site supervisors. In accordance with art. 82 LAA, the employer shall, to prevent occupational accidents and illnesses, take all measures shown to be necessary by experience, applicable according to the state of the art, and adapted to the prevailing conditions. Partial demolition of weakened elements or jacking operations for instrumentation require strict propping to prevent any sudden structural failure.
Management of critical kinetics and confinement failures
On an engineering structure affected by alkali-aggregate reaction, degradation accelerates when waterproofing barriers fail or mechanical confinement provided by passive reinforcement reaches breaking point. If dimensional monitoring over time reveals a slope discontinuity in expansion curves or if crazing is accompanied by spalling of concrete cover slabs, the site manager and the site foreman must switch without delay to the emergency protection protocols specified by standard SIA 269.
- Immediate heavy-duty propping of areas under high shear or bearing stresses (beam supports, corbels, hollow piers), to relieve load from concrete whose modulus of elasticity is collapsing.
- Installation of mechanical ball telltales and precision digital dial gauges to monitor at close intervals (weekly) the edges of major cracks exceeding 1.0 mm in width.
- Total and watertight diversion of stormwater runoff or chloride-laden water, as internal relative humidity above 80% is the primary driver of expansive gel formation.
- Systematic scaling of loose concrete flakes to eliminate the risk of falling debris onto traffic lanes or workstations.
If monitoring confirms severe residual reactivity coupled with decohesion of the cement matrix identified by petrographic analysis, strengthening by additional external prestressing or confinement using active transverse tie rods becomes essential. This active mechanical confinement restrains internal crack opening and restores the load-bearing capacity of the structural element, thereby extending the safe operation of the structure under continuous monitoring.
Frequently asked questions
How can simple plastic shrinkage be differentiated from alkali-aggregate reaction crazing?
Plastic shrinkage crazing occurs early, is superficial, is often oriented according to the wind direction during placing, and remains dormant over time. Alkali-aggregate reaction appears after several years of service as a three-directional network with mesh sizes of 5 to 20 cm, evolves over time, is bounded by dark rims, and is associated with whitish alkali gel exudates weeping along damp cracks.
Why is laboratory petrographic analysis essential?
Surface visual examination is merely an indication, never conclusive proof. Petrographic analysis on core samples taken from the core of the structure allows the cement matrix to be examined under optical and electron microscopes. It formally confirms the presence of reactive minerals (opal, chalcedony), detects microcracks traversing aggregates, and positively identifies the expansive silica gel characteristic of the mechanism.
Which instrumentation should be prioritised for dimensional monitoring on the structure?
The standard protocol relies on fixed measurement bases anchored in sound concrete, monitored using a removable mechanical extensometer or continuously recording inductive displacement sensors. These dimensional measurements must strictly be paired with temperature and humidity probes in the core of the concrete to isolate actual chemical expansion from purely thermal or hygrometric dimensional changes.
Can waterproofing alone stop the alkali-aggregate reaction?
Eliminating water ingress significantly slows swelling kinetics, but does not instantly neutralise the pathology. Massive concrete elements retain high internal humidity for several years. Waterproofing remediation must be regarded as a means to curb gel formation, but it must strictly be accompanied by dimensional monitoring to verify the actual stabilisation of residual expansion.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 269Bases for the maintenance of existing structures
