Key takeaways
- Installing partitions on the raw slab guarantees the sound reduction between adjoining rooms.
- Erecting partitions on the screed makes future alterations easier but degrades sound insulation.
- The evaporation of a liquid flowing screed requires controlled ventilation before jointing.
- A work schedule recorded in writing protects the company against rework for which it is not responsible.
Partitions on raw slab or on floating screed: acoustic impacts and water management
On a building construction site in Switzerland, the choice of installing the partitions in plasterboard either directly on the raw concrete or after the floating screed has been poured determines all of the building's performance in use. This phasing is not a mere matter of logistical convenience, but engages the drylining installer's technical responsibility with regard to flanking sound paths and the mechanical stability of lightweight structures.
| Analysis criterion | Option 1: Partitions on raw slab (before screed) | Option 2: Partitions on floating screed (after screed) |
|---|---|---|
| Airborne sound insulation | Excellent decoupling between adjoining rooms | Increased flanking transmission through the continuous screed |
| Impact sound insulation | Screed locally decoupled in each room | High risk of impact transmission from one room to another |
| Moisture management | Risk of water absorption at the foot of the board | Dry substrate when the partitions are erected |
| Floor fixing and tracks | Solid anchoring with no risk to the heating coils | Risk of drilling through the underfloor heating pipes |
| Future spatial flexibility | Complex dismantling requiring the screed to be made good | Easy demolition with no impact on the floor build-up |
The preferred option for the requirements of the SIA 181 standard is to fix the metal frame sections directly to the concrete of the slab. This arrangement interrupts the horizontal propagation of sound waves. In return, the plasterer must protect against the mixing moisture brought in by the screed layer. When a cement screed or a calcium sulphate flowing screed is placed, hundreds of litres of water evaporate into the enclosed volume.
When site management imposes option 2 to speed up the progress of the structural work, the screed is laid over the full surface. The subsequent installation of the lightweight partitions creates mechanical continuity of the floor between rooms. To limit sound losses in this case, the foreman must saw the screed at each partition or make sure that acoustic through-joints have been formed by the screed layer.
Sequence of services, screed and painting: validation of the stages and contractual formalisation
The success of the interior finishes relies on seamless interlocking between the drylining installer, the plumbing or electrical installers, and the painter. Incorporating the technical services into the lightweight partitions requires the metal frame to be erected and only one face to be boarded. The plasterer temporarily leaves the room so that the technical trades can insert their cables, flush-mounted boxes and insulated pipework.
- Setting out and erecting the frameFixing the sections to the floor and ceiling, installing the vertical studs at 600 mm or 400 mm centres, boarding one face only to stiffen the structure without closing the cavity.
- Work by the technical tradesPulling the electrical conduits, installing the sanitary distribution pipes and the reinforcements for heavy fittings within the free thickness of the partition.
- Insulation and closingInstalling the acoustic mineral wool, checking that there are no flanking sound paths around the openings, and screwing on the second lining with staggered joints.
- Pouring the screed and dryingLaying the floor screed, maintaining regular ventilation to bring the relative air humidity below the critical threshold of 70 % before any joint treatment.
- Jointing and painting preparationApplying the jointing compounds with paper tape or glass mesh depending on the required quality level (Q2, Q3 or Q4) before the painter comes in.
A recurring pitfall concerns the treatment of joints before the screed has dried. Forming the joint tapes in an atmosphere saturated with moisture prevents the binders from setting properly and softens the core of the boards. The tapes blister or crack as soon as the commissioning heating suddenly dries out the rooms. The painter will then find defects on the delivered surfaces, attributable to failure to observe the drying times.
To lock down responsibilities, the foreman draws up a written phasing agreement at the coordination meeting. This document records the exact order of the operations, the minimum drying times and the permissible relative air humidity thresholds. If a change to the general schedule is imposed, written confirmation sent to site management relieves the plastering company of board deformations or joint cracking caused by execution outside the ambient tolerances.
Impact of screed moisture on partitions and acoustic trade-offs
Placing a liquid screed or a traditional floating cement screed (CFC 281) brings a colossal volume of water onto the construction site, amounting to several hundred litres per dwelling. When the metal-frame partitions are installed on the raw slab before the floor is poured, this mixing water evaporates into the enclosed interior volumes. Without regular ventilation, the relative air humidity quickly exceeds 85 % to 90 % during setting. Such a saturated atmosphere compromises the integrity of the plasterboard and damages the insulating mineral wool enclosed between the studs.
| Analysis criterion | Sequence with partitions on raw slab (before screed) | Sequence with partitions on floating screed (after screed) |
|---|---|---|
| Sound insulation according to the SIA 181 standard | Complete decoupling between rooms; a clean break in the screed prevents the propagation of structure-borne and airborne noise. | Continuity of the screed under the partition forming a lateral flanking sound path that is difficult to damp. |
| Exposure to mixing water | Maximum vulnerability of the linings and insulation to ambient moisture; strict mechanical ground clearance required. | Almost no exposure; the screed has already released its excess water before the plasterer arrives. |
| Edge sealing connection | Direct installation of the resilient perimeter strip along the plasterboard, forming a continuous trough. | Fixing of the metal frame directly to the finished floor, decoupled, using suitable plugs. |
| Future layout flexibility | Later demolition of a partition leaving a deep groove in the screed that must be filled. | Clean and quick dismantling of the partitions with no rework of the existing floor build-up. |
Absorption of liquid water or saturated vapour causes the mechanical failure of the gypsum. The boards lose their rigidity, the screws pull through the linings and the reinforced joint tapes come loose. To eliminate this risk, the teams must observe a strict ground clearance and make sure that the resilient perimeter strip laid by the screed layer projects above the finished floor level. Conversely, erecting the partitions on dry screed avoids these defects, but degrades the airborne and impact sound insulation according to the SIA 181 standard, as the continuous screed carries vibrations from one room to the next.
Sequence of technical services, drying check and handover to the painter
The work of the electrical installers (CFC 232) and plumbing installers (CFC 250) determines the progress of the plasterer-drylining installer. The built-in services must be fully run, fixed and pressure-tested before the second face of the lightweight partitions is closed. Fitting linings over unfinished pipework inevitably leads to later perforations and damage when a route has to be corrected or a leak repaired. The plastering foreman requires joint validation of the installation of the services at the coordination visits before authorising the insertion of the sound insulation and the screwing on of the closing linings.
- Acceptance of services and framesCheck that the sanitary ducts, electrical conduits and door-frame reinforcements are fully completed before closing.
- Installing the linings and raising the workScrew on the first face, install the acoustic mineral wool and close the work while maintaining the required ground clearance.
- Pouring and ventilating the screedAllow the screed layer to work and establish continuous hygienic ventilation to remove the mixing water without thermal shock.
- Joint treatment and surfacingCarry out the joint bridging and the compounds as soon as the relative air humidity falls durably below 70 %.
- Joint handover to the painterAccept the substrates together with the painter (CFC 272) to confirm the absence of moisture, the flatness and the agreed finish level.
Securing this schedule requires a formal written agreement in accordance with the SIA 118 standard and the Code of Obligations. When site management imposes a rushed schedule, such as painting early on plaster that is still damp or pouring the screed without protecting the bases of the walls, the plasterer enters a formal notice of reservation in the site minutes. This written record protects the company against any financial charge linked to cracking, crazing or blistering caused by the moisture-related defects of the other trades.
Handling sequencing disputes and preserving the contractor's rights
When the schedule requires the partitions to be erected on the raw slab, coordination with the electrical and plumbing installers determines progress. If the technical ducts in the floor block the positioning of the floor sections, or if the incorporation of the services into the metal frames takes place after boarding has begun, the site manager must immediately notify a partial interruption of the installation. Forced work without a formalised agreement exposes the plastering company to bearing the cost of damaged studs and non-compliant perforation of the plasterboard.
Reversing the sequence is the most frequent dispute: pouring the liquid screed before erecting the partitions in order to save overall drying time. This decision shifts the installation of the lightweight partitions onto the floating screed, creating a continuous rigid connection that degrades the airborne and impact sound insulation performance set by the SIA 181 standard. As soon as this change of sequence is raised at a site meeting, the plasterer must send a written notice to site management pointing out the loss of sound reduction and declining any responsibility for the final in-situ measurements.
The massive input of water generated by pouring screeds is a physical risk for plasterboard work that has already been erected. In the event of insufficient ventilation or relative air humidity exceeding the permissible tolerances, the linings absorb this residual water, causing the boards to swell, the tapes to soften and mould to appear. The foreman records the humidity and ambient temperature daily in the site diary. If the interior climatic conditions threaten the linings, jointing and smoothing operations must be stopped by written notification.
Handing the substrate over to the painter without a joint inspection record is what crystallises disputes at the end of the work. The acceptance protocol for the plastering substrate must be the subject of a tripartite written agreement between site management, the plasterer and the painter. This document validates the flatness, the absence of visible joint ghosting and the agreed surface quality level, thereby delimiting responsibilities before any primer or wall finish is applied.
Frequently asked questions
What to do if site management demands that the partitions be installed on freshly poured screed?
The contractor must refuse to proceed until the residual moisture content of the screed has been validated by a calcium carbide measurement supplied by the screed layer. Installing frames or boards on a damp floor causes capillary rise, corrosion of the tracks and rotting of the boards. A formal notification of refusal for a non-compliant substrate preserves the plasterer's rights.
How to react when the electricians drill through the metal studs after the first face has been boarded?
The foreman suspends the boarding of the second face and draws up a joint inspection record with site management. Holes that have not been deburred or that are made outside the openings provided at the factory weaken the stud's rigidity and risk cutting through the cables. The plasterer records the defect in writing and waits for the formal instruction to proceed before closing the partition.
Why record in writing the order chosen between erecting the partitions and pouring the screed?
The order determines the sound insulation according to the SIA 181 standard and the behaviour with regard to moisture. If the screed is poured after the partitions on the raw slab, the plasterer must have the protective measures for the partition bases recorded. If the order is reversed, the written agreement formally relieves the company of the lateral sound transmission generated by installing on a floating screed.
Who is responsible for tape ghosting visible after the paint has been applied?
If the painter applies his finish to a plaster substrate without making a prior written reservation, he accepts the substrate as it stands. However, to prevent any blockage at final acceptance, the plasterer organises a joint visual check of the surfaces under raking light before the painter comes in, in order to have the conformity of the agreed quality level validated.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 181Noise protection in buildings: acoustic requirements for interior walls and floors.
- norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work: rules on communicating notices and contractor's duties.
