Key takeaways
- A tender without an express designation of the finishing grade exposes the company to unpaid rework.
- SIA 242 requires the plastering grade to be defined according to the actual use of each room.
- Formally refusing the implicit grade protects the tradesperson against late demands from the painter or the architect.
- Offering a priced option for a higher grade from the outset showcases your expertise and defuses disputes.
Lock in the surface grade room by room to rule out any tacit interpretation
Submitting a plastering quote without specifying the surface finishing grade turns the acceptance phase into a financial lottery. On construction sites in French-speaking Switzerland, the reflex of pricing a standard finish without writing it down creates an immediate misunderstanding. Site management or the CFC 272 painter often expect a smooth surface ready for a matt lacquer, whereas the quantity surveyor simply priced a standard joint treatment on plasterboard. Under art. 1 CO, a contract is concluded when the parties have expressed their mutual and corresponding intention. If the tender is silent, there is no agreement on the expected finishing level.
The requirements for plaster and drywall surfaces must be agreed in writing before work begins, according to the intended use of the rooms, the raking light and the planned final coating.
norme SIA 242
The contractor must never accept a summary description that merely says "filler ready for painting". This vague wording is a constant source of disputes when raking light comes in through the glazed bays. Each room has different visual constraints. A windowless corridor, a living room bathed in sunlight through a full-height window or a service shaft do not require the same levelling operations. The quote must therefore explicitly link each partition or false-ceiling item to its standardised grade.
| Room and exposure | Contractual grade | Description of operations included | Limits of the service |
|---|---|---|---|
| Technical rooms, cellars | Grade 1 (Q1) | Filling of board joints, tightening without smoothing, screws roughly concealed | Raw surfaces, irregularities tolerated, not intended to receive paint directly |
| Offices, bedrooms (diffuse light) | Grade 2 (Q2) | Basic jointing followed by fine smoothing of the tapes and fixings, without overall skim coating | Usual standard; tool marks and transitions may remain visible under raking light |
| Living rooms with glazed bays | Grade 3 (Q3) | Standard jointing completed by wide skimming of the joints and pore filling | Reduces surface shadows, suitable for matt or textured wall coverings |
| High-quality surfaces, direct raking light | Grade 4 (Q4) | Continuous full skim coat over the entire board surface, fine mechanical sanding | Maximum flatness, masks the texture differences between board paper and filler for satin paint |
Stating the priced option from the outset to protect the plasterer's margin
The best defence against excessive demands is to include in the base tender the appropriate usual grade, accompanied by a priced option for moving to the higher grade. This commercial and technical approach clarifies the separation of responsibilities. The client or their representative thus becomes aware that perfect flatness under raking light is not a basic finish but a specific surface treatment involving additional coats of filler and overall sanding.
- Qualify the base substrateEnter the precise wording: "Partitions and ceilings provided in surface quality Q2 according to SIA 242, suitable for matt paints applied by roller or medium-textured wallpapers".
- Insert the clause refusing implicit standardsState in black and white: "Any requirement for a complete absence of cast shadows under natural or artificial raking light falls under grade Q4 and cannot be demanded as part of the standard service".
- Offer the priced Q3 or Q4 optionAdd the option: "Extra to the living room partitions and lounge false ceilings item: continuous skim coating of all facings to achieve grade Q4 according to SIA 242".
- Relieve the plasterer of the obligations of CFC 272Note that priming, pigmented undercoat and gloss-check work are the painter's responsibility before the final painting.
In practice, separately pricing a full skim coat to go from Q2 to Q4 represents a substantial investment in hours. A complete thin-film skim on plasterboard requires careful preparation of the mix, a cross pass with a wide smoothing blade and meticulous sanding with a long-handled sander under suitable lighting. The order of magnitude of this extra is commonly between CHF 15 and CHF 25 per square metre depending on the surface configuration and storey heights; see /soumissions/ for the precise preparation of the quote.
Standard clause refusing implicit standards and handling raking light
In calls for tenders for plastering and drywall in French-speaking Switzerland, the specifications are too often limited to a vague mention such as "smooth filler ready for painting". This imprecise wording is a major source of disputes when the painter or site management accepts the substrates. Under SIA 242, the standard surface quality for light partitions or full-coat plaster corresponds to grade Q2, suitable for textured wall coverings or lightly stressed matt paints. In the absence of any specification in the quote, this grade Q2 is the usual technical rule. Tacitly assuming that a standard filler must meet appearance requirements under raking light is a contractual error. To defuse any conflict, the contractor must enter in their tender a formal refusal of any implicit grade higher than their base proposal.
The tender must include a standardised text setting out the exact technical framework of the prices submitted. The following wording is inserted directly under the partition summary or in the special conditions: "The unit prices of this tender are calculated exclusively on the basis of a surface grade Q2 according to SIA 242, for all rooms without specific designation. Any requirement relating to raking light, satin or lacquered finishes, or a complete skim coat of grade Q3 or Q4 is covered by our enclosed priced option. The absence of an explicit order for this option will confirm execution of the work at standard grade Q2, excluding any inspection under non-diffuse incident light."
| Type of room or facing | Finish specified in the description | Priced base grade | Wording of the option |
|---|---|---|---|
| Technical rooms, service shafts, unused attics | Waterproofing coating or raw facing | Q1: basic jointing without sanding | Not applicable (functional grade sufficient) |
| Standard offices, bedrooms, corridors | Standard matt paint, fine finishing render | Q2: standard jointing with sanding | Option Q3: extended skimming of joints for semi-matt paint |
| Entrance halls, circulation areas with raking light, atriums | Lacquered or satin paint or continuous raking light | Q2: formal reservation issued on this choice | Option Q4: full thin-film skim coat for a uniform surface |
Contractual integration and test-surface protocol
To turn the tender into a rigorous contractual document when the contract is awarded under SIA 118, the plasterer must have the exact distribution of finishing grades recorded in the minutes of the clarification meeting. Too many awards are concluded on a lump-sum amount where the remarks of the tender are forgotten. A simple generic reference to the rules of the art is not enough, because the standard distinguishes four grades of execution with sharply different financial implications. Under the general principles of the Code of Obligations on the contract for work, the parties' agreement must clearly cover the exact nature of the work ordered. The final award document must therefore link the agreed amounts to the surface grades validated per zone, neutralising from the outset any divergence of interpretation during execution.
- Checking the lighting and layout plansIdentify on the architect's plans and the electrician's diagrams the full-height windows, light coves and wall lights likely to reveal the joints under raking light.
- Notifying technical reservations in the tenderSystematically attach an explicit technical reservation to each sensitive room in the tender schedule as soon as the desired finish exceeds the capability of a grade Q2.
- Recording in the negotiation minutesHave it formally recorded at the award meeting either that the extra for the higher grade is added, or that the client waives in writing any strict visual criteria.
- Producing a validated test surfaceAt the start of the work, produce a reference panel of at least ten square metres, representative of the room concerned, lit according to the future operating conditions, and record its approval in writing.
This methodical approach protects the company against the classic transfer of responsibility when the painters step in. When the finishing work starts, the jointly approved test surface is authoritative before site management. It embodies the grade agreed in the quote and is the only accepted reference for assessing the flatness and grain of the filler. No subjective complaint based on unforeseen lighting can then be raised against the plasterer, thus guaranteeing unreserved approval of the progress payment statements.
Surface disputes: enforcing the specification against late claims
When the finishing painter refuses to take over the substrates or site management demands a complete skim coat on a partition tendered without particular specification, the plasterer finds themselves on the front line. If the tender was silent, the client's side systematically tries to impose maximum visual requirements at the price of the basic standard. To defuse the conflict, the foreman or company manager must immediately produce the written documents of their tender and recall the technical framework of SIA 242, which governs plastering, rendering and drywall work.
- Call for a joint inspection recordSummon site management and the paint applicator on site before any further intervention, in order to record the raw state of the substrate.
- Neutralise non-compliant lightingFormally refuse any inspection under artificial raking light, inspection lamp or unshaded low sun; impose the observation conditions of SIA 242, under diffuse light or the final lighting.
- Compare with the reference surfaceCompare the disputed area with the test panel validated in the preparatory phase or, failing that, with the written specifications stating the grade selected room by room.
- Record in minutesDraw up a joint note recording the deviations under the 2 m straightedge and recalling the grade contractually owed in the face of the aesthetic expectations expressed.
As soon as the work executed corresponds strictly to the grade stipulated in the original quote, the painter's refusal of the substrate stems from a coordination failure by the project manager. SIA 118 governs the contractor's rights against unagreed claims: executing a higher grade constitutes a change to the order giving entitlement to additional payment. The existence in the initial tender of a priced option for the higher grade cuts short any negotiation on the applicable unit prices and allows an immediate switch to a clear addendum.
Frequently asked questions
What should I do if the tender specification asks for a "smooth and clean substrate for painting" without stating a grade?
Such a mention is legally imprecise and a source of disputes. The contractor must qualify this wording in their tender by stating that they are pricing a standard grade under SIA 242. They add an express statement refusing any implicit higher grade. At the same time, they offer the move to the higher grade as a priced option, thereby obliging site management to decide contractually, before the award, on the actual finishing level wanted for each room.
How do I formalise the priced option for a higher grade in the tender?
Enter the base service with grade Q2 or Q3 according to use, then insert a clearly identified option item. This line states the unit supplement per square metre for moving, for example, from Q2 joint filling to a continuous Q4 thin-film skim coat. The wording must specify the rooms concerned, the limits of the service and the fact that this extra includes sanding time and inspection under raking light.
Who bears the cost of a test surface on the construction site?
The production of a test surface must be expressly priced in the tender or be the subject of a prior agreement with site management. If it is not provided for in the contract documents, its execution may be invoiced on a daywork basis or included in the preparatory costs. Once jointly approved, it serves as the sole contractual reference for assessing the finished work against the criteria of SIA 242, ruling out any unjustified later claim.
Can the painter demand grade Q4 if the plastering tender states grade Q3?
No. The painter must adapt to the substrate contractually agreed between the client and the plasterer. If the plastering contract stipulates a grade Q3 in accordance with SIA 242, the painter cannot demand a complete Q4 skim coat unless site management issues a formal variation order. If a more thorough skim coat proves indispensable for their paint system, this additional work must be ordered and paid for as an additional service.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 242Rules for plastering, rendering and drywall work, defining in particular the surface quality grades and their acceptance criteria.
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work, governing the handling of order changes and quantity measurements.
