Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 271Surface quality levels and tolerancesChapter 6 of 10 in the section

Crack after acceptance: normal shrinkage, workmanship defect and warranty

After acceptance of the work, a crack appearing in a lightweight partition or a suspended ceiling often triggers an immediate dispute. This chapter teaches you to identify the real physical cause of the problem, to distinguish normal hygrometric shrinkage from an installation defect, and to assert the limits of your contractual warranty with regard to building movements.

Key takeaways

  • Surface shrinkage microcracks are not defects attributable to the drywall contractor.
  • Cracking caused by slab deflection stems from a structural stress of the structural work.
  • The absence of a reinforcing tape or a decoupling profile directly engages the installer's liability.
  • The notice of defects must be given by written notification and lead to a joint inspection record.

Determining the origin of the crack: plaster shrinkage, structural movement or technical omission

On a plasterboard partition or a suspended ceiling, the appearance of a crack after handover of the work provokes strong reactions from the client. Before undertaking any repair, the foreman must analyse precisely the morphology of the defect, its orientation and its location. A crack is not systematically a sign of a workmanship error: the physics of materials and the deformations of the structural work generate mechanical stresses that the interior lining cannot always absorb on its own.

Types of cracks found after acceptance in dry construction
Type of crackVisual appearanceMain physical causeAttributable to the CFC 271 trade
Hygrometric shrinkageFine hairline surface crack on the joint compoundRapid drying of the jointing compound or variations in relative humidityNot attributable if drying times and installation conditions were respected
Structural work movementDiagonal crack or shear crack at the head of the partitionDeflection of the upper slab or differential settlement of the concreteNot attributable; stems from the structural design of the building
Omitted reinforcementContinuous straight crack along the plasterboard bevelled edgesForgotten micro-perforated jointing tape or glass-fibre tapeAttributable to the plasterer for failure to follow installation rules
Rigid blocked junctionOpen crack at the corner between dry partition and masonry wallAbsence of bridging tape or decoupling profileAttributable to the plasterer if the specified connection was not decoupled

Hygrometric shrinkage remains a normal physical phenomenon. When the heating is commissioned or with seasonal variations in the indoor climate, the jointing compounds and boards undergo moisture equalisation. This shrinkage sometimes creates a very fine, perfectly stable hairline that does not pass through the thickness of the lining. By contrast, structural cracks originate from the deformation of the load-bearing elements. A concrete slab that deflects under service loads applies vertical crushing on the head of the partition if a sliding connection has not been specified. Likewise, the connections between masonry and metal framing undergo unavoidable differential expansion.

Handling the claim under SIA 118: written notification, limits and rectification

As soon as the client notices damage, the contractual framework requires a formal procedure. Where the parties have agreed to apply SIA 118, a two-year warranty period takes effect from acceptance of the work. During this two-year period, the entitled party may report at any time the defects that appear. However, for the claim to be legally valid and bind the company, it must be made by a detailed written notice describing the exact nature and location of the cracks observed.

  1. Receipt of the written notice of defectThe company checks the original acceptance date of the construction site and examines the description of the cracks sent by site management or the owner.
  2. Joint technical visit on siteThe team leader attends with a crack gauge to measure the opening, check whether the crack is active and probe for the presence of the reinforcing tape in the compound.
  3. Drawing up the technical cause reportThe plasterer writes a technical reply that determines whether the origin lies in a workmanship defect or in a deformation transmitted by the load-bearing structure.
  4. Deciding who bears the cost and the rectification methodIf the company is at fault, a repair by bridging or re-plastering is scheduled; if the structural work is the cause, a repair quote is proposed.

Art. 368 CO sets out the client's rights in the event of a defect in the work, including free rectification if the irregularity results from poor workmanship. However, art. 369 CO releases the contractor where the defect stems from erroneous instructions of the client or from the conduct of other trades. If a civil engineer did not provide an expansion joint in a large continuous ceiling area, or if the architect refused the creation of a sliding head under a long-span slab, the plasterer's warranty cannot be invoked.

Joint diagnosis on site and instrumentation of the defects

When a crack appears after acceptance of the works, the drywall plasterer must neither intervene hastily nor reject the claim without a technical check on site. The joint procedure begins with a combined visit bringing together the foreman, site management and, if necessary, the civil engineer responsible for the work. The first objective is to classify the cracking: a stabilised phenomenon or active kinematic deformation? The examination provides information on the precise geometry of the crack path, whether straight or sinuous, and on the mechanical condition of the connections around the masonry walls or reinforced concrete slabs.

Visual inspection is not enough once the tradesperson suspects a structural movement of the structural work. Fitting a strain gauge or a graduated millimetre crack gauge makes it possible to record the change in the opening over an observation period of several weeks. Seasonal hygrometric variations cause reversible cycles of opening and closing in interior plasters and plasterboard. By contrast, if the measuring marker shows continuous widening without ever closing again, the defect inevitably results from slab deflection, concrete creep or foundation settlement. Any premature filling is then pointless and the plastering company's liability is totally excluded.

Differential diagnosis matrix of interior cracking after acceptance
Defect observedIdentified construction originDynamic behaviourContractual responsibility
Fine hairline surface crackNormal hydraulic shrinkage of the plaster binderStabilised after complete dryingTolerance accepted or local repair
Continuous crack along a door frameOmitted stop profile or missing tapeStable or reactivated by the doorsPlasterer (workmanship defect established)
Horizontal crack at the head of the partitionSlab deflection without sliding connectionChanging with the imposed loadSite management and engineer
Diagonal crack passing through the partitionSupport settlement or floor bendingContinuous progressive deformationStructural work (structural movement)

Technical repair protocols and limits of intervention under warranty

Where the plasterer's liability is formally established by a characterised workmanship defect — omitted reinforcing tape, excessive fixing spacing or failure to respect the drying time of the jointing compound —, restoration requires a deep repair of the lining. A superficial skim is merely a short-lived cosmetic treatment: the residual stresses in the board inevitably reopen the crack under the loads on the building. The plasterer carries out a meticulous mechanical repair in order to restore the continuity of the build-up and the uniformity of the surface.

  1. Opening the crackChase out the crack in a bevel with a triangular scraper over a width of 5 to 10 millimetres, then remove the dust by careful vacuuming.
  2. Conditioning the substrateApply a bonding primer to neutralise the suction of the dry plaster and prevent rapid drying out of the repair mortar.
  3. Filling and bridgingFill the chase with a non-shrinking filler, then immediately press a micro-perforated tape into the fresh coat.
  4. Skimming and sandingApply two coats of finishing compound extending 20 centimetres beyond the repair, then carry out fine sanding after complete drying.

Completion of the warranty operations must be recorded in a rectification report signed jointly with site management. This written document certifies that the repaired areas have been fully restored, closes the registered claim and definitively releases the contractor from any further obligation regarding these specific elements. Upon signature of this document, the client is required to release the retention money relating to the plastering package, and may not invoke subsequent defects caused by overall structural deformations of the concrete structural work.

Arbitrating persistent disagreements and closing the warranty obligations

When the technical dialogue stalls over a claim for cracking after acceptance, the plastering site foreman must formalise their position without delay. The dispute generally concerns attribution: the client sees a defect in execution, while the tradesperson notes the foreseeable effects of the drying out of plasters or framing deformations. Under SIA 118, the notice of defects requires a reasoned reply. In the event of persistent deadlock, the parties request a joint technical expert opinion, entrusted to a neutral expert of the trade or to the Romandy umbrella association, before any legal proceedings.

The technical expert opinion probes the build-up to verify the conformity of the assemblies. The presence of a reinforcing tape embedded in the joint compound, compliance with screw spacings and the installation of a flexible decoupling profile at the head of the partition are the decisive criteria. If the opening results from deflection of the upper slab beyond the permissible values or from structural settlement of the structural work, the plasterer's liability is entirely discharged. The warranty limit applies formally: the drywall contractor is never liable for building movements that exceed the mechanical absorption capacity of the materials specified in the contract.

If, on the other hand, the technical findings reveal a failing specific to the trade — such as a rigid connection without a spacer tape against a load-bearing wall or direct bridging over fresh concrete —, the plasterer must carry out the repair. This intervention under warranty is confined to rectifying the linings and cutting an appropriate shadow gap, in accordance with the recognised rules of the trade under the Code of Obligations (CO). Redoing subsequent decorative finishes is subject to separate agreements where the original skimming respected the agreed tolerances.

Frequently asked questions

Does a microcrack at the junction between a lightweight partition and a concrete ceiling constitute a warranty defect?

No, a fine hairline microcrack of less than two tenths of a millimetre along a rigid junction without a decoupling profile specified in the description is considered normal shrinkage. Under SIA 118, hygrometric and thermal variations of materials do not constitute a workmanship defect where the plasterer has applied the specified tapes. If no recessed joint was ordered by site management, the phenomenon is structurally unavoidable.

Who bears the cost of repainting after the plasterer has repaired a crack under warranty?

The plasterer's warranty covers exclusively the restoration of their substrate to the initially agreed finish level, most often a standard surface grade. If the crack stems from a plasterer's defect, the plasterer must bear the repair of the compound. By contrast, repainting the entire room does not automatically fall to the tradesperson if a simple localised touch-up, invisible at the regulation viewing distance, can be carried out by the painter.

How should one react if site management withholds the financial guarantee for thermal shrinkage cracks?

The contractor must immediately send a written objection by registered letter, contesting the deduction from the performance guarantee. SIA 118 should be relied upon to demand a joint inspection record on site. If the instrumentation proves that the opening varies with the seasons or that the screed pushed the partition, the plasterer demands the release of the bank securities by demonstrating the absence of technical fault in their connections.

Does the absence of a decoupling tape under the floor profile engage the plasterer's ten-year liability?

Forgetting a resilient perimeter tape under a floor or edge profile is an established workmanship defect, but it does not fall under the ten-year warranty reserved for intentionally concealed defects or collapse of the work under the Code of Obligations (CO). This defect falls within the ordinary period for notifying defects under SIA 118. The tradesperson must correct the rigid connection if shear cracks appear.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction works, governing acceptance of the work, notice of defects and warranty periods.
  • code des obligationsGeneral rules applicable to the contract for work and services, delivery of the work and liability for construction defects.

In the same section