Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 271Surface quality levels and tolerancesChapter 5 of 10 in the section

Accepting the plasterwork: joint inspection record, useful reservations and rectification deadline

At the end of dry construction work, the acceptance record confirms the conformity of the work. You will learn to carry out a methodical room-by-room inspection, to replace ambiguous wording with quantified deviations according to the finishing levels, and to negotiate realistic rectification deadlines that protect your liability as a contractor while guaranteeing an impeccable substrate.

Key takeaways

  • The joint acceptance record under SIA 118 requires a rigorous room-by-room examination.
  • The vague entry "finishes to be redone" must be banned in favour of a measured and mapped deviation.
  • Each technical reservation identifies the targeted contractual surface grade, from level Q2 to level Q4.
  • A realistic schedule sets the rectification of defects before the paints of the CFC 272 trade are applied.

Reject the entry "finishes to be redone" and qualify each defect room by room

On a plasterwork and light partition construction site, entering the general wording "finishes to be redone" in the record is an administrative and technical trap. This imprecise entry locates no anomaly, specifies no acceptance criterion and exposes the craftsman to arbitrary demands. Acceptance of the work is always carried out room by room, face by face, by comparing the delivered substrate with the quality grade agreed in the contract. For a standard Q2 level, residual tool marks and plaster excess thicknesses of less than one millimetre remain acceptable, whereas a Q4 level requires a continuous thin skim coat to eliminate differences in texture. The joint inspection record therefore requires naming the precise element, the physical nature of the defect observed and its amplitude measured with a straightedge or steel rule.

Quality grade Q2 (standard)
Usual surface quality in dry plasterwork. It includes the jointing of boards with reinforcing tape and a finishing pass ensuring a continuous transition with the facing, without total removal of tool marks.

Localised marking ensures that targeted rectification does not turn into a complete refinishing of the facing. In each room, site management and the plasterer record the tangible deviations: a raised or recessed joint, an unsanded joint on a suspended-ceiling drop, or missing plaster around a technical box. If the wall shows a flatness deviation, it is measured with the two-metre straightedge. Recording actual millimetre dimensions and the axis reference of the architect's plan ends any subjective discussion between the parties.

Examples of how to record reservations in interior plasterwork
Vague entry rejectedLocalised defectTechnical criterion and levelPrescribed rectification
Living room finishesLiving room 102, south partition, joint 2Excess thickness of 1.8 mm outside Q2 toleranceSpot sanding and levelling pass
Non-compliant kitchen ceilingKitchen 103, plaster suspended ceiling, axis BOffset of 2.5 mm under 2 m straightedgeWide plaster coat to soften the joint
Visible tape in bedroomBedroom 201, bulkhead at bed headTool mark and missing plaster on thinned edgeTargeted skim coat to level Q3
Defective corridor cornersCorridor 200, internal corner at door framePaper reinforcement visible under finishing coatLocal cutting back, re-bonding and smoothing

Agreeing the rectification protocol, intervention deadlines and signature under SIA 118

Joint acceptance seals the transfer of risks and starts the warranty periods of the work. Under SIA 118, defects noted during the inspection round are recorded in a document signed jointly by the client and the contractor. The document distinguishes minor defects, which do not prevent normal use of the premises, from major defects justifying postponement of acceptance. For each imperfection retained, the parties agree on a realistic execution deadline. Demanding a forty-eight-hour deadline to redo plaster coats remains technically impracticable: application requires observing setting times, complete drying through to the core and controlled ventilation before any mechanical sanding.

  1. Joint surveyWalk through each room with site management in order to record each reservation factually, with measurements and linked to the plan.
  2. Drying planningSet a rectification deadline that takes into account the ambient humidity, the plaster thicknesses and the time needed for complete hardening.
  3. Targeted interventionCarry out the rectification limited to the listed areas, protecting adjacent elements such as door frames.
  4. Joint checkCarry out the follow-up visit only on the points listed in the initial record in order to have the certificate of clearance of reservations signed.

The Code of Obligations frames these rights: art. 368 CO defines the client's rights in case of defects in the work, comprising repair, price reduction or damages. In practice on the construction site, the follow-up visit for clearance is strictly limited to the reservations originally formulated. When the sanding and plaster touch-ups meet the agreed tolerances, site management and the plasterer sign the closing slip. This signature discharges the company for those specific points, frees the schedule for the painters of the CFC 272 trade and authorises the release of the corresponding retention money.

On-site inspection method: service lighting, straightedge and contractual tolerances

The validity of a reservation depends directly on the physical conditions under which the joint inspection is carried out. On construction sites in French-speaking Switzerland, the most frequent dispute during the walkthrough concerns the lighting used to judge the facing. A foreman or a dry-lining plasterer must never accept an inspection carried out with a raking lamp or a floor spotlight sweeping the surface at a sharp angle, unless this specific lighting condition and the Q4 quality grade were expressly included in the tender specification. Visual inspection is always carried out with the future service lighting or under natural diffuse light, standing at a minimum distance of one metre perpendicular to the partition or suspended ceiling.

The geometric assessment of a defect requires standardised measuring tools and not mere subjective observation. The acceptance team systematically places a rigid two-metre aluminium straightedge and a twenty-centimetre steel rule to locate hollows and bumps. The deviation is read using a graduated measuring wedge or calibrated feeler gauges. A visible joint is not in itself a technical defect if the deflection remains within the tolerances of the agreed finishing grade. Out-of-plumb walls are checked with a precision spirit level or a plumb line over the full height of the partition, while internal or external corners are checked with a metal square over at least fifty centimetres of leg.

Joint qualification of common plasterwork anomalies at acceptance
Raw observation by site managementObjective on-site measurementTechnical qualification retainedJoint action recorded
Marked joint in the living roomOffset measured at 1.5 mm under the 20 cm steel rule for a contractual Q2 levelContractual tolerance met for a substrate intended for a thick renderingReservation dismissed, compliance with tolerances noted in the record
Wavy ceiling under the glass roofLocal hollow of 6 mm under the 2 m straightedge along the hanger axisFlatness defect outside permissible toleranceReservation admitted, levelling plaster redone over a width of 60 cm
Corridor corner not squareAlignment deviation of 4 mm over a square leg of 50 cmGeometric defect affecting the later fitting of skirting boardsReservation admitted, building up and correcting with filling plaster
Hairline crack at the top of the partitionStraight crack of 0.2 mm at the junction with the concrete slabStructural movement without rupture of the isolation stripInterface finding without execution fault, monitored under warranty

Joint clearance of reservations, handover to the painter and start of the warranty

The act of acceptance marks a decisive legal turning point governed by SIA 118: it transfers the risks of the work to the client and formally starts the two-year warranty period for apparent defects. When minor defects are recorded in the acceptance record, they do not prevent acceptance of the work, provided the functionality of the premises remains assured. However, the document must irrevocably record the exhaustive list of touch-ups accepted by the plasterer, excluding any later reopening of the file for elements that were visible during the joint inspection.

The intervention schedule for clearing the reservations must be set by mutual agreement when the record is signed. This deadline must take into account the drying constraints of interior plasters and the progress of the other finishing trades, in particular the painter's work. A realistic period of ten to fifteen working days is commonly adopted to allow a qualified worker to be made available without disrupting other ongoing construction sites.

  1. Targeted execution of the touch-upsThe plasterer works exclusively on the defects listed in the record: localised sanding, an additional finishing coat, or spot repair of a joint tape in accordance with the agreed tolerances.
  2. Joint on-site check of clearanceThe site manager and site management walk through the rooms concerned again. Each cleared point is initialled jointly on the original acceptance document.
  3. Final clearance certificate and release of retentionSigning the slip confirming full clearance of the reservations definitively extinguishes claims for apparent defects and triggers the process of releasing the retention money or the company's bank guarantee.

Deadlocked record: disagreement on tolerances and technical arbitration

When site management refuses to record precise dimensions and imposes a global unmeasured reservation, or flatly refuses to countersign the joint record, the team leader or site manager must immediately secure his contractual position. Under SIA 118, acceptance of a work cannot be deferred for minor defects that compromise neither the use of the premises nor the later intervention of the painter. A difference of opinion on the flushness of a taped joint or on local flatness under the straightedge in no way justifies blocking the final account entirely, as long as the plasterer provides material proof of conformity with the contractual quality level.

  1. 1. Formal notification with joint surveyImmediately send a registered letter to site management and the client. Enclose your own room-by-room joint survey, supported by dated photographs and millimetre readings under the two-metre straightedge, while formally rebutting the vague reservations.
  2. 2. Demand for access and rectification scheduleServe formal notice on site management to free access to the rooms concerned and to ensure sufficient construction site lighting. Define in writing the time slots allotted for the targeted touch-ups. Without effective availability of the rooms, no delay in clearance can be attributed to your company.
  3. 3. Joint technical expert opinion from the tradeIf disagreement persists on the conformity of a plaster coat or a plasterboard facing, request the intervention of a technical expert from the trade or a representative of the professional associations of French-speaking Switzerland. The deviation measurements taken under the straightedge objectively settle conformity against the agreed tolerances.
  4. 4. Objection to unilateral deductions from the progress statementFormally contest any re-invoicing for sanding or plastering carried out by the painter without prior written agreement. The plastering contractor holds the contractual right to repair his own proven defects himself. The application of a primer coat by the finishing trade without written reservation amounts to tacit approval of the delivered surface.

Frequently asked questions

What to do if the client demands an inspection of the partitions under artificial raking light?

The acceptance inspection must be carried out under normal service lighting conditions or under conventional diffuse light. Using a raking light source deliberately aimed at the plasterboard joints is admissible only if a higher surface quality was expressly stipulated in the contract for work. For a standard level, remind site management that visual assessment is made at normal distance without artificial tangential lighting.

Who bears the cost of repairing a partition damaged after provisional acceptance?

Once the acceptance record is signed, custody of the work and the risk of damage pass to the client under SIA 118. If knocks from a float, perforations or scratches occur during the later passage of electricians, plumbers or painters, these damages are not plasterwork defects. Their repair is the subject of a daywork slip or an additional order that can be invoiced.

How to formalise the clearance of reservations when site management is absent?

If site management does not appear on the agreed date for the clearance inspection, carry out an exhaustive unilateral survey. Document each corrected point with clear, precise photographs, accompanied by the flatness measurements. Notify this complete file the same day by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt, inviting site management to formalise its written discharge within a reasonable period of ten working days.

Can a painter refuse to work on plasterboard without a reservation entered in the record?

No. The painter must verify the substrates before starting his work. If a flatness or jointing defect is visible, he must issue a reasoned written notice before any application. If he starts his priming or plastering work without having raised any objection at acceptance or before his intervention, he is deemed to have accepted the plasterwork substrate as it stands and assumes responsibility for it.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work (inspection of the work, notice of defects and warranty)
  • code des obligationsGeneral rules of the contract for work concerning delivery, the client's rights in case of defects and repair

In the same section