Key takeaways
- The main contractor alone answers to site management for defects in the finished work.
- The framing and insulation must be inspected before the second board layer is closed.
- Three technical hold points avoid destructive dismantling and later acoustic or mechanical disputes.
- Checking working conditions and equipment protects the company from statutory joint and several liability.
The three hold points before the second face is closed
Once the second face of a dry-lining partition has been boarded and jointed, the metal structure and its acoustic insulation quilt become invisible. Inspection after the fact is impossible without destructive probing. To prevent a decoupling defect or a lack of insulation from leading the client's representative to reject the work at acceptance under the SIA 118 standard, the contractor must set up a systematic validation procedure before the closing board is installed.
- Inspection of the framing and resilient stripsBefore any screwing, check that the acoustic sealing strip has been applied under the floor and ceiling channels. Check the spacing of the metal studs, the crimping or screwing onto the horizontal tracks, and the expansion gaps at the head connection under the concrete slab. The studs must be free to slide if the structure undergoes a foreseeable deflection.
- Checking penetrations, load reinforcements and door framesInspect the door-frame reinforcement profiles, their sheet thickness and their mechanical connection to the slabs. Confirm the presence of the timber noggins or metal plates provided to support heavy suspended loads. Check that electrical conduits and pipework passing through do not restrain the framing and that the acoustic sleeves are in place.
- Continuous mineral wool installation and closing of one faceInspect the complete filling of the cavity with mineral wool. The insulation panels must be installed with tight joints, without settling or gaps, particularly around opposite electrical boxes, which must be offset. Confirm that the first face has been screwed correctly with the screws suited to the required spacing before authorising the opposite boarding.
| Item to inspect | Acceptance criterion | Disqualifying defect |
|---|---|---|
| UW perimeter profiles | Continuous foam strip under the entire flange | Profile in direct hard contact with the concrete |
| CW vertical studs | Spacing as per the system, 10 mm head gap | Stud rigidly fixed at the head under a deflecting slab |
| Internal mineral wool | Tight-fitting fill without any air gap | Quilt sagging or missing at the foot of the partition |
| Fixing of the first board layer | Screw heads flush without tearing the paper | Skewed screws, paper pierced or excessive spacing |
Liability for the work and supervision of the subcontractor
Delegating the installation to a third-party company does not change in any way the contractual relationship between the plastering contractor awarded the work and the client. Under art. 364 CO, the contractor's liability is subject to the general rules applicable to the execution of the work, whether it carries out the work itself or through delegated personnel. If the subcontractor botches the reinforcement tapes or delivers surfaces that do not meet the agreed quality levels, it is the contractor awarded the work that must carry out the remedial work, and it cannot plead the fault of its auxiliary.
Supervision is not limited to the geometric inspection of the partitions. It extends to compliance with social legislation and hygiene rules on the construction site. In accordance with art. 5 LDét, the contracting contractor is civilly liable for subcontractors' failure to comply with net minimum wages and working conditions. In plastering and lightweight partitions, the site foreman must demand proof that the fitters have been declared, compliance with the applicable collective agreements and the supply of collective and personal protective equipment suited to carrying heavy loads and to the emission of sanding dust.
Formalising the hold point and handling non-conformities
The inspection of the first face and the cavity tolerates no documentary compromise. On construction sites run under the SIA 118 standard, approval of the internal assembly before the second face is closed is a contractual hold point. The site manager of the plastering contractor awarded the work and the team leader of the subcontracting company carry out a joint walk-round for each progress section, for example per floor plate or per group of offices. This visual and dimensional inspection leads to the signing of a closing release slip. Without this signed validation, screwing on the closing boards remains prohibited. If a board is installed before the reservations are formally lifted, the main plasterer demands dismantling at the subcontractor's expense in order to inspect the metal framing, the sound insulation and the technical services built in.
| Inspection point | Frequent non-conformity | Corrective measure required |
|---|---|---|
| Perimeter resilient strip | No strip under the UW profile or sound bridge at the foot | Removal of the track, cleaning of the floor and installation of a continuous sealing foam |
| Screw fixing and spacing | Skewed screws, heads tearing the paper or spacing greater than 25 cm | Replacement of screws that are not flush and addition of intermediate fixings |
| Internal insulation quilt | Compressed mineral wool, gaps in the studs or air voids | Edge-to-edge fit without compression, full wedging of the CW studs |
| Openings for sanitary and electrical services | Electrical boxes face to face without minimum acoustic offset | Lateral offset of the boxes by at least two stud spacings or installation of plaster shells |
| Door-frame reinforcements | Reinforced profiles not mechanically fixed to the floor angles | Correct screwing of the stud feet with brackets on the rough slab |
Final liability towards the client rests entirely with the plastering contractor awarded the work. Under the rules of the Code of Obligations on the contract for work, the general contractor or holder of the contract answers for the acts of its subcontractors as for its own work. Site management has no legal relationship with the delegated installation team. If an acoustic failure or a structural crack appears after acceptance as a result of negligence hidden under the plaster, the client will invoke the five-year warranty against the holder of the contract. An internal self-inspection sheet then allows the plasterer to exercise its right of recourse against the defaulting subcontractor, on the basis of incontestable technical evidence.
Working conditions, safety and coverage of joint and several liability risk
Subcontracting in finishing work in French-speaking Switzerland exposes the main contractor to rigorous monitoring of working conditions on the ground. The Ordinance on Construction Work requires ergonomic and safe workstations for handling plasterboards. Fitters must have mechanical board lifters for suspended ceilings, platform stepladders with secure platforms and compliant mobile plasterer's scaffolding. Handling mineral wool and cutting boards require direct source extraction systems or the wearing of suitable respiratory protective equipment, in order to meet the requirements for ambient air quality. The contractor awarded the work checks that the subcontractor's workers have the required personal protective equipment from the moment they arrive on site.
From a legal and financial standpoint, the liability of the contractor awarded the work is engaged by the duty of care defined in the law on posted workers and the law on undeclared work. The contracting plasterer must require from the subcontractor, before work begins, proof of compliance with the minimum wages and working conditions set by the collective labour agreement of the trade. If a subcontracting company uses posted personnel without prior notification to the cantonal authorities or without paying the mandatory supplements, the holder of the contract may be held jointly and severally liable for the amounts due. Keeping an attendance register on the construction site and checking work permits are the only ways to avoid administrative sanctions and a sudden halt to the progress of the work.
Subcontractor default: recording the defects and reworking the partitions
When the progress inspection reveals major defects or when a subcontractor boards over without having the hold point validated, the liability of the contractor awarded the work towards the client remains total and indivisible. Under the Code of Obligations, the main contractor answers for the acts of its auxiliaries exactly as for its own. Faced with a proven defect in the framing, the insulation or the incorporation of the sanitary and electrical services, the response must be immediate in method: block access to the area, record the findings in a joint written record and suspend advance payments relating to the package concerned.
- Formal notification of the stop to installationA formal notice of interruption is sent in writing to the subcontractor the same day. It lists the non-conformities identified against the execution drawings and requires screwing to stop, failing which the work will be rejected in its entirety.
- Destructive probing openingIf the closing board has been installed without release of the hold point, the foreman orders the removal of sample boards at the critical locations, in particular at lintels, electrical boxes and acoustic junctions.
- Formal notice and remediation periodThe company sets a short but achievable period to remove the non-conforming boards, rectify the framing or the sound bridges, and then present the opened-up work for a new formal inspection.
- Substitution and execution by a third partyIf the period expires without satisfactory correction, the law of obligations allows another team to be brought in to rectify the defects, the costs incurred being charged directly to the final account of the defaulting fitter.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if the subcontractor has closed the second face without prior validation?
Demand an immediate stop to work and order targeted destructive probing. Removing several boards at sensitive locations makes it possible to check the stud spacing, the continuity of the sound insulation and the presence of the door-frame reinforcements. The costs of reopening, replacing damaged boards and making good are entirely borne by the fitter who passed the hold point without written authorisation.
How should one react if the subcontractor's workers are not wearing their protective equipment?
The main site manager must intervene without delay. The Ordinance on Construction Work requires safety equipment to be worn and allows the immediate removal of any person endangering their own health or that of others. If the subcontracting team refuses to use respiratory protection when sanding or goggles when cutting profiles, immediately suspend their access to the area.
Can the client address our subcontractor directly on the construction site?
No. Under the SIA 118 standard and Swiss law on the contract for work, the client has no direct contractual relationship with the subcontractor. Any remark, variation order or claim must go through site management and be addressed to you directly. Formally instruct your subcontractors never to change an installation on the mere verbal instruction of anyone outside your company.
How do you properly document a defect before engaging a third-party company to rectify it?
Draw up a precise joint inspection record with time-stamped photos, laser measurements and the mention of the item numbers on the installation drawing. Attach the written formal notice granting a remediation period in accordance with the Code of Obligations. This technical file is the key document for justifying the deduction of the third-party company's invoices when the final account of the subcontracted package is drawn up.
Texts and standards cited
- code des obligationsthe contractor's liability for its auxiliaries and the client's rights in the event of defective execution
- norme SIA 118general conditions for the execution of construction work and relations between the parties involved
- ordonnance sur les travaux de constructionoccupational safety measures and obligations relating to personal protective equipment
