Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 211.1Pathologies of reinforced concrete, diagnosis and strengtheningChapter 8 of 10 in the section

Non-destructive testing of a structure: radar, ferroscan and test pits

This chapter sets out the non-destructive detection methodology to locate rebar, prestressing tendons and services before any core drilling. The site manager learns how to cross-reference radar and magnetic technologies, identify physical shadow zones in concrete and set up targeted destructive exploratory breakouts in accordance with the diagnostic requirements of standard SIA 269.

Key takeaways

  • The magnetic ferroscan accurately measures the first layer of reinforcement up to 60 millimetres.
  • High-frequency radar penetrates up to 40 centimetres but confuses cables and PVC pipes.
  • The screening effect of the first layer of steel systematically masks deeper layers from the waves.
  • Targeted mechanical breakout remains the only way to calibrate diameters and actual condition.

Comparative performance of ferroscan and GPR according to depth

Non-destructive testing of a load-bearing reinforced concrete element determines the safety of subsequent operations, whether installing heavy-duty anchors or opening a floor penetration. In accordance with the principles of standard SIA 269 on the maintenance of existing structures, examining the condition of a structure begins with surveying the internal geometry of the rebars. Two families of portable devices share the field: the electromagnetic detector, commonly referred to as a covermeter or ferroscan, and high-frequency structural radar based on the emission of electromagnetic radar waves.

Suitability of inspection methods according to depth and targets
TechnologyEffective depthIdentifiable targetsCritical blind spots
Electromagnetic covermeter0 to 80 mmReinforcing bars, welded wire mesh, actual coverNon-metallic ducts, cables beyond 80 mm, underlying reinforcement
Ground penetrating radar (GPR)30 to 400 mmPrestressing ducts, clear voids, deep reinforcementDistinction between steel and plastic, exact bar diameters, very dense reinforcement
Breakout with light chipping hammerLimited to the steelDiameter via calliper, corrosion patterns, bar profileSpot area without an overall view of the rebar grid

The ferroscan exploits the variation in a magnetic field induced by ferromagnetic metals. It delivers an accurate measurement of the concrete cover and allows an estimation of the nominal diameter of the first-layer bars, provided that the bar spacing exceeds the cover. Beyond 60 to 80 millimetres in depth, the signal attenuates sharply and loses all metrological reliability. Synthetic electrical conduits or drainage pipes remain strictly invisible to this tool.

High-frequency GPR relies on wave reflections when crossing media with distinct dielectric permittivities. It visualises the interface between concrete and a foreign body up to 300 or even 400 millimetres deep in dry concrete. However, radar does not measure a diameter: it detects a reflection hyperbola. It is incapable of distinguishing between a large-diameter steel bar, a multilayer pipe filled with water or an empty prestressing duct. As soon as the spacing of the top reinforcement drops below 80 millimetres, the closely spaced metallic echoes form a continuous barrier that reflects the entire wavefront, plunging the soffit of the slab or the bottom rebars into a total shadow zone.

Setting-out methodology and mandatory confirmation breakout

Work planning must ensure that operations compromise neither the overall stability of the building nor the safety of the teams. For any through-penetration greater than a diameter of 50 millimetres or for installing structural anchors in a prestressed concrete zone, the combined use of both methods is mandatory. In application of art. 229 CP, which provides penal sanctions for breaching the recognised rules of the art of construction and endangering life or physical integrity, the site foreman or site manager must ensure that the layout of main reinforcement is not severed blindly.

  1. Preliminary scan with ferroscanGridding of the surface on a 50 by 50 centimetre mesh. Marking the centreline of first-layer rebars with wax crayon and recording minimum cover values to identify clear passage zones.
  2. Cross-pass GPR scanningExecuting perpendicular profiles using an antenna of at least 1.5 to 2.6 GHz. Identifying deep hyperbolas, locating service ducts and mapping geometric peculiarities of the structure.
  3. Destructive confirmation breakoutTargeted mechanical exposure of a reference bar using a light chipping hammer with on-tool dust extraction. This localized breakout confirms the actual diameter with callipers and calibrates the radar dielectric model.
  4. Marking the exclusion zoneDelineating the permissible drilling area on the concrete face with a lateral tolerance margin of 30 millimetres relative to rebar and 100 millimetres relative to prestressing tendons.

Physical detection limits and elements masked beneath reinforcement

Non-destructive testing of an existing structure falls within the assessment principles of standard SIA 269. During core drilling or heavy-duty anchoring operations on slabs or walls, the site manager must deal with an invariable physical principle: no detection device penetrates a continuous metallic screen without major signal alteration.

The ferroscan, based on magnetic induction, saturates as soon as the top reinforcement layer is too dense. Its operating range stops dead at rebars close to the formwork surface. High-frequency GPR (1.5 GHz to 2.6 GHz) emits electromagnetic waves. As soon as these waves encounter a reinforcing bar, the dielectric contrast produces a pronounced hyperbolic reflection on the radargram. If the reinforcement grid has a spacing of less than 100 mm, the reflections overlap and create an impenetrable mask for elements located on the underside.

Actual discrimination capability of devices depending on the obstacle encountered
Target elementFerroscan (magnetic)GPR (radar waves)Direct operational risk
1st layer of rebarAccurately visible (cover and approximate diameter)Visible as clear hyperbolasSeverance during shallow drilling
2nd layer (deep rebars)Completely invisibleDetectable if the top mesh is wide (> 150 mm)Rupture of bending reinforcement in tension zones
Prestressing ducts (metallic)Invisible (excessive depth)Visible if isolated; invisible under dense meshFatal severance of tensioned strands
Empty PVC / PE conduitsCompletely invisibleWeak signal or inverted hyperbola depending on moisturePerforation of penetrations or cast-in services
Grouting voids / honeycombingInvisibleDiffuse diffraction, complex interpretationLoss of bond for anchor bolts

Another frequent trap on transformation construction sites involves green or water-saturated concrete. The dielectric constant of water dissipates radar wave energy within a few centimetres, reducing the effective reading depth to less than 80 mm compared with over 300 mm in mature dry concrete.

Confirmation protocol by targeted destructive mechanical breakout

Data obtained by radar or magnetic methods provide only a layout probability and a cover estimate. In accordance with the survey procedure prescribed by standard SIA 269, definitive validation of the substrate condition requires a mechanical confirmation breakout before commencing large-diameter core drilling.

  1. Marking the grid on the concrete faceTransfer the rebar centrelines detected by radar using permanent marker by crossing two orthogonal passes. Delineate the clear work zone intended for the future penetration.
  2. Exploratory breakout with light chipping hammerOpen a small inspection window using a light chipping hammer with limited impact (impact energy below 3 Joules) to remove concrete cover without shocking the cement matrix or notching the steel bars.
  3. Physical inspection with calliperMeasure the actual diameter of the exposed steel with callipers and verify actual cover to recalibrate the radar dielectric model across the remainder of the slab.
  4. Formal drilling sign-offAdjust the core drilling centreline to maintain the required safety clearance relative to load-bearing reinforcement before starting the diamond core bit.

Organising these operations requires constant vigilance. According to art. 17 OTConst, measures must be taken at workstations and traffic routes so that workers are not endangered by the collapse of building components or falling objects. In the event of drilling that breaks through to the slab soffit, the area below must be strictly cordoned off.

Furthermore, the contractor remains bound by its duty of diligence regarding the overall safety of the structure. Art. 229 CP punishes with a custodial sentence not exceeding five years or a monetary penalty anyone who intentionally breaches the recognised rules of the art of construction and knowingly endangers the life or physical integrity of persons (not exceeding three years or a monetary penalty through negligence). Severing main reinforcement due to lack of prior verification directly engages the chain of command on the construction site.

Procedure to follow in the event of a discrepancy between radar assessment and drilling

On an alteration or structural strengthening construction site, striking reinforcement during core drilling or unexpectedly encountering a service duct requires an immediate shutdown of the tool. Non-destructive tests provide probabilistic indications but do not replace the internal physical reality of concrete, particularly beyond the first layer of reinforcement where high-frequency radar experiences diffraction or dielectric attenuation phenomena.

  1. Cordoning off and suspension of workImmediately establish a safety perimeter below the slab or around the affected structural element. Lock out the core drill or rotary hammer to prevent any inadvertent resumption.
  2. Targeted visual confirmation breakoutCarry out a localized breakout using a light chipping hammer, without heavy percussion, to expose the damaged steel without cracking adjacent sound concrete or impairing the bond of neighbouring bars.
  3. Joint measurement and condition surveyRecord with callipers the residual diameter of the sheared steel cross-section, its orientation and its exact depth from the concrete face for transmission to the civil engineer.
  4. Validation of the corrective measureAwait the static structural recalculation prepared in accordance with the principles of standard SIA 269 before proceeding with chemical anchoring of bridging bars, a steel splice plate or bonded carbon-fibre reinforced polymer strips.

Frequently asked questions

Can structural radar guarantee the complete absence of ducts beneath the first layer of reinforcement?

No. The mesh or rebars of the first layer create an electromagnetic shield that scatters radar waves. Plastic-sheathed cables, empty conduits or PVC pipes located beneath this dense reinforcement return a very weak echo. The engineer must systematically require a light mechanical confirmation breakout or cross-reference measurements with original as-built drawings before authorising any deep drilling.

What is the realistic depth limit of high-frequency radar on a reinforced concrete slab?

In mature dry concrete, a 1.5 to 2.6 GHz high-frequency radar antenna can discriminate reinforcing bars up to 30 to 40 cm deep. Beyond that, or as soon as the concrete exhibits high residual moisture or very congested reinforcement (spacing under 10 cm), the signal attenuates sharply. The device can no longer distinguish the exact position or size of deep reinforcement.

Why carry out a destructive mechanical breakout when a complete radar scan has been completed?

Radar detects a break in dielectric impedance but does not directly measure the actual diameter of a bar or the presence of underlying corrosion. In accordance with the principles of standard SIA 269 for the assessment of existing structures, localized mechanical breakout constitutes the only physical calibration method. It validates actual cover, inspects the steel grade and confirms the calculation assumptions of the appointed civil engineer.

What should be done if the ferroscan and radar provide conflicting indications on bar position?

The ferroscan is limited to roughly 10 to 12 cm depth but offers excellent accuracy for the first layer of ferromagnetic reinforcement. Radar reaches deeper but may interpret a non-metallic conduit as a reinforcement element. In the event of a discrepancy, marking must be suspended and an inspection window of roughly 10x10 cm opened with a light chipping hammer to visually verify the substrate.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 269Bases for the assessment of existing load-bearing structures: data collection, inspection and verification of structural safety
  • CP art. 229Breach of the recognised rules of the art of construction

In the same section