Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 271Fire protection and acoustics of dry constructionChapter 7 of 10 in the section

Measuring sound insulation: method, rooms chosen, flanking transmission and verdict

At acceptance of a building, a non-compliant acoustic result puts the partition directly in question. This chapter details how in situ measurements are carried out to SIA 181, the method for locating leaks and identifying flanking transmission paths, and how to draw up a joint test report so as to establish objectively the responsibility of the drylining contractor.

Key takeaways

  • SIA 181 requires in situ measurements that verify the actual overall performance of the room.
  • Test rooms are chosen from the least favourable geometric configurations of the project.
  • Flanking transmission through the slab or the façade often explains the failure of a drylining partition.
  • The joint test report records the raw results and the plasterer's technical reservations.

Understanding the in situ method of SIA 181 and the choice of test rooms

When an acoustician comes to the construction site to validate insulation against internal airborne noise, they are not assessing an isolated element in the laboratory but a completed spatial situation. SIA 181 defines the requirements for noise protection in buildings by setting limit values applicable to the finished work. This overall approach measures the total sound attenuation between a source room and a receiving room, taking into account without distinction the separating wall, the junctions, the suspended ceilings, the floors and the adjoining façades.

The rooms to be tested are never selected at random. Site management or the acoustic engineer commissions checks on the most critical representative rooms: shortest spans with a small source volume, partitions crossed by technical ducts, or lightweight walls connected directly to curtain-wall façade mullions. For the plasterer, attending this selection ensures that the rooms tested correspond exactly to the standard details validated during the tender and technical execution phase.

  1. Standardised sound emissionThe acoustician sets up an omnidirectional sound source in the source room and generates white or pink noise covering the analysis spectrum required by SIA 181.
  2. Recording of sound pressure levelsThe integrating sound level meter records the average pressure level in the source room, then the residual level in the receiving room, with doors and windows closed.
  3. Reverberation measurementThe reverberation time of the receiving room is measured in order to correct the raw sound level according to the intrinsic absorption of the volume tested.
  4. Calculation of the rating valueThe measured spectra are weighted to obtain the rating of the actual airborne sound insulation in accordance with the contractual requirements.

Identifying flanking transmission and drawing up the joint test report

When a measured value does not reach the specified requirement, the immediate reflex of site management is to blame the execution of the drylining partition: lack of mineral wool, poorly screwed lining or omission of flexible sealant. Yet acoustic energy follows four distinct paths: direct transmission through the separating panel and three indirect flanking paths via the ceiling, the floor or the adjoining façade. A detailed acoustic measurement by intensity measurement or with a surface microphone makes it possible to quantify the exact share of energy radiated by each wall.

Diagnosis of acoustic transmission paths in the event of non-compliance
Path observedCommon technical originTechnical responsibility of the tradeJoint verification
Direct (partition)Resilient strip missing under tracks, frame offset omittedDrylining plasterer (CFC 271)Local destructive inspection or thermography
Flanking via floorContinuous screed under partition, no edge stripScreed and floor coverings (CFC 281)Review of the installation plan and screed core sampling
Flanking via façadeContinuous hollow curtain-wall mullion, junction not sealedMetal façades and windowsSound intensity measurement on the profile
Flanking via slabConcrete slab too light with no break, or continuous suspended ceilingStructural work or structural work coordinationVibration measurement on the bare slab

The presence of the plastering works foreman during the measurement campaign is essential. If a sound level exceedance is found, require heavy acoustic sheets to be applied to the partition in order to measure the noise passing exclusively through the lateral flanks. This technical counter-measure shows mathematically whether the weakness comes from the separating panel or from the adjacent works carried out by other finishing-work or structural-work trades.

At the end of the tests, the acoustician and site management draw up the technical conclusions. Under art. 367 CO, after delivery, the client must check the condition of the work as soon as is practicable and notify the contractor of any defects. In the event of a joint finding, the test report must state the precise condition of the rooms during the test (presence or absence of coverings, doors fitted, installation penetrations sealed or open) and must expressly set out the plasterer's reservations concerning the parasitic transmissions identified through the peripheral walls.

Separating the sound reduction index: diagnostic methods and isolating the paths

When the value measured in situ to SIA 181 proves lower than the project requirements, site management immediately blames the drylining partitions. Yet the overall sound pressure does not distinguish direct transmission from indirect transmission. To clear the plasterer's responsibility, the share of sound transmitted by the wall and the share carried by the adjoining parts of the building must be quantified. Third-octave band analysis provides a first lead: a targeted drop at mid frequencies signals an airtightness defect, whereas a marked deficit at low frequencies points to a rigid coupling with the structural work.

The acoustician commissioned uses targeted investigation techniques to identify the parasitic paths. Sound intensity measurement maps the surface energy flows and makes it possible to check whether the radiation comes from the lightweight wall or from the adjacent elements. In addition, fitting accelerometer sensors on the concrete slab, the façade lining or the metal studs assesses the structure-borne vibration level. Finally, temporary sealing with heavy sheets or lead-lined mats applied against the partition makes it possible to measure the residual noise passing exclusively through the lateral flanks, removing any ambiguity about where the defect comes from. Comparing the curve obtained in situ with the manufacturer's laboratory test certificate confirms whether the CFC 271 work is behaving normally.

In situ acoustic diagnosis: distinguishing direct and flanking paths
Symptom measuredPredominant leakage pathTechnical origin foundResponsible trade
Leak at high frequencies (> 1000 Hz)Direct sound bridgeSealant joint omitted under the base track or penetrations without sealingPlastering and drylining (CFC 271)
Radiation from the glazed façadeContinuous flanking transmissionNo break at the partition-mullion junctionMetal façades or windows
Transmission via the floorContinuity under screedFloating screed continuous under the partition or skirting boards wedgedScreeds and poured floors (CFC 281)
Structure-borne noise at the top of the partitionRigid coupling on the underside of the slabResilient strip missing or crushed by deflectionStructural work or plastering, depending on the tender

Joint test report and technical arbitration at acceptance

The comparison of the measured values with the general award quote and the approved detail drawings takes place within the formal framework defined by SIA 118. The plastering contractor must never sign a statement of non-compliance without requiring the full inclusion of the spectral data and of the reservations concerning ancillary works. Before any conclusion, the background noise level of the building and the influence of outdoor noise must also be deducted from the calculation. If the client's acoustician merely records an unsatisfactory raw value, the test report must specify that the measurement reflects an overall room-to-room performance and not the intrinsic capacity of the drylining system installed in accordance with the manufacturer's instructions.

  1. Verification of test conditionsCheck the volume of the source and receiving rooms, the reverberation time used and the complete closure of all moving elements of the building.
  2. Requirement for decoupling by maskingFormally request a comparative measurement with heavy acoustic screening of the separating partition in order to assess the sound threshold of the flanking transmissions.
  3. Joint review of the interfacesRecord in the test report the condition of the adjoining junctions: screed break, decoupling of suspended ceilings, sealing of technical ducts and elastomer strips under profiles.
  4. Entry of reasoned reservationsRefuse the financial attribution of the defect as long as the respective contribution of each building component has not been determined in accordance with SIA 181.

In summary, the final acoustic insulation results from the inseparable interaction between the structural work, the façades, the technical installations and the lightweight partitions. For the plastering foreman, rigour means documenting every perimeter junction from the time of assembly, with joint photographs taken before the linings are closed. Faced with an unfavourable measurement verdict at handover, this technical traceability, coupled with a critical reading of the acoustician's report, is the only valid defence for having the physical limits of the installed system recognised and redirecting action towards the real failures of the structure.

Recourse protocol and technical arbitration in the event of non-compliance

When an acoustic report concludes there is a shortfall against the requirements of SIA 181, site management is often tempted to blame the drylining plasterer's lightweight partition immediately. Accepting this finding without technical analysis exposes the company to heavy and entirely unnecessary remedial work if the problem comes from the adjacent trades. Before any intervention on the plasterboard linings, it is for the site foreman to challenge the one-sided attribution and to demand a methodical search for the transmission paths.

  1. Verification of measurement conditions and assumptionsCheck in the test report whether the test rooms correspond to the planned volumes and whether the reverberation time was correctly measured. A cracked anhydrite or cement screed, leaky door joints or ventilation in operation distort the overall in situ insulation result.
  2. Locating sound bridges by velocimetryAsk the acoustician for a sound intensity analysis or accelerometer measurements on the lateral walls, the lightweight façade and the slab. This analysis identifies unambiguously whether the noise radiates through the bare masonry, the continuous glazing band or the uncompartmented technical plenum.
  3. Decoupling test with a temporary screenIf doubt remains about the assembly of the partition, apply a temporary dense, heavy lining against one of the faces or mask the critical perimeters with mineral wool panels under a heavy sheet. If the insulation index does not improve, the partition is definitively cleared.

If the measurement reveals a genuine defect in the drylining partition, such as rigid bridging of the frame or the absence of a resilient sealing strip under the perimeter profiles, the company must correct the junctions precisely. On the other hand, if the structural coupling occurs in the floor or the façade mullion, the dispute relates to the overall design or to the other trades, releasing the drylining contractor from its retention money.

Frequently asked questions

Who commissions and bears the cost of the joint acoustic acceptance measurements on the construction site?

Site management initially commissions the acoustician for the overall compliance check. If the target values of SIA 181 are not reached and the responsibility of the drylining partition is formally contested with technical evidence, the plastering company may demand a joint expert assessment. The costs of these additional measurements fall on the party whose work is found defective after the parasitic transmission paths have been definitively identified.

How can I prove that the acoustic transmission comes from the continuous façade rather than from my partition?

The acoustician uses an intensity probe or places accelerometers on the mullion or the façade panel connected to the partition. Measuring the surface radiation shows that the acoustic energy passes through the metal façade profile running from one room to the next. If the vibration level of the façade exceeds that of the plasterboard partition, external flanking transmission is formally established.

Can a faulty acoustic seal under the floating screed be held against me as a plasterer?

No, unless the execution drawings entrusted you with installing the perimeter resilient strip on the floor before the screed was poured. The drylining plasterer works on the finished screed or on the bare slab according to the tender details. If the screed touches the partition rigidly without a perimeter strip, the sound bridge is the responsibility of the screeder or of a coordination error by site management.

What essential items must appear on the joint in situ measurement test report?

The document must record the precise numbers of the source and receiving rooms, the temperatures and humidity levels, the emission spectrum, and the possible presence of raised floors or suspended ceilings. It must necessarily bear the signatures of the acoustician, site management and the site manager, together with the drylining contractor's formal reservations concerning the flanking transmissions detected.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 181Noise protection in buildings, acoustic requirements and in situ measurement methods
  • norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work, verification of defects and joint acceptance

In the same section