Key takeaways
- The award specification must expressly state the quality level according to SIA 242.
- Level Q2 is the standard delivery for substrates receiving a textured wall covering.
- Full skim coating is an additional service defined contractually between the lots concerned.
- The joint inspection record releases the plasterer before the painter applies the first coat of primer.
Define the finish level according to SIA 242 from the tender stage
On Swiss construction sites, the recurring dispute between plasterer and painter stems from differing assessments of the surface condition delivered. The painter regularly refuses to work on a plasterboard facing without demanding an extra charge for surfacing or without shifting responsibility for raking-light shadows onto the plasterer. To put an end to these disputes, the quality grade required for each wall must be recorded in writing in the respective tenders for the plastering (CFC 271) and painting (CFC 272) lots.
The SIA 242 standard sets out the technical criteria applicable to plastering, rendering and drywall work, in particular the definition of surface quality grades and their permissible execution tolerances.
norme SIA 242
Unless the contract states otherwise, standard execution corresponds to quality grade Q2. This basic finish includes joint treatment in two passes with reinforcing tape, covering of screw heads and removal of residual burrs. This substrate is designed to receive dispersion renders with a grain size above 1 mm or thick wall coverings. It is in no case intended to receive a plain matt paint directly under raking light, still less a satin lacquer.
| Grade | Plasterer's work (CFC 271) | Coating admissible for painter (CFC 272) |
|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Joint filling with tape, no surfacing | Concealed finish, bonded tiling, lining waterproofing |
| Q2 | Standard two-pass jointing, levelling, localised sanding | Textured wallpapers, thick renders from 1.0 mm |
| Q3 | Widened joints, fine tightening, partial smoothing of the board facing | Regular matt paints without pronounced raking light |
| Q4 | Full continuous skim coat over the entire board surface | Lacquers, gloss paints, direct raking light |
Delimiting the plasterer's skim coating and the painter's filling primer
The conflict often escalates around skim coating. Designers frequently specify a perfectly smooth appearance without appreciating the technical boundary between smoothing with plaster compound and the application of a painter's primer. Grade Q4 means the plasterer applies a continuous skim film of surfacing compound over all the boards, with a minimum thickness of one millimetre, followed by general mechanical sanding with a drywall sander under suitable lighting.
Conversely, the application of a filling primer sprayed with an airless gun is strictly the painter's responsibility. The painter cannot require the plasterer to ensure uniform porosity of the substrate or the opacity needed to mask the ghosting of the board facing and compound. The plasterer delivers a flat geometry free of ridges and hollows; the painter regulates the absorption of the substrate and fills residual micro-porosity with a pigmented base coat.
- Visual check under diffuse lightingThe plasterer and the painter inspect the walls together under the actual conditions of use of the rooms, without projecting artificial raking light not provided for in the contract.
- Geometric check with a straightedgeThe foreman checks local flatness using a 2 m straightedge and a 20 cm rule to ensure that the tolerances of SIA 242 are met.
- Signing the joint inspection recordBoth firms sign the handover record confirming that the substrate is compliant and authorising the painter to start work.
- Responsibility for the primer coatAs soon as the painter applies the first primer coat, the substrate is considered accepted without reservation by the finishing work.
Prior contractual agreement on the surface grade between plasterer and painter
The recurring dispute between the drywall plasterer and the painter almost systematically stems from a mismatch of expectations not formalised in the tenders. When the specification simply states a substrate that is "clean and flat, ready to receive paint", the plasterer applies the customary standard level, namely quality grade Q2 according to SIA 242. The painter, meanwhile, tasked with a careful paint finish, notably where full-height glazing creates strong raking light, discovers a substrate whose jointing shows through the thin film. They then demand a complete skim coat that the plasterer has neither priced nor allowed for in their installation rates.
To put an end to these differences, the site management and the two firms must fix the agreed grade in writing before award or, at the latest, at the technical coordination meeting for the finishing work. SIA 242 defines clear boundaries between the plastering services of CFC 271 and the painting preparation work of CFC 272. The plasterer delivers geometry, flatness and a mechanical surface condition; the painter deals with porosity, adhesion and the final opacity of the facing.
| Agreed grade | Services due from the plasterer (CFC 271) | Preparatory services by the painter (CFC 272) | Lighting permitted for assessment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q2 (standard) | Board jointing with reinforcing tape, finishing passes and localised sanding to ensure a continuous transition without steps. | General light sanding, impregnating base coat or filling primer to even out the absorption of the board facing and compound. | Diffuse perpendicular light. Shadows cast under raking light do not constitute a defect. |
| Q3 (enhanced requirements) | Q2 jointing followed by wide joint coating and partial skimming with a spatula to close the pores of the board facing. | Light sanding, pigmented primer coat, fine spot repairs before application of the matt finishing coats. | Normal site lighting or indirect natural light. Residual micro-relief is tolerated. |
| Q4 (maximum requirements) | Complete coating of the entire surface by a continuous skim coat at least one millimetre thick, fine mechanical sanding. | Opacifying primer, optical inspection, lacquered or satin finishes or demanding smooth wall coverings. | Artificial or natural raking light corresponding exactly to the future operating conditions of the rooms. |
The golden rule for avoiding conflict lies in matching the decorative effect ordered from the painter to the substrate specified for the plasterer. A painter applying a felted matt finish or a fine decorative render is not entitled to demand a Q4 substrate from the plasterer if the contract states Q2. Conversely, an architect who plans wall lights grazing the ceiling must order, and pay for, grade Q3 or Q4 in the plastering specification, otherwise the plastering-painting interface becomes unmanageable.
The joint inspection record for substrate handover
The handover between plasterer and painter marks the boundary of responsibilities. All too often, the painter enters the released rooms, notes presumed defects in flatness or sanding, but starts spraying primer without formal notification. Yet, under SIA 118 and trade practice, the painter's intervention on the surfaces constitutes acceptance without reservation of the substrate supplied by the preceding lot, shifting onto the painter the burden of correcting imperfections at their own cost.
- Call-out to the construction siteThe plastering foreman notifies the site management of the completion of their surfaces and requests a joint visit, with the painter's team leader necessarily present, before any painting operation.
- Checking flatness and moistureThose present check overall flatness with a two-metre aluminium straightedge and measure the residual moisture of the plaster, which must be dry enough to receive the painter's organic binders.
- Visual examination according to the protocolThe visual inspection is carried out at a minimum regulatory distance of two metres, under lighting representative of the agreed future use. The use of high-power raking lamps is strictly prohibited if the contract specifies grade Q2.
- Signing the interface recordThe parties record any reservations in writing (excess burrs, localised gaps, chipped edges) with a precise deadline for the plasterer's touch-ups. Without reservation, the painter signs the discharge and takes custody of the substrate.
Once the record has been signed without reservation, the plasterer's responsibility for the visible surface condition lapses. Later damage caused by other trades (late chasing by the electrician, impacts caused by the sanitary fitter or the floor layers) is no longer covered by the plasterer's warranty and must be dealt with by separate day-work orders issued by the site management.
Disputes over finish grade: arbitration protocol and responsibilities
When the painter refuses to work, describing the substrate as unsuitable, the construction site comes to a standstill. The plasterer maintains that they delivered the level required by the contract, often a Q2 or Q3 grade compliant with SIA 242, while the applicator demands a perfect surface to avoid ghosting under raking light. To decide without sliding into costly stoppages, the site management must immediately summon both trades for a joint check on site.
- Checking the lighting criteriaThe facing is checked strictly under the natural light conditions or the final operating lighting provided for in the project. The use of mobile raking spotlights to detect micro-undulations on a Q2 or Q3 grade is prohibited by the rules of the trade.
- Examination of flatness and edgesThe check is carried out with a two-metre straightedge and a rule according to the tolerances of SIA 242. A distinction is made between compound misalignments attributable to the plasterer and simple roughness or surface porosity intended to be compensated by the painter's base coats.
- Drawing up the formal recordThe site management records its observations in minutes signed on the spot. The document states whether the surfaces comply with the level ordered in the specification or whether local repairs fall to the plasterer before the primer coat is applied.
If the record establishes that the plasterer complied with the grade agreed in the works contract, the painter's additional requirements amount to a change of standard. A move from grade Q2 to continuous Q4-type surfacing cannot be demanded of the plasterer without a prior financial addendum. The site management must then decide: order additional skim coating from the plasterer as an extra, or entrust the painter with applying a filling compound or surfacing skim within their own preparatory work. Conversely, if poorly sanded joint edges, hollows or excess build-up exceed the permitted tolerances, the plasterer must correct the defective areas at their own expense. SIA 118 governs the formal notification of such repairs, which must be carried out before any painting work begins in order to preserve the chain of responsibilities.
Frequently asked questions
What lighting should be used to judge the conformity of a plastering substrate?
A plasterboard facing or render is assessed exclusively under natural ambient light or under the final artificial lighting of the room, in accordance with SIA 242. Judging a substrate with a portable lamp or a raking spotlight not provided for in the final installation is not permitted. Artificial cast shadows reveal micro-irregularities inherent in the material which in no way constitute a flatness defect.
Who bears the cost of the additional sanding demanded by the painter on a Q2 substrate?
If the contract specification provided for a Q2 finish, the plasterer need only deliver levelled, tight joints sanded free of coarse burrs. If the painter demands a surface free of any difference in texture for a gloss lacquer, this surfacing corresponds to grade Q4. This additional service must be the subject of a formal order from the site management, invoiced as an extra to the plasterer or included in the painter's preparatory work.
Can the painter refuse to apply a primer on a surface accepted at Q3?
No, the painter cannot refuse the substrate without an objective reason based on SIA 242. Grade Q3 ensures wide filling of the tape and careful surfacing, but does not completely eliminate ghosting under raking light. Applying a filling primer or a pigmented primer coat is part of the painter's rules of the trade to even out the absorption of the substrate and guarantee adhesion of the finish, and does not constitute a re-rendering.
How to formalise the transfer of responsibility between plasterer and painter on the construction site?
The transfer of responsibility is established by means of a joint inspection record of substrate acceptance drawn up with the site management. This written protocol lists the rooms checked, any local reservations to be cleared by the plasterer and the date the surfaces are released. As soon as the painter begins applying paints or primers without issuing a formal notice, they are deemed to have accepted the substrate as it stands under SIA 118.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 242Plastering, drywall construction, partitions and suspended ceilings: quality requirements and tolerances
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work
