Key takeaways
- The SIA 242 standard sets level Q2 as the default standard execution for boards.
- Level Q1 meets technical requirements only, with no requirement for visual appearance.
- Going from Q2 to Q3 requires wider finishing passes without guaranteeing the absence of shadows under raking light.
- Level Q4 requires a full skim coat over the entire surface, which significantly increases working time.
The four finishing grades under the SIA 242 standard and their technical boundaries
In Swiss finishing work, the quality of a drywall surface is not a matter of subjective judgement at acceptance of the work, but of a technical agreement defined at the tender stage. The SIA 242 standard governs plastering and lightweight partition work by establishing a classification into four distinct grades, from Q1 to Q4. Each level corresponds to a precise protocol for fitting, reinforcement and filler application. Judging a partition without express reference to one of these grades exposes the company to arbitrary disputes, often amplified by construction site lighting or unforeseen raking light.
- Quality grade Q1
- Minimum surface quality for partitions and ceilings with no decorative requirements. The joints of the plasterboards are filled with jointing plaster or filler with embedded reinforcing tape, and the screw heads are concealed. No sanding is required. This level is intended for concealed surfaces, service shafts or substrates intended to receive heavy mechanical lining.
- Quality grade Q2
- Basic standard quality under the SIA 242 standard. It comprises the basic Q1 jointing, supplemented by a finishing or smoothing pass applied over the joint to ensure a continuous transition with the cardboard facing. Tool marks and burrs are removed by sanding. This level is suitable for medium or thick textured coatings, but tolerates residual tool marks under raking light.
- Quality grade Q3
- Higher quality requiring extended treatment. In addition to the Q2 steps, the joints are widened over a considerable width to soften the transition slopes, and the remaining pores of the cardboard are saturated by a tight overall skim with a wide spatula. This grade reduces texture contrasts but does not guarantee perfect flatness under direct raking light.
- Quality grade Q4
- Maximum quality requiring continuous coverage of the entire surface with a skim coat or a smoothing layer with a minimum thickness of approximately one millimetre. This operation completely evens out the absorption and texture of the substrate. This treatment reduces cast shadows to a minimum, without however cancelling the general flatness tolerances of the partition.
Contractual specification, quote and rigorous pricing of extra costs
A higher quality grade is never a favour granted to the client, but a priced technical service. From the submission of the tender, the finishing grade must be expressly stated for each type of work. In the absence of any written specification in the contract documents, the SIA 242 standard sets grade Q2 as the default execution standard for plasterboard partitions and linings. When site management rejects a substrate because it can see the pattern of the joints under raking light although the specification stated Q2, the plasterer must recall the normative framework.
The craftsman's obligation is to provide a substrate that complies with the agreed specifications, and the Code of Obligations governs the contractual agreement concluded between the parties. Changing the required level during the works without a financial addendum seriously upsets the company's economic balance. In matters of contracts for work, art. 363 CO defines the contractor's obligation to carry out the promised work in return for payment of the agreed price. If the client demands a Q3 or Q4 appearance after the fact on a tender awarded at Q2, these operations constitute additional services.
| Surface grade | Technical operations required | Permissible final coatings | Assessment lighting |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Basic jointing, embedding of tapes, no sanding | Heavy tiling, technical underlayers, concealed linings | Ordinary construction site lighting, no requirement |
| Q2 (standard) | Joint finishing, removal of burrs, local sanding | Renders thicker than 1 mm, textured wallpapers | Diffuse natural light without raking incidence |
| Q3 (careful) | Widened joints, tight overall skim to fill the pores | Fine matt paints, fine wallpapers, fine plasters | Diffuse light, tolerates partial shadows under raking light |
| Q4 (high-end) | Full skim coat over the entire surface (minimum thickness 1 mm), sanding | Satin or gloss lacquers, very demanding smooth coatings | Ambient or raking artificial lighting provided for in the project |
What each grade actually delivers: from the raw operation to total surfacing
The SIA 242 standard structures the execution of plasterboard facings and lightweight partitions according to four precise levels of requirement. Each step corresponds to a sequence of defined manual operations, using specific binders and spreading tools. Confusing these technical levels with a subjective level of care exposes the construction site to systematic disputes when the subsequent finishes are applied.
- Quality grade Q1 (rough filling)
- Basic treatment with no visual requirement. It comprises the mechanical or manual filling of the joints between boards, the embedding of the reinforcing tape in the jointing compound and the simple concealing of the screw heads. Excess compound burrs are simply scraped off with a spatula without any subsequent sanding.
- Quality grade Q2 (contractual standard)
- Standard finish intended for medium or thick textured coatings. It is obtained by applying a filling pass over the Q1, followed by a finishing pass with a taping knife over a minimum width of 20 to 30 centimetres along the joint. The whole is sanded to remove tool edges, without seeking continuity of texture with the board's cardboard.
- Quality grade Q3 (careful finish)
- An operation requiring the compound coating of the joints to be widened beyond 30 centimetres and a feather-edge skim over the rest of the cardboard facing. This thin pass closes the surface porosity of the cardboard without, however, completely masking the pattern of the joints under raking light.
- Quality grade Q4 (full high-requirement surfacing)
- Continuous coverage of the entire surface with a skim coat applied at a thickness greater than 1 millimetre. This treatment masks differences in absorption and creates a homogeneous mineral surface that minimises cast shadows under critical oblique lighting.
| SIA grade | Plastering operations required | Surface appearance delivered | Intended field of use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Filling of the bevel, fitting of the tape, concealing of screw heads. | Visible joints, burrs scraped off, no fine flatness sought. | Invisible surfaces, closed technical suspended ceilings, tiling underlayers. |
| Q2 | Q1 supplemented by a finishing pass, moderate widening, sanding of edges. | Geometric continuity without breaks, visible cardboard/compound contrast. | Thick wallpapers, rough interior render, heavily filled matt paints. |
| Q3 | Q2 supplemented by pronounced widening of the joints and tight skimming of the cardboard. | Smoothed surface, cardboard pores closed, residual micro-shadows possible. | Satin paints, fine papers, smooth non-gloss wall coverings. |
| Q4 | Q2 supplemented by continuous full surfacing at least 1 millimetre thick. | Absolute uniformity of material, no cardboard/plaster transitions. | Gloss lacquers, integrated raking lighting, full-height glazed openings. |
Specification in the tender and economic reality: refusing free Q3
In tenders governed by the SIA 242 standard, level Q2 is the default standard execution when no explicit mention appears in the descriptive quote. Demanding a result with no visual transition under raking light on work invoiced at Q2 amounts to a unilateral change to the agreed services. The drywall plasterer must lock down the tender to make clear that the local flatness of a joint does not confer the continuous smooth appearance of a fully skimmed surface.
The extra cost of a higher grade stems from a complete methodological break. To go from Q2 to Q3, the craftsman must carry out an additional pass that doubles the working width around each joint and requires an intermediate drying time. Going to Q4, for its part, requires a full skim coat, by hand or mechanical spraying, involving the transport and application of two to three kilograms of compound per square metre, followed by general sanding with an extension pole sander with integrated dust extraction. This volume of labour hours and consumables can in no case be given away as part of the usual finishes.
To protect the company against abusive complaints when the painters come in, the site foreman must ensure that the quote states the selected grade for each room in so many words. As soon as site management points out after the fact that taut or glossy finishes fall to the painter, an addendum for additional Q3 or Q4 surfacing must be issued before authorising the application of any primer.
Handling surface complaints and disputes
When site management or the CFC 272 painter disputes the flatness or appearance of a plasterboard facing, the first check concerns the inspection conditions set by the SIA 242 standard. Inspections are never carried out under a raking construction site spotlight or with a torch, but under the intended service lighting or in diffuse daylight, at a minimum observation distance. Examining a standard substrate under aggressive oblique lighting artificially creates cast shadows that do not constitute a defect within the meaning of the contract.
If the architect demands the complete disappearance of joint patterns on a partition awarded at grade Q2, the team leader or site manager must rely on the description in the accepted tender. The standard grade Q2 tolerates perceptible transitions under raking light. Demanding the complete absence of shadows or texture variations amounts to requesting a complete skim coat of class Q3 or a general full skim of class Q4. This requirement changes the agreed service and generates additional smoothing and sanding work.
In this situation, the contractor draws up a written joint inspection record before any intervention by the painter. He confirms in writing that the surface delivered complies with the geometric tolerances of the SIA 242 standard for the specified grade Q2. If the client maintains his wish to obtain a higher finish to receive a lacquer or a fine wall covering, a supplementary offer detailing the extra cost of the continuous skim coat must be signed before the work is started. Giving in on the construction site by carrying out unpriced skimming sets an untenable precedent and erodes the company's profitability.
The SIA 118 standard governs changes to orders and requires extra costs to be announced before any execution of services not provided for in the original contract. When the work requires additional coats of compound, the craftsman must price the labour hours and associated consumables, then submit a daywork slip or a fixed-price addendum. Without prior formal agreement, any touching-up taken beyond grade Q2 remains at the company's expense, which loses the right to claim payment for it later.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if the tender specification states no quality grade?
In the absence of any contractual specification in the call for tenders documents or the contract for work, grade Q2 applies by default under the SIA 242 standard. This standard finish corresponds to filling the joints with reinforcing tape and a finishing pass without general surfacing. If site management later demands a Q3 or Q4 surface condition, the contractor is entitled to invoice an addendum for additional work.
Can the painter demand a Q3 substrate in order to apply a matt paint?
No. For the application of a standard matt paint or a medium-grain render, grade Q2 is the usual and sufficient base according to professional rules. The painter cannot demand a Q3 substrate without an express specification in the original quote. If the client has ordered a semi-gloss or satin paint requiring a Q3 substrate, the responsibility for ordering and paying for the prior skim coat lies with the project management.
Why does intensive mechanical sanding not replace a Q3 skim coat?
Over-sanding a grade Q2 surface never achieves Q3 quality and risks seriously damaging the board's cardboard. Moving to Q3 relies on adding material: wider skimming of the joints and a skim coat over the pores to even out the absorption of the substrate. Sanding serves only to remove tool burrs and cannot fill hollows or erase texture differences between the plaster and the cardboard.
Does grade Q4 guarantee a rigorously flat surface with no shadow at all?
Even at grade Q4, the SIA 242 standard accepts that minimal residual shading may remain under extreme raking light. Q4 involves a continuous skim coat over the entire surface of the board and careful sanding, drastically limiting tool shadows. However, absolute flatness does not exist in craft drywall construction. To minimise any shadow effect under raking light, the final light sources must be planned from the planning phase.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 242Definition of surface quality grades Q1 to Q4 and execution tolerances for plastering and drywall construction
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work, addenda and remuneration of additional services
