Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 271Interior plasters: substrates, coats and smoothingChapter 8 of 10 in the section

Damp old wall: lime plaster, vapour permeability and the cement mistake

This chapter details the hygrothermal behaviour of old masonry and the vapour-permeable function of mineral interior plasters. You will learn to specify and apply a traditional multi-coat lime system, to identify the defects caused by a cement render finish, and to determine precisely the limits of the plasterer's intervention when faced with unstabilised structural water ingress.

Key takeaways

  • Cement blocks water vapour and drives mineral salts higher up the masonry.
  • The microporosity of natural lime allows the moisture contained in the load-bearing wall to evaporate continuously.
  • Application is carried out in three successive coats of decreasing mechanical strength from the substrate to the finish.
  • Lime plaster never solves hydrostatic water pressure or a drainage failure.

Blocking of vapour permeability by cement and the phenomenon of salt migration

Vapour permeability
Capacity of a wall or plaster build-up to let water vapour migrate through its capillary network without liquid accumulation or degradation of the mineral binders.

An old rubble-stone or ashlar wall bedded in lime works in a dynamic balance with the indoor environment. The original materials have a high open porosity. This structure allows water coming from the ground or from atmospheric variations to pass through the wall in gaseous form, then evaporate freely at the surface. When the plasterer works on a renovation, maintaining this water-vapour permeability is an essential condition to prevent the facing from disintegrating.

Wrongly applying a hybrid mortar heavily dosed with cement, or a pure cement plaster, creates an almost impermeable barrier. With a resistance to vapour diffusion considerably higher than that of the old substrate, cement abruptly stops surface evaporation. The liquid water trapped behind this rigid crust can no longer escape. By capillary action, the damp front then rises vertically through the masonry until it finds a release zone, often at the level of the upper floors or behind the timber skirting boards.

The degradation mechanism is explained by the cycles of evaporation and crystallisation. In a sound wall, soluble salts migrate with the water and are deposited at the surface without mechanical stress. Under an impermeable cement plaster, crystallisation takes place in the transition zone between the original mortar and the new coat. This subflorescence phenomenon develops very high internal pressures that break up soft stones, loosen the joints and eventually push the cement mortar off in sheets.

In plastering, the use of rigid hydraulic binders damages old substrates. The salts concentrated behind the impermeable layer degrade the joints. The plasterer must rule out cement rendering on these substrates and apply a microporous mortar that allows evaporation without detachment.

Applying the lime build-up and recognising structural limits

Interior lime plaster follows the rule of decreasing binder dosages and moduli of elasticity. The base coat is stronger than the finish. On an old wall that has been dried out, the masonry is wetted to saturation the day before, then wetted again before application to prevent the mixing water from being absorbed.

  1. Bonding scratch coatSpray application of a rough slurry 3 to 5 mm thick based on natural hydraulic lime NHL 3.5 or NHL 5, richly dosed with 0/4 mm sand to create mechanical bond without sealing the substrate.
  2. Main plaster coatAfter 48 hours, application of a 10 to 15 mm rough coat in hydraulic lime NHL 2 or NHL 3.5. This coat, levelled with a straightedge, forms the breathable body and evens out the overall flatness of the wall.
  3. Finishing coatAfter partial carbonation, application of a fine plaster 2 to 3 mm thick in air lime CL 90 or weak hydraulic lime with 0/1 mm fine sand, floated or felted to ensure vapour permeability.

The success of a traditional mineral plaster depends closely on the curing conditions on the construction site. Air lime sets by slow carbonation on contact with the carbon dioxide in the surrounding air. The plasterer must rule out any abrupt artificial drying by forced-air dehumidifier or heater, which would cause the immediate burning of the fine coat. Moderate natural ventilation allows even hardening without crazing.

Technical comparison of binders for interior plasters on old masonry
Plaster binderVapour permeanceModulus of elasticityBehaviour on a damp wall
Pure Portland cementVery low (vapour-barrier effect)High (rigid and brittle)Blocks water, promotes rising damp and blistering
Hydraulic lime (NHL)Medium to highModerate (good flexibility)Allows gradual drying out, tolerates moderate damp
Air lime (CL 90)Maximum (high vapour permeability)Very low (very flexible)Ideal as a thin finish, slow carbonation in air

Despite its remarkable hygrothermal properties, lime plaster is not a remediation method against active structural damp. Faced with continuous water infiltration, groundwater under hydrostatic pressure or a complete absence of external perimeter drainage, the plasterer reaches the physical limits of the material. A masonry wall permanently saturated with liquid water will prevent proper carbonation of the air lime and cause massive efflorescence at the surface.

Binder formulation and evaporation kinetics of interior plaster

On old masonry of limestone rubble, molasse or mixed rubble bonded with weak lime, the hygrothermal behaviour of the wall depends entirely on its capacity to transfer water vapour from the core of the masonry to the occupied space. The historical introduction of hybrid mortars rich in Portland cement upset this balance: by combining excessive resistance to vapour diffusion with too high a mechanical rigidity, cement pushes capillary water back towards untreated areas or concentrates salts under the plaster body, causing blistering through crystal pressure.

Vapour permeability
Ability of a masonry wall and its mineral finishes to regulate and remove water in vapour form by continuous capillary and molecular diffusion, without creating a break in surface tension or liquid accumulation at the interface between coats.

To restore this dynamic, the plasterer adapts the mortar composition to the geological nature of the stone and the level of moisture exposure. A natural hydraulic lime of class NHL 2 or NHL 3.5 is preferred for the bonding scratch coat and the main plaster coat in damp conditions, complemented by an air lime slaked as putty or powder for the finishing coat. This combination guarantees a network of open macropores, promoting water migration without breaking down the binding matrix.

Comparison of the mechanical and hygrothermal characteristics of plaster mortars
Main binderVapour resistance factor (µ)Dynamic modulus of elasticityBehaviour in the presence of capillary moisture
Pure Portland cement (CEM I)15 to 30High (> 20 GPa)Impermeable barrier effect, forced lateral and upward migration of water
Natural hydraulic lime (NHL 3.5)6 to 10Moderate (5 to 8 GPa)Gradual evaporation, open porosity suited to salts in transit
Air lime (CL 90)3 to 6Low (< 3 GPa)Maximum vapour permeability, slow carbonation, reserved for dry finishes

Mixing the mortar requires a washed quarry sand, free of clay or organic fractions. A graded particle size curve, for example 0/4 mm for the rough coat then 0/2 mm for the finish smoothed with a sponge float, limits shrinkage during carbonation setting. Overdosing the hydraulic binder or compacting too vigorously with the trowel closes the pores at the surface, locally recreating the physical error typical of cement.

Application requirements and decision-making in the face of structural damp

  1. Stripping and preparing the jointsCompletely remove old cement plasters, soaked gypsum plasters or impermeable paints over a minimum height of fifty centimetres above the visible line of the rising damp. Rake out friable joints with a flat chisel to a depth of two to three centimetres, dust off by brushing and wet the substrate to saturation without leaving a shiny film of water.
  2. Spraying the bonding scratch coatSpray a scratch coat three to five millimetres thick, dosed with hydraulic lime NHL 3.5 or NHL 5 depending on the compactness of the stone, with a coarse sand. The texture remains rough and speckled to ensure the mechanical key of the main plaster coat without forming a continuous impermeable film.
  3. Applying the vapour-permeable main plaster coatBuild up the main plaster coat in one or two passes of ten to fifteen millimetres each after the undercoat has firmed up. Pull off with a notched straightedge or lightly score the surface to help the finish adhere, maintaining damp curing by spraying if ventilation dries the mortar out prematurely.
  4. Smoothing coat and compatibility of finishesApply the thin finishing coat in air lime or NHL 2 to a maximum thickness of three millimetres. Smooth with a wooden float or felt. Never subsequently cover it with a blocking facing, vinyl wallpaper or an impermeable synthetic resin that would stop the work from releasing moisture.

The plasterer immediately reports to site management any continuous liquid water ingress or any deep crumbling of the rock. According to standard SIA 118 and the rules of the trade for plastering work, the contractor checks that the substrate is suitable to receive the mineral system. If the ambient thermo-hygrometric conditions do not allow constant evaporation towards the indoor air, for example in a windowless cellar with no air extraction, the lime build-up remains ineffective without prior remediation of the ventilation.

Adhesion failures and moisture defects: site management and technical fallback

When lime plaster blisters, turns powdery or shows heavy efflorescence a few weeks after application, the plasterer is facing either disturbed drying kinetics or water saturation exceeding the mortar's evaporation capacity. On an old rubble wall, the classic mistake is to locally reapply a levelling coat or to seal the area with an organic fixative. This intervention makes the damage worse: it concentrates the mineral salt load under an impermeable film, causing the plaster body to detach in sheets during the next evaporation cycle.

As soon as defects appear, the first step is to sound the work with a hammer and a spatula to delimit the hollow areas. All detached, hollow-sounding or powdery plaster must be stripped back to the bare masonry. Disintegrated stone joints are raked out to a depth equal to twice their width. If hygroscopic salts appear on the surface as white needles, vigorous dry brushing is imperative: washing with large amounts of water is prohibited, as it would redissolve the sulphates and nitrates and send them back into the core of the wall.

Work can resume only after the water source has been stabilised by the competent trades. If drying out remains partial but under control, the plasterer applies a specific porous remediation mortar with a high content of air voids, able to store salts without bursting, topped with an air lime finish without surface tension. The incorporation of water-repellent admixtures or Portland cement into the repair mix remains strictly excluded in order to preserve the overall vapour-permeable balance of the work in accordance with standard SIA 118.

Frequently asked questions

What should be done if the lime plaster body turns to powder or dust after application?

Dusting results from premature drying: the mixing water was drunk up by the dry stone or evaporated by a draught before carbonation. The powdery substrate must be wetted to saturation with clean water sprayed without run-off, for several consecutive days. If the lime is completely dead at the surface, a superficial mechanical stripping is required before applying a new fine coat rich in binder onto a substrate that has been rewetted beforehand.

Can silicate paint be applied directly onto fresh lime plaster?

No. Even though silicate paint offers excellent vapour permeability, its potassium silicate requires a stabilised mineral substrate that has completed its chemical set. On a hydraulic or air lime plaster, an incompressible drying time of at least four weeks is required. Early application blocks the carbonation of the mortar, produces indelible mottling and compromises adhesion through lack of silicification on the nascent calcium carbonate.

Why do whitish efflorescences appear just above the skirting boards?

This saltpetre line marks the evaporation front of the capillary fringe. Moisture rising from the ground passes through the masonry and evaporates into the open air as soon as the zone enclosed by the skirting board ends. The dissolved salts crystallise at that precise spot. The solution requires removing the impermeable skirting boards, stripping the contaminated plaster to fifty centimetres above the damp line and ventilating the foot of the wall by means of a recessed joint.

How can normal rising damp be distinguished from infiltration under pressure?

Rising damp produces diffuse, constant, upward-moving moisture, generally limited to one and a half metres from the ground, without fluid flow. Infiltration under pressure, on the other hand, shows up as active seepage, drops beading on the plaster or sudden variations in moisture correlated with outdoor rainfall. In this second case, no interior lime plaster can withstand it: external drainage or waterproofing work is first indispensable.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work, management of notices and work stoppages

In the same section