Key takeaways
- Complete decoupling of two parallel frames far outperforms increasing the thickness of mineral wool.
- A minimum free gap of ten millimetres between the studs prevents any conduction of acoustic vibrations.
- The mineral wool must remain flexible and uncompressed in order to absorb the sound wave without creating a link.
- Double boarding with staggered joints provides the surface mass essential to satisfy SIA 181.
Breaking mechanical transmission through full decoupling of the frames
On construction sites, it is often believed that filling the cavity of a partition with mineral wool guarantees silence. In Swiss building acoustics governed by SIA 181, the effectiveness of a separating partition is not measured by the volume of compressed insulation. Doubling the thickness of mineral wool without decoupling the metal studs brings only a marginal gain, capped at one or two decibels. Maximum acoustic performance relies on the mass-spring-mass system, in which the vibrational independence of the two faces of the element is the decisive factor.
- Acoustic decoupling
- Total elimination of any rigid contact between two load-bearing frames or between the boards of a partition, preventing the mechanical vibrations generated by airborne sound waves from propagating through solid conduction.
On a single frame made of CW metal profiles, both boards are fixed to the same vertical studs. The steel then acts as a direct transmitter: the sound pressure strikes the first board, makes the metal frame vibrate, and this oscillation is passed into the adjacent room through the second board. To break this structure-borne transmission, the plasterer erects two parallel rows of UW profiles at floor and ceiling, leaving a free air gap of at least ten millimetres between the backs of the vertical studs.
Independence must also be ensured with respect to the structural work. Perimeter profiles and setting-out tracks never bear directly on the bare slab or against adjoining concrete or masonry walls. The dry-lining installer applies a resilient acoustic sealing strip of cellular foam or elastomer beneath each perimeter profile. This sealed, flexible joint blocks flanking transmission while ensuring perimeter airtightness, which is essential to the final acoustic performance.
Optimising the boards and the cavity without creating transmission through compression
The role of the mineral wool in the cavity is not to damp the vibrations of the profiles, but to absorb the acoustic energy resonating in the closed cavity, avoiding the sounding-box effect. To fulfil this damping function, the material must have open porosity and low dynamic stiffness. A light glass wool or rock wool with a density of fifteen to thirty kilograms per cubic metre offers the optimum resistance to airflow.
| Cavity configuration | Mechanical link | Acoustic behaviour | SIA 181 compliance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Empty cavity, no insulation | Separate double frame | Pronounced internal resonance effect | Insufficient between separate units |
| Dense, compressed stuffing | Bridging through contact of dense fibres | Solid transmission through compression | Risk of failing in-situ checks |
| Flexible, uncompressed mineral wool | Complete decoupling preserved | Optimum dissipation of the internal wave | Compliant with the enhanced requirements |
The performance of a decoupled double wall depends directly on the surface mass of its outer boards. To reach the enhanced requirements of SIA 181 between sensitive rooms, double boarding on each frame is required. The use of high-density or acoustic plasterboard improves sound reduction at low frequencies. The plasterer fixes the first layer of boards with suitable screws, carefully fills all joints without tape, then fits the second layer, staggering the vertical joints by at least forty centimetres.
- Fitting the resilient stripApply the sealing strip under the profiles at floor and ceiling to decouple the tracks from the structural work.
- Erecting the parallel framesSet out the two rows of studs, maintaining the prescribed air gap of at least ten millimetres with no intermediate link.
- Inserting the fibrous absorberSlide the flexible mineral wool batts into the frame without compressing them against the profiles of the opposite row.
- Double boarding and jointsScrew the boards on, staggering the joints by at least forty centimetres, then seal the base with flexible sealant.
Mass of the boards and the real role of the absorber under SIA 181
The physical principle of sound insulation in dry construction rests on the mass-spring-mass system. The plasterboard linings provide the surface mass, the closed air cavity forms the elastic spring, and the mineral wool acts as a porous damper dissipating the energy of sound waves through internal friction. A frequent mistake on construction sites is to completely fill the cavity with a thicker or denser wool in an attempt to double the insulation. Physical reality flatly contradicts this: in a given cavity, doubling the thickness of a fibrous blanket improves the sound reduction index by only one to two decibels. The decisive gain comes not from the insulation but from breaking the direct mechanical links, achieved by full decoupling between the two boards.
To meet the requirements of SIA 181, whether the legal minimum values or the enhanced requirements recommended between dwelling units, the dry-lining installer calibrates the specific airflow resistance of the insulation. A light mineral wool of 15 to 30 kg/m³ guarantees an ideal resistance, between 5 and 15 kPa·s/m². Using a dense, rigid insulation brings no acoustic advantage in a non-separating partition; on the contrary, compressed between the twin studs, it creates a solid contact that short-circuits the air spring. The acoustic mass must be provided exclusively by the boards. By increasing the thicknesses or using special high-density plasterboard, the resonance frequency of the assembly is lowered well below the speech spectrum.
| Frame configuration | Boards per face | Insulation in the cavity | Indicative index Rw + C | Observed acoustic behaviour |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single 75 mm metal frame | 1 standard 12.5 mm plasterboard | 50 mm flexible mineral wool | 44 to 46 dB | Direct mechanical transmission from one board to the other via the profiles. |
| Single 75 mm metal frame | 2 standard 12.5 mm plasterboards | 50 mm flexible mineral wool | 51 to 53 dB | Gain provided by surface mass, but residual coupling through the frame. |
| Separate double frame 2x50 mm | 2 standard 12.5 mm plasterboards | 40 mm flexible mineral wool | 62 to 64 dB | Complete mechanical decoupling of the boards and elimination of rigid bridges. |
| Separate double frame 2x50 mm | 2 high-density acoustic boards | 2x40 mm uncompressed mineral wool | 68 to 71 dB | Maximum performance meeting the enhanced requirements of SIA 181. |
Installation practice and control of rigid links on site
Achieving in situ the insulation values measured in the laboratory requires total rigour when setting out and erecting the frames. The two rows of metal profiles must at all times keep a free air gap of at least 10 millimetres between their inner flanges to avoid any contact under load or through warping. The setting out of acoustic partitions must start with the insertion of a continuous resilient strip under the perimeter profiles in contact with concrete slabs, bare ceilings and adjoining walls. The use of a closed-cell polyethylene foam or an elastomer interrupts the propagation of solid-borne vibrations to the building's load-bearing structure.
- Airtight fitting of the perimeter profilesApply a continuous resilient strip under the tracks at floor, ceiling and against the end walls. Fix the profiles mechanically without crushing the strip, so as to maintain its damping capacity.
- Contact-free setting out of the studsErect the vertical studs back to back at 600 mm centres, offsetting them by 300 mm from one row to the other. Maintain an air gap of at least 10 mm with no transverse link.
- Installing the fibrous damperInsert the mineral wool batts into one of the frames or in two thin layers. The total thickness of insulation must remain less than the cavity to rule out any compression.
- Staggered screwing and sealing at the baseFix the boards with crossed joints between successive layers. Leave a 5 mm gap at the base of the board above the bare slab, then seal with flexible acrylic sealant.
Acceptance of the work with regard to SIA 181 is verified by acoustic checks carried out in situ after completion of the plastering work. The plasterer/dry-lining installer ensures the absolute airtightness of all perimeter junctions and service duct penetrations. A simple hairline crack or an unsealed millimetre gap in the acoustic sealant is enough to create a major sound leak that degrades overall insulation at mid and high frequencies.
Non-compliance in in-situ measurements: diagnosis and remedying of rigid links
When in-situ acoustic acceptance measurements reveal an insulation shortfall against the requirements of SIA 181, the first reflex is often, wrongly, to blame the mineral wool. In practice, the cause of the shortfall almost always lies in a rigid mechanical acoustic bridge linking the two boards or in a perimeter defect. The plastering contractor must then carry out a methodical diagnosis before considering destructive remedial work.
- Checking boxes and service penetrationsCheck that there are no face-to-face openings within the same frame cavity. Open the boards to check that each electrical opening has its acoustic shell or a flexible airtight sealing, with no rigid through-contact.
- Probing junctions and stray fixingsInspect the air space between the two rows of studs with an endoscope camera. Look for screws that are too long and have caught the opposite stud, or offcuts of frame and plaster that have fallen to the base and form a hard wedge.
- Checking perimeters and flexible jointsRemove the skirting boards or cover profiles to check that the acrylic joint is effectively broken at the bare floor, slabs and adjoining walls. The resilient strip must be compressed without tearing and free of any levelling grout.
If the rigid bridge lies in the frame itself through accidental tying, the remedial technical solution requires removing one of the two outer layers to decouple the studs, or fitting a third layer of high-density plasterboard on the accessible board, with scrupulous staggering of the joints and perimeter sealing with neutral elastomer sealant.
Frequently asked questions
Can the two frames be tied together with sheet-metal spacers to gain rigidity?
No. Connecting two rows of profiles with metal brackets or spacers creates a direct structural acoustic bridge. This mechanical coupling ruins the mass-spring-mass principle and loses between 6 and 10 decibels of overall sound reduction index under SIA 181. For tall partitions, rigidity is achieved exclusively by increasing the width of the profiles, never by tying the two lines of studs together.
Should the void between the two frames be completely filled with mineral wool?
No, partial filling of 50 to 75% of the total cavity thickness is enough to damp internal resonances. Stuffing the cavity with a wool that is too dense or too thick risks compressing it against the boards, which creates unwanted solid transmission. Effectiveness depends on the spring effect of the air and on decoupling, not on the density of the absorber.
How should electrical boxes be treated acoustically in a double-frame partition?
The openings must absolutely be offset by at least 60 centimetres from one face to the other, and two boxes must never be placed within the same stud spacing. Each box must be sealed with a specific acoustic airtight box or enclosed in a prefabricated plasterboard box lined with insulation, without touching the profiles of the opposite row.
Which type of board should be preferred to meet the enhanced requirements of SIA 181?
Surface mass remains the decisive factor. The recommended build-up comprises double boarding on each face, made with high-density acoustic plasterboard. Staggering the joints between the first and second layers, combined with careful jointing and a bead of acrylic sealant at the perimeter, guarantees the sound reduction without unduly increasing the total thickness of the assembly.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 181Noise protection in buildings (minimum and enhanced requirements for airborne sound insulation)
